Key Takeaways
- Mixed quarter, growth moderation visible: Volume growth slowed in commercial vehicles and tractors, while two-wheelers and passenger vehicles held up. Management calls it a mixed bag but expects a rebound from Q2.
- Powertrain margins compressed by idle capacity: EBITDA/value-add fell from 55%+ to 50–51% over eight quarters, driven by inflation and new plants at Sriperumbudur, Pune and Faridabad running at low utilization. Those plants are expected to fill by Q4.
- Aluminium segment delivered rare Q1 strength: Standalone aluminium revenue of INR 207 crores exceeded Q4’s INR 197 crores, a seasonal reversal, with margins improving on operating leverage rather than metal prices.
- DR Axion integration is working: Margins improved to ~18% in Q1 on better inventory management, operational leverage and technical support from Craftsman, with full-year guidance of 16–17%.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether storage solutions orders actually rebound in Q2, the pace of powertrain capacity absorption, and any decision on backward integration into foundry.
Powertrain: Volume Headwinds & Margin Mechanics
- CV and tractor weakness was telegraphed: Heavy-duty commercial vehicles were muted after a pre-buy in Q4 for OBD norms; tractors softened on uneven monsoon. Only passenger vehicles held their own.
- The margin drag is structural, not mix-driven: Management explicitly rejected mix change as the cause of the 500 bps EBITDA/value-add decline, attributing it instead to inflation and new capacity built over the last two to three years that is yet to be filled.
- Supplementary plants are the main culprit: Three new plants added at Sriperumbudur, Pune and Faridabad are incurring costs with low utilization, shaving percentage points off margins. These are expected to fill by Q4 of this year.
- Cost pressures are persistent: No price increases are possible on existing machining products; wages, welfare, consumables and power costs all rose year-on-year, partially offset by productivity and automation.
- Quarterly trajectory promises recovery: Q1 is the trough; Q2 and Q3 will be better, Q4 far better, as operating leverage returns with higher volumes. Full-year powertrain growth is guided at 15–20%.
Srinivasan Ravi: "I would not attribute to mix change. I would attribute it to mostly the inflation and the increased capacity is what we have built-up, which is yet to be filled in because we had quite a good surge in the last two, three years."
Aluminium Segment: Operating Leverage Kicking In
- Seasonal pattern broke favourably: Standalone aluminium revenue rose from INR 197 crores in Q4 FY23 to INR 207 crores in Q1 FY24, a quarter that is normally weaker. Margins improved purely on operating leverage, not aluminium pricing.
- Two-wheeler demand is stabilising: EV confusion in buyer minds is now clearer, and the segment is expected to show stability in Q2 with some growth. Craftsman supplies two of the top four EV two-wheeler makers, though volumes remain below 1% of the aluminium business.
- Passenger vehicle order book is full: Both Craftsman standalone and DR Axion are accelerating on sales revenue, with good traction in Q2, a small correction in Q3, and very strong Q4 performance expected.
- Lightweighting tailwind is real: Aluminium is now competitive versus iron and forgings for certain applications, making it the preferred choice for new platforms, both EV and ICE.
- Export growth is constrained, not demand-limited: Exports are growing phenomenally but are bottlenecked by casting capacity; management is not confident aluminium exports will increase dramatically because European high pressure die casting capacity remains large.
Industrial Engineering: Storage Slowdown, Q2 Rebound Expected
- Storage solutions dragged the segment: Storage, which is 47% of the Industrial Engineering segment, was hit by a capex slowdown and a wait-and-watch posture among customers. Orders came in late in Q1 but are now being received.
- Inventory correction is largely done: Indirect exports saw some slowdown, but direct exports were not significantly impacted. Management believes the inventory correction has mostly already happened.
- Q2 orders are already better: Orders for Q2 are far stronger than Q1, and a rebound is expected in Q2 itself. The full-year growth path for storage solutions remains 15–20%.
- Segment margins to end flat: Industrial Engineering margins are expected to end the year at similar levels to last year, with storage solutions looking up from Q2 onwards.
DR Axion: Integration Delivering, Margins Guided
- Synergies are tangible and fast: Since the management change on 1 February, DR Axion has seen better leverage on operational costs, technical support from Craftsman, and inventory improvement from very low levels to 3–4 weeks, which saves on material costs and insulates against aluminium price swings.
- Q1 margins hit ~18%, but Q3 will dip: Q2 margins are sustainable at ~18%; Q3 normally dips due to customer plant shutdowns; Q4 is sustainable again. On a full-year conservative basis, management guides 16–17%.
- Customer concentration is narrow but expanding: DR Axion has only three key customers today, but is getting new inquiries from existing and new customers, including a Korean OEM proposing a plant in Pune.
- Cultural integration is ahead of schedule: Management says DR Axion "looks like Craftsman as the day passes," drawing on Korean production culture strengths while adopting Craftsman's aggressive approach to delivery and new product development.
Srinivasan Ravi: "It doesn't look like a company which is a subsidiary. It looks like Craftsman as the day passes. And we are drawing from the Korean strength, which is great production culture and also very meticulous on certain aspects of the business and very aggressive approach towards both the delivery as well as to for the new product development."
Capacity, Capex & the Foundry Bottleneck
- Capex plan held at INR 320–330 crores: Three types of capex are underway: maintenance (INR 150 crores, based on INR 58 crores quarterly depreciation), growth, and automation. Automation capex is partly manufactured in-house and partly sourced from market leaders to reduce manpower dependence.
- Foundry capacity is the binding constraint: There are only about 10 medium-to-large scale foundries in India capable of producing larger critical powertrain parts. This bottleneck affects both domestic growth and export orders. Management is working with foundry partners to increase capacities and aims to crack the bottleneck in the coming quarter.
- Backward integration is under contemplation: Management is considering setting up its own foundry for some portion of casting requirements if the foundry shortage continues to constrain growth, but called it "too early to comment in a public forum."
- Capacity strategy is deliberately agile: Management will not put capacity far in advance of orders; capacity building must be simultaneous with order wins, and agility in project management is the key differentiator.
- China Plus One is a real but slow-burn opportunity: De-risking is happening significantly in powertrain and industrial engineering, but India's manufacturing footprint is very small versus China. Even small wins would increase Craftsman's sales dramatically, but large capacities are a prerequisite that no MNC will place orders without.
Srinivasan Ravi: "Craftsman by itself is too small to say that we will be able to get the bulk of the business or something like that. But I think even a small business increase will -- I mean the sales win will increase our sales quite dramatically. But I think, capacities are the key. Without capacities no customer is willing to venture out and place orders on Indian supplies."
Strategy: EVs, Acquisitions & the Long Game
- EV strategy is pragmatic, not evangelical: Management noted that European markets have stepped back from firm 2035 ICE bans, with three major countries backing out. India-specific born-EV models are under design for FY25 launch, and Craftsman will have a good chance to bid. By 2035, a significant EV percentage is expected in India, but ICE passenger vehicle growth will continue.
- Aluminium content will rise regardless of powertrain: Whether EV or ICE, the trend toward lightweighting means more aluminium per vehicle to reduce weight and increase battery range.
- Acquisitions are on the radar: Management is looking at further acquisitions in powertrain and aluminium segments. DR Axion was complementary (Craftsman: two-wheeler, high pressure die casting; DR Axion: four-wheeler, gravity and low pressure die casting).
- Capital raise possible next year: If China Plus One opportunities materialise at scale, the company may need to raise capital next year. For steady 15–20% growth, it remains self-sufficient.
- Off-highway and construction equipment offer decades of runway: Management sees significant headroom for two to three decades in off-highway vehicles, and construction equipment is expected to pick up in late Q3 or Q4.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Powertrain revenue growth | 15–20% for the full year | FY24 |
| Powertrain capacity absorption | New supplementary plants at Sriperumbudur, Pune and Faridabad filled | By Q4 FY24 |
| Storage solutions growth | 15–20% for the full year; strong recovery starting Q2 | FY24, with Q2 rebound |
| DR Axion full-year margins | 16–17% on a conservative basis | FY24 |
| DR Axion Q2 margins | Sustainable at ~18% | Q2 FY24 |
| Capex | INR 320–330 crores maintained | FY24 |
| Industrial Engineering margins | End the year at similar levels to last year | FY24 |
| Foundry bottleneck resolution | Working with partners to increase capacities | Coming quarter |
| Capital raise | May raise capital if China Plus One opportunities materialise at scale | Next year (FY25) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹1,038 cr, not comparable YoY due to DR Axion consolidation |
| Consolidated EBITDA | ₹218 cr |
| Consolidated EBITDA margin | 21% |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹81 cr |
| Consolidated PAT margin | 8% |
| Standalone revenue | ₹756 cr, +12% YoY |
| Standalone EBITDA | ₹166 cr, flat YoY (₹165 cr in Q1 FY23) |
| Standalone EBITDA margin | 22%, vs 23% in Q1 FY23 |
| Standalone PAT | ₹54 cr, vs ₹56 cr in Q1 FY23 |
| Consolidated debt-to-EBITDA | 1.51 times |
| Standalone debt-to-EBITDA | 1.66 times, vs 1.48 times in FY23 |
| Net debt | ₹1,054 cr, including ₹375 cr DR Axion acquisition payout |
| Capex (Q1 FY24) | ₹81 cr |
| Full-year capex guidance | ₹320–330 cr, maintained; ₹150 cr maintenance, ₹170 cr growth and automation |
| Automotive Powertrain segment revenue growth | +10% YoY |
| Aluminium segment revenue growth (standalone) | +21% YoY |
| Industrial Engineering segment revenue growth | +6% YoY |
| Storage business revenue | ₹78 cr |
| Automated storage revenue | ₹19 cr; static storage ₹59 cr |
| DR Axion (subsidiary) revenue | ₹281 cr |
| DR Axion EBITDA | ₹52 cr |
| DR Axion EBITDA margin | ~18% for Q1; full-year conservative guidance 16–17% |
| Direct export sales | ₹63 cr |
| Standalone powertrain capacity utilization | Just above 60% |
| Aluminium segment capacity utilization | Crossing 70% |
| Consolidated ROC (pre-tax, annualized) | 23% |
| Consolidated ROE (annualized) | 22% |
| Consolidated EPS | ₹35.25 |