Key Takeaways
- Mukutban turned EBITDA positive in March, hitting the milestone ahead of expectations and without incentives, after management deliberately slowed the ramp-up to contain losses from high initial variable costs.
- A credible ₹850/ton EBITDA target for FY24, built on ₹250/ton lower fuel costs, ₹50/ton in identified cost projects, and Mukutban incentives kicking in during H2, with management’s ambition to do better.
- The Reliance acquisition thesis is playing out: management unlocked value not from the physical assets but from the brand (Perfect Plus), distribution integration, and capacity ramp-up that Reliance could not achieve.
- Premiumization and trade focus are protecting realizations: the premium portfolio reached 54%, and a deliberate shift away from non-trade OPC helped hold pricing even as central India softened slightly.
- What to watch next quarter: whether Mukutban’s cost trajectory continues its decline (₹300-400/ton further reduction promised), the pace of volume ramp-up toward the 2,00,000-ton exit target, and any movement on the stuck West Bengal incentive receipts.
Mukutban: The Turnaround Story
- Cost collapsed from start to exit: Variable cost of cement fell from over ₹4,500/ton at startup to under ₹2,800/ton by March, achieved by focusing on cost rationalization rather than chasing volumes at a loss.
- EBITDA positive without incentives: The plant hit breakeven in March before any government incentives flowed, a milestone management says came ahead of market expectations.
- Incentives are the next catalyst: At roughly ₹600/ton, incentives will begin reflecting in the P&L only toward the middle of H2 FY24, because input tax credit from capital expenditure must be consumed first before GST payments begin. Once they kick in, management calls them a "game changer."
- Volume ramp-up is now deliberate and profitable: The plant exited at ~1,00,000 tons, targets an average of 150-160 tons through FY24, and aims to exit at 2,00,000 tons. Management’s stated principle is "ramping up profitably," not ramping up for its own sake.
- Clinker logistics unlock system-wide gains: Mukutban clinker can reach Durgapur as cost-efficiently as from Maihar or Satna, releasing Maihar and Satna clinker for the most profitable UP and Madhya Pradesh markets.
- Market reach expands as costs fall: Currently ~80% of Mukutban cement sells within Maharashtra (Vidarbha, Khandesh, Telangana area); the radius will expand from 150-200 km to 250-300 km as costs drop further, with sales teams already in place.
Ghose: "Our first objective for Mukutban is not to ramp up just for the sake of ramping up but ramping up profitably."
Cost & Margin Roadmap
- Power and fuel cost to drop at least ₹250/ton: From a base of ₹1,500, driven by the newly commissioned WHRS at Mukutban, the Bikram coal mine starting in Q3 FY24, solar initiatives, and higher alternative fuel usage.
- Identified cost projects worth ₹50/ton nationally: Management expects at least this much from specific initiatives, with the stated ambition to do "much better than that."
- Captive coal is the structural unlock: Bikram (starting October FY24) will cover 38-40% of kiln fuel requirement; once Marki-Barka follows (November 2025), captive coal will meet about 60% of total kiln fuel.
- Mukutban cost to fall another ₹300-400/ton: On top of the already-achieved reduction, further step-change savings are expected from raw material and fuel options in FY24.
- Structural cost disadvantages persist vs peers: Management acknowledged that larger capacity (2 crore tons vs 0.45 crore tons next door) forces higher lead distances, and neighbors with captive coal blocks adjacent to their plants enjoy lower power and mining costs. These are not fixable in the near term.
- EBITDA per ton target of ₹850 for FY24: This includes Mukutban and assumes incentives kick in during H2; the strategy is built on prices not rising significantly, with any price increase treated as a bonus.
Saraogi: "Just to give you a sense, when we started Mukutban operation, our variable cost of cement was more than INR4,500 and when we exited in the month of March, it was less than INR2,800."
The Reliance Integration Payoff
- Capacity ramp-up that Reliance could not achieve: When Birla took over, utilization of the Reliance plants was very low; management ramped them to near-maximum capacity.
- Brand built from scratch in three months: The company had only a three-month window to change the brand post-acquisition, creating Perfect Plus and positioning it at the premium end, while retaining the distribution system and sales force.
- Distribution transformed from fragmented to unified: Dealers who previously identified as "Reliance distributor" or "Satna cement distributor" now operate as MP Birla distributors, with top-tier A-category dealers joining the network.
- Manufacturing integration is seamless: Products from both legacy brands are now produced equally from any plant through standardized quality parameters; the UP market is supplied from six different plants without customers knowing the source.
Ghose: "I don't look at the success of the Reliance merger, in terms of just acquiring physical assets of production, the real value of acquisition, which has been unlocked, is by the assets which we created both in terms of the brand, and the distribution or go to market, a route to market, which you would say."
Premiumization & Trade Strategy
- Premium portfolio reached 54%: Management claims the company was "a little ahead of the curve" on premiumization, with Perfect Plus now the flagship premium brand across the entire Hindi Speaking Markets geography, supported by national media.
- Trade focus protected realizations: A deliberate shift away from non-trade OPC, except in very small markets, helped hold pricing even as central India saw slight weakening and headline prices stayed flat.
- Contiguous geographic footprint is a strategic asset: Growth has happened contiguously from Bengal through to the west and down to Maharashtra, unlike the disjointed regional presence of peers, creating logistics and brand continuity advantages.
- Kundanganj optimization shows latent capacity: Rated capacity of 0.2 crore tons was ramped to 0.27 crore tons through internal optimization alone, with no additional investment.
People & Operating Model
- New executive team built from industry veterans: Rajat Prusty joined from Adani (formerly 30 years at ACC) as Chief Manufacturing Officer; Kalidas Pramanik (15 years at ACC, then Coromandel Fertilizer) brings logistics and sales expertise; a new Head of IT joined from Penna Cement.
- OKR methodology introduced: The company adopted the Objectives and Key Results framework (used by Google, Intel, Adobe), working in three-month horizons with specific, visible objectives, explicitly to operate in what management calls a volatile and dynamic environment.
- Tamal Pal heading strategy: Instrumental in securing new mining leases for the captive coal mines Bikram and Marki-Barka.
Ghose: "The importance of OKR is, they realize that today's volatile environment and dynamic environment, you need to keep your end objective clear, your longer-term vision clear, but work in short time horizons of three months with very, very specific objectives with results, which will be visible, which will show you, where you are going."
Incentives & Balance Sheet Items
- Incentive receipts to outstrip accruals: This year, receipt of incentives was about ₹200 crores, similar to accrual; going forward, receipts are expected to outstrip accruals "to a large extent," with Uttar Pradesh procedural delays now resolving.
- West Bengal incentives remain stuck: This is an old, frozen case with no further accrual; the High Court directed the state government to pay, but payment has not been received, and the company has gone back to court. Management expects resolution "sooner than later."
- Kundanganj incentive still has runway: Contrary to suggestions it expired in FY23, the incentive runs through the end of FY24.
- Total incentive quantum is ₹2,300 crores: Disclosed in response to an analyst question.
- Limestone reserves adequate: Each plant has at least 20 years of reserves, addressing scarcity concerns.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth | More than 15% growth in volume terms | FY24 |
| EBITDA per ton | Working with a number of ₹850/ton, including Mukutban and H2 incentives | FY24 |
| Power & fuel cost reduction | Lower by at least ₹250/ton from ₹1,500 base | FY24 |
| National cost savings | At least ₹50/ton from specific projects; ambition to do better | FY24 |
| Mukutban cost reduction | Another ₹300-400/ton reduction | FY24 |
| Mukutban volume exit rate | Exit at ~2,00,000 tons of cement | FY24 exit |
| Bikram coal mine start | Operations to begin | Q3 FY24 (October) |
| Mukutban incentive flow | ~₹600/ton incentives to reflect in P&L | Middle of H2 FY24 |
| Marki-Barka coal mine start | Operations to begin | November 2025 |
| Captive coal coverage | 38-40% of kiln requirement from Bikram; ~60% once Marki-Barka also commissioned | At respective mine commissioning |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| EBITDA per ton (including Mukutban) | ₹615, vs ₹650 in Q4 FY22, a drop of ~₹35 |
| EBITDA per ton (sequential growth) | +₹240 QoQ |
| EBITDA per ton (full year FY23, including Mukutban) | ~₹480 |
| EBITDA per ton target (FY24) | ₹850 |
| Power and fuel cost per ton (Q4) | ~₹1,300 |
| Power and fuel cost per ton (full year FY23) | ~₹1,500 |
| Expected power and fuel cost reduction (FY24) | More than ₹250 per ton from ₹1,500 |
| Volume growth target (FY24) | More than 15% |
| Premium portfolio share | 54% |
| Blended cement share | 85% |
| Mukutban cement volume (March exit) | ~1,00,000 tons |
| Mukutban cement volume target (FY24 exit) | ~2,00,000 tons |
| Mukutban variable cost of cement (March exit) | Less than ₹2,800 per ton, down from more than ₹4,500 at start |
| Mukutban incentive | ~₹600 per ton, total quantum ~₹2,300 crores over 20 years |
| Kundanganj capacity | 0.27 crore tons, ramped up from rated 0.2 crore tons |
| Captive coal meeting kiln requirement (post-Bikram) | 38% to 40% |
| Captive coal meeting kiln requirement (post-Marki-Barka) | ~60% |
| West Bengal incentives outstanding | ~₹140 crores |
| Total incentives received in FY23 | ~₹200 crores |