Key Takeaways
- Decent quarter, margin reset: EBITDA margin fell from 29% to 24% YoY, driven by commodity pass-through and a 20% manpower cost inflation that management calls the "elephant in the room" for manufacturers.
- Aluminium business turns the corner: Auto aluminium EBIT margin swung from -3.8% to +1.9%, with management declaring "the worst is behind us" and targeting double-digit EBIT margins in FY23.
- 20% growth guided, working capital flat: Management guided minimum 20% real growth for FY23 across all three segments, while committing that working capital will not grow even at 25% growth, freeing cash for debt reduction.
- Daimler risk quantified and deferred: A 10% impact on auto powertrain value addition is expected only in FY27-28, with management arguing dependency is already reducing and double-digit growth continues despite the eventual loss.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the price hike requests in industrial engineering translate into margin recovery, the pace of auto aluminium volume ramp-up, and any revision to the ₹215-220 Cr CAPEX plan if growth exceeds 20%.
Auto Aluminium Turnaround
- Profitability inflection: EBIT margin improved from -3.8% in FY21 to 1.9% in FY22, despite being "caught on the wrong side of the trailing quarter" on aluminium prices and operating at low capacity utilization.
- Commodity pass-through fixed: The trailing-quarter pricing mismatch that hurt margins has been corrected; the company now takes a more realistic average and almost all customers have adopted real-time pass-through, eliminating revenue leakage from commodity swings going forward.
- Volume growth on deck: New order wins described as "quite sizeable" from OEMs and Tier-1 suppliers beyond the existing PSA/Stellantis relationship, with OEMs showing faster implementation speed; details promised in the next earnings call.
- Mix shift underway: Two-wheeler share expected to drop below 80% in FY23 from 87%, with a target of 50-50 two-wheeler vs four-wheeler by FY25, reducing exposure to the segment that dragged Q4 value addition down to ₹36.5 Cr from ₹39.62 Cr YoY.
- Three-year ambition: FY22 revenue of ₹440 Cr is targeted to reach ₹1,000 Cr by FY26, driven mainly by passenger vehicles across conventional ICE, PV and EV, with only a small contribution from two-wheeler EV.
Srinivasan Ravi: "What was ₹440 Crores for FY22 if I fast forward to '26 I think we'll reach ₹1000 Crores number and we'll be very close to the ₹1000 Crores number in the previous year itself, the way it is going, the order wins what we're having."
Margin Pressures & Mitigation
- Manpower cost inflation: Manpower-related expenses rose ~20% YoY and now represent 18-20% of value addition; management describes this as "the elephant in the room" and is reserving CAPEX for modernization, semi-automation and automation to deliver 20-30% growth with the same headcount.
- Power cost headwind: Unplanned power outages in North and West plants forced diesel generator usage at ₹35/unit vs ₹7-8/unit grid power; power cost at ~9-10% of value addition is expected to increase, potentially shaving 1-2 EBITDA percentage points, though better capacity utilization and topline growth should more than nullify the impact via overhead absorption.
- Industrial engineering margin path: EBITDA margin declined from 17% to 16% because price hikes for sub-assemblies have not yet been requested; the company will approach customers in the current quarter and expects genuine price protection in Q2-Q3 given longstanding relationships, targeting a return to 17-18%.
- Storage solutions margin normalization: The business grew from ₹104 Cr to ₹253 Cr and has reached optimum size; the negative influence it exerted on industrial engineering segment margin last year will get nullified in the coming quarter, with future margins "surely better."
- Operating leverage as the offset: At current 55-60% capacity utilization, significant overhead absorption gains are available as volumes ramp; management expects the combination of price hikes, mix improvement and volume growth to more than compensate for input cost inflation.
Srinivasan Ravi: "I think the elephant in the room for every company, most of the companies like us will be on the manufacturing cost related to manpower which they are seeing for 20%-30% inflation... This is one of the reasons which was I was little guarded or reserved while talking about CAPEXs."
Auto Powertrain: Growth Despite Daimler Overhang
- Daimler risk quantified and distant: Daimler will stop 10,000 trucks in India (of 15,000), but Brazil volume of ~60,000 continues; the net impact is ~10% on auto powertrain value addition, arriving only in FY27-28, with a further possible shift of Brazil to Cummins only if BSVII-equivalent emission norms arrive around FY28.
- Dependency already reducing: Management declined to disclose Daimler revenue but stated that value addition dependency is reducing; Daimler represents slightly above 10% of company value addition, and 80% of the Daimler-related value addition comes from exports to Brazil, not India.
- Consolidation tailwind: With no one else investing in auto powertrain manufacturing in India, consolidation is benefiting Craftsman; management expects ~20% growth for the next 2-3 years and double-digit growth to continue even after the Daimler loss in FY28.
- Export engine diversifying: Japanese manufacturers are making India a global hub for diesel engines for pickup trucks targeting the African market (emission level 1-2-3), while tractor manufacturers are also increasing exports to Africa; farm exports now represent 10% of farm revenue and are likely to increase.
- Segment mix stable: Powertrain mix expected to remain consistent: CV ~54%, farm ~18%, off-highway ~20%, PV ~8%.
Srinivasan Ravi: "We see it growing in the auto powertrain because nobody's investing further there and consolidation is happening in India. I see that we will continue to grow in good double digit, 20% maybe for the next 2-3 years shortly, after that also I think the double-digit growth in spite of loss of Daimler in FY28 I think we'll continue."
Working Capital, Debt & Cash Flow
- Inventory-driven working capital build: Debt reduction on the term loan front happened, but working capital borrowing increased because higher commodity prices and the need to secure material availability on time forced the company to build inventory; overall debt remained more or less the same.
- Working capital inflection promised: Management committed that even at 25% growth, working capital will not grow going forward; the number of days is expected to come down as commodity price fluctuation moderates.
- Debt reduction target: Total debt reduction of ~₹100 Cr expected in FY23, a combination of term loan and working capital loan reduction.
- Cash flow generation: Expected cash flow of >₹400 Cr in FY23 against CAPEX of ~₹200 Cr, leaving substantial surplus for debt reduction and potential growth CAPEX revisions.
- ROCE improvement path: Lower working capital days, operating leverage and the auto aluminium profitability turnaround are all expected to lift consolidated ROCE; auto aluminium alone is targeted to move from negative ROCE in FY21 to above 15%, closer to 20%.
Srinivasan Ravi: "I would say that even for 25% growth the working capital will not grow going forward."
Industrial Engineering & Storage Solutions
- Storage solutions scaling rapidly: Revenue grew from ₹104 Cr to ₹253 Cr; the company has established itself as a very strong player in static racking and is now getting right pricing; a further minimum 50% growth is expected in the current year.
- Pending order book healthy: Storage solutions pending orders stood at close to ₹150 Cr as of the call date, providing near-term visibility.
- Q4 margin performance real: Industrial engineering Q4 EBIT margin of 16% had no one-offs; it was driven by better pass-through on automated storage solutions and right pricing on static racking; similar margins are realistic for the next 2-3 quarters.
- Price hike catalyst pending: The segment's EBITDA margin decline from 19% to 16% reflects costs not yet corrected by price hikes; management will approach customers for genuine price protection on sub-assemblies in the current quarter, with benefit expected in Q2-Q3.
- Capital-light returns: Storage solutions is not a high-CAPEX business; EBITDA margins are low double-digit and ROCE is in line with the company overall at ~20%.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Real growth | Minimum 20% across all three segments (commodities factored in) | FY23 |
| Q1 FY23 revenue | ~₹600 Cr with same segment mix as Q4 | Q1 FY23 |
| Working capital | No increase even at 25% growth; days to come down | FY23 |
| Total debt reduction | ~₹100 Cr reduction | FY23 |
| CAPEX | ₹215-220 Cr; may be revised upward if growth exceeds 20% dramatically | FY23, revisable in Q2 |
| Auto aluminium EBIT margin | Double-digit (from ~2% in FY22) | FY23 |
| Auto aluminium ROCE | Above 15%, closer to 20% | FY23 |
| Auto aluminium revenue | ₹1,000 Cr | FY26 |
| Industrial engineering EBITDA margin | Return to 17-18% | Post price hikes in Q2-Q3 |
| Storage solutions growth | Minimum 50% growth | FY23 |
| Daimler impact on powertrain value addition | ~10% impact | FY27-28 |
| Growth beyond FY25 | ~20% for 2-3 years, moderating to ~10% thereafter | FY25-FY28 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Standalone revenue | ₹2,206 cr, +43% YoY |
| Value-added growth | 32% YoY, real terms |
| Standalone PBT | ₹248 cr, +68% YoY |
| Consolidated PBT | ₹252 cr |
| PAT | ₹160 cr, highest ever; ₹97 cr in FY21 |
| EBITDA | ₹539 cr, +20% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 24%, down from 29% in FY21 |
| EBIT margin | 15%, down from 16% in FY21 |
| PBT margin | 11%, up from 10% in FY21 |
| PAT margin | 7%, up from 6% in FY21 |
| EPS | ₹76, up from ₹48 in FY21 |
| ROCE (pre-tax) | 20%, up from 16% in FY21 |
| ROE | 15%, up from 11% in FY21 |
| Debt to equity | 0.63x, improved from 0.72x in FY21 |
| Debt to EBITDA | 1.33x, improved from 1.57x in FY21 |
| Total debt | ₹713 cr; long-term ₹522 cr, working capital ₹193 cr |
| CAPEX | ₹227 cr, in line with depreciation |
| Automotive powertrain revenue | ₹1,154 cr, +42% YoY |
| Auto aluminium revenue | ₹440 cr, +33% YoY, mostly commodity-driven |
| Industrial engineering revenue | ₹612 cr, +51% YoY |
| Storage solutions revenue | ₹253 cr for FY22, up from ₹104 cr in FY21; Q4 revenue ₹65 cr |
| Storage solutions order book | ~₹150 cr pending as of call date |
| Auto powertrain capacity utilization | 60%–70% for FY22 |
| Auto aluminium capacity utilization | 57% for FY22 |
| Auto aluminium EBIT margin | 1.9%, up from -3.8% in FY21 |
| Auto aluminium pre-tax ROCE | 2%, up from -3% in FY21 |
| Two-wheeler share in aluminium business | 87% in FY22, expected below 80% in FY23 |
| FY23 CAPEX guidance | ₹215–₹220 cr, supporting 20%–25% growth |
| FY23 expected debt reduction | ~₹100 cr |
| Monthly revenue capacity | ~₹300 cr at current product mix |
| Power cost as % of value addition | ~9%–10% |
| Manpower cost as % of value addition | ~18%–20%, up ~20% YoY |