Key Takeaways
- Tepid growth, one-time drags: GDPI growth was suppressed by the 1/n accounting method for long-term non-motor business and the loss of a crop insurance retender; management expects growth visibility to return from Q3 as the 1/n base effect ends.
- Motor third-party reserving hit profits: A conservative step-up in motor third-party provisioning, reflecting rising claim severity and a four-year premium freeze, added 2.31% to the Q2 claims ratio and over 3% for the half-year.
- Combined ratio elevated at 115.3%: The reported combined ratio includes the 1/n impact; even excluding it, the ratio of 112.1% carries a 3% load from the extra motor TP provisioning.
- Expense control provides a cushion: The expense of management ratio fell to 30.5% (29.1% ex-1/n), running below the Board-approved glide path and creating leeway to pursue profitable business in H2.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised Q3 growth visibility materializes as the 1/n base effect rolls off, the pace of the targeted 5-percentage-point improvement in motor OD loss ratio, and any regulatory movement on a motor TP premium hike.
Growth Headwinds & Recovery Path
- 1/n accounting distortion: Long-term non-motor premiums are recognized on a 1/n basis, creating a base effect that suppressed reported GDPI; this accounting treatment ends in September 2025, so growth becomes visible from Q3 onwards.
- Crop insurance loss: The company lost crop insurance business following a retender, which also dragged on GDPI; management says the crop deficit is largely digested, with at most another INR150 crores of impact in H2.
- October signals a turn: While the private sector overall degrew 1.5% in October, Chola MS posted 5.4% growth, reducing its year-to-date degrowth; management is watching whether auto sales momentum sustains through November and December.
- Reinsurance commission tailwind ahead: As 1/n premium flows into the P&L, reinsurance commissions that were deferred will start rising, providing a bounce-back to profitability.
Suryanarayanan: "It is a necessary trade-off between whether you want to have an attrition and have investment book and earnings now and then liability really getting deferred into the subsequent years. So that's the call that the Board really took and that's what is driving."
Claims & Underwriting Performance
- Motor third-party reserving stepped up: Recognizing rising severity in court-awarded claims and the continued absence of a motor TP premium increase for four years, the company increased its reserving; this added 2.31% to the Q2 claims ratio and over 3% for the half-year, with management asserting its provisioning level is a good 10% higher than many peers.
- Motor OD loss ratio under pressure: Motor own-damage claims ratios are moving up for both the industry and Chola MS, reflecting competitive intensity; corrective measures have been taken, including a benefit from the GST rate on parts dropping from 12% to 5%, which reduces claim severity, particularly for the company given its larger commercial vehicle proportion at 37%.
- Motor OD improvement target: The company wants the OD loss ratio to come down by approximately 5 percentage points in H2 from the changes already implemented.
- Health segment mix shift: The health and personal accident segment saw a marginal decline even excluding the 1/n effect, driven by the benefit mix on the overall health book falling from 46%-47% to around 40%.
- Combined ratio composition: The reported combined ratio of 115.3% drops to 112.1% without the 1/n impact; that 112.1% still includes 3% from the additional motor third-party provisioning.
Expense Management & Glide Path
- Expense ratio trending below plan: The expense of management ratio came in at 30.5% (29.1% without 1/n), a 2.2-percentage-point reduction from the corresponding period's 32.7%; this is lower than the glide path plan approved by the Board and presented to the regulator.
- H2 leeway created: Because the expense of management is running below the glide path commitment, the company has room to take on good profitable business in the second half without breaching regulatory limits; this is the last year of the glide path.
Investment & Capital Management
- Portfolio shift toward corporate bonds: The investment book has been moved from heavily government securities to more corporate bonds to increase yield, without diluting the rating profile; government securities now sit slightly above 40%, against a regulatory minimum of 30%.
- Leverage declining by design: Leverage has fallen from 6.1-6.2x, driven by a conscious Board decision on the two-wheeler business; given the absence of price increases and the risk of inflation, the Board opted to write new two-wheeler policies on a 1+5 basis, which reduces leverage now rather than deferring liability into subsequent years.
- Motor book composition shift: Own-damage market share stands at 6.3%, while motor third-party share has been brought down from 5.4% to 4.7%, further impacting leverage.
Reinsurance Strategy
- Accepted business scaled up: Reinsurance accepted volumes are higher than in the past, spread across property, crop, motor, and group health; the economic combined ratio of this accepted business is better than the core business combined ratio.
- Tactical, not structural: Management characterized the move as tactical, triggered partly by the loss of crop business and the opportunity to cut down on commission in the core portfolio; no clear forward commitment was given on whether the strategy continues beyond the current year.
Regulatory & Pricing Outlook
- Motor TP premium frozen for four years: The industry has seen no increase in motor third-party premium rates for four years, even as court-awarded claim severity has risen; management says the industry would welcome a hike effective from April 1, but preliminary regulatory steps would need to begin now for that timeline to hold.
- GST change a tailwind: The reduction in GST on auto parts from 12% to 5% lowers claim severity, a benefit that accrues disproportionately to Chola MS given its 37% commercial vehicle mix.
Suryanarayanan: "We will not talk about the competition's combined ratio or what is shaping it. I think that's outside the ambit and scope of this particular call. We would rather stick to what we are trying to do and what is shaping our combined ratio at this point in time."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Growth visibility | Base effect of 1/n reporting ends, growth becomes visible | From Q3 FY26 |
| Crop insurance residual impact | At most INR150 crores additional drag on growth | H2 FY26 |
| Motor OD loss ratio | Reduce by approximately 5 percentage points from corrective actions | H2 FY26 |
| Expense of management | Remain below glide path, creating leeway for profitable business | H2 FY26 (final glide-path year) |
| ROE band | Direction to remain in 16%-18% ROE band; working to get closer to those levels | Near future |
| Motor TP premium hike | Industry would welcome April 1 effectiveness; preliminary steps needed now | Conditional on regulatory action |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY26 |
|---|---|
| Gross direct premium (GDPI) | ₹1,835 cr for Q2; ₹3,647 cr for H1 FY26 |
| Gross written premium (incl. reinsurance inward) | ₹2,221 cr for Q2; ₹4,217 cr for H1 FY26 |
| Crop insurance GDPI impact | ₹323 cr loss in Q2; ₹383 cr loss in H1 FY26 |
| Premium received in advance (long-term non-motor) | ₹100 cr for Q2; ₹202 cr for H1 FY26 |
| Motor market share | 5.3% |
| Motor OD market share | 6.3% |
| Motor TP market share | 4.7%, down from 5.4% |
| Motor composition | 52% cars, 37% commercial vehicles, 12% 2-wheelers |
| New vehicle share of motor premium | 23% |
| Expense of management (H1 FY26) | 30.5%; 29.1% without 1/n effect, vs 32.7% in H1 FY25 |
| Claims ratio | 81.9% for Q2; 81.5% for H1 FY26, higher by 2.31 ppt for Q2 and over 3 ppt for H1 YoY |
| Combined ratio (H1 FY26) | 115.3%; 112.1% without 1/n effect, including 3 ppt from motor TP provisioning |
| Motor TP reserving impact on CoR | At least 3%; reserving level at least 10% higher than many peers |
| Investment corpus | Over ₹18,380 cr as at H1 FY26 |
| Mark-to-market gains (debt and equity) | About ₹500 cr as at H1 FY26 |
| Profit before tax (H1 FY26) | ₹266 cr |
| Return on equity (H1 FY26, not annualized) | 6.2% |
| Solvency ratio | 2.112x |
| Reinsurance accepted business (H1 FY26) | ₹570-odd cr |
| Government securities portfolio allocation | Slightly above 40%; regulatory minimum 30% |
| Health benefit mix | Around 40%, down from 46-47% in earlier years |
| October 2025 motor growth | 5.4% for Chola MS vs industry private sector degrowth of 1.5% |
| FY25 ROE | Crossed 18%; prior year about 15% |