Key Takeaways
- Revenue surged 62% YoY, but gross margins compressed sharply: Export volume grew 44% YoY as the company expanded its geographic footprint, yet gross margin fell 500 bps YoY to 25.8% on higher input costs.
- The balance sheet is a competitive weapon: Cash-rich procurement (payment by day 3, 2% cash discount) lets the company buy paddy cheaper than peers, while competitor bankruptcies automatically redirect business to a stable, well-capitalized supplier.
- Private label is the sticky, high-margin anchor: Customers who build their own brand on Setia's supply treat it as their "baby" and rarely switch; this, plus own-brand sales, sustains pricing power amid commodity volatility.
- Ramadan pipeline is largely de-risked: 80-85% of current inventory is already sold, with ₹250-275 Cr or maybe 300 Cr expected to ship before Ramadan (22 March), insulating near-term revenue from price swings.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether gross margins stabilize as the paddy cycle progresses, the pace of branded sales growth in new geographies, and any update on the new Gujarat plant's product mix and timeline.
Topline Growth & Geographic Expansion
- Volume-led revenue surge: Q3 export sale volume grew 44% YoY, driving operating revenue up 62% YoY; 9MFY23 export volume grew 58% YoY, with the company registering record-high revenue and profitability for the period.
- Geographic breadth as a moat: The company now exports to 90+ countries, recently entering Central Asian markets like Turkmenistan and Kazakhstan; a wide distribution network allows it to sell at prevailing market prices regardless of procurement cost.
- Country-level momentum: Management flagged remarkable progress in Yemen, Israel, and Egypt, while the Gulfood event in Dubai (Feb 20-24) was expected to bring many existing and prospective customers together.
- Direct-to-supermarket channel: Over 200 supermarkets worldwide work directly with the company, creating a short chain (manufacturer, buyer, consumer) with stable, committed counterparties versus wholesalers.
- Ramadan tailwind: Some Ramadan orders were supplied in Q3 and the flow is continuing; 80-85% of current inventory is already sold, with ₹250-300 Cr of rice expected to ship before 22 March, insulating the quarter from price volatility.
Rajeev Setia: "It's very simple. We buy on one side and sell on the other side like any business. So, if we get, I mean whatever is the cost of procurement accordingly the market price is open and accordingly we sell. The advantage of the company is a very wide distribution around the world."
Margin Dynamics & Procurement Advantage
- Gross margin compression: Gross margin fell from 30.8% in Q3FY22 to 25.8% in Q3FY23, a ~500 bps decline, driven by an increase in input cost; on a QoQ basis, an analyst noted gross margins fell ~100 bps.
- EBITDA still grew strongly: Despite the gross margin squeeze, Q3 EBITDA rose 130% YoY, helped by strong revenue growth, operational efficiency, and moderate freight expenses (freight prices fell this year).
- Cash-rich procurement edge: The company deducts 2% cash discount immediately and pays vendors on the 3rd day, not even a week; this lets vendors "sleep comfortably" and sell cheaper, giving Setia a pricing advantage over competitors.
- Paddy season dynamics: Planted area for paddy increased 10-15% versus last season, yet paddy price is still up approximately ₹10 per kg this year, indicating sustained input cost pressure.
- Inventory is hedged by sales: The company does not buy all material at the start of the season; it buys frequently while simultaneous sales are ongoing, and inventory is hedged by established sales, making it a continuous buy-sell, sell-buy process.
- Margin volatility acknowledged: Management conceded margins have been volatile, calling it "partial nature of this industry as regards to bulk cargo," but emphasized that private label branding and own branding sustain pricing.
Rajeev Setia: "It is partial nature of this industry as regards to bulk cargo is concerned. But in the private label branding and own branding that sustains us for the price."
Brand Strategy: Private Label Stickiness & Own-Label Push
- Private label creates lock-in: Customers who develop their own brand on Setia's supply treat it as their "baby"; after 6-12 months of good quality and reasonable pricing, they do not want to change suppliers due to the high risk, and profitability on this business is very good.
- Customer longevity: Private label relationships include customers of 30 years (from the 1990s), with many 25-year and 20-year-old relationships; sustainability is long.
- Own-brand strategy: The company always tries to sell its own brand first; own label may be sold at break-even initially to enter a country, but margins gradually improve as the brand gains acceptance.
- Branded sales traction: In one African country, supply grew from 4-5 containers a year to over 100 containers as the brand spread; management's endeavor is to increase branded sales in every part of the world.
- India online-first approach: In the domestic market, the company is moving to online channels first (own website, Amazon, Flipkart, Jio Mart) to let the brand become famous before finding distributors, aiming for reasonably good profitability.
- Brown rice launch: A brown rice product has been launched that cooks quickly (~14-15 minutes, same as competitor LT Food's brown rice), and a mechanical roasting process has been restarted for roasted rice.
Rajeev Setia: "He loves his baby the most and we get the price. He does not want to change, it's a very big risk for anyone who is running a brand to change the supplier."
Competitive Landscape & Risk Management
- Competitor bankruptcies are a tailwind: When a competitor goes bankrupt, a huge chunk of their business automatically comes to Setia because buyers look for stable suppliers; the company is choosy, taking only cash business and good-margin buyers, leaving credit-based business for others. (Sankesh Setia)
- No acquisitions needed: Management explicitly declined interest in acquiring competitors' assets: "Absolutely not I will never acquire any company from my own industry. I can expand on my own." The business flows organically when competitors fail.
- Pakistan exits the field: Management noted Pakistan is no longer a competitor because domestic food security means they will consume their own rice; this removes a major rival from export markets.
- Export credit fully insured: Entire export turnover is insured with ECGC under a multiple buyer exposure policy; new buyers are checked online against ECGC adverse risk before shipping; very rarely sells on credit (DA basis), and only to very old buyers known for 20-30 years; new buyers are against payment delivery; even if a buyer refuses cargo, the to-and-fro expense is insured.
- Geographic margin segmentation: Developed markets (Europe, Canada, USA) are premium markets with better prices; USA business requires FDA clearance and commands good margin; Iran is purely turnover business with no margin, sometimes losses; in the Middle East, the company targets smaller customers (5,000-20,000 tons) who pay better, avoiding top-tier 100,000-ton buyers.
Sankesh Setia: "So, anybody gets bankrupt automatically a huge chunk of business comes to us. So, this goes in our favour. So, it makes no sense for us to acquire them automatically the business is anyhow coming there, and we are very choosy at that time, because a lot of times you know because out of our total sale only 2 to 3% of our business is on credit basis means udhar, open credit without LCs or without any bank guarantees. So out of all our business only 23% of the business is like that so sometimes let's say there is an exporter who was exporting 500 crores of rice annually and out of which 200 crores of supplies were on credit basis. So, I will not touch that business, I am not looking for the buyers who buy on credit."
New Initiatives & Capacity Build-Out
- Gujarat plant for diversification: A plant is coming up in the Mundra area of Gujarat, leased by the company from a family concern; products will include sesame seed, groundnut (moongfali), turmeric (haldi), and spices; 99% of customers are into multiple products and ask for other items like tea; the company will go for commodity business in food products where it can make money.
- Storage capacity expansion: The acquired factory (Chatter Chemical, formerly a Solvex mill) has had big warehouses put up and silos are coming; this is mainly for storage because plants are integrated with the existing old factory.
- Online sales channels: The company is selling online through its own website, Amazon, Flipkart, and Jio Mart; Reliance people visited the office 2 days prior and planned to buy in a big way.
- Next-generation involvement: Sankesh and Ankit (next generation) work hard and travel; Sankesh disclosed the order book on the call, which management was initially not interested to share, signaling a more aggressive disclosure posture from the new generation.
- Not entering ready-to-eat: Management explicitly ruled out readymade rice or quick-cooking rice products because they require burning a lot of cash to market and do not sell quickly; preference is to improve existing products.
Rajeev Setia: "It's a monopoly and Pakistan has no Aata, they will eat rice. So, they are no longer a competitor with us; so, sky is the limit and let's see what happens in the future."
Governance & Disclosure
- Earnings call frequency: Management resumed holding earnings calls after a long gap and committed to more frequent calls in the future, expressing regret for the hiatus.
- Conservative governance posture: Management stated the company is historically very conservative and carefully run; on corporate governance, they are "implementing everything" and approaching professionals where needed.
- Unanswered questions: Management declined to quantify the margin difference between branded and non-branded exports, or between developed and emerging markets, calling profitability "very subjective" for a commodity item; also declined to provide gross margin guidance or a quarterly volume breakup of branded vs. traded sales, and could not provide a precise net debtors figure on the call.
Rajeev Setia: "I feel little regret on my part, that I after one or two con-calls after long gap, I have resumed calling and it will be more frequent in the future. This is what I assure."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Earnings call frequency | Hold earnings calls more frequently going forward | Ongoing (starting Q3 FY23) |
| Ramadan shipments | ₹250-300 Cr of rice shipped before 22 March 2023 | Before 22 March 2023 |
| Inventory coverage | 80-85% of current inventory already sold out | Current quarter |
| Gujarat plant | New plant in Mundra for sesame seed, groundnut, turmeric, spices | No date given (coming up) |
| Next earnings call | "Definitely again call or meeting after the annual results" | Post-FY23 annual results |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Operating revenue | ₹353.9 Cr, up 62% YoY from ₹218.9 Cr |
| Export sales value | ₹312.4 Cr, up 66% YoY |
| Export sales volume growth | 44% YoY |
| Gross profit | ₹91.1 Cr, up 35% YoY |
| Gross margin | 25.8%, down 505 bps YoY from 30.8% in Q3FY22 |
| EBITDA | ₹51.4 Cr, up 130% YoY from ₹22.4 Cr |
| EBITDA margin | 14.5%, up 430 bps YoY from 10.2% |
| Profit after tax | ₹37.5 Cr, up 134% YoY from ₹16 Cr |
| EPS | ₹7.2 |
| Total inventory (as of 31 Dec 2022) | ₹439 Cr |
| Branded sales as % of exports | 6–7% |
| Private label as % of exports | ~90% or a little more |
| Countries exported to | 90+ countries, recently touched 91 |
| Direct supermarket relationships | 200+ supermarkets globally |
| Inventory pre-sold | 80–85% of current stock already sold |
| Expected shipments before Ramadan (22 Mar) | ₹250–300 Cr of rice |