Key Takeaways
- A quarter of quiet execution: Disbursements grew 2% QoQ, asset quality stayed pristine with gross NPA at 0.28%, and the restructured book outperformed all expectations with only ₹1 crore slipping to NPA.
- NIM compression is managed, not alarming: NIM fell 5 bps to 3.55% as cost of funds rose 24 bps, but management committed to holding 3.5% NIM and 2.5% spread for the next few quarters before a long-run glide to 3% and 2.4%.
- The ECL migration is a one-time optics event: Net NPA rose to 0.35% solely because ₹21 crores moved from NPA provisioning to standard provisioning under the new ECL model; underlying credit cost was just 0.04% with zero write-offs.
- CEO succession is the open question: The MD demits office this month, a headhunting agency is shortlisting candidates, and the new MD & CEO is expected by end of Q3 FY23; the board has appointed an interim MD to run assets until then.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the new CEO appointment lands on time, the pace of the self-employed segment recovery back to 30% incremental share, and any further cost-of-funds pressure on the promised 3.5% NIM floor.
Asset Quality & the Restructured Book
- Gross NPA improved: Under IRAC norms, gross NPA moved from 0.3% to 0.28%, reinforcing the company's position as the lowest-NPA player in the industry.
- ECL migration mechanics: The company migrated from IRAC to the ECL model because ECL provisioning (₹208.86 crores) exceeded IRAC provisioning (₹204.83 crores), and regulation requires holding the higher of the two. This triggered a withdrawal of ₹20.31 crores from NPA provisioning and creation of ₹33.5 crores in additional standard provisioning, optically pushing net NPA to 0.35%.
- Net slippage near zero: Gross slippage of ₹12 crores was fully offset by ₹13 crores in recoveries, yielding net slippage of just ₹1 crore. Credit cost for the quarter was 0.04%, and full-year guidance is capped at 0.12% to 0.14%.
- Restructured book outperformance: Out of ₹647 crores in restructured outstanding, 21% of customers are paying in advance, not a single case among those fallen due is in DPD, and only ₹1 crore has slipped to NPA from the entire pool. Initial expectation was 7% slippage (₹49 crores), later moderated to 5% (₹35 crores).
- Zero write-offs: The company has recorded zero write-offs this quarter, last quarter, last one year, and last two years.
- All restructured accounts exit by March: Every restructured loan account will be out of the restructured book by end of the financial year, with exits staggered from December through March.
Girish Kousgi: "Since we are the lowest in the industry, I think a lot of banks draw that comfort, and they lend us at AAA rate rather sometime, we get the best rate."
Margins, Spreads & Cost of Funds
- NIM and spread trajectory: NIM dropped 5 bps to 3.55% and spread dropped from 2.66% to 2.51% because cost of funds increased by 24 bps (5.8% to 6.04%), partially offset by yield improvement from 8.46% to 8.55%.
- Near-term floor: Management committed to maintaining 3.5% NIM and 2.5% spread for the next few quarters, with a long-run expectation of settling around 3% NIM and 2.4% spread as the base grows larger and growth becomes harder to sustain.
- Yield management as a lever: No rate hike was taken in Q2 because the company had increased rates in Q1 and was comfortable on margin. A marginal increase is planned for Q3, and management stated it can moderate yield up or down to protect profitability and return ratios when needed.
- Cost of funds pass-through: The rise in cost of funds was quick, and rates could slightly increase further in the current quarter. If rates stabilize, yields may still increase by a small amount, but management does not expect interest rate increases by a large extent in the next few quarters.
- Borrowing mix shift: CP share in the borrowing mix has declined from 18%-19% to about 8% over the last six quarters, while bank borrowing stands at 54%. No significant change is expected in the next couple of quarters.
- Liquidity buffer trimmed: Previously maintained higher liquidity, but the company has reduced it to 7-8 months because of better planning and improved business and fundraising milestones.
Girish Kousgi: "For the simple reason, I think once we grow on a larger base, showing growth to be difficult. But still, we want to maintain that growth level. And therefore, there, it will be a trade-off between growth and margins."
Growth, Demand & Segment Mix
- Disbursement growth: Sequential growth of about 2%; YoY growth was marginal because Q2 FY22 had a spillover effect from COVID-impacted Q1 FY22, making the base high at ₹2,208 crores.
- Demand breadth: Demand is "pretty good" across all geographies, all segments, and all products, with the affordable segment seeing slightly higher demand than non-affordable. The premium segment is seeing slightly less demand (by about 5%) due to increased construction costs.
- Geographic soft spots: Demand is slightly slow in Kerala and the Delhi NCR region. Karnataka exposure as a percentage of total AUM has come down even though absolute numbers have gone up, because other states are now contributing.
- Salaried vs self-employed: The salaried segment is driving better growth compared to self-employed non-professional, but the self-employed segment is improving every quarter and expected to return to 30% incremental share in another quarter or two. The target incremental mix is 70% salaried and 30% self-employed.
- Growth ambition: The company plans to grow disbursements and the book at 18% to 20% for the next three to four years, explicitly stating it does not chase market share.
- Branch expansion: Four new branches were opened in the quarter, three in Telangana (Hyderabad) and two in Karnataka (Bangalore), because Karnataka and Telangana are the top two performing states in the South. The full-year plan remains 12 to 15 branches, with new branches expected to start disbursements from month one.
Girish Kousgi: "No. See, we don't chase market share. We have a plan, we have a vision and we try to execute to reach there. As of now, our plan is to grow at 18%, 20% for the next three to four years' time."
Builder Funding Pilot
- A tiny experiment: The company is experimenting with builder funding at very small ticket sizes, targeting up to 0.5% of the book over the next three years. The portfolio will shift from 100% retail to 99.5% retail and 0.5% builder funding.
- Pilot posture: Management acknowledged the risk explicitly, calling it "more of a pilot" that will start "very, very small." It will take 12 to 18 months to build even a reasonable, very small exposure, and the company never intends to cross the 0.5% cap within three years.
- Strategy continuity: Apart from this small builder funding addition, there is no change in policy, product, profile, or segment.
Girish Kousgi: "Having said that, we know it's very risky. So we will start very, very small. And this is more of a pilot, I could say."
Leadership Transition
- MD & CEO succession: The MD demits office on 20th October 2022. The task of finding a new CEO has been given to a headhunting agency, shortlisting has begun, and the new MD & CEO is expected to join at the end of Q3 FY23, before the end of the calendar year.
- Interim arrangement: The board has given Girish Kousgi the role of MD to run the assets of the company until a new person joins.
- CFO and CRO hiring: The board decided to hire a CFO and CRO from the market as professionals. Shortlisting is underway for both roles. The existing CFO and CRO are permanent employees with no definite tenure and will continue functioning until new hires join. Mr. Udhaya Kumar has been designated as interim CRO after the superannuation of the previous CRO.
- Business continuity: Management stated that business will be as usual after the MD demits, the team remains, guidance remains, and present momentum will be continued.
Capital, Funding & Provisions
- Capital raise readiness: A capital raise is planned and may happen before March, but may not be the full ₹1,000 crores. Timing and quantum are not decided, but the company is ready to raise capital as and when needed.
- NHB funding pipeline: Around ₹2,500 crores in NHB funding is in the pipeline, with a couple of loan sanctions in the final stage.
- ECL provisioning going forward: Management stated that structurally, ECL is always going to be higher than IRAC, and therefore provisioning going forward will be based on the ECL model.
- Deposit base strategy: The long-term strategy is to increase the deposit base, but near-term action depends on how well it fits into the cost structure, since deposit costs are currently higher than other sources.
- CP and NCD posture: The company is agnostic to funding source as long as the cost is right; if CP rates go up, it will not avail CP. For incremental borrowing, 25% must come via NCD irrespective of cost.
Girish Kousgi: "I think structurally, even though technically, it says IRAC or ECL whichever is higher, but if you see the structure; ECL is always going to be higher compared to IRAC. And therefore, going forward, the provisioning would be based on ECL model."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| NIM and spread floor | Maintain 3.5% NIM and 2.5% spread | Next few quarters |
| Long-run NIM and spread | Settle around 3% NIM and 2.4% spread | Long run (no date) |
| Disbursement and book growth | 18% to 20% growth | Next three to four years |
| Self-employed incremental share | Return to 30% of incremental disbursements | One to two quarters |
| Builder funding exposure cap | Not to exceed 0.5% of portfolio | Within three years |
| New MD & CEO appointment | Candidate to join | End of Q3 FY23, before calendar year-end |
| Restructured book exit | All restructured accounts out of the book | By end of FY23, staggered December through March |
| Full-year credit cost | 0.12% to 0.14% maximum cap | FY23 |
| Branch expansion | 12 to 15 new branches | FY23 |
| Capital raise | May happen, may not be full ₹1,000 crores | Possibly before March |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Disbursements | ₹2,245 cr, marginal Y-o-Y growth vs ₹2,208 cr in Q2 FY22, sequential growth of about 2% |
| Book growth | 22% Y-o-Y |
| Revenue growth | 40% Y-o-Y quarterly, 38% half-yearly |
| Operating profit growth | 33% Y-o-Y quarterly, 37% H1-on-H1 |
| PAT growth | 15% Y-o-Y quarterly, 31% half-yearly |
| NIM | 3.55%, down 5 bps QoQ; near-term guidance 3.5%, long-term 3% |
| Spread | 2.51%, down from 2.66% QoQ; near-term guidance 2.5%, long-term 2.4% |
| Portfolio yield | 8.55%, up from 8.46% QoQ |
| Incremental yield | 9.02% |
| Cost of funds | 6.04%, up 24 bps from 5.8% QoQ |
| Incremental cost of funds | 6.48% |
| Gross NPA (IRAC) | 0.28%, improved from 0.3% QoQ |
| Net NPA (ECL) | 0.35%, up from 0.3% under IRAC last quarter due to migration to ECL model |
| Credit cost | 0.04% for the quarter; full-year guidance 0.12% to 0.14% |
| Total provision in books | ₹279.94 cr, comprising ₹131.33 cr standard, ₹77.53 cr NPA, ₹67 cr restructured, and ₹3.38 cr for undisbursed commitments |
| Restructured book outstanding | ₹704.85 cr (including interest accrual), original principal outstanding ~₹647 cr; provision held ₹67 cr |
| Stage 2 loans | ~₹1,050 cr, provision held ~₹60 cr; combined with restructured book ₹1,750 cr |
| Slippages | ₹1 cr net (₹12 cr gross slippages, ₹13 cr recovered) |
| Write-offs | ₹0, no write-offs in the last two years |
| Employee expenses | ₹17.83 cr, vs ₹22 cr in Q1; normalized ex-provisions ~₹16.87 cr vs ~₹16.8 cr in Q1 |
| Average business per employee | 31, marginal increase from 30.87 QoQ |
| Branches | 4 new branches opened during the quarter; FY23 plan remains 12–15 branches |
| DSA sourcing mix | 79% of originations, rest from branches |
| Self-construction share of advances | ~30% (including plot purchase and construction) |
| LTV on self-construction | ~65% (without composite) |
| Rack rate | 8.75% |
| CP share in borrowing mix | ~8%, down from 18%–19% six quarters ago |
| Bank borrowing mix | 54% |
| Unutilized bank lines | ~₹3,860 cr; total commitment line including NHB pipeline ~₹8,800 cr |
| Liquidity | 7–8 months of requirements |
| Investment income (SLR, LCR) | ₹41.52 cr as of Sep 30, vs ₹19.12 cr as of Jun 30 |
| Capital raise | Planned, may be partial amount before March; DR below 8, capital adequacy comfortable |