Key Takeaways
- Tariff repair is the central thesis: Management called Indian pricing "absurdly low" and sees a path from ₹200 to ₹300 ARPU over multiple rounds, but refused to commit to any timeline.
- Bharti Hexacom delivered a one-off ARPU pop: The ₹4 sequential jump was partly driven by the full-quarter resumption of Manipur services after a Q3 shutdown, plus stronger data upgrades in Rajasthan and Northeast.
- Capex has peaked: FY24 was an elevated year with ~4,000 towers added; management guided for clear moderation in FY25, particularly on the wireless radio side.
- Non-mobile engines are building: Homes, B2B, and digital businesses all flagged as growth tailwinds, with the Google Cloud alliance and FWA scale-up as near-term catalysts.
- What to watch next quarter: Any signal on tariff repair timing, the pace of Bharti Hexacom's debt paydown toward a dividend policy, and whether FWA at scale begins to move the broadband net-adds needle.
Tariff Repair: The Industry's Existential Question
- The pricing diagnosis: Management described India's tariff architecture as "broken," with unlimited plans acting as a one-size-fits-all subsidy that lets high-affordability customers pay far less than they could. The current ~₹200 ARPU is, in their view, unsustainably low.
- The ₹300 destination: The stated view is that even ₹300 ARPU would leave India among the cheapest telecom markets globally. The journey there would require "substantial repair" and would not happen in a single shot, implying at least two rounds of industry-wide price action.
- No timeline, no milestone: Management explicitly declined to comment on any specific timing, on the possibility of an annual tariff hike, or on a reported ₹250 ARPU milestone for next year. The commitment is directional only.
- Competitive reality check: Acquisition intensity remains high and "surprising" given modest organic customer growth. Some churn is rotational (buy SIM, throw away SIM), and 5G monetization remains absent, with management hoping "sanity prevails" at some point.
Vittal: "I think the return that the industry really needs is predicated on tariff repair and this is really the heart of the problem that we have today with our pricing and tariffs are at an absurdly low level relative to any other part of the world."
Bharti Hexacom: The Quarter Under the Hood
- ARPU jump had a one-off tailwind: The ₹4 sequential increase (vs. Airtel's ₹1) was partly structural (data upgrades in Rajasthan and Northeast) and partly mechanical: Manipur telecom services were shut for most of Q3 and reopened in early December, so Q3 captured only ~3 weeks of revenue while Q4 had the full quarter.
- Debt reduction accelerated: The company repaid ~₹1,500 Crores of debt in Q4, closing the year with net debt/EBITDA at 2.14x. Management expects further repayment over the next few quarters.
- Capex to moderate: FY24 was an elevated year; FY25 will see moderation, though rural rollout continues.
- Dividend policy waits on deleveraging: The dividend was raised from ₹3 to ₹4 (effectively ₹1.5 to ₹4 post stock split), but a formal dividend policy will only be evaluated once bank debt is repaid or close to repaid. Until then, decisions will weigh profit, cash generation, and future commitments case by case.
- ROE/ROCE target declined: Management would not give a target number, pointing instead to tariff repair and "war on waste" programs as the levers for financial health.
Ray: "I think we still have some debt in our books, bank debts which we expect to get repaid over the next few quarters. Once we get rid of the debt or come close to getting rid of the debt we will evaluate as to how do we define our dividend policy."
Capex Cycle: Peaking and Pivoting
- Wireless capex has peaked: FY24 represented an elevated level driven by the 5G rollout and 33,000+ rural sites over six quarters. Management guided for clear moderation in FY25, particularly on the radio side.
- Rural coverage nearing saturation: Another 25,000+ sites are planned over the next couple of quarters (lower than last year), after which rural coverage will largely saturate. Top 50–60 cities will still need incremental coverage as they grow, but at a much more modest pace.
- Capital is rotating toward growth engines: Transport infrastructure, enterprise (data centers, subsea cables), and homes will see stepped-up investment. Data center and cable investments are lumpy by nature (land, construction, milestone-based).
- 5G cost recognition nearly complete: A large part of 5G-related costs is already in the P&L; a few circles remain and will be done very soon. Depreciation and amortization have not fully peaked because assets are amortized from the month of capitalization, but moderation is expected within two quarters.
- Bolt-on B2B acquisitions possible: Management is evaluating potential acquisitions in the B2B area as part of capital allocation.
Non-Mobility Growth Engines
Homes & Broadband
- Net adds moderated to 3.6 lakhs in Q4, with ARPU declining as entry-level plans pulled the mix lower. Management acknowledged more work is needed given the opportunity size.
- FWA is the near-term catalyst: Now live in 25 cities, scaling to full deployment in the coming eight weeks, with full-scale impact expected in Q2. FWA will run on SA architecture, complementing fiber rather than replacing it.
- Structural programme underway: Expanding fiber presence, driving penetration of converge offers, leveraging digital targeting, and rehauling network infrastructure.
Enterprise & B2B
- Domestic business growing at 18–20% , driven by connectivity share gains, CPaaS solutions (SpamShield on Airtel IQ), IoT, and early expansion into cloud and analytics. The recent Google Cloud alliance targets an Indian cloud market expected to reach $18 billion by 2027.
- Global/wholesale segment remains soft: OTT companies cut back on cable investments and fiber build-out orders, and messaging traffic is shifting from Telco SMS to in-app notifications. This segment is roughly half the enterprise portfolio.
- Private 5G networks: 8–9 private networks currently running for enterprises.
Digital & Other
- Digital businesses grew 50% in FY24 , focused on CPaaS, financial services, IoT, security, and Cloud.
- Payments bank delivered its highest-ever QoQ growth of 22% on savings bank account balances.
- DTH turned around: After two years of decline, the customer base grew by over 200,000 net adds annually, the only operator to grow customers. A moderate price hike driven by broadcaster increases contributed to revenue growth.
Operational Rigour: Churn, Costs, and the War on Waste
- Churn fell from 2.9% to 2.4% QoQ: Structural interventions kicked in 5–6 months ago. The country was divided into 1km x 1km grids, 20–25 churn markers are tracked, and sales and network teams work together on grid-level experience. Churn is split into the first 4 months (acquisition quality) and month 5+ (tenure/experience-related).
- Network cost per site declined in absolute terms for only the second time in company history, despite massive mobile expansion, 5G rollout, and increased power costs. This was enabled by on-ground execution rigour, digital tools, and data science. Management sees further headroom.
- Smartphone upgradation recovering: After the chipset shortage pushed entry-level smartphone prices from ₹5,000–₹5,500 to ₹8,000–₹9,000, consumers took time to absorb the shock but are now returning to purchase, driving higher smartphone shipments year-on-year.
- Postpaid opportunity: Over 8 crore credit-scored customers are eligible to move to postpaid, supported by digital analytics, omnichannel journeys, and small-format stores.
Vittal: "We think of Airtel as having only two types of people those who serve customers and those who serve those who serve customers."
5G: Built, Not Yet Billed
- Rollout is largely done: 5G was deployed at "tremendous speed" using NSA technology, which management says saved capex and delivered a superior experience (recognized by OpenSignal). It is now available across the country.
- Monetization remains absent: Management acknowledged the headwind but attributed it to competitive dynamics, responding to what is happening in the marketplace. The hope is that "sanity prevails" at some point.
- SA pilot underway: Standalone architecture is being piloted in one state and extending to another circle. Mid-band holdings (1800 and 2100 MHz) are key to the SA strategy. FWA will be an SA deployment.
- Cost recognition nearly complete: A large part of 5G costs is already in the P&L, with a few circles remaining. Depreciation and amortization will see some moderation over the next two quarters as the full-quarter impact flows through.
Vittal: "Obviously there is some headwind in terms of monetization, but again it is a competitive market. We have responded to what we have seen happening in the market place and hopefully at some point we will see if sanity prevails."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Capex moderation | Overall capex to moderate, particularly wireless radio side | FY25 |
| Rural site rollout | Over 25,000 sites planned | Next couple of quarters |
| FWA at scale | Full-scale impact expected | Q2 FY25 (coming eight weeks) |
| 5G cost recognition | Remaining circles to be completed very soon; depreciation moderation in ~2 quarters | Near-term / ~2 quarters |
| Bharti Hexacom debt repayment | Bank debt to be repaid | Next few quarters |
| Bharti Hexacom dividend policy | Evaluate defining a policy once debt is gone or close to gone | After debt repayment |
| Rights issue guidance refresh | More formal revised guidance or commentary | Next 3–5 months |
| Tariff repair | Multiple rounds needed to move from ~₹200 toward ₹300 ARPU | No timeline given |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total revenue | ₹1,868 cr, up more than 3.5% sequentially |
| Mobility revenue growth | Upwards of 4% QoQ |
| EBITDA | ₹914 cr |
| EBITDA margin | 48.9%, improved close to 1 ppt QoQ |
| Net income | ₹223 cr |
| Operating free cash flow (full year) | ₹1,467 cr (EBITDA minus capex) |
| Net debt to EBITDA | 2.14 at year-end |
| Debt repaid in Q4 | ₹1,500 cr |
| Network additions (full year) | 4,000 towers |
| ARPU | ₹209, a ₹4 jump QoQ, impacted by one day less in the quarter; added ₹16 in FY2024 |
| Revenue earning customer net adds | 0.67 cr in Q4 |
| Smartphone net adds | 0.78 cr in Q4 |
| Mobile churn | 2.4%, down from 2.9% in Q3 |
| Postpaid net adds | 0.08 cr, steady QoQ |
| 5G customer base | Close to 7.2 cr as of March 2024 |