Key Takeaways
- Aluminium margin hit is a timing issue, not structural: A 10% drop in aluminium prices compressed reported margins as high-cost inventory cleared, but the underlying pricing mechanism has moved to real-time, limiting future drag.
- Stellantis/Peugeot revenue delayed by testing cycle: The customer insists on a full 4–5 month testing cycle, pushing the previously expected ₹50–60 cr FY23 contribution into FY24, though the overall aluminium business is still guided to grow 20% next year.
- Unplanned ₹70 cr CAPEX signals a new, sizeable aluminium win: A customer order won in April 2022 now requires production start by Q4 FY23, adding ~₹150 cr in annual revenue at full ramp in FY25.
- Management guides 20% growth on value addition, not reported topline: Commodity price swings inflate or deflate revenue; the company asks investors to measure growth on gross profit to see the real work done.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Q3 seasonal weakness is shallower than last year as guided, the pace of aluminium margin normalisation now that real-time pricing is in place, and any further CAPEX creep beyond the ₹275 cr full-year target.
Aluminium Segment: The Margin Story
- Reported margin depressed by inventory lag: The company carries 8–12 weeks of raw material and WIP, so when aluminium prices fell 10% sequentially, billing prices dropped immediately while COGS reflected older, higher-cost inventory. Management estimates ~₹10 cr that would have flowed through EBITDA was lost to this timing difference.
- Pricing mechanism now real-time: Earlier, trailing-quarter aluminium prices were applied to the next quarter, creating a persistent lag loss when prices rose. The market has shifted to current-quarter or monthly averaging, so residual effects into the next quarter are now limited to inventory already on hand.
- Operationally, margins were in line with Q1: Value addition dipped only from ₹71 cr to ₹68 cr QoQ despite the price headwind; if aluminium prices had been stable, revenue would have been ~₹205 cr instead of the reported ₹196 cr.
- Margins are consistent across sub-segments: Two-wheeler (predominantly high-pressure die casting) and industrial/PV/CV (gravity and low-pressure die casting) carry more or less the same margins.
- The 20% FY24 growth commitment is on value addition: Management explicitly ties its aluminium growth guidance to gross profit, not reported topline, because commodity price fluctuations can mask the underlying volume and machining work.
Srinivasan Ravi: "We have been advocating in the past for that top line minus COGS is the value addition and that is the real work the company does otherwise it is a commodity price fluctuation which is either inflating the top line or depressing the top line... So, when we say growth, we say normally that growth in gross profit or growth in value addition."
New Order Wins & Product Pipeline
- Unnamed aluminium customer win (April 2022): A sizable order that was not expected to execute this financial year now requires production start by end of Q4 FY23, triggering ~₹70 cr in additional CAPEX. FY24 is a ramp-up year with ~₹150 cr revenue expected; FY25 should see the full ₹150 cr annualised.
- Stellantis/Peugeot order delayed by testing: Product development is on time and infrastructure is being set up, with samples expected in Q4 FY23. However, the customer requires a full 4–5 month testing cycle even though the product is already tested from a different source, pushing production start to Q2 or Q3 FY24.
- EV startup orders in development: Received orders from a new EV startup early this year; some parts are under development, some in trial production. Revenue is factored in only from FY24 onwards, even though production starts from Q3 FY23.
- EV strategy is selective on parts and pricing: Management is aggressive only on critical parts, avoiding simple parts sold on commodity pricing. With volumes split among 10–20 players, picking winners and commanding higher pricing for lower volumes is essential to avoid losing on automotive-scale pricing expectations.
Srinivasan Ravi: "I would say that we are aggressive to take critical parts, we don't want to take simple parts on a commodity pricing, and plus at automotive pricing we need automotive numbers, volumes. And if it is the volumes are getting split up with 10 to 20 players, and at the same automotive price we stand to lose."
Segment-Level Performance
| Segment | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Auto Powertrain | ▬ Stable | EBIT margin drop described as "optical," driven by disproportional growth in material-heavy business vs machining charges. QoQ EBIT fell only from ₹95 cr to ₹93 cr; value addition rose ₹9 cr. Inflation and suboptimal utilisation in farm-sector plants were headwinds. |
| Aluminium | ▼ Margin optically depressed | Top-line grew from ₹171 cr to ₹196 cr QoQ despite falling aluminium prices. The inventory timing hit masked what management says were operationally in-line margins. |
| Industry Engineering | ▲ Margin expanded | Good overhead absorption, more stable steel prices, and storage solutions driving the bulk of revenue growth. Export orders are growing but not at the 40% H1 rate seen elsewhere. |
| Tractor | ▼ Already at trough | Production was muted earlier than retail/OEM sales numbers indicated. Not expected to drop much further in Q3 as it is already at a very low level. |
- Industry engineering competitive moat: Management claims extremely high entry barriers and no competition from the Indian market for the equipment it ships globally.
- Export traction slower than expected: Global economic headwinds have kept industry engineering exports steady rather than exponential; new customer additions face a ~1 year gap between product development and actual revenue.
Srinivasan Ravi: "Entry barrier is extremely high and where we are not having any competition here from the Indian market... when we are making this equipment and shipping across the world, we don't have much competitors anywhere in the world."
CAPEX & Balance Sheet
- FY23 CAPEX guided to ~₹275 cr: Includes the unplanned ₹70–75 cr for the new aluminium order; management is trying to control the total.
- FY24 CAPEX planned around ~₹250 cr: Assumes 20% growth; net block and capital employed are not expected to increase significantly because depreciation runs at ₹210–220 cr.
- Working capital and debt under control: Top-line growth has not strained working capital, and overall debt remains manageable.
- New aluminium CAPEX is capital-efficient: The additional ₹70 cr is low because existing building and resources from previous years' CAPEX have been diverted to this order.
Srinivasan Ravi: "We are trying to control the CAPEX in spite of the unplanned CAPEX of 75 crore to 275 crores. So, we will be around to 275 crore this year. This CAPEX will be vindicated by the situation that we had two years 40% the CAGR growth year-on-year."
Seasonality & Near-Term Outlook
- Q3 is structurally the weakest quarter: Year-end inventory correction by customers, multinational plant shutdowns (two weeks), low December automotive production for year-of-manufacture reasons, and post-festive season inventory correction all converge. Management says it is difficult to even replicate Q2 levels in Q3, but Q3 FY23 will be far better than last year's Q3.
- Q4 expected to be strong: Barring new international or geopolitical headwinds, the diverse portfolio means if one cylinder underperforms, another will do better.
- Commodity price headwind on powertrain margins persists: Commodity prices have settled at a higher level, which depresses EBITDA margins while inflating the top line; this situation will continue.
- Power costs stable as a percentage of revenue: H1 power and fuel was ₹70 cr vs ₹112 cr for all of FY22; pro rata, the percentage of topline is almost the same due to efficiencies of scale.
- Tax structure shift likely this year: The company is weighing cash outflow vs total benefit and is likely to move to the new tax structure in FY23 itself, though it still carries some MAT credit post-Q2.
Srinivasan Ravi: "The quarter three is always a challenge for inventory correction for customers, end of the year multinational companies within the country closing down their plants for two weeks plus also the automotive December production keeping it low for a year of manufacture reasons all that and the post festive season inventory correction. So, all put together we always see a challenge on Q3."
Strategic Context: EV & Light-Weighting
- EV two-wheeler parts revenue starts FY24: Production begins Q3 FY23, but revenue is factored in only from next year.
- Light-weighting shift to aluminium yet to take off in India: Requires fundamental model design changes or new platforms to accommodate new standards. At current aluminium prices (~₹180/kg vs ~₹280/kg earlier), the economics may be revisited.
- EV market maturation is a multi-year story: Current models are being redesigned for cost effectiveness by startups, while mature companies do good design from the start. Management is cautious about picking winners in a fragmented field.
Srinivasan Ravi: "We cannot add up all the numbers of the customer projections and projected to our investors that will be giving a wrong picture. There will be some failures from customer side or there may be some delay in projects."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| FY23 CAPEX | ~₹275 cr, including unplanned ₹70–75 cr for new aluminium order | FY23 full year |
| FY24 CAPEX | ~₹250 cr, assuming 20% growth; net block not expected to rise significantly as depreciation is ₹210–220 cr | FY24 |
| Aluminium business growth | 20% growth on value-added basis (gross profit), regardless of Stellantis ramp-up timing | FY24 vs FY23 |
| New aluminium customer revenue | ~₹150 cr (ramp-up year) | FY24 |
| New aluminium customer full ramp | Full-year ₹150 cr | FY25 |
| Stellantis/Peugeot production start | Q2 or Q3 FY24, subject to sample approval after 4–5 month testing cycle from Q4 FY23 | Q2/Q3 FY24 |
| Q3 FY23 performance | Far better than last year's Q3, though difficult to replicate Q2 levels due to seasonal headwinds | Q3 FY23 |
| Tax structure shift | Likely to move to new tax structure, weighing cash outflow vs benefit; currently carrying some MAT credit | FY23 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ~₹2,900 cr (FY23 expected), currently clocking >40% growth |
| Value addition | ₹376 cr (auto powertrain ₹232 cr, aluminium products ₹68 cr, industry engineering ₹76 cr) |
| EBIT – Auto powertrain | ₹93 cr, down from ₹95 cr QoQ |
| CAPEX | ~₹275 cr (FY23 expected), up from original ₹225–250 cr guidance due to unplanned ₹70–75 cr aluminium order CAPEX |
| Depreciation | ₹210–220 cr (annual run rate) |
| Net borrowings | ~₹720 cr |
| Power & fuel cost | ₹70 cr (H1 FY23), ~5% of topline of ₹1,447 cr |
| Storage solutions revenue | ₹111 cr (Q2 FY23), H1 FY23 ₹199 cr vs H1 FY22 ₹134 cr |
| Industry engineering exports | ~₹40 cr per quarter, out of ~₹90 cr quarterly revenue |
| Aluminium business revenue | ₹196 cr (Q2 FY23), up from ₹171 cr QoQ; run rate ~₹800 cr |
| Aluminium business mix | Two-wheeler 68%, passenger vehicles 2%, commercial vehicle 9%, non-auto 15% |
| Aluminium raw material price impact | ~3–4% margin impact on top line due to ~10% drop in aluminium prices and pipeline inventory |
| H1 Powertrain revenue mix | CV ₹385 cr, off-highway ₹150 cr, farm sector ₹125 cr, passenger vehicle ₹66 cr |
| FY24 growth guidance | 20% on value-added basis |
| Tax rate outlook | 25–26% expected from next financial year, likely shift to new tax structure in current year itself |