Key Takeaways
- Resilient quarter, tariff frustration clear: Revenue grew 0.6% QoQ despite two fewer days, but the CEO called 8.5% return on capital employed “way too low” and pinned recovery hopes on industry tariff rationality.
- 5G rollout is a capex story, not yet a revenue story: Urban coverage nears completion this year, but 5G is being given away free as unlimited data, and device adoption remains slow with extending replacement cycles.
- War on waste is the margin engine: A relaunched cost program targeting network, sales, capex, and failure demand is protecting 52.2% EBITDA margins against energy and rollout headwinds.
- Adjacent businesses are scaling fast but will stay small: Airtel Finance, cloud, IoT, and data centers are growing at 50%+ and are capital-efficient, but management explicitly stated they will never approach the core mobility business in size.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the SG&A softening from channel commission cuts sustains, any tariff action from the industry, and the first peel-off of capitalized 5G opex as sites go live.
Tariff & Return Profile
- The core tension: Consolidated revenue and margins held up, but the CEO framed the quarter through the lens of return on capital employed, which at 8.5% he described as unacceptable for the business.
- Pricing architecture critique: Management argued India’s one-size-fits-all pricing approach is broken relative to how any consumer industry works, and that ARPU and rate per GB are lower than markets like Pakistan, Sudan, or Sub-Saharan Africa.
- ARPU mechanics: Reported ARPU of Rs.193 was depressed by two fewer days; normalized ARPU was Rs.195, driven by smartphone upgrades, data monetization, and modest flow-through from the entry plan tariff increase from Rs.99 to Rs.155.
- The tariff bet: Management expressed hope that “some sense will prevail in the industry to move up tariffs sooner rather than later,” but offered no timeline or catalyst beyond that hope.
Vittal: “Yet our concern on return on capital employed remains. At 8.5% this is way too low and we hope some sense will prevail in the industry to move up tariffs sooner rather than later.”
5G Rollout & Capex
- Rollout pace: 5G is now live in ~3,500 cities and towns, adding 35–40 cities per day, with urban coverage expected to conclude this year along with some key rural pockets.
- Architecture choice paying off: The decision to deploy Non-Standalone Architecture (NSA) is delivering better coverage, lower capex, lower carbon footprint, and better experience versus Standalone, though SA remains ready for enterprise use.
- Capex trajectory: FY24 capex is guided to the same ballpark as FY23 at Rs.28,500 crores. Wireless capex on 5G is expected to decline in FY25 as urban coverage completes, though transport and home broadband investments will continue.
- Capex relief signal: Management flagged that slowing global device shipments, extending replacement cycles, and rising entry-level smartphone prices could reduce the capex needed for rural 5G rollout in FY25 if the trend persists.
- Spectrum refarming plan: Over time, as 5G device penetration increases, Airtel will start refarming mid-band spectrum including 2300 MHz to 5G, with Delhi and Mumbai potentially moving faster and shifting to SA first.
- Millimeter wave spectrum: The acquired millimeter wave spectrum has already paid back through savings on spectrum usage charges; currently no plan to use it, only trials underway to check propagation characteristics for the long term.
Vittal: “It was a bold decision to go with NSA which is non standalone architecture of 5G. This is already giving us better coverage, lower capex, lower carbon footprint and better experience.”
5G Monetization & Adoption
- Free 5G, limited uptake: 5G is being offered as unlimited data on existing plans for customers with a 5G device, but not everyone has opted in because it requires using the Airtel Thanks App.
- Behavioral tailwinds: For customers who do not claim the unlimited offer, Airtel is seeing growth in consumption, lower churn, and growth in data monetization via impulse data packs triggered by daily data breaches.
- Device bottleneck: Movement to 5G will be limited in the near term because device replacement cycles are extending and approximately 25–30% of shipments are still feature phones. Only 33% of postpaid users have a 5G handset versus under 10% in aggregate.
- Capacity confidence: Management is not worried about unlimited 5G data impacting capex for the next five years, citing 100 MHz tranches of spectrum and massive efficiency gains.
- Ecosystem gap: The CEO noted the telecom industry is well ahead of the rest of the ecosystem on 5G, with devices, applications, and content still needing to catch up over the coming years.
Vittal: “The telecom industry is right now well ahead of the rest of the ecosystem.”
War on Waste & Margins
- Program relaunch: The war on waste initiative was relaunched with four focus areas: network costs (66,500 sites identified for energy, rental, and re-engineering actions), sales costs (data science to identify early churn at outlet level), capex (all capacity investments into 4G stopped as 5G offloads up to 30% of traffic), and failure and interactions reduction.
- Network opex control: India network opex rose only 7.5% in FY23 despite serious cost headwinds from energy and rollouts, driven by relocation of high-cost sites and re-engineering.
- SG&A frustration: SG&A cost growth was driven primarily by competitive intensity to acquire customers, which management described as “fruitless money being spent” given high early-tenure churn. Some softening was seen in Q4 as Airtel began lowering some channel commissions and tracking the impact over 45 days.
- Churn pattern: Churn after the first four months is very low; the high overall churn is concentrated in those first four months, driven by industry-wide high commissions and acquisition costs.
- 5G opex treatment: 5G opex is currently capitalized because the rollout is still underway; it is expected to start peeling off in coming quarters as more 5G sites are lit up and central criteria are met.
Ray: “We have always held that this is fruitless money being spent and people keep on churning but to remain competitive in the market we need to have terms which are rightful.”
Business Segment Performance
| Segment | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Mobility | ▲ Resilient | 0.74 crore 4G net adds; postpaid net adds of 663,000 driven by 5G pivot and new Rs.599 nuclear family plan; revenue market share at lifetime high of 38.7%. |
| Broadband | ▲ Strong | 4 lakh net adds in Q4; 0.16 crore full-year net adds; presence expanded to just under 1,200 cities; bulk of growth now from top 200–300 cities. |
| B2B (Airtel Business) | ▬ Flat sequentially | Revenue flat because low-margin deals were let go; margins expanded 130 bps; full-year revenue growth just under 16%, highest in a decade; connectivity market share up 220 bps to 34%. |
| DTH | ▼ Soft | Lost 39,000 customers due to cricket seasonality; core business looking better; April and May net additions strong; convergence strategy outperforming the DTH industry. |
| Digital & New Businesses | ▲ Fast growth | Cloud and IoT growing at well over 50%; Payments Bank monthly transacting users up 14.5% QoQ to ~5.5 crore; Airtel Finance served 2.8 lakh+ customers with Rs.1,200 Crores annualized lending run rate. |
- B2B order book: Management advised not to read too much into the past quarter’s revenue slowdown, stating that funnels and order books for the coming quarter look strong and the underlying growth trajectory remains intact.
- Rural expansion: Expansion into 60,000 high-potential villages is progressing in line with plan, with early results encouraging and contributing to higher 4G share of net additions.
- Top 150 cities focus: These cities account for ~40% of the telecom market and concentrate 80% of postpaid, broadband, converged homes, and 95% of B2B; Airtel is driving an integrated omni-channel approach to win them.
Adjacent Businesses & Capital Allocation
- Airtel Finance launch: Partnered with Axis Bank and NBFCs via API integrations on the Airtel Thanks App to offer loans and credit cards; a 15-person team is building ML and AI-led credit profiling algorithms, doing approximately Rs.100 Crores of lending within a couple of months of launch.
- Lending model: Airtel earns a margin on disbursal by offering collection services on behalf of the bank without carrying balance-sheet risk.
- Data center build: Construction has started on a 25 MW green data center in Kolkata, the first to operate fully on green energy. For hyperscalers, data centers are built to suit with commitment already in place and revenues begin upon handover in 12–18 months.
- Digital business scale: Management stated digital businesses including cloud, cyber security, IoT, data centers, CPaaS, and lending could be quite big but will never be in the same ballpark as the core mobility business; all are very capital-efficient, riding on existing data infrastructure.
- Capital allocation sequence: Airtel will continue to invest in the business for competitive growth, then leverage down the balance sheet to more comfortable levels; after that, the time will come to return money to shareholders.
- Indus Towers stance: If the tower business is stable, there is no intention to put any capital and Airtel might theoretically even dilute its stake. If one player’s challenges cause volatility, Airtel may creep up and take control in the short term to prevent it, because the tower business is described as the company’s “heartbeat.”
Vittal: “The tower business is our heartbeat so we cannot afford to have that in any ways face volatility so if it is means in a short term to prevent volatility because one player could have challenges if we have to creep up and actually take control we will but if that business is stable there is no intention for us to actually put any capital.”
Fixed Wireless Access & Fiber Strategy
- FWA economics challenged: CPE costs at $170–$180 are much higher than the cost per connected home pass for fiber, and fiber delivers a consistent dedicated experience. Management sees FWA as at best a technology to go where fiber cannot go and then follow up with fiber.
- Long-term experience risk: The CEO pointed to T-Mobile in the US, which is already beginning to see challenges on network experience through FWA after five to seven years, as a cautionary example.
- FWA bundling possibility: Bundling FWA with high-value DTH homes is technically possible because the DTH box works on Wi-Fi, but the issue remains economics, not reliability.
- Fiber as tower backhaul: Airtel is leveraging its FTTH rollout to wire towers, described as a “huge game changer” for efficiency, having added ~33,650 km of fiber in FY23.
Vittal: “In the case of fixed wireless access you may get a very good experience when the networks are empty but in five to seven years like we are seeing in the case of T-Mobile in the US already beginning to see challenges on network experience through fixed wireless access so it is at best a technology that can be used to go where fiber is not able to go and then follow that up with fiber.”
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| 5G urban coverage | Urban coverage concluded, plus some key rural pockets | This year (FY24) |
| FY24 capex | Same ballpark as FY23 at Rs.28,500 crores | FY24 |
| FY25 wireless capex | Wireless capex on 5G to decline relative to FY24 | FY25 |
| 5G opex recognition | Capitalized 5G opex to start peeling off as sites go live | Coming quarters |
| Capital allocation | Leverage down balance sheet, then return money to shareholders | After competitive investment phase |
| 4G capacity capex | All capacity investments into 4G stopped | Effective immediately |
| Home passes rollout | ~0.16 crore home passes per quarter | Ongoing quarterly run-rate |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | Over ₹36,000 cr, +0.6% QoQ |
| EBITDA margin | 52.2% |
| India business free cash flow (FY23) | ~₹23,000 cr, EBITDA minus capex for full year |
| Net debt to EBITDA (India) | 3.4x; consolidated at 2.8x |
| Return on capital employed | 8.5% |
| Capex (Q4) | ₹9,000 cr, described as a little elevated |
| Capex (FY23) | ~₹28,500 cr for the full year |
| Reported ARPU | ₹193; normalized at ₹195 adjusting for two fewer days |
| 4G net adds | 0.74 cr |
| Postpaid net additions | 663,000 |
| Home broadband net adds | 4 lakh; full year impact 0.16 cr |
| DTH net adds | -39,000, largely due to seasonality |
| B2B revenue growth (FY23) | Just under 16%, highest in the last decade |
| B2B margin expansion (Q4) | 1.3% |
| Connectivity market share | 34%, up 220 bps |
| Revenue market share | 38.7%, lifetime high on a comparable basis |
| 5G coverage | ~3,500 cities and towns, adding 35–40 cities per day |
| Payments bank annualized revenue | ₹1,516 cr, up 18–19% QoQ |
| Digital businesses annualized revenue | Well over ₹1,100 cr |
| Airtel Finance annualized lending run rate | ₹1,200 cr; 2.4 lakh annualized credit card insurance run rate |
| Network opex growth (FY23) | 7.5% for India, despite energy and rollout headwinds |
| Sites added (FY23) | 37,492; fiber added 33,650 km |
| 5G traffic offload | Up to 30% in sites where 5G launched |
| SG&A cost growth (FY23) | 36% (per an analyst's math) |