Key Takeaways
- Maiden call, milestone year: Cantabil crossed ₹500 crores in sales for the first time, with PAT nearly doubling, and held its first-ever earnings conference call.
- Same-store strength drove the beat: Q4 revenue grew 30% YoY on the back of 13%+ same-store sales growth and higher volumes, not price hikes.
- E-commerce is small but the margin wildcard: Online sales hit 2.5% of turnover with a target of 6–7% in FY24, but management concedes e-commerce growth will require some gross margin compromise.
- Store rollout is steady, not accelerated: The plan is 70–80 new stores per year, funded internally, with a path to 700 stores by March ’26; management explicitly ruled out a faster pace.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether same-store sales growth holds at the 5–6% guided level, the pace of inventory-day reduction toward the 130–135 day target, and any gross margin erosion as e-commerce scales.
The Quarter: How ₹500 Crores Was Crossed
- Topline surge: Q4 FY23 sales grew 29.90% YoY to ₹173 crores, lifting full-year revenue 23.96% to ₹552 crores.
- Volume-led, not price-led: Total pieces sold rose from 40 lakhs in FY22 to 50 lakhs in FY23, while management confirmed no price hikes are planned and prices will almost remain the same.
- Same-store engine: Exceptional same-store sales growth of 13+ percent in Q4 was driven by higher average bill values, fine-tuned assortment planning, and incentivized front-end staff trained by an in-house training and development team.
- Profitability leap: FY23 PAT grew 76.67% YoY to ₹67.24 crores, with PAT margin at 12.19%; EPS for the quarter jumped 107.63% YoY to ₹10.34.
- Return ratios: ROE crossed 30% to 30.38% and ROCE stood at 47.22% for FY23.
- Gross margin improved: Gross margin rose to 56% in FY23 from 55% in FY22.
Vijay Bansal: "After opening 5 showrooms like this way, the idea came that we should develop this brand as chain of stores and we started opening showrooms. Then in 2013 we came with the IPO and there was a recession in the market immediately after IPO and many of the competitive brands were closed. This way we struggled for the last 3 years, but our intensions were strong, we enhanced our product quality, reduced the discount, concentrated on visuals so that we can give our customers a world class shopping experience."
Store Expansion: Steady, Tier-2/3, and Internally Funded
- Current footprint: 447 stores at FY23-end, with 69 new stores added during the year; the mix is 70% company-owned and 30% franchise.
- Opening cadence: 6 to 7 new stores per month, translating to 70–80 per year, with the 70:30 company-to-franchise ratio maintained.
- Geography focus: Majority of new stores will come in Tier-2 and Tier-3 towns, where purchasing power has evolved tremendously in recent years.
- Funding: All expansion will be done through internal accruals; the company intends to remain debt-free, with lease liability characterized as a notional IndAS 116 adjustment.
- Store-count trajectory: Expect around 530 stores by end of FY24, around 610 by end of FY25, and 700 stores by March ’26.
- No faster pace: When asked if 650–700 stores could be achieved sooner, management explicitly declined, stating it is difficult to do 700 stores before 3 years and they do not plan to go at a much faster pace.
- Format experimentation: 25 exclusive ladies’ and kid’s wear stores have been opened as an experiment; family stores (currently 18% of mix) and ladies/kid’s exclusive stores (1%) are the two categories that can increase their share.
- Store economics: CAPEX per store is ₹2,000 per sq ft, or ₹25–30 lakhs per store; 50–55 company-owned stores are planned for FY24.
Deepak Bansal: "As purchasing power has evolved tremendously in this Tier-2 and 3 towns in the last few years, so majority of our new stores will be coming in these towns. All new expansion will be done through internal accruals."
E-Commerce: Small Base, Big Ambition, Margin Question
- FY23 performance: Net e-commerce sales crossed ₹13.5 crores, representing 2.5% of total turnover; the company listed on Myntra, AJIO, Tata CLiQ, Flipkart, Amazon, and Nykaa, and recently launched its own website.
- Omnichannel live: An omnichannel system has been implemented for faster deliveries and a seamless shopping experience.
- Profitability in year one: The company did not achieve very good margins in the first year of e-commerce, though it did not make a loss.
- Targets: E-commerce is targeted to reach 6–7% of total turnover in FY24 and 8–10% in FY25; management is clear about maintaining profitability and targets at least 10% PAT from the e-commerce space in the future.
- The margin trade-off: Management acknowledged that as the share of e-commerce increases, some gross margin compromise will be necessary, which is why the safer gross margin target is 55% even though potential exists to do more.
Basant Goyal: "But we are very clear about the fact that we want to maintain profitability in the e-commerce space as well. ... in the future we are very clear that we want at least 10% PAT from the e-commerce space as well."
Margins & Balance Sheet
- EBITDA margin target: Pre-IndAS EBITDA margin target is 20%; post-IndAS, 30%, with potential to increase 1–2% year-on-year because most costs are fixed in nature and topline growth will generate operating leverage.
- Gross margin guardrail: Targeting to maintain gross margin at 55% or above; the ceiling is set by e-commerce dilution, not by the core offline business.
- Inventory: Inventory days stood at around 140 days, slightly elevated due to new product launches and higher sales expectations; the target is 130–135 days, expected to be achieved in 2–3 more quarters.
- Working capital: Net working capital days at 113; target is 95–100 days, also expected in 2–3 quarters.
- Store replenishment: Fresh inventory is sent to stores 2.5 to 3 times per month, with two seasonal collections (Spring-Summer and Cold-Winter); the End of Season Sale also features fresh collection.
- Debt-free intent: The company intends to remain debt-free; the lease liability on the books is a notional adjustment under IndAS 116, not financial debt.
- Dividend: When cash surplus arises in the future, the company will consider increasing the dividend.
Shivendra Nigam: "Post-IndAS margin whatever the growth would concern, so what we are being expecting in this EBITDA margin, so chances of being taken from the 1 or 2% because mostly the cost is fixed in nature and the moment my topline will increase I will be able to generate more margin to safer side."
CAPEX & Infrastructure
- Three-pronged CAPEX plan: Total CAPEX for the coming 2–3 years is directed at store expansion, the warehousing-cum-office facility (Cantabil House), and enhancing production capacity.
- Cantabil House: A new 1.5 lakh sq ft, 11-story office building is under construction with a total CAPEX of ₹45 crores; ₹25–30 crores will be spent in FY24 and the remainder in FY25.
- Production capacity: Enhancing capacity in the production facility is part of the CAPEX plan for the coming 2–3 years.
Product & Assortment
- Sales mix: Men’s wear currently contributes 85% of sales; at the ₹1,000 crores revenue target, men’s wear is expected to be 83–84%, with ladies’ and kid’s wear share increasing slightly.
- Accessories push: The company recently increased all accessories and is giving bigger space to the accessory segment in new, larger stores.
- Franchise model mechanics: Inventory for all franchise stores sits on the company’s books; sales are booked only as over-the-counter sales to the end-user, with all sales under the company’s GST number and stocks shown in the books including all franchise stores.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Same-store sales growth | 5% to 6% annually | FY24 and each year thereafter |
| Store openings | 70–80 new stores per year, 70:30 company-to-franchise ratio | Annual run-rate |
| Store count | ~530 stores | End of FY24 |
| Store count | ~610 stores | End of FY25 |
| Store count | 700 stores | March ’26 |
| Revenue | ~₹1,000 crores in sales | March ’26 |
| E-commerce share of turnover | 6–7% | FY24 |
| E-commerce share of turnover | 8–10% | FY25 |
| E-commerce PAT margin | At least 10% | Future (no date) |
| Gross margin | Maintain at 55% or above | Ongoing |
| Post-IndAS EBITDA margin | 30%, with potential 1–2% YoY increase | Ongoing |
| Inventory days | 130–135 days | 2–3 quarters |
| Working capital days | 95–100 days | 2–3 quarters |
| Cantabil House CAPEX | ₹25–30 crores spent | FY24 |
| Cantabil House CAPEX | Remainder of ₹45 crores spent | FY25 |
| Debt | Remain debt-free | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹173 cr, +29.90% YoY |
| FY23 Revenue | ₹552 cr, +23.96% YoY; crossed ₹500 cr for the first time |
| EBITDA | ₹41.73 cr |
| FY23 EBITDA | ₹163.65 cr, +28.61% YoY |
| FY23 PAT | ₹67.24 cr, +76.67% YoY; PAT margin 12.19% |
| EPS | ₹10.34, +107.63% YoY |
| FY23 EPS | ₹41.18, +76.66% YoY |
| FY23 ROE | 30.38% |
| FY23 ROCE | 47.22% |
| Gross margin | 56% for FY23, vs 55% in FY22; target to maintain 55% minimum |
| Post-IndAS EBITDA margin | 30%, with potential to increase 1 to 2% YoY |
| Same-store sales growth | 13% plus |
| Same-store sales growth target | 5% to 6% for FY24 |
| Store count | 447 as of 31 Mar 2023, 69 new stores added in FY23; 70% company-owned, 30% franchise |
| Store opening plan | 6 to 7 new stores per month; targeting 70 to 80 stores per year |
| Total retail area | 5.25 lakh sq ft; average store size 1,200 sq ft |
| E-commerce revenue | ₹13.5 cr in FY23, 2.5% of total turnover; targeting 6 to 7% of turnover in FY24 |
| Volume sold | 1.5 lakh pieces in Q4; 50 lakh pieces in FY23 vs 40 lakh pieces in FY22 |
| Inventory days | ~140 days; target 130 to 135 days |
| Net working capital days | 113 days; target 95 to 100 days |
| Revenue per store | ~₹1.4 cr for FY23, ~₹1.6 cr for Q4 (per an analyst's math) |
| Store breakeven | 6 to 8 months |
| FY26 revenue target | ~₹1,000 cr with ~700 stores by March 2026 |