Key Takeaways
- Soft quarter, margin reset: Aluminum segment margins fell sharply for a second straight quarter as softening aluminum prices and a festive-season demand slump drove a ~INR 20 crores topline drop, crushing operating leverage on a small base.
- Acquisition transforms the story: The DR Axion deal, closing shortly, will push consolidated PV revenue above 60% and unlock access to a global top-3 OEM strong on EV, a customer Craftsman could not previously penetrate.
- One-off charges mask underlying health: Bunched zero-margin equipment sales (~INR 30 crores) and a ~INR 5 crores forex notional loss distorted reported profits; management points to absolute nine-month EBITDA growth in powertrain (INR 302 cr to INR 380 cr YoY) as the real signal.
- Debt ratios stay in check despite M&A: Leverage will hold at ~1.33x this year, the same as last year, with no equity raise needed; management expects improvement by September on an annualized basis even after the acquisition.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised Q4 rebound materializes across all three segments, the pace of the two large aluminum order ramp-ups, and any stabilization in the storage solutions business.
Aluminum Segment: The Quarter's Pain Point
- Price-driven margin compression: Aluminum prices continued to soften from Q2 into Q3, preventing the inventory-related margin recovery management had expected; pipeline inventory adjustments from declining prices hit Q2, and the continued softness blocked a Q3 rebound.
- Operating leverage collapse: A topline reduction of INR 20 crores translated to an INR 8–9 crores value-addition hit, which on the segment's small revenue base caused a disproportionate percentage margin decline.
- Utilization cratered on festive timing: Nine-month average utilization ran at ~60%, but Q3 was far lower because a steep September/October ramp-up in anticipation of festive demand met customer production slowdowns in late October; festival holidays, OEM inventory buildup, and heavy two-wheeler dependence (~70%) triggered plant and annual shutdowns.
- Seasonality offers a path out: Q3 is historically weak for aluminum; Q4 is always far better, and management sees stable-to-increasing aluminum prices now, calling the near-term outlook "far, far better."
- Scale is the structural fix: Management stated that once the division crosses INR 1,200 crores topline, it can stick to an 18% EBITDA margin; at the INR 175–200 crores absolute EBITDA level (a couple of years out), margin fluctuations will narrow to 1–2%, not the wild swings seen today.
Srinivasan Ravi: "When I look at the ₹100 crores EBITDA number is too small for aluminum division... when we cross that ₹175 crores, ₹200 crores level... at that level we'll not have this bigger fluctuation for ₹5 crores, ₹10 crores. It may be that 1% may or 2% may go up and down, but not as much, the base being bigger."
DR Axion Acquisition: Strategic Rationale & Financial Impact
- Customer access is the prize: The acquisition makes Craftsman a key supplier to a global top-3 passenger vehicle manufacturer that recently overtook the previous number three and is very strong on EV, including in North America; it provides entry to Japanese and Korean OEMs where Craftsman had no prior breakthrough.
- Portfolio rebalancing: Post-acquisition, over 60% of consolidated revenue will come from the passenger vehicle segment; DR Axion brings 100% gravity and low-pressure die casting capability, complementing Craftsman's predominantly high-pressure die casting auto aluminum business.
- Capex relief: The deal reduces the need for Craftsman to invest further in gravity or low-pressure die casting capacity, lowering the future aluminum capex cycle and providing equilibrium to attract more customers.
- No time-to-return gap: Management emphasized that acquiring an operational asset avoids the long gestation of greenfield projects, a critical advantage in current market conditions.
- Financial guardrails: Repayment is structured over seven to eight years at only INR 30–40 crores per year plus INR 20–30 crores interest, putting limited pressure on the aluminum division; debt-to-EBITDA will stay at ~1.33x this year, same as last year, and improve by September on an annualized basis.
- EV optionality, not immediacy: DR Axion's Korean parent makes EV components; when EV matures in India, Craftsman may have an early-bird advantage via the strategic alliance, but management acknowledges demand is still nascent and subsidy-dependent.
Srinivasan Ravi: "With this, we are a key supplier, and I think strategically it's very important, so that we are looking at a customer who is today Number 3 in the world. They've overtaken the earlier Number 3 as a passenger vehicle manufacturer globally. And more importantly, this particular manufacturer, of course, is very-very strong on EV, even in North America, totally."
Segment-Level Distortions & Underlying Health
- Industrial engineering margin aberration: ~INR 30 crores of equipment was supplied to customers at 0% margin (COGS to COGS) because repeat orders from 2018–19 had to be taken at the old price; this bunched up in Q3 and made segment EBITDA look lopsided. Excluding this, margins were reasonable, and the aberration reverses from Q4.
- Powertrain: measure absolute EBITDA, not margin %: Product mix shifts quarter-to-quarter (e.g., a material-heavy customer taking more supply) change the value-addition percentage, but absolute nine-month EBITDA grew from INR 302 crores to INR 380 crores YoY. Management urges investors to track absolute EBITDA, not topline margin percentages.
- Interest cost spike is partly transient: Three drivers: 200 bps rate increase, negative arbitrage on an FD of over INR 300 crores (loan drawn and placed as FD for a couple of months), and a ~INR 5 crores forex notional loss that may partially correct in Q4.
- Raw material pass-through timing: All powertrain and aluminum business is pass-through, but quarterly/monthly contract lags and inventory timing create temporary adverse or positive effects; Q1 saw a positive, Q2/Q3 adverse, and some positive is expected in Q4. No problem on an annual basis.
- Storage solutions: a demand pause, not structural: Q3 turnover fell to INR 80 crores from INR 111 crores in Q2 because major retail and e-commerce players held back investments, planning to restart only from January; management expects recovery from Q4.
Srinivasan Ravi: "Please don't measure EBITDA as a percentage of the topline, again on the value-addition only, because the product mix changes... our EBITDA when we look at it may be around 6% on the topline, but on the value-addition it may be 25% or 30%."
Growth Levers & Order Pipeline
- Powertrain driving volume: Nine-month growth of 39% versus a flat industry came from new products contributing; top 10 customers across CV, farm, construction equipment, industrial engines, PV, and two-wheelers provide clear visibility through monthly schedules and quarterly forecasts.
- Two large aluminum wins ramping: One of the two orders (INR 200 crores and INR 150 crores) has already started and is ramping up; the second, for a domestic PV customer, begins in Q2 next year before the festive season, with both contributing meaningfully in H2, not H1.
- CV pre-buy potential: Real-time emission norms effective April may allow manufacturing until March 31 and selling anytime next year, creating a smooth transition with possible pre-buy and demand pull-forward.
- Two-wheeler at a floor: Management stated "it cannot go lower than this"; EV contribution in aluminum remains insubstantial because aluminum requirement on critical two-wheeler EV parts is low, and exponential EV growth is unlikely without extended government subsidies.
- Automated storage gestation: Longer project cycles (site readiness, finalization, implementation) mean momentum will gather gradually.
Capital Allocation & Balance Sheet
- FY24 capex plan: INR 325–350 crores, with maintenance capex of ~INR 225 crores (equal to depreciation) and capacity expansion of INR 100–150 crores spread across segments but weighted toward auto powertrain.
- Powertrain capacity tightening: Utilization is reaching 75–80% soon; beyond 80–85% is impractical due to seasonality, line balancing, and customer peak demand, so capacity addition is becoming urgent if the market picks up.
- Debt trajectory improving: Excluding the DR Axion payout, debt would have reduced 15–20% in real terms this year despite capex; company debt will reduce next year. Future borrowing will be limited to maintenance capex and powertrain opportunities.
- No equity dilution: Management explicitly ruled out raising equity in the current situation.
- Tax regime shift imminent: The gap between old and new tax regimes has narrowed to a single-digit crore number; the company will most likely move to the new regime in Q4 itself.
Srinivasan Ravi: "There is no need to raise any equity in the current situation and the way we are going it, by September itself, on an annualized basis, it will be improved further in spite of the acquisition of DR Axion."
Margin & Return Profile Outlook
- No margin expansion expected: Management sees a possible tailwind from operating leverage but a headwind from upward inflation and product mix shifts; at 20% growth, inflation can be nullified and margins kept intact.
- ROCE improving: Pre-tax ROCE in industrial engineering improved from 10% full-year last year to 15% now (nine-month last year was 5%); overall ROCE will be better this year versus last year.
- Asset turns context: With the current product mix and ~45% value-addition, the INR 3,000 crores gross block yields ~0.5x on value-addition overall.
- Aluminum full-year margin: Full-year margin will be "far, far better" than last year, with substantial growth in absolute value-addition and EBITDA.
Srinivasan Ravi: "I don't see any margin expansion happening. There can be possibly the advantage or the tailwind of operating leverage. There is also headwind of upward inflation overall at the product mix. So I think if we grow at 20%, we can nullify the inflation and we'll still manage the keep the margins intact is what we are hoping for."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Q4 recovery | Q4 will be much better than Q3 and much better than Q4 last year, across all three segments | Q4 FY23 |
| 20% CAGR | Management sticks to 20% CAGR promise from IPO; some years more, some years less | Ongoing (IPO-era commitment) |
| FY24 segment growth | Powertrain, aluminum, industrial engineering all growing 15–20% vs FY23 | FY24 |
| Debt-to-EBITDA | Hold at ~1.33x this year; improve further by September on annualized basis despite DR Axion acquisition | FY23 year-end; September annualized |
| Aluminum margin stability | Once topline crosses INR 1,200 cr, stick to 18% EBITDA margin; at INR 175–200 cr absolute EBITDA, fluctuations narrow to 1–2% | A couple of years out |
| Tax regime shift | Most likely moving to new tax regime | Q4 FY23 |
| FY24 capex | INR 325–350 cr (excluding acquisition) | FY24 |
| DR Axion takeover | Legal formalities ongoing; takeover expected shortly | Near-term |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue (9M) | ₹2,195 cr, vs full year last year ₹2,206 cr |
| EBITDA (9M) | ₹499 cr, vs ₹380 cr in 9M last year and ₹537 cr full year last year |
| EBITDA margin (9M) | 23%, vs 24% full year last year |
| EBIT margin (9M) | 15%, flat vs full year last year |
| PBT (9M) | ₹259 cr, exceeding last year's full year PBT |
| PAT (9M) | ₹167 cr, vs ₹160 cr full year last year |
| PAT margin (9M) | 8%, vs 7% full year last year |
| ROCE pre-tax annualized | 23%, vs 20% full year last year |
| ROE annualized | 18%, vs 15% last year |
| EPS not annualised | ₹79.24, vs ₹75.94 last year |
| Net debt (net of cash) | ₹650 cr, down ₹29 cr from ₹679 cr in March '22 |
| Debt-to-equity | 0.82 |
| Debt-to-EBITDA | 1.6, or 1.3 excluding acquisition finance |
| Capex (9M) | ₹249 cr, mainly maintenance and technological improvement |
| FY24 capex estimate | ₹325 cr – ₹350 cr, excluding acquisition |
| Cash conversion cycle | 59 days, improved from 62 days in FY22 |
| Auto powertrain segment revenue (9M) | ₹1,134 cr, +39% YoY from ₹817 cr |
| Aluminum segment revenue (9M) | ₹544 cr, growth from ₹385 cr |
| Industrial engineering segment revenue (9M) | ₹517 cr, +48% YoY from ₹350 cr |
| Storage business turnover (9M) | ₹279 cr, +48% YoY from ₹188 cr |
| Storage quarterly turnover | ₹80 cr, down from ₹111 cr in Q2 |
| Auto powertrain segment EBITDA (9M) | ₹289 cr, +33% YoY from ₹218 cr |
| Aluminum segment EBIT (9M) | ₹42 cr, +38% YoY from ₹30 cr |
| Industrial engineering EBIT (9M) | ₹44 cr, growth from ₹13 cr |
| Q3 value-add: auto powertrain | ₹249 cr, vs ₹190 cr in Q3 last year |
| Q3 value-add: aluminum | ₹61.5 cr, vs ₹60 cr in Q3 last year |
| Q3 value-add: industrial engineering | ₹58.3 cr, vs ₹48 cr in Q3 last year |
| Direct export sales (9M) | ₹162 cr |
| FY24 growth expectation | 15% to 20% across all three segments |
| Aluminum 9M EBITDA margin | 14%, expected to improve with Q4 |
| Aluminum EBITDA target margin | 18% once topline crosses ₹1,200 cr |
| DR Axion half-year sales | ₹500 cr |
| Interest cost one-time forex loss | ~₹5 cr |
| I&E zero-margin equipment supply impact | ₹30 cr in Q3, distorting segment margin |