Key Takeaways
- SSG negative, but full-year target stands: Same-store sales growth was -3% in Q2, yet management is not revising the 4-5% full-year target, betting on a 7-8% recovery in H2.
- Gross margin expanded on sustainable markup: Passing raw material cost corrections to customers and increasing per-unit markup drove ~200-300 bps of gross margin expansion, which management calls sustainable.
- Volume tells a healthier story than value: Like-to-like volume grew +1% in H1 while value fell, because lower average selling prices masked underlying unit demand.
- Store rollout behind plan, Q3 catch-up promised: Only 23 net stores opened in H1 against an 80-85 full-year target; October already added 10, with a similar pace expected through November and December.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the festive-season SSG uptick holds into the post-Diwali months, the pace of store openings against the Q3 catch-up promise, and any clarity on the SSG calculation discrepancy.
Same-Store Sales & Demand
- SSG dragged by calendar shifts and sluggishness: Demand was sluggish in Q1 and worsened in Q2, amplified by the preponement of Shradh and Raksha Bandhan moving 10 days earlier, which created a prolonged period of shopping refrain in August.
- Festive season turned positive: The 28-day window from post-Shradh to Diwali delivered "very decent" positive SSG, and management says the season is going good going forward.
- Volume vs value split: Like-to-like volume grew +1% in H1, but value declined -1.25% because average selling price fell. Management passed raw material cost corrections to customers through lower prices, so the unit demand signal was healthier than the revenue number suggests.
- Demand is broad-based geographically: Growth is coming from both urban and rural areas, with 13% volume growth equally split between metro and Tier 2/3 cities.
- SSG calculation discrepancy unresolved: The presentation showed 3.48% while management stated -3% for Q2. Management explained the life-to-life comparison method but did not reconcile the two figures.
Bansal: "we are not revising our any estimate 4% to 5% what we are on a totality basis for the year should come. Yes, we understand for this achieving 4%-5% number we need to have it 7% to 8% growth for the remaining six months and which are very hopeful that should come."
Margins & Profitability
- Gross margin expansion mechanism: Gross margin expanded ~200-300 bps in Q2 and ~240 bps in H1. The company passed raw material cost benefits to customers via lower prices, but simultaneously increased its markup per unit, so margin per piece rose even as selling prices fell.
- EBITDA margin under pressure from SSG: EBITDA margin was slightly lower on a percentage basis because same-store sales were negative while fixed costs remained unchanged, and new stores take time to mature.
- Bigger stores trade PSF for better profitability: Larger stores have lower per-square-foot revenue, which management calls the industry norm, but deliver better EBITDA margin and overall profitability because retail cost as a percentage is lower.
- Depreciation rising with store profile: Higher depreciation reflects roughly 100 store openings over the last 1.5 years (90+ company-owned), larger average store size of 1,600 sq ft, higher capex per store, and Ind-AS 116 lease rental conversion.
Bansal: "This markup is sustainable."
Store Expansion & Retail Footprint
- H1 openings lagged, Q3 acceleration underway: The company opened 23 net stores in H1 against a full-year target of 80-85. October added 10 stores, and management expects a similar pace in November and December to cover the shortfall.
- Footprint now at 556 stores: The network comprises 425 company-owned and 135 franchisee stores, with retail area crossing 7 lakh sq ft as of September 30, 2024.
- Ladies and kids exclusive stores planned: The company will open approximately 40 exclusive ladies and kids stores to highlight the Cantabil ladies collection, signaling a push to build category identity beyond the core menswear brand.
Bansal: "bigger stores tend to have a lower PSF but that's the norm of the industry because when you increase the store the PSF tends to go down. But your EBITDA margin shouldn't go down, your realization shouldn't go down."
Category Strategy & Fast Fashion
- Fast fashion entering the mix: The company plans to make 25% of its collection fast fashion, with the design team already working on it. The approach modifies the existing collection rather than adding new SKUs, and the product will be available across all stores.
- Brand DNA constrains the pivot: Management was explicit that the majority of the brand remains basic, minimalistic fashion and that it "can't change the DNA of the brand completely," framing fast fashion as a complement, not a transformation.
- Ladies and kids share targets set: At the ₹1,000 Cr revenue target, ladies wear is expected to contribute 15-20% and kids 6-7%. Ladies wear share should rise to 12-13% in the nearer term.
- Accessories ratio stable at 5%: The category mix has not shifted meaningfully.
- Margin differences across categories are narrow: All categories operate above 50% gross margin, at roughly 52-53%, with only 1-2% variation between categories. Management did not provide a specific accessories margin.
Bansal: "we are planning to go with the like 25% of the collection which should be in the category of fast fashion. But majority of the brand is about basic fashion, minimalistic fashion. So, we can't change the DNA of the brand completely."
Channels & Working Capital
- Online growing off a small base: E-commerce revenue grew from ₹6.5 Cr to ₹10 Cr in Q2, with H1 growth at 32%. The FY27 target is 8-10% contribution, aiming for double digits.
- Inventory build is seasonal, not structural: Inventory was higher as of September 30 because winter inventory was piled up. Existing store inventory increased only ~2%, with the bulk of the cash outflow in H1 going toward inventory for new stores plus the winter build.
- Inventory days to hold at ~120: Management expects this level to persist.
- Capex fully funded internally: The warehousing-cum-office facility capex will close by this financial year, and all capex is from internal accruals with no additional equity needed.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Same-store sales growth | 4-5% for the full year, requiring 7-8% in H2 | FY25 |
| New store openings | 80-85 net new stores | FY25 |
| Revenue growth | 15-18% | FY25 |
| EBITDA margin | 26-27% | By December |
| PAT margin | Approximately 10% | FY25 |
| Gross margin | Maintain above 55% | Ongoing |
| Revenue target | ₹1,000 crores | FY27 |
| E-commerce contribution | 8-10% of revenue | FY27 |
| EBITDA margin (long-term) | 28-30% | Coming years |
| PAT margin (long-term) | 10-12% | FY26-27 |
| Warehousing capex completion | Fully closed | This financial year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹151.2 cr, +12% YoY vs ₹135.1 cr in Q2FY24 |
| Revenue from operations (H1) | ₹279.1 cr, +13% YoY vs ₹246.9 cr in H1FY24 |
| EBITDA | ₹34.6 cr vs ₹29.6 cr in Q2FY24 |
| EBITDA margin | 22.8% vs 21.9% in Q2FY24 |
| PAT | ₹6.6 cr vs ₹7.5 cr in Q2FY24 |
| PAT margin | 4.3% |
| Volume growth (H1) | 15.5% |
| Same-store sales growth | -3% |
| Same-store sales growth (H1) | -1.2% |
| Gross margin expansion | ~200-300 bps YoY |
| Store count | 556 (425 company-owned, 135 franchisee-operated) as of Sept 30, 2024 |
| Net store additions (H1) | 23 stores |
| Retail area | 7+ lakh sq ft as of Sept 30, 2024 |
| Online revenue | ~₹10 cr, up from ~₹6.5 cr in Q2FY24 |
| Revenue growth guidance (FY25) | 15%-18% |
| EBITDA margin guidance | 26% to 27% by December |
| Store expansion target (FY25) | 80 to 85 new stores |
| Total CAPEX guidance (FY25) | ₹40 to ₹50 cr |