Key Takeaways
- Flattish quarter, export-led miss: Revenue and profit were roughly flat YoY as Red Sea disruptions and Russian sanctions delayed export containers, causing lost sales in Writing Instruments that management does not expect to recover.
- Consumerware holds up, but at a price: The segment grew 5% YoY, though volume growth of 8% signals a mix shift to lower-ASP products and some discounting was needed to move goods in a weak demand environment.
- Glassware is the big bet, now live: Trial production has begun at the new Rajasthan facility, making Cello the only domestic player across all glassware and tableware; saleable output is expected by end-November, with a meaningful revenue contribution in Q4.
- Full-year growth guide softened: The prior 15–17% growth target will “change a little bit” after the soft Q2, though management still expects a “good number” and a much stronger second half, aided by glassware.
- What to watch next quarter: The pace of the glassware ramp-up toward saleable production, whether festive demand in Consumerware sustains into Q3, and any resolution of the export logistics headwinds.
The Export Shock: What Went Wrong in Q2
- Container delays destroyed sales: New sanctions on Russia and the Red Sea scenario created 2–3 month delays in export containers, primarily hitting the Writing Instruments segment; management stated those sales are lost and cannot be recovered completely.
- Russia remains challenged: Domestic difficulties in Russia continue to weigh on that market, adding a second layer of export pressure beyond the logistics snarls.
- Writing Instruments outlook is cautious: The segment is expected to at least match last year’s number, with a chance of slight growth, helped by a seasonally strong final quarter.
Gaurav Rathod: “those were lost sales that I don't think we can recover completely because in those fronts as well in those countries, that sale was lost”
Consumerware: Growth with a Margin Trade-Off
- Topline grew, mix softened: Consumerware posted 5% YoY value growth on 8% volume growth, indicating additional sales came from lower-ASP products; management cautioned against reading the business through a volume/value lens given the INR10 to INR5,000 product range.
- Discounting crept in: Gross margin in Consumerware declined slightly due to “very weak demand” that forced some discounting in the market; management characterized the discounting as limited and noted peers saw far steeper gross profit declines.
- Opalware utilization has room: The opalware facility is running at roughly 75% capacity; full utilization is expected only by next year, not this year.
- Demand recovery would unwind the discounting: Management expects that as demand picks up, the need for discounting comes down, offering a natural margin tailwind.
Glassware: The Next Growth Engine
- Facility is live, ramp-up underway: Trial production has commenced at the state-of-the-art Rajasthan plant; saleable production is targeted by end-November, giving roughly four months of sales contribution this fiscal year.
- Full capacity target: Management aims to exhaust the 20,000 metric ton capacity within the next two years, with the plant expected to be at full capacity by March.
- Product portfolio spans the table: The range includes drinking glasses, tumblers, storage containers, bowls, plates, dinnerware, tea cups and mugs, positioning Cello as the only domestic consumer product company across all glassware and tableware.
- Pricing strategy mirrors imports: Cello will price at similar levels to imported glassware, using supply consistency and price stability as its competitive edge in a fragmented, import-dominated market.
- Margins will take time: Gross margins for glassware are expected to eventually match opalware levels, which are slightly better than other businesses, but only once production is fully ramped up; at lower capacity, margins will be challenging.
- No cannibalization with plastic: Management sees completely separate demand, channels and end-usage between glass and plastic products, so the new line should be additive rather than substitutive.
- Consumerware share set to rise: With glassware coming on stream, Consumerware will become a faster-growing segment and its percentage of the overall mix will definitely increase.
Gaurav Rathod: “Glassware is a production that takes time to settle. It's not something that settles within a month or a couple of months. But once it's settles, it settles for about 10 years, and you don't have to look at it.”
Margins: Holding the Line
- Gross margin steady at 52%: Overall gross margin was maintained at 52% despite the soft quarter, with the Consumerware discounting offset elsewhere.
- Molded Furniture margin pressure was raw-material-led: The gross margin decline in Molded Furniture came from raw material costs, not discounting.
- Industry-wide deflation is a net-neutral: Raw material and energy costs have fallen dramatically year-on-year; Cello has passed on some discount but realization from a P&L perspective has not changed much.
Inorganic and Structural Moves
- Plastic acquisition in due diligence: Cello is exploring an acquisition of a plastic company with a similar but more niche product line, generating INR150–175 crores in revenue; the deal is still on the table with due diligence ongoing.
- WimPlast merger initiated: The process to merge WimPlast into Cello World has begun, and the INR100 crores loan from WimPlast to Cello has been repaid using QIP proceeds.
- Distribution expansion underway: Writing Instruments distribution is targeted to reach over 1.5 lakh outlets by year-end and touch 2 lakh-plus outlets in the next 8–9 months.
- Vertical demerger is a distant possibility: Management said that if glassware becomes too big, a demerger would probably make sense, but it is not currently looking at demerging the three verticals.
Gaurav Rathod: “So, I guess, of course, if we say tomorrow, glassware becomes too big, then kind of it would probably make sense.”
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Medium-term growth | 12% to 15% growth over the next 2 to 3 years | 2–3 year horizon |
| Glassware saleable production | Saleable output from the new facility | End of November 2024 |
| Glassware full capacity | Exhaust the 20,000 MT capacity | Within the next 2 years |
| Glassware plant at full capacity | Plant running at full capacity | By March 2025 |
| Opalware full utilization | Completely use up the opalware facility | By about next year (FY26) |
| Writing Instruments distribution | Reach over 1.5 lakh outlets | By end of FY25 |
| Writing Instruments distribution | Touch 2 lakh-plus outlets | In the next 8–9 months |
| Return to prior growth rate | Go back to 15–17% growth as previously guided and achieved | Will take a couple of quarters |
| Full-year FY25 growth | Previous 15–17% guidance will “change a little bit”; still expects a “good number” | FY25 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹490 cr, flattish YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹132 cr, margin 27% |
| PAT | ₹52 cr, margin 16.7%, growth 2.1% YoY |
| Consumerware revenue growth | 5% YoY |
| Consumerware gross margin | 53.6% |
| Writing Instruments gross margin | 57% |
| Molded Furniture gross margin | 45.4% |
| Revenue mix | Consumerware 68%, Writing Instruments 15%, Molded Furniture 17% |
| Channel mix | General trade 74.6%, export 8.5%, online 10.8%, modern trade 6.1% |
| H1 FY25 revenue | ₹991 cr, YoY growth 3% |
| H1 FY25 EBITDA | ₹267 cr, margin 27% |
| H1 FY25 PAT | ₹164 cr, margin 17% |
| H1 FY25 cash flow from operations | ₹65 cr |
| Glassware plant installed capacity | 20,000 metric tons per annum |
| Glassware plant peak revenue potential | ₹230 cr to ₹250 cr without value addition |
| Glassware plant capex | ₹250 cr |
| Opalware capacity utilization | ~75% |
| Writing Instruments distribution outlets | ~135,000 to 140,000, aspiration of 2 lakh plus |
| New SKUs launched in H1 FY25 | ~100 |