Key Takeaways
- Flat volumes, profit engine intact: Volume growth was just ~20 bps, but operating profit grew 21% YoY to INR 801 crores, powered by sustained cost efficiencies and benign commodity costs.
- Rural demand has flipped: Rural growth, once 2x urban, has fallen below urban levels, dragging down focus states like UP and Bihar despite market share gains there.
- Small competitors are returning: As commodity prices soften, local players who exited during inflation are re-entering with deep discounts, creating a pricing disadvantage for the market leader.
- Adjacent categories are the growth bet: Cheese, dairy, croissants, and the new Better Snack Co platform are being built out through JVs and innovation, targeting categories with very low household penetration.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether rural demand stabilizes enough to pull focus states back to double-digit growth, and how management navigates the pricing gap as local competitors return.
Demand & Volume
- Consumption story intact but stalled: Biscuit per capita consumption is only 2 kilos, with 370 consumption occasions per annum but just 1 biscuit per occasion, leaving headroom for volume-led growth when demand returns.
- Rural engine sputters: Rural growth has dropped below urban growth after years of outperformance, attributed to a weak monsoon and a soft agricultural economy, despite deeper rural distribution.
- Focus states hit hardest: Growth in UP and Bihar has slowed because these markets are predominantly rural, though Britannia has gained share in all of them.
- Premium mix holds: The portfolio has only shifted toward premium brands with no evidence of downgradation; management says the business stays within a ~20% premium band and would only get hurt if that stretched to 30%.
- Volume growth target deferred: Management wants to grow the top line much faster, but argues that in weak demand, "even throwing money is throwing money at the wall" and demand must correct first.
Varun Berry: "In times like this, Percy, even throwing money is throwing money at the wall, so we've got to make sure that the demand corrects before we start to do that."
Competitive Dynamics
- Local players are back: Smaller competitors who went out of business during the inflationary period are re-entering as commodity prices drop, offering big discounts and margins.
- Market leader's pricing bind: Britannia, as the market leader, must take prices up first when commodities rise and then cut when they soften, creating a structural disadvantage versus nimbler local players who can undercut on the way down.
- Snacking model still unproven: The strategy of nuclear factories with smaller distribution radii to counter the "transportation of air" problem in snacking is still being tested; local players enjoy high margins and discounts, and the jury is out on whether differentiation will be enough.
Varun Berry: "Snacking, as you know, is basically transportation of air, so we were looking at a model whereby we could set up nuclear factories all across the country and have a smaller radius of distribution and hence have an advantage over all of the larger players who have a limited number of factories."
Adjacent Categories & Innovation
- Cheese scaling up: The Bel joint venture is bringing in cheese categories, cream cheese, spreads, and a INR 10 sachet; a new cheese plant commercialized this quarter will start producing cheddar and processed cheese by fiscal year-end, with whey powder, SMP and SCM already consumed by the biscuit business.
- Better Snack Co launched: A new brand platform for healthier snacking debuted with makhana in 3 flavors, launched only in modern trade and e-commerce with reasonably good results so far.
- Salty snacks still in test: The category has been in test markets for 3 years; management will only go national when absolutely comfortable with the marketing mix and confident of a strong right to succeed.
- Core biscuit innovation continues: Jim Jam Pops, 50 50 Golmaal, and a renovated Bourbon were launched; Jim Jam is doing extremely well.
- Dairy ambition growing: Dairy is becoming a big play and management intends to "play much harder there."
Distribution & Reach
- Direct distribution engine still expanding: Direct reach grew from 21 lakh outlets (March 2019) to 27.3 lakh (September 2023); total reach from 54 lakhs to 66 lakhs, with bulk of growth from direct while indirect stayed flat.
- Rural distribution as a counter-cyclical lever: Management believes continued rural distribution growth can counter the rural slowdown, as it has over the past decade when rural growth outpaced urban on the back of distribution gains.
- Urban strength remains: Britannia is stronger in urban markets, with market share 1.3x urban versus rural and distribution 1.2x urban.
Costs, Margins & Commodities
- Profit engine delivered: Operating profit grew 21% YoY to INR 801 crores (18.3% margin), with 24-month growth at 58%, driven by cost efficiency programs that have delivered over INR 2,000 crores of cumulative cost reduction.
- Commodity tailwinds, with risk: Palm oil is deflationary and packaging is positive; flour is inflationary and sugar flattish to slightly inflationary; the Middle East and Russia-Ukraine strife create upside risk that management is watching closely.
- Cost efficiency programs scaled 7x: Structured programs covering truck utilization, distance travelled, market damages, renewable energy, fuel consumption, and line throughput have expanded from 1x to 7x scale between FY23 and FY24.
- Employee cost drop is optical: The large QoQ decline in employee costs reflects base effects from options in the prior year, not a real change; employee costs have been reasonably stable.
- Margin outlook cautious: Management said it is "reasonable to assume" gross margins around 42.5-43%, but gave no formal guidance, citing commodity uncertainty from geopolitical conflicts.
Varun Berry: "Cost efficiencies has been a very strong pillar for our profit growth. We've had more than INR 2,000 crores of cost reduction during this period, and that continues to be a pillar for us even in the future."
International & Factory Footprint
- International delivering: Middle East and Africa are growing double digits with improved margins; Egypt continues to perform well; Nepal is a spectacular growth story on both top and bottom line; Kenya has teething troubles but a good future outlook.
- Factory capacity expanding: Bihar's second factory commercialized with 3 product lines; UP and Tamil Nadu factories operating at desired efficiencies; more lines being added to Ranjangaon.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Focus states recovery | Return to double-digit growth in focus states (UP, Bihar) | "Next quarter onwards" |
| Cheese plant start-up | Cheddar and processed cheese production begins | By end of this financial year |
| Pricing action | Measured pricing corrections taken wherever necessary | Conditional on commodity situation remaining positive |
| Salty snacks national launch | National rollout only when marketing mix is proven | No date; in test market for 3 years |
| Acquisition appetite | Evaluate adjacent-category and near-country opportunities at the right price; will not break the bank | Ongoing; PE money drying up may create opportunities |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹4,370 cr, +1% YoY and +23% on a 24-month basis |
| Operating profit | ₹801 cr, +21% YoY and +58% on a 24-month basis |
| Operating margin | 18.3%, up from 16.3% in FY23 |
| PBT growth | 21% YoY, 53% on a 24-month basis |
| PAT growth | 19% YoY, 53% on a 24-month basis |
| Volume growth | ~20 bps, flattish |
| Gross margin | 42.5–43%, expanded 250 bps over pre-pandemic levels |
| Cumulative price cut from peak | ~1.5%, against a cumulative price increase of 22–23% during inflation |
| Advertising and promotion spend | +1.5% YoY, including grammage-based consumer promotions not fully reflected in P&L |
| Direct distribution reach | 27.3 lakh outlets, up from 21 lakh in March 2019 |
| Total distribution reach | 66 lakh outlets, up from 54 lakh |
| Innovation pipeline annualized revenue | ~₹200 cr |
| Own manufacturing share | 65% |
| Ranjangaon factory capacity contribution | 15% of total capacity requirement |
| Cake market share | ~35% |
| Rusk market share | ~23–24% |
| Cheese market share | ~13–14% |