Key Takeaways
- Record profit in a regulatory storm: The company delivered its highest-ever quarterly profit despite a cascade of government interventions — broken rice ban, white rice ban, 20% duty on non-basmati parboiled, and MEP on basmati.
- Revenue surged 30% sequentially to ₹400 Cr, driven by aggressive exhibition-led selling and a 35% mix from small packaging (1 kg and 5 kg).
- Inventory is large but largely pre-sold: The ₹626 Cr inventory drew analyst scrutiny, but management says 70–75% is already committed against contracts, and the single-crop nature of rice makes carry-forward necessary.
- The model prizes margin over tonnage: Management explicitly avoids high-revenue, sub-2%-margin customers, instead chasing profitable, quality-sensitive buyers across 92 countries — a strategy it says is far from saturated.
- What to watch next quarter: Gulfood order conversion, the pace of basmati procurement as prices fall, and any concrete movement on the dividend/buyback suggestion that Rajeev Setia has now “taken note” of.
The Regulatory Gauntlet & How the Quarter Was Won
- A quarter of serial shocks: The government imposed a ban on broken rice, then a ban on white rice, then a 20% duty on non-basmati parboiled rice, and finally a minimum export price (MEP) on basmati at $1,200/ton (later reduced to $950/ton).
- Profitability emerged from the chaos: When the MEP was imposed, sales slowed, but the company had cash flow and used the window to buy rice at cheaper prices, which then fed through to margins.
- Exhibition engine fired: The sales team participated aggressively in global food exhibitions — World Food Agro Istanbul, AgroExpo Uzbekistan, Thaifax Thailand, Indus Food Noida — which management credits for the 30% sequential revenue jump.
- Small packs, big contribution: Small packaging (1 kg and 5 kg) made up roughly 35% of Q3 revenue, reflecting a consumer-ready shift that supports the higher-margin, branded approach.
- Red Sea freight risk is passed through: All quotations are offered FoB; when ocean freight spikes, contracts convert to FoB terms and customers absorb the fluctuation. Management says post-COVID, customers have become “habitual” to freight shocks.
Rajeev Setia: “After the COVID, the ocean freight has gone so high, so exorbitant and to some extent our customers have become habitual. They know these kinds of shocks will come and go.”
Inventory, Debt & the Balance-Sheet Debate
- Inventory of ₹626 Cr is not excessive, per management: With quarterly sales crossing ₹400 Cr, the stock level is proportionate. Rice is a single-crop-per-year commodity, so certain varieties must be carried forward across quarters.
- 70–75% of inventory is already sold: The bulk of the stock is held against pre-existing contracts, not speculative accumulation.
- Procurement is year-round, not seasonal: Management pushed back on the assumption that buying happens only in the two-month harvest season, stating procurement occurs throughout the year. If prices are high and customers will not accept higher prices, the company waits.
- Debt is cheap and manageable: Borrowing of ₹150 Cr is low relative to monthly export sales of ₹110–115 Cr. Effective interest cost is 4–5% after the 3% government subvention, which Rajeev Setia called “peanut.”
- Credit is rare and tightly controlled: The company sells almost exclusively on cash-against-documents terms. Only very old, tested customers receive limited credit.
- Inventory valuation discipline: Management emphasized that stock must be valued at cost or market price, whichever is lower. Taking a higher valuation to anticipate future selling prices would paint an inaccurate picture of profitability.
Rajeev Setia: “We have subvention also of 3%. Bank charges 7.5, 7.75 and sometimes close to 8. We get 3% subvention; it is 4 to 5% interest. It’s peanut.”
Customer Strategy: Margin Over Tonnage
- Profitable customers only: The company deliberately avoids high-volume, low-margin relationships — for instance, Saudi Arabian buyers that could generate ₹1,000–1,500 Cr in turnover but yield less than 2% profitability.
- The model is not saturated: Management guaranteed there is still significant scope to increase sales within the small-customer, high-margin framework, with many countries and customers still available.
- 92-country footprint, no concentration: When asked for a regional sales split (GCC, USA, etc.), management declined to give percentages, citing too many countries to break out, and emphasized the business is not country-specific.
- Gulfood is the next catalyst: The company will participate in Gulfood in Dubai (February 19–22, 2024), the largest food event, where it meets 70–80 existing customers from 40–50 countries and adds new ones. Management is “always optimistic” about getting good business from the event.
- Peer context: The highest export revenue among peers is not more than ₹3,000 Cr, and the company is already halfway there, per management’s framing.
Ankit Setia: “I mean there are customers in Saudi Arabia, you can do higher revenues with them. Maybe you know you can do 1,000-crore turnover, 1,500-crore turnover, but in terms of profitability, it will be less than 2%. And working with, you know, such customers, so we avoid them.”
Operations & Automation
- PLC-based automation underway: Over the last three months, the company has been working on automating processing plants, moving from manual to PLC-based systems. An example: paddy drying, which took 20 hours manually but could vary 15–30 hours, is being converted to AI-based, computer-measured parameters for humidity and temperature.
- Gandhidham unit roof repair: The cyclone-damaged C-type roof has been removed and the unit will be ready for production and processing in the coming season.
- Gandhidham diversification intent: Management sees opportunities for food products like peanuts, sesame seed, and turmeric in that port area. Rajeev Setia has it in mind and will “definitely go for it,” but only after developing specialization in buying and quality.
- E-commerce is gradual: The business is “gradually getting up” with repeat orders. The company has started advertising on social media channels (recently spending around ₹1,00,000) and is selling through Amazon, Flipkart, Jio Mart, and its own site. It has also started selling larger packs (25 kg and 30 kg+) online.
- Ready-to-eat is a distant horizon: Ankit Setia feels basmati rice exporting still has significant untapped scope; ready-to-eat products are “for the future.”
Rajeev Setia: “I was recently in Dubai about two months back. What I saw two people are sitting in the office on the computer. They are managing the loading and unloading of containers that was happening. The machine is picking up, machine is putting up.”
Industry Context & Competitive Dynamics
- Industry attrition is real: Rajeev Setia stated candidly that many players in the industry “are no longer existing” and huge bad debts have occurred. The company’s principles have helped it survive.
- NCEL has changed the G2G channel, not banned it: The government formed NCEL for government-to-government exports; private players can now bid on NCEL tenders and supply rice. “It’s not like a ban, only the players have changed.”
- Ethanol has lost its rice allocation: The government withdrew broken rice allocation for ethanol because food supply takes priority for price control. Ethanol manufacturers face raw material shortages and will need to use alternatives like horticulture or straw.
- Basmati crop is flat; non-basmati is down: Basmati production is unchanged year-on-year, while non-basmati production has declined, which management says is why the government took restrictive steps.
- Competitor questions deflected: When asked if the company gained market share in Saudi Arabia due to KRBL’s issues, management declined to comment on competitors and redirected the conversation to its own customer strategy.
Rajeev Setia: “Sanjeev Ji, I should be very, very candid with and clear with you in this industry how many people are no longer existing around. Very huge bad debts have happened and the company, I mean, the company’s principles are such that we are going through all along.”
Capital Allocation: Dividend, Buyback & Cash Deployment
- Dividend and buyback suggestion acknowledged: An analyst proposed a dividend payout of 15–20% of net profits and a buyback. Rajeev Setia said he has “taken note” and will discuss further, but added that he has “not considered” a buyback as yet.
- Cash flows earmarked for raw material: Cash generated will go into the business in coming years, specifically for buying paddy and rice as customers become bigger.
- Diversification is food-only and unplanned: Management is open to opportunities in food products but nothing else, and nothing is “straight planned right now.”
- Basmati procurement is opportunistic: With the crop size 10–15% higher this year and prices falling, management is waiting for prices to come down further before buying more.
Rajeev Setia: “Look very simple first thing first, the size of the crop is 10 to 15% higher this year, one. Secondly, you see it’s the opportunity business also or your business wisdom also plays.”
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Gandhidham unit operational | Roof repaired; ready for production and processing of rice | Coming season |
| Gandhidham food diversification | Will “definitely go for it” in food products (peanuts, sesame, turmeric) | Only after developing buying specialization and quality; no date |
| Gulfood participation | Company exhibiting at Gulfood in Dubai | February 19–22, 2024 |
| Dividend/buyback consideration | Rajeev Setia has “taken note” of the 15–20% payout and buyback suggestion; will discuss further | No timeline; buyback “not considered as yet” |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹400 cr, +13% YoY and +30% QoQ |
| EBITDA | ₹52 cr |
| PAT | ₹39 cr |
| EBITDA margin | 11%–14% (guided range), achieved within this range |
| 9M EBITDA margin | 13.0%, expanded 228 bps YoY |
| 9M PAT margin | 9.5%, expanded 175 bps YoY |
| Small-packaging share | ~35% of Q3 revenue (1 kg and 5 kg packs) |
| Inventory | ₹626 cr as of Dec 31 |
| Inventory sold against contracts | ~70–75% of stock, per sales team |
| Bank borrowings | ~₹150 cr as of Dec 31 |
| Cash balance | ₹250 cr+ |
| Effective interest rate | 4%–5% (bank charges 7.5%–8% less 3% subvention) |
| Basmati raw-material procurement cost | ~25%–30% higher YoY |
| Basmati crop size | 10%–15% higher this year |
| Countries exported to | 92 countries |