Key Takeaways
- Challenging quarter, one-time P&K hit: Profit was dragged down by a one-time loss on imported DAP and complex fertilizers; excluding this, profit was comparable to the year-ago quarter.
- TAN project economics intact: Despite a rise in capital cost, the project IRR remains a healthy double-digit number, supported by higher gas prices and a new Rajasthan state capital subsidy.
- Subsidy delays strained working capital: A temporary gap in subsidy allocation led to higher borrowings and a sharp increase in finance costs, though an additional INR 80,000 crore has now been allocated and disbursement has started.
- Crop Protection and Specialty Nutrients surge: The business posted strong growth, driven by the Seed to Harvest program and channel expansion, though the high growth rate is partly base-effect driven and H2 volumes are seasonally lower.
- What to watch next quarter: The pace of subsidy disbursement and its impact on interest costs, the contribution from DAP trading in the Rabi season, and the trajectory of IMACID's volumes after its operational correction.
The P&K Shock: One-Time Loss and Subsidy Mechanics
- Root cause of the loss: The company held 3.1 lakh metric tonnes of DAP opening stock on which the government paid a lower subsidy, while procurement prices were high and the rupee depreciated, making it impossible to pass on costs due to the informal MRP cap.
- Subsidy allocation gap: The original subsidy allocation was consumed quickly by escalating gas and imported fertilizer prices, creating a four-to-six-week gap before an additional INR 80,000 crore was allocated.
- Disbursement now underway: The additional subsidy disbursement has started rapidly, and the company is hopeful a substantial portion of its outstanding will be released soon.
- Pursuing the commitment: Management continues to pursue the government on the DAP opening stock loss, citing a prior commitment that the business would be conducted on a no-loss basis.
Baijal: "See, jocularly as they say, sometimes the road to hell is paved with good intentions. The intentions were good, but the way the calculations were done, there was a little, lot to be desired. So, this is a discussion which is ongoing with the government."
TAN Project: Returns Intact Despite Cost Escalation
- Capacity doubled: The Ammonium Nitrate project capacity is being expanded to 2,40,000 tonnes, with completion planned over the next 34 months.
- IRR remains healthy: Higher gas prices create an opportunity for better absolute margins, offsetting the capital cost increase and keeping the IRR in the same healthy double-digit range as originally planned.
- Rajasthan policy boost: A new state investment policy announced in October 2022 provides a substantial capital subsidy payable over 10 years on total project cost, which will further improve project financials.
- Cost-competitive ammonia: The extra 1,06,000 tonnes of ammonia required will come from energy improvement projects and equipment upgrades that are standalone-justifiable, creating a double benefit and a lower cost per tonne versus competitors.
- Shared infrastructure advantage: The combined urea-ammonia plant means overheads and costs are shared, giving the TAN project a structural cost advantage over standalone producers.
Mathur: "Actually, that's a very interesting thing. On the one hand while we've had an increase in our capital cost, but there are positive factors which have also contributed, which have essentially kept our IRR in the same range as it was earlier, which is a healthy double-digit number."
Balance Sheet Strain: Interest Costs and Working Capital
- Borrowing-driven cost spike: Finance costs rose sharply, majorly because average borrowings were higher by about INR 3,000 crore, with interest rate increases playing a smaller role.
- Subsidy delay as the trigger: Delayed subsidy payments forced higher working capital borrowings, making it the key driver of the interest cost increase.
- Relaxation expected: As the subsidy allocation and disbursement situation improves, management expects interest costs to ease going forward.
Crop Protection and Specialty Nutrients: Building a Growth Engine
- Strong headline growth: The business posted significant growth, driven by the Seed to Harvest program which enhanced farmer connect across core markets.
- Base effect and seasonality: Growth numbers are amplified by a lower base, and the quantity of Crop Protection Chemicals consumed in the second half is typically lower, so the H1 run-rate is not directly extrapolatable.
- Channel expansion underway: Management sees scope to expand both the width and depth of the channel in core geographies, with new geographies in the south and west expected to start contributing as progress continues.
- Full-portfolio strategy: The Crop Protection portfolio in existing geographies is built to cover every single crop and every single pest, weed, and fungus, supporting the channel push.
Bulk Fertilizer and Trading: Navigating Policy and Prices
- Volume growth in NPK: Bulk fertilizer volumes, especially NPK, increased substantially, adding to revenue as the company expands into five states where NPK usage is higher.
- DAP price decline: Import prices for DAP declined more than 20% from peak levels during Q2, and NPK fertilizer prices also trended downward.
- Rabi season outlook: With the reduction in DAP procurement prices and if subsidy remains around the earlier level, the company expects a positive contribution from DAP in the Rabi season.
- Informal MRP cap to stay: The industry does not expect the informal cap on DAP MRP to be lifted in the Rabi season.
- Trading strategy recalibrated: Going forward, the company will watch government policy in writing more closely before making decisions, and is looking at portfolio diversification including the NPK business.
- No backward integration into DAP manufacturing: The company keeps examining it but needs a business case; a PLI scheme from the government would spark interest, but as of now acceptable returns on manufacturing investment look unlikely.
Mathur: "I'm not sure I agree with you that this business is uncertain. Actually, the uncertainty, if you look at, barring last year and this year which was a very, very different situation in the world... If you take out this 1.5 year period that has elapsed, it's been a pretty steady business."
IMACID and Gas: Peripheral but Material
- IMACID operational issues corrected: The plant was shut twice during the quarter, once for a turnaround and once due to contractual non-assurances on the offtake side driven by price differentials; the contractual issue has since been corrected.
- Volume recovery expected: IMACID is expected to do reasonable volumes in its Q4 (Chambal's Q3), though management cannot comment on resulting profitability as it is a separate entity.
- Gas price floor: Management expects gas prices to remain at USD 15 or higher and believes they will not return to the USD 10-11 range seen earlier.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| TAN project completion | Capacity of 2,40,000 tonnes | Over the next ~34 months |
| Ammonia surplus for TAN | Achieve 1,06,000 tonnes requirement | Within ~24 months |
| TAN project IRR | Healthy double-digit number, comparable to or better than original | |
| No further P&K trading losses | Based on declining price trends and contracts made; subject to subsidy declared from 1st October | Balance of FY23 |
| P&K subsidy level | Industry does not anticipate significant reduction; expected to remain around current mark | For the NBS rate from 1st October |
| Interest cost relaxation | As subsidy allocation situation improves | Going forward |
| DAP Rabi contribution | Positive contribution expected if procurement price reduction holds and subsidy remains around earlier level | Rabi season |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| One-time loss in P&K business | ₹230+ cr, from higher imported fertilizer prices, adverse USD-INR movement, and lower subsidy on opening DAP stock |
| DAP opening stock (1 Apr) | 3.1 lakh MT, on which government paid a lower subsidy |
| Import price of DAP | Declined >20% from peak levels during Q2 FY23 |
| Current gas price | ~USD 28 per MMBtu (NCV basis) |
| Expected long-term gas price | USD 15 or higher, versus earlier USD 10–11 |
| Urea production (Gadepan I & II) | 5.4 lakh tonnes |
| Urea production (Gadepan III) | 3.43 lakh tonnes |
| Total urea production | 8.82 lakh tonnes |
| Crop Protection Chemicals revenue (H1 FY23) | ~₹500 cr |
| Average higher borrowings (driver of interest cost) | ~₹3,000 cr higher |
| Subsidy outstanding context | Government allocated additional >₹80,000 cr; full-year outlay discussed at ₹2,25,000–2,50,000 cr |
| Ammonium Nitrate project capacity | 2,40,000 tonnes |
| Ammonium Nitrate project cost increase | ~40% increase over earlier ₹1,200 cr investment |
| Ammonium Nitrate project timeline | ~34 months to complete; delay of ~6 months |
| Surplus ammonia availability | ~90,000 tonnes per annum currently; targeting 1,06,000 tonnes within ~24 months |
| DAP import dependency | 55–60% of DAP is imported, not expected to change soon |