Key Takeaways
- Muted quarter, SSG still negative: Revenue grew 7% YoY but same-store sales declined 4%, driven entirely by an ASP reduction as raw material cost benefits were passed to customers.
- Margin compression from operating deleverage: EBITDA margin fell to 30.9% from 34% YoY, as store expansion costs were fully incurred while SSG was absent; e-commerce mix shift added ~1% of margin pressure.
- Store expansion engine intact: The company opened larger-format stores (1,700 sq ft average) and launched footwear as a new category across 50 stores and 4 exclusive outlets, with 80–90 new stores planned for FY25.
- ₹1,000 crore target delayed, not abandoned: Management now expects to hit the long-standing revenue milestone by mid-FY27, a few quarters later than the prior mid-FY26 target, citing SSG headwinds.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Q4 SSG stabilizes as guided (flat to slightly negative), any early read on footwear sell-through, and whether the election-year demand recovery materializes from April.
Same-Store Sales & Demand
- SSG decline driven by ASP, not volume: The 4% SSG drop came from a 4% ASP reduction as raw material price correction was passed to consumers via lower MRP, not higher discounting; quantity decline was only 0.9%.
- Winter category held stable: ~60% of Q3 value came from winter products; the late onset of winter recovered by January, and discounting levels were unchanged year-on-year.
- Shirts and trousers the weak spot: The slowdown concentrated in regular, non-seasonal items like shirts and trousers, while winter performed in line.
- No tier-based divergence: SSG trends were uniform across Tier 1/2 and Tier 3/4 towns, with no geography-specific pattern.
- Q4 outlook subdued: Management expects flat or slightly negative SSG in Q4, with January numbers described as slightly muted; demand improvement is anticipated from April onward, linked to election-year money entering the market.
Bansal: "Due to the reason that our main SSG is negative due to the fall in the ASP. So we are planning to like increase our margins and there will be an increase in the ASP. So, with the increase in the ASP we hope that our SSG will be back to the normal."
Margins & Cost Structure
- Operating deleverage the core pressure: EBITDA declined significantly in Q3 because manpower and rental expenses were fully incurred on the expanded store base while same-store sales growth was absent; the 4% margin reduction is attributed to store growth costs running ahead of revenue.
- Gross margin held at 59%: Gross margin after factory labour was maintained at 59% for the 9-month period, with no reduction; the margin pressure sits below the gross line.
- E-commerce mix a structural drag: E-commerce sales reached ~6% of revenue and caused a ~1% reduction in overall margin; the segment itself is at break-even.
- Bigger stores, lower PSF: New stores average 1,700 sq ft versus the company average of 1,200 sq ft; per-square-foot sales tend to decline in larger stores, though retail cost remains the same, so total revenue rises.
- Procurement push underway: Management expects a couple of quarters to see results from procurement negotiations; maintaining current gross margin is described as a challenge, but improvement is possible.
Nigam: "EBITDA margin keeping 28%-30% in mind and 17%-18% of the margin we are keeping. So that would be all the plan."
Store Expansion & New Formats
- FY25 expansion plan intact: The company plans to open 80–90 new stores next financial year despite muted demand, with the mix remaining 75% COCO and 25% FOFO.
- Larger-format stores the new norm: New stores are being opened at ~1,700 sq ft, materially above the 1,200 sq ft company average, and are meeting sales expectations while achieving breakeven in 1.5 years, unchanged from prior cohorts.
- High street preference: New store locations will be predominantly on high streets rather than in malls.
- Women's category scaling: ~33 exclusive women's stores are currently operating, with 11–12 more in the pipeline and 15–20 expected to open this year; women's merchandise will be entirely outsourced or third-party fabricated, with no in-house production planned.
Bansal: "In the new markets, we are doing slightly bigger stores. Our new average store size in the last quarter is coming to be something like 1700 square feet. And our average company store size is 1200 square feet."
Footwear Launch
- Early-stage category test: Footwear was introduced in 50 older, larger-format stores and 4 exclusive footwear stores, with 2 more exclusive stores in the pipeline; management will decide on further expansion after 6 stores are operational.
- Not retrofitting all old stores: Footwear will not be expanded to all existing stores due to space constraints; however, ~70% of new stores will include footwear.
- Separate discounting structure: Footwear uses flat discount only and cannot be mixed with apparel promotions like buy-2-get-5 due to different margin profiles.
- Too early to quantify: Management declined to share footwear contribution per store, citing only ~2 months of operations since launch.
Women's & Kids Category
- Revenue trajectory improving: The women's category is performing well, with new stores delivering good revenues; per-square-foot sales are lower than men's but improving year-on-year, and winter saw good growth.
- Higher retail cost structure: Retail cost is higher in women's and kids stores than in men's stores, though management did not address analyst questions on discount and return proportions relative to the men's business.
- Outsourced manufacturing only: Women's merchandise will be exclusively outsourced or fabricated through third parties; no in-house production is planned, reflecting a deliberate sourcing strategy for the category.
Bansal: "Initially, there was some error also in our part because we are new into the ladies and the kids category. But right now, we have also got the right strategy to expand in the ladies and the kids category."
Balance Sheet & Operations
- Interim dividend declared: 20% per equity share.
- Manufacturing capacity expanding: Factory capacity is being enhanced to ~18–20 lakh pieces by the end of this financial year.
- Inventory days expected to improve: Management expects inventory to be slightly lower in terms of days by financial year-end.
- Raw material and job work fluctuation: Variations in raw material expense and job work charges reflect the mix of own manufacturing versus job work; last year had higher inventory pressure and more cash flow tied up in inventory, so less job work was done.
- Equity raise rationale: When asked why equity was raised when the company was debt-free and internal approvals sufficed for 20–25% growth, management stated that an FII wanted to participate in the growth plan and it would help improve margins; the question of whether expansion plans would accelerate was not directly addressed.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Store expansion | Open 80–90 new stores | FY25 |
| SSG recovery | Return to positive SSG, driven by ASP and margin increases | Next financial year |
| Q4 SSG | Flat or slightly negative | Q4 FY24 |
| Demand improvement | Election-year money to lift demand | From April onward |
| Long-term EBITDA margin | 28%–30% | Longer-term basis |
| Long-term PBT margin | 17%–18% | Longer-term basis |
| ₹1,000 crore revenue target | Target unchanged, with ±10% tolerance | Mid-FY27 (delayed from mid-FY26) |
| Footwear expansion decision | Decision after 6 exclusive stores operational | After 6 stores opened |
| Manufacturing capacity | Enhanced to 18–20 lakh pieces | By end of current financial year |
| Inventory days | Slightly lower in days terms | By end of current financial year |
| Gross margin improvement | Results from procurement negotiations | A couple of quarters |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹174 cr, +7% YoY vs ₹163 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Revenue from operations (9M FY24) | ₹421 cr, +11% YoY vs ₹380 cr in 9M FY23 |
| EBITDA | ₹53.9 cr vs ₹55.9 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| EBITDA margin | 30.9% vs 34% in Q3 FY23 |
| Profit before tax | ₹30.9 cr vs ₹36 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| PBT margin | 17.7% vs 22.2% in Q3 FY23 |
| PAT (9M FY24) | ₹43.9 cr vs ₹50.4 cr in 9M FY23 |
| PAT margin (9M FY24) | 10.4% vs 13.3% in 9M FY23 |
| Gross margin (9M FY24, after factory labour) | 59%, maintained YoY |
| Same-store sales growth (SSG) | -4%, ASP -4% and quantity -0.9% |
| SSG volume (9M FY24) | -0.5% |
| Store count | 533 EBOs, 379 company-owned and 134 franchisee; 66 stores added in 9M FY24 |
| Retail area | ~6.38 lakh sq ft as of Dec 31, 2023 |
| E-commerce revenue share | ~6% of total revenue for FY24, up from 2.5% last year; ~1% margin impact |
| Inventory | ₹250 cr as of Dec 31, 2023 vs ₹238 cr last December |
| Revenue target | ₹1,000 cr, now expected by mid-FY'27, extended from mid-FY'26 |
| Interim dividend | 20% per equity share |