Key Takeaways
- Disbursement hit by internal distraction, not demand: The Ambala branch fraud in July forced a quarter of process tightening, training and centralized controls, pulling disbursements below last year's Q2 level. Management expects to catch up in H2 and still cross INR10,000 crores for the full year.
- Spread and NIM improved as rate hikes flowed through: The portfolio saw the full-quarter benefit of the last rate hike on INR5,500 crores of loans, lifting spreads and NIMs. Management reiterated full-year guidance of 2.5% spread and 3.5% NIM.
- Restructured book slippage tracked above initial estimates but provisioning is pre-funded: About 14% of the exited restructured pool slipped into NPA versus an expected 10%, and management added a second overlay of INR17.28 crores. Total provisions of INR85 crores are deemed more than sufficient.
- A deliberate pivot to higher-ticket loans is underway: The APF channel launched in July targets INR25 lakh to INR1 crore properties, and the aspiration is to lift the average HL ticket size from INR22 lakhs to INR27–30 lakhs over three years, accepting some spread compression to get there.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether October's normalized run rate delivers the promised INR1,000 crores/month disbursement pace, the final restructured book picture as the November tranche crosses 90 days, and any quantification of the RBI penal-interest guideline impact.
The Ambala Fraud: Impact and Operational Reset
- One-off confirmed, INR39.67 crores provided: Extensive review found the fraud was isolated to the Ambala branch only; the final crystallized net amount was fully provided for in Q2.
- Disbursement momentum broken by process diversion: Post-fraud, management introduced centralized disbursement (live 3 October), centralized reconciliation, strengthened credit sanctioning, and branch-level training across all 208 branches. These activities diverted frontline focus from business generation through the quarter.
- Centralized disbursement mechanics: Branches now submit requests by a 12:00 noon cutoff; head office performs an additional maker-checker verification before routing to Canara Bank for DD collection by 4–5 PM. Sanctioning authority remains decentralized at branches.
- Operational TAT not expected to suffer: Management stated the new controls will not materially increase turnaround time or affect customer servicing.
Suresh Iyer: "it is confirmed once again that it is purely a one-off incident in one of the branches at Ambala and it is not found in any of the other branches."
Spread, NIM and the Rate-Hike Pass-Through
- Q2 NIM lift was mechanical: In Q1, only part of the INR5,500 crores portfolio reset benefited the quarter; Q2 captured the full three-month effect. The remaining INR6,000-odd crores of the book has yet to reset and will provide further uplift in coming quarters.
- Cost of funds held flat: MCLR-linked bank term loans saw small increases, offset by commercial paper raised at slightly lower rates. The majority of bank borrowings are repo-rate linked and unchanged. NHB limits are exhausted, with fresh sanctions expected in October/November, which would provide the cheapest borrowing avenue.
- Incremental lending rate slightly up: Festive-season discounts offered earlier were largely pulled back, though this was also true in Q1 so the QoQ impact was minor. A small festive scheme for new customers was announced at a slightly lower rate.
- The buffer is being deployed for growth, not margin expansion: On a steady-state basis without the segment shift, spreads and margins would have risen. Management is instead using the buffer to offer competitive rates in higher-ticket segments, with a firm floor of 2.5% spread.
Suresh Iyer: "this rate hike is yet to have the full impact... on a steady-state basis, if we had not changed gears or if we had not changed the segment, probably we would have seen an uptick in the spread and margin, but we would like to enter the new segment, and this is a good time where we can use this buffer to offset that thing and enter the new market."
Restructured Book: Slippage and Provisioning
| Metric | Detail |
|---|---|
| Restructured pool that exited moratorium | INR460 crores |
| Slippage into NPA from exited pool | ~14% (INR64 crores), versus ~10% initially expected |
| Remaining restructured pool yet to exit | INR210 crores (last tranche exits November) |
| Expected additional slippage | Less than INR30 crores, even at the same 14% rate |
| Total provisions held | INR85 crores (INR68 crores mandatory + INR34.28 crores in two management overlays) |
| Additional prudence | Entire non-NPA restructured pool of INR613 crores treated as Stage 2, even where technically Stage 1 |
- Provisioning adequacy: Management believes the INR85 crores total provision is more than sufficient and does not foresee any additional requirement from the restructured book. The final picture will be clear by March, when the November tranche crosses 90 days past due.
- Recovery efforts strengthened: Additional staff are being deployed on the recovery front.
Suresh Iyer: "So going forward, from the restructured book, we don't expect or foresee any kind of additional requirement that may come."
Growth Strategy: Higher Tickets, New Channels
- APF channel launched in July: Targeting CAT B and CAT C developers with project sizes of 100–150 units, property values of INR25 lakhs to INR1 crore, and a focus on the 2 BHK/3 BHK segment. Early response has been good.
- Ticket size aspiration: Average HL ticket size to move from INR22 lakhs to INR27–30 lakhs over the next three years, driven by the INR25 lakh+ segment push and the APF channel.
- Demand by segment: The INR25 lakh–INR50 lakh and above-INR50 lakh segments showed improvement in Q2 versus Q1. The affordable housing segment may be slightly slow post-CLSS withdrawal, but mid-size demand is healthy across all operating markets.
- Channel mix target: Over a 2–3 year horizon, management wants the DSA channel to reduce from 80%+ to about 60%, with 20% from APF, 10% from digital sourcing, and 10% from walk-ins and repeat loans.
- Competitive posture: No single player is seen as overly aggressive; Can Fin will offer good rates to retain good customers and is comfortable using the rate-hike buffer to push growth while holding the 2.5% spread floor.
Suresh Iyer: "we would not hedge -- we are now a little more comfortable in offering a good rate to push growth. And that is what has been our indication from the beginning that if we have that buffer, we will definitely use it to push growth."
Asset Quality and Credit Costs
- GNPA marginally up seasonally: The move from 0.55% to 0.57% is seasonal and in line with March and June results.
- Standard asset provisioning decreased by INR7 crores: The 0–30 day bucket absolute value came down, the portfolio moved to regular payments, and the overall SMA-0/1/2 pool reduced. The ECL model uses a 5-year repayment analysis.
- Normalized credit cost: Write-offs are expected to run at not more than 10 bps.
- Prepayment uptick is manageable: The absolute QoQ increase in prepayment and amortization was only INR100 crores total, or roughly INR30 crores per month across 208 branches.
- RBI penal-interest guideline flagged, not quantified: The guideline that penal interest cannot be compounded or be a percentage of the loan "will have an impact," but management has not quantified it.
Financial Outlook: ROA, Efficiency and Capital
- ROA settling toward 2%: Management would prefer 2.2%–2.3% but acknowledges that as the book grows and the mix shifts to higher-ticket loans, 2% is a more appropriate long-run expectation.
- Cost-to-income ratio to rise temporarily: IT transformation expenses will push the ratio to about 18%–18.5% over the next two years; beyond that, book growth should absorb costs and bring the ratio down.
- IT transformation underway: Most processes (centralized disbursement, lead sourcing, reconciliation, CRM) were implemented by end-September and went live 1 October. The system integrator vendor is expected to be finalized by mid-November, with no expenses incurred so far this year.
- Capital and leverage: Up to 18% AUM growth can be funded from internal accruals; beyond that, management would look to capital markets. Gearing will not exceed 8x.
- Effective tax rate lower in Q2: Around 20%, benefiting from a deferred tax asset of about INR13 crores arising from the Ambala provision.
Suresh Iyer: "I would love to have a ROA of 2.2%, 2.3%. But as the size increases, as we also are moving into the slightly higher ticket size loans, I think we'll have to be a little more... I would say figure of 2% in the longer run would be a little more appropriate rather than looking for an increase in the ROA rather of 2.3% or 2.4% from the current level."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Full-year disbursement | Cross INR10,000 crores | FY24 |
| Quarterly disbursement run-rate | INR3,000 crores per quarter | Q3 and Q4 FY24 |
| Monthly disbursement run-rate | INR1,000 crores per month | From October onward |
| Spread floor | Not below 2.5% | Ongoing |
| Full-year spread and NIM | 2.5% spread, 3.5% NIM | FY24 |
| Disbursement growth | 20% year-on-year | Next 3 years |
| AUM growth | ~18% (with 20% disbursement growth and current prepayment levels) | Ongoing |
| Average HL ticket size | Move from INR22 lakhs to INR27–30 lakhs | Next 3 years |
| Cost-to-income ratio | ~18% by year-end; 18%–18.5% during IT transformation | FY24; next 2 years |
| ROA | 2% (excluding one-time items) | Ongoing |
| Credit cost (normalized write-offs) | Not more than 10 bps | Ongoing |
| Gearing ceiling | Not beyond 8x | Ongoing |
| Restructured book resolution | Complete picture available | By March FY24 |
| Channel mix | DSA 60%, APF 20%, digital 10%, walk-in/repeat 10% | 2–3 year horizon |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Disbursements | ₹4,000 cr in H1 FY24, targeting at least ₹10,000 cr for the full year |
| Loan book growth | 16% YoY, slightly down due to Q2 disbursement shortfall |
| Net interest margin (NIM) | 3.62%, improved QoQ; full-year guidance maintained at 3.5% |
| Spread | 2.6%, improved QoQ; full-year guidance maintained at 2.5% |
| Gross NPA | 0.57%, marginally up from 0.55% QoQ due to seasonal impact on non-restructured book |
| Provision coverage ratio (including management overlay) | ~63% |
| Profit after tax (ROA) | 2.01%; would have been 2.21% excluding the one-time Ambala fraud provision |
| Total provisions made in Q2 | ₹72 cr, including ₹39.67 cr for Ambala fraud (100% provision) and ₹17.28 cr management overlay |
| Restructured book slippages to NPA | ₹64.18 cr moved into NPA during Q2, representing ~14% of the ₹460 cr restructured pool that had exited moratorium |
| Restructured book outstanding | ₹63.20 cr yet to exit restructuring (October/November), with total restructured pool originally at ~₹680 cr |
| Cost-to-income ratio | 16.25%; expected to rise to ~18% by year-end due to IT transformation and branch expansion |
| Average ticket size (home loans) | ₹22 lakhs; targeting ₹27–30 lakhs over the next 3 years |
| Average ticket size (non-home loans) | ₹8 lakhs |
| Prepayments and amortization | ₹1,165 cr in Q2, up from ₹1,025 cr in Q1 |
| Investment income | ₹31 cr, flat QoQ |
| Gearing | Below 8x; management comfortable not exceeding 8x |
| Credit cost guidance (normalized) | Not more than 10 bps for absolute losses and write-offs |
| Disbursement growth target (medium-term) | ~20% YoY disbursement growth over the next 3 years |