Key Takeaways
- Credit growth smashed guidance: Advances grew 20% YoY against an initial 8% target, as the feared COVID wave and recession did not materialize and a very good climate for credit demand emerged.
- Asset quality improved sharply: Gross NPA fell from 8.42% to 6.37% and Net NPA from 3.21% to 2.19%, driven by strong cash recoveries of ₹1,876 crores plus ₹1,205 crores from written-off accounts.
- Net profit nearly doubled YoY: An ~89% YoY surge was powered by strong NII growth, robust recoveries, and controlled credit costs, with annualized EPS already at 55.22 against a full-year guidance of 40.
- Tax migration executed cleanly: The bank moved to the lower 25% tax regime with a ₹2,451 crores DTA reduction funded entirely from excess provisions built over 1.5 years, so no P&L hit was taken.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the deposit-rate-led margin compression from the "666" scheme offsets the NII momentum from rising advances, and if the provisioning run-rate of ~₹2,700 crores per quarter begins to decline.
Credit Growth: The 20% Surprise
- Broad-based advance growth: The 20% YoY expansion was spread across RAM (16.4%) and Corporate (25%), maintaining the guided 55/45 mix within a plus/minus 2% band. Agriculture led RAM at ~22%, followed by MSME at ~13% and Retail at 12.52%.
- Corporate pipeline is building: Management sees traction in infrastructure, NBFCs, petroleum, coal products, chemicals, iron & steel, and food processing, with good corporate demand expected in the current quarter.
- Overseas book contributed meaningfully: ₹21,000 crores of the ₹1.4 lakh crores total growth came from overseas advances, mostly lending to foreign banks and high-rated corporates including one Indian Housing Finance company via ECB funding.
- The guidance gap: When pressed on whether 15-20% is the range for "decent double-digit growth," management deflected rather than confirming a specific band, noting only that the initial 8% guidance was far exceeded.
Prabhakar: "When I say 8%, we have shown 20% growth. So, when I say decent double-digit growth, you can understand."
Asset Quality & Recoveries
- NPA ratios improved materially: Gross NPA fell 205 bps QoQ to 6.37% and Net NPA fell 102 bps to 2.19%, with management hopeful of achieving the 6% gross NPA guidance and bringing net NPA below 2% in a shorter period.
- Recovery engine delivered: Cash recovery of ₹1,876 crores was supplemented by ₹1,205 crores from written-off accounts, a difficult task achieved by directly contacting written-off borrowers. Upgradation added ₹1,523 crores.
- Slippages were small-ticket and contained: Total slippages of ~₹3,500 crores were predominantly from Agriculture (₹1,200 crores), MSME (₹1,300 crores), and Retail (₹600 crores), with only ₹400 crores from other accounts.
- Restructured book is shrinking: The RF2 book reduced from ₹24,000 crores to ₹20,000 crores due to ~₹3,000 crores in recoveries, with cumulative slippages in RF2 at ~13%. Combined RF1 plus RF2 came down QoQ to ₹16,000 crores, though MSME OTR adds ₹2,300 crores.
- ECLGS slippages remain low: Out of ~₹18,500 crores disbursed, slippages were only ₹669 crores, or roughly 3-4%.
- Infra NPA declined sharply: Infra NPA reduced by ~₹1,600 crores QoQ to 6.79%, driven by repayments in both regular and NPA accounts.
- Provisioning philosophy is aggressive: In large accounts requiring 15% provision, Canara Bank has made 100% provision. The ₹2,700 crores quarterly provision includes accounts where provisions were made proactively to maintain a healthy PCR of 85.36% and a future-ready balance sheet.
Prabhakar: "I will not comment about the figure, but I will share with you our principles. Our principle is, if you have followed me in the last 2 years, I have always said that I want to have a healthy PCR, and also my balance sheet should be ready for the future."
NII, Margins & the Deposit Trade-Off
- NII grew on multiple engines: NII rose 18.51% YoY and 9.57% QoQ to ₹7,434 crores, driven by 20% growth in interest received on advances, the REPO rate increase impact, MCLR increases, and higher rates on corporate advances.
- The REPO benefit is sticky: The ~₹250 crores additional interest from the July REPO rate increase will continue in the coming quarter, and further NII growth is expected from MCLR increases, corporate rate hikes, and spread increases, not solely from RLLR-linked repricing.
- NIM expanded but deposit strategy creates tension: NIM increased from 2.77% to 2.86%, with a target of 2.90%. However, management chose to pass on 50 bps more than market to depositors via the "666" scheme (7% for general, 7.5% for seniors), arguing that supporting a loyal base of 10+ crores depositors during high inflation secures long-term deposit growth and liquidity.
- The scheme worked for mobilization: The "666" deposit scheme garnered over 8 lakh fixed deposits in 12 days, all from retail customers, providing comfortable liquidity for credit demand.
- Deposit rates are expected to rise further: Management views that deposit rates are bound to rise due to market liquidity conditions, and being first in the market with the 666 scheme gives an advantage.
Prabhakar: "I have a depositor base of more than 10 crores, and my depositors are very loyal to Canara Bank. So, during the time of high inflation, we thought that we have to pass on some benefit to the depositors. ... pass on some benefit to the depositors, they will be with you life-long; that is the concept along with maintaining the margin."
Tax Migration: A 1.5-Year Plan Executed
- Clean migration to the 25% regime: The bank moved from the higher tax rate to the 25% regime during Q2, a move management had been working on for the last 1.5 years.
- DTA adjustment was pre-funded: The ₹2,451 crores reduction in Deferred Tax Assets was funded entirely from excess tax provisions deliberately built up in FY22 and Q1 FY23, so no P&L hit was taken. Accumulated losses meant no tax was technically payable in either period, but provisions were built up precisely for this migration.
- Effective tax rate not disclosed: When asked for the actual effective tax rate for the full year going forward, management stated the statutory rate move to 25% but did not provide the expected effective tax rate.
Prabhakar: "This particular migration from higher tax to lower tax we are working for the last 1½ years. It is not that today we have taken the decision. ... It is a well calculated move which is paying dividend today."
Costs, Capital & Subsidiaries
- Cost-to-income ratio is low but staff costs will rise: The cost-to-income ratio stood at 43.68%, described as one of the lowest. Staff costs declined ₹300 crores QoQ because Q1 included a full PLI payout (15 days) while Q2 had none, and senior staff retiring reduces cost while new recruits cost less. Going forward, staff costs will be moderate but may increase to give maximum benefits to staff given good profits. The next PLI payout will be in Q1 FY24.
- Capital position strengthened significantly: CRAR improved from 14.37% to 16.51% and common equity from 10.09% to 11.14%, positioning the bank for future credit growth.
- Treasury income was soft but manageable: Treasury income was lower this quarter due to market conditions, though proactive actions in Q1 had generated good gains. No significant depreciation impact was felt on the portfolio this quarter, and next quarter the situation is expected to improve with depreciation expected at most ₹200-300 crores.
- Subsidiaries are long-term value bets: CanFin Homes is delivering good operating and net profit, Canara HSBC is seeing very good business traction, and Canara Robeco is described as an excellently managed mutual fund. Management expects these subsidiaries and associates to give huge returns going forward, which is why the bank is not selling its stake. Canara HSBC valuations are expected to be very good when it comes out with an IPO.
Prabhakar: "Today profit in terms of comparison to parent Canara Bank may be less but going forward these companies or subsidiaries are going to give huge returns. That is why we are not selling the stake in these companies."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Credit growth | "Decent double-digit growth" for the full year, significantly above initial 8% guidance | FY23 |
| Gross NPA | Achieve 6% | FY23 |
| Net NPA | Less than 2% "in a shorter period" | Undated |
| NIM | Achieve 2.90%, up from 2.86% | FY23 (March 2023) |
| Tax rate | Statutory rate now at 25%, down from ~35% | Effective Q2 FY23 |
| Staff cost | Moderate going forward; may increase to give staff benefits but not significantly | Ongoing |
| PLI payout | Next payout in Q1 FY24 | Q1 FY24 |
| RAM growth | Continue at 16-18% decent double-digit growth | Ongoing |
| Agriculture growth | Remain around 21% next quarter | Q3 FY23 |
| MSME growth | Move from 13% to 14-15% and continue | Ongoing |
| Deposit growth | Decent double-digit growth expected | Q3 and Q4 FY23 |
| Treasury depreciation | At most ₹200-300 crores next quarter | Q3 FY23 |
| EPS | Improve further going forward; FY23 guidance of 40 is "now history" | FY23 |
| Overall performance | "Do better than what we did earlier" and try to better all ratios | Next quarter |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Net profit | ₹2,525 cr (per an analyst's math), +89% YoY and +25% QoQ |
| Operating profit | ₹6,905 cr, +23% YoY and +4.5% QoQ |
| Net interest income (NII) | ₹7,434 cr, +18.51% YoY and +9.57% QoQ |
| Net interest margin (NIM) | 2.86%, up from 2.77% YoY; full-year guidance 2.90% |
| Return on assets (ROA) | 0.79% for the quarter; March 2023 projection was 0.70% |
| Return on net worth | 18.86% |
| Cost-to-income ratio | 43.68% |
| Earnings per share (EPS) | ₹55.22 (annualized), up from ₹29.86 in Sep 2021; H1 cumulative ₹50.27 |
| Gross NPA ratio | 6.37%, down from 8.42% QoQ |
| Net NPA ratio | 2.19%, down from 3.21% QoQ |
| Provision coverage ratio | 85.36%, up from 82.44% QoQ |
| Credit cost | 1.31% |
| Slippages | ₹3,500 cr (0.35% of loans); breakup: Agri ₹1,200 cr, MSME ₹1,300 cr, Retail ₹600 cr, other ₹400 cr |
| Total business growth | 13.89% YoY; balance sheet at ₹19.58 trillion |
| Credit growth | ~20% YoY; RAM 55% of portfolio grew 16.4%, Corporate 45% grew 25% |
| Deposit growth | 9.82% YoY; 666 deposit scheme mobilized over 8 lakh FDs in 12 days |
| Capital adequacy (CRAR) | 16.51%, up from 14.37% QoQ; CET1 at 11.14% |
| Restructured book | ~₹18,300 cr (RF1 ₹4,420 cr, RF2 ₹12,089 cr, MSME OTR ₹2,300 cr); cumulative slippages RF1 ~3%, RF2 ~13% |
| ECLGS disbursements | ~₹18,000 cr (sanctions ~₹19,000 cr); slippages ₹669 cr (~3-4%) |
| Employee cost | ₹3,119 cr, down ~₹300 cr QoQ due to absence of Q1 PLI payout |
| Liquidity coverage ratio | 122% (90-day average), vs RBI requirement of 100% |