Key Takeaways
- Consistent earnings delivery: EBITDA per ton held at the INR850 region for the third straight quarter, a stability management says not all major peers have matched.
- Mukutban ramp-up ahead of plan: Variable cost has halved year-on-year, and the unit is tracking ahead of internal projections, with the March exit rate now expected much ahead of schedule.
- Premium strategy pivots to pricing power: Premium share has peaked near 54%; the next leg is raising the premium on products rather than just pushing volume, with Perfect Plus already priced above some A-segment brands in core markets.
- Volume growth levers are operational, not price-led: The 15% volume growth target rests on Mukutban optimization, clinker swapping, debottlenecking, and Chanderia running full steam, with flat pricing assumed for H2.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Prayagraj grinding unit ramps quickly, the pace of Project Shikhar Phase 2 fixed-cost savings, and any demand disruption from elections and the festive season in Rajasthan and MP.
Mukutban Ramp-Up & Cost Transformation
- Variable cost halved: The reduction in variable cost is about 50% from where the unit started exactly a year back, driven by captive mines eliminating high-cost distant limestone and the kiln running longer periods.
- Tracking ahead of plan: Management is hopeful of achieving the March 2024 exit rate much ahead of schedule, with the ramp-up tracking ahead of internal projections.
- Exit utilization target: 55% to 60% utilization by Q4 exit, with no artificial cap: the unit sells wherever economical, including non-trade sales in Gujarat and Maharashtra when pricing is lucrative.
- Two-way volume benefit: Mukutban services southern MP, Gujarat, and Chhattisgarh, releasing clinker capacity from Maihar and Satna; that freed-up capacity then supplies profitable markets in Eastern UP, MP, Bihar, and parts of West Bengal.
- Unit-level profitability undisclosed: Management declined to disclose Mukutban's unit-wise EBITDA per ton or whether it aligns with the consolidated number.
Sandip Ghose: "the reduction in our variable cost is about 50% since then... from where we started off exactly a year back"
Brand & Premium Strategy
- Double-engine brand strategy: Birla Corporation operates simultaneously in the value and premium segments, a positioning management calls rare among peers. In some markets, the combined value-plus-premium franchise makes it the market leader.
- Premium share near saturation at 54%: Management does not want to vacate the value segment; the strategy now shifts to increasing the premium on products rather than just growing premium sales volume.
- Perfect Plus pricing power: In key markets like Eastern UP and large parts of MP, Perfect Plus is priced a couple of rupees higher than some leading A-segment brands, even as those competitors diluted their price position. Birla Corp held both price position and market share.
- Rakshak launched: A super-premium water-repellent cement brand introduced in Maharashtra, positioned against ACC Gold and Ambuja Kavach, with supply to adjoining markets.
- Brand extensions progressing: Perfect Plus Concrete (RMC) is in test marketing via a pilot plant in Lucknow with positive response; waterproofing material and wall putty under the Perfect Plus brand are seeing good trade acceptance.
Sandip Ghose: "We are one of the few companies who offers travel between the popular value, which I call the value segment, and the premium segment simultaneously."
Volume Growth & Capacity Expansion
- 15% volume growth target maintained: Interim volume to come from Mukutban optimization, clinker swapping (including to Durgapur), debottlenecking, and Chanderia running at full utilization. Corporate utilization expected to exit H2 above 90%.
- Chanderia fully stretched: Expansions are fully utilized and the unit is now producing in full steam, contributing additional volume. The plant has operated without blasting for eight years, with management considering the technique perfected and not a handicap.
- Prayagraj grinding unit announced: A new unit entitled to a UP government incentive of 300% of investment, producing fly ash in-market to increase serviceability in a core market. Ramp-up expected very soon.
- Maihar clinker expansion deferred: Originally planned for 2025, the next major clinker capacity expansion at Maihar has been postponed by about a year due to the Mukutban delay.
- Kundanganj incentive offset: Incentives at Kundanganj expire next year; management expects Mukutban incentives to kick in by then, compensating the bottom line.
Cost & Margin Levers
- Project Shikhar Phase 1 delivered ~INR50/ton savings: Phase 2 will tackle fixed overheads and costs, though management cautioned that not much will accrue in the next six months, with results visible going forward.
- Project Unnati underway: A newly disclosed go-to-market initiative covering brand sales distribution, digitization, and logistics. The Integrated Logistics Management System (ILMS) is getting operational in two main plants, providing total visibility of outward movement to the dealer level.
- Material cost headwind: Material consumption cost rose from INR352 cr to INR377 cr sequentially, primarily due to higher slag prices at Durgapur and some increases in outside limestone purchases.
- Fuel cost flat: Q3 fuel cost expected to remain at Q2 levels of INR1.75 per 1,000 kilocal. Raw material prices are budgeted on a static basis with no decline assumed.
- Captive power steady: Expected to maintain at 60% of power requirements.
- Limestone reserve extension: Following the completed Sanghi limestone acquisition, similar plans are in the pipeline for extending limestone reserves.
Pricing & Demand Environment
- Flat price scenario assumed for H2: Management is budgeting a flat price environment from October to March; some price increases were seen in October but slackening in November. Any tailwind would be beneficial but is not factored into plans.
- Price mix improvement of ~3% expected in H2: Driven by mix and geomix rather than outright price increases. Maharashtra saw only a marginal price increase; Telangana had a yo-yo situation with no effective increase.
- Volume growth came through realization, not pricing: Improved realization was driven by premiumization and cost efficiencies.
- Demand risk in core markets: Demand can get affected in Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh due to elections and the festive season, though non-trade demand from infrastructure is sustaining. Management remains confident of 15% volume growth despite these variations.
- Mukutban marketing push coming: Significant, tailor-made marketing activity planned in Maharashtra and Mukutban markets over the next few months to improve brand salience and presence.
Sandip Ghose: "We have a very clear roadmap and our internal visibility on this. And we have also factored in certain tailwinds, but equally we have factored in contingencies in case some of those tailwinds were not to materialize."
Consistency & Competitive Positioning
- Three quarters of steady performance: Management highlighted the consistency of performance over the last three quarters, noting that not all peers, including some major ones, have had such consistency.
- EBITDA per ton target held at INR850 region: Internal budgets are unchanged from the start of the year, with the roadmap factoring in both tailwinds and contingencies.
- Premium strategy shift to pricing, not volume: Having reached a peak in premium volume share, the focus moves to increasing the premium commanded on products rather than just growing premium sales volume, while maintaining a balanced value-premium portfolio.
Sandip Ghose: "I personally think it's been creditable without patting ourselves on the back, is the consistency of our performance in the last three quarters. Not all our peers have had a consistent performance in the last three quarters, including some major ones who have had ups and downs."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth | 15% volume delivery maintained | FY24 |
| EBITDA per ton | INR850 region; internal budgets unchanged | FY24 |
| Mukutban exit utilization | 55%–60% | Q4 FY24 exit |
| Corporate utilization exit | More than 90% | H2 FY24 exit |
| Mukutban March exit rate | Achieved much ahead of schedule; tracking ahead of internal projections | Ahead of March 2024 |
| Fuel cost | INR1.75 per 1,000 kilocal, flat from Q2 | Q3 FY24 |
| Price mix improvement | ~3% increase through mix and geomix | H2 FY24 |
| H2 pricing assumption | Flat price scenario; no increase budgeted | October–March |
| Captive power share | Maintain at 60% of power requirements | Ongoing |
| Project Shikhar Phase 2 benefits | Not much in next six months; results visible going forward | Beyond six months |
| Prayagraj grinding unit | Ramp-up expected very soon | Near term |
| Maihar clinker expansion | Postponed by about a year from original 2025 timeline | ~2026 |
| Kundanganj incentive expiry | Offset by Mukutban incentives kicking in | Next year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| EBITDA per ton | ₹673, achieved in H1 FY24 |
| EBITDA per ton target | ~₹850, maintained for full year FY24 |
| Operating margin | Not stated |
| Net profit | Not stated |
| Volume growth target | 15%, maintained for FY24 |
| Capacity utilization | 87%, up from prior quarters driven by Mukutban ramp-up |
| Capacity utilization exit target | >90%, expected by H2 FY24 end on a corporate level |
| Mukutban production | ~1.5 lakh tons, in September 2024; further increase in October |
| Mukutban capacity utilization | ~40%, till Q2 FY24; exit FY24 target of 55%–60% |
| Mukutban variable cost reduction | ~50%, reduction from same time last year |
| Mukutban exit volume target | 2 lakh tons overall, with Maharashtra at ~1.5 lakh tons by Q4 FY24 |
| Mukutban incentive | ₹600 per ton, budgeted on a longer-term basis |
| Premium product share in trade sales | 54%, of which Perfect Plus contributes 65% of premium volume |
| Perfect Plus share in Mukutban sales | >40%, of premium products sold in new markets |
| Project Shikhar savings | ₹50 per ton, achieved in Phase 1 |
| Project Unnati / ILMS savings | ₹17–₹20 per ton, beginning to materialize |
| Fuel cost | ₹1.75 per 1,000 kilocal, in Q2 FY24 |
| Captive power share | 60%, of power requirements; expected to maintain at this level |
| Material consumption cost | ₹377 cr, up from ₹352 cr in Q1 FY24 due to higher slag and outside limestone purchase |
| Price increase expectation (mix/geomix) | ~3%, expected in H2 FY24 |
| Mukutban lead distance (Maharashtra) | 250–300 km, primary focus area |
| Mukutban lead distance (Gujarat) | 750–800 km, opportunistic market with better pricing |
| Mukutban overall lead distance | 350–400 km, weighted average |
| Prayagraj facility incentive | 300% of investment, under UP government scheme |