Key Takeaways
- Resilient quarter despite shocks: The Biparjoy cyclone and Balasore train accident tested aggregation skills, yet the company achieved considerable soil sales and contained damage, with soiled material estimates falling 10–15% from initial projections.
- Crop protection is the new growth engine: The crop protection chemicals and speciality nutrients segment delivered a sterling performance, supported by a wide range of new product introductions and a seed-to-harvest program that is deepening farmer relationships.
- Subsidy policy remains the dominant P&L variable: A steep NBS rate cut was baked into results via a provision management called “a fairly large number” but refused to quantify, while the special DAP subsidy faces a potential review in December.
- Portfolio strategy absorbs margin pressure: The company is deliberately maintaining product flow across complex fertilisers even at low or negative margins to preserve market share and cross-selling leverage, framing it as a calibrated optimization game.
- What to watch next quarter: The December NBS rate review outcome, the pace of recovery at IMACID, and any government movement on MRP or subsidy policy as the Rabi season progresses.
Cyclone & Accident Recovery
- Damage contained through rapid segregation: The company substantially segregated sound and unsound stock after the Biparjoy cyclone and Balasore train accident, processed sound stock for market, and brought soiled material estimates down 10–15% from initial projections.
- Insurance response underway: Insurance companies provided an INR 20 crore advance payment, and the company is now obtaining approvals to sell salvaged material and settle the claim.
- Sales held up despite weather headwinds: Considerable soil sales were achieved even with rain deficiency in August and early September, demonstrating channel and operational resilience.
Baijal: “I’m very glad that you asked that question. In fact, if you see this quarter, this quarter has tested Chambal’s aggregation skills. And we have not been found wanting.”
Crop Protection & Speciality Nutrients
- Sterling performance, new product wave: The segment was the highlight of the quarter, with a wide range of weedicides, insecticides, and seed treatment products introduced during the period.
- Seed-to-harvest program paying off: The program, described as the cornerstone of the company’s farmer-closeness policy, has yielded immense benefits and supports cross-selling of the broader portfolio.
- B2C scale-up ambition: The product portfolio is lined up to support a INR 1,750 crore top line for at least five years, with no acquisitions planned as of now.
- Japanese partnership expansion: New molecules introduced from Nichino and Nissan signal that Japanese partners are looking beyond their established Indian relationships, with more tie-ups in advanced discussion for molecules going off-patent in coming years.
- Low credit risk: No inventory provisioning was taken on the crop protection side, as the business has been maintained on low credit terms.
Srivastava: “So, if you look at the partnerships which these Japanese companies had, it was already with some established players. But now, if you look at some two, three molecules which we have introduced in last year as well as in this year, these have come from Nichino, and those are coming from Nissan. So, they are also looking beyond, they are also looking at expanding their partnership beyond their established players.”
Subsidy & Policy Environment
- NBS rate cut provisioned but undisclosed: A steep fall in NBS rates was baked into results by writing down inventory and futuristic sales to current NRV; management called the provision “a fairly large number” but explicitly declined to quantify it.
- Special DAP subsidy under review: The special INR 4,500 per metric ton subsidy for DAP could be a subject of review in December, introducing near-term policy uncertainty.
- Government holding MRP steady for now: Management stated the government does not intend to change any MRP, including NPKs, as of now.
- Urea energy norms: industry at the frontier: Management believes further reduction in energy efficiency norms may not be in the best interest of industry or government, noting both plants are already below the 5.5 G Cal category benchmark.
- Gadepan 3 policy cliff looms: The new investment energy benefit scheme runs only until FY26; management refused to predict government policy beyond that, citing dependence on election outcomes, minister composition, and potential deregulation or NBS in urea discussions.
Baijal: “We feel that the norms that the industry today has, if you compare it internationally, we are already amongst the best in the world. Further reduction in that number may not be in the best interest of the industry and the government as well.”
Portfolio Strategy & Margin Management
- Deliberate low-margin flow to hold market share: The company follows a portfolio approach across complex fertilisers, urea, DAP, potash, and CPC-SN, maintaining product flow even at low margins or losses to preserve channel presence and cross-selling capability.
- Calibrated optimization, not indiscriminate selling: Management described the approach as an optimization game between stakeholder expectations, budgets, market constraints, and government policy, with precise execution on timing of liquidation as the key differentiator.
- Price outlook softening: Management expects fertiliser prices to cool in the next quarter, already seeing softness in some NPK grids, with no expectation of rapid escalation from Ukraine war or Middle East developments.
- Complex fertiliser volumes not collapsing: When asked if the historical 3–5 lakh ton volume trajectory would change given subsidy shifts, management responded “we are halfway through the season more or less. I don’t think it will be that fast.”
Baijal: “I would put it this way that we have a redrawn expectation on the business profitability expectation from our stakeholders. And we also have our budgets to meet. We also understand the constraints the market provides and the constraints of the government policy within the four corners. We have to design it in a way that, we achieve to a large extent most of the objectives. So, it is kind of a optimization game between all these issues.”
IMACID & International Operations
- Humdrum performance, recovery expected: IMACID is making profits but had problems; adjustments in rock prices helped, and management expects it to end the year with a reasonable profit, with Q3 or Q4 being good.
- Phosphatic price dynamics: International prices of DAP, NPK, and MOP declined on lower input costs, though lately showing a reversal; sales volumes were higher on a sequential quarter basis.
Capital Projects & Efficiency
- Technical ammonium nitrate project on track: The EPC contract awarded to Larsen & Toubro with Casale, S.A. as technology licensor is progressing well.
- Energy-saving schemes focused on Gadepan I and II: A major scheme for Gadepan III is under study but cannot be discussed yet; management committed to providing an answer by May 2024 on how much surplus ammonia volume will increase from de-bottlenecking turbines and changing the converter basket in Gadepan II.
- Energy-saving benefit tied to gas price assumption: The INR 100 crore savings estimate is staged at a gas price of $16 and will change if gas prices move.
- Nitric acid value chain expansion contingent on absorption: The company will exploit available ammonia capacities, including potential surplus from efficiency projects and Gadepan 3 equipment, rather than building a dedicated ammonia plant; plants will be designed with interoperability for ammonia, WNA, CNA, and further value addition.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Energy-saving scheme answer | Quantify surplus ammonia volume increase from Gadepan II de-bottlenecking and converter basket change | By May 2024, after FY24 annual turnaround |
| IMACID profitability | End the year with a reasonable profit; Q3 or Q4 will be good | FY24 |
| B2C top-line scale | Product portfolio lined up to stand INR 1,750 crore top line | At least five years |
| DAP special subsidy review | Special INR 4,500/MT subsidy could be reviewed | December 2023 |
| Gadepan 3 energy benefit scheme | Current scheme runs until FY26; policy beyond that is uncertain and management will not speculate | FY26 expiry |
| Complex fertiliser volume trajectory | Current volume trajectory not expected to change rapidly; halfway through season | H2 FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Urea production | 9.08 lakh metric tons |
| Urea sales | 8.38 lakh metric tons |
| Urea production by plant | G1: 2.8 lakh tons, G2: 2.69 lakh tons, G3: 3.57 lakh tons |
| Subsidy receivables | ₹550 crore as on September 30, 2023 |
| Subsidy receipts | ₹6,800 crore during Q2 |
| Average gas cost (last 6 months) | 16.7 on NCV basis |
| Power cost | ₹944 crore, vs ₹1,443 crore in Q1 FY24 |
| Freight cost | ₹207 crore, vs ₹214 crore in Q1 FY24 |
| Packing cost | ₹34 crore |
| Urea closing inventory | ~138,000 tons after Q2 |
| Traded fertiliser POS inventory | ~1,19,000 tons (DAP, NPKs, MOPs combined) at end of Q2 |
| Insurance advance received (cyclone/accident claim) | ₹20 crore |
| Crop protection channel inventory (Rabi) | ~50% of Kharif crop level |
| Crop protection price trend (Kharif and Rabi molecules) | Down 10% to 15%, now picking up to last year levels |
| Domestic B2C business topline target | ₹1,750 crore by FY27 |
| DAP inventory in India | 0.22 crore tons (0.22 crore tons) on November 1, equivalent to two months of POS sales |
| NPK inventory in India (all grades) | 0.39 crore tons (0.39 crore tons), around 2.2 months of farmer sale requirement |
| MOP inventory in India | ~0.1 crore ton, almost four months forward sale inventory |