Key Takeaways
- 20% value-add growth guided across all segments: Management committed to 20% YoY value addition growth in auto powertrain, aluminium, and industrial engineering for FY24, with top-line growth slightly higher in aluminium and auto powertrain.
- Aluminium margins doubled on operating leverage: EBIT margins in aluminium jumped from 4% to 11.4% QoQ, driven by capacity utilisation rising from 59% to 76% of net block, and management expects further improvement from product mix.
- DR Axion acquisition closed, margin normalisation promised: The ₹375 crore acquisition contributed two months of depressed margins (11% EBITDA) due to one-time die investment pass-through and accounting migration; management guided to 14-15% EBITDA for FY24.
- Powertrain Q4 was soft, Q1 starting stronger: Q4 powertrain revenue declined QoQ on muted construction, farm sector mismatch, and Daimler Brazil headwinds, but Q1 is seeing traction from commercial and passenger vehicle segments.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether DR Axion EBITDA normalises to the promised 14-15%, the ramp-up of the domestic SUV manufacturer order starting July, and any stabilisation in the farm and construction equipment segments.
Segment Performance & Drivers
- Auto powertrain Q4 dip: Revenue declined sequentially due to muted construction machinery and farm sector demand, a supply-to-sales mismatch in farm, unfavourable product mix, and headwinds at Daimler Brazil from Brazil's weak economy; Q3 had been a strong comparator.
- Industrial engineering Q4 surge: 20% QoQ growth came from the capital goods sector's typical year-end sales push, plus conditional mining exports of ₹116 crores for the full year.
- Aluminium margin leap: EBIT margins improved from 4% to 11.4% QoQ entirely on operating leverage as value addition to net block rose from 59% in Q3 to 76% in Q4; the improvement is structural, not one-off.
- Aluminium product mix tailwind: Aluminium prices have steadied after month-on-month drops, the passenger vehicle parts percentage is rising, and new products including EV two-wheeler parts are kicking in at normalised prices.
- Industrial margin drivers: Higher value addition and utilisation, one-stop capital goods sales with 3-4 month gestation, and an upswing in the high-end automated storage solution business all contributed.
- Raw material cost rise is mix, not inflation: Higher raw material cost as a percentage of revenue, both sequentially and YoY, reflects product mix shifts rather than high-cost inventory.
Srinivasan Ravi: "I think the operating leverage is the main key for this improvement in margin in the aluminium segment."
DR Axion Acquisition: Integration & Outlook
- Two-month margin optics explained: The reported 27% gross margin and 11% EBITDA for the two-month consolidation period were depressed by pass-through of die investments made in March, which are not part of sales, and by migration to a new Oracle ERP system; margins will normalise at the 10-month figure in Q1.
- EBITDA guidance for FY24: Management expects DR Axion EBITDA margin in the region of 14% to 15%, with upside to 15%+ if aluminium pass-through is more perfect; even with adverse commodity movement, margins will stay upward of 13%.
- Inventory and capacity reset: DR Axion previously held only 3-4 days of raw material inventory; Craftsman raised it to 30 days to manage aluminium alloy price fluctuations. Some capacity invested by earlier management came online only late in Q4, with more coming in early Q1, and a further 10% capacity increase is factored into capex, with 20% headroom by July.
- Customer concentration risk: DR Axion has only three customers, which limits growth directly in proportion to customer growth; 10-15% growth is described as a given for now.
- Technology complementarity: DR Axion is 80% gravity die casting and 20% low-pressure die casting, complementing Craftsman's high-pressure die casting capability; high-pressure die casting orders will leverage Craftsman's existing facility.
- EV pipeline emerging: DR Axion is already in discussion for passenger vehicle EV parts for the domestic market, and one customer is looking at setting up a new plant in the Western region which, if awarded, could lift growth.
Srinivasan Ravi: "No, in FY 2024, itself, will be in the region of 14% to 15%. Only in case of very adverse commodity movement because, there the prices are settled on a trailing quarter, so I think you understand that."
Growth Drivers & Order Pipeline
- Stellantis order ramping: Production started and will scale up in Q3.
- Domestic SUV manufacturer entry: Craftsman has come in as a second supplier for a critical part; engine parts are under validation and production starts in July, with Q2 onwards showing an upward trend and Q3 reaching a high peak.
- PSA new business: New aluminium product business from PSA started in a small way in Q3 and will reflect in standalone numbers.
- Off-highway and generator orders: Multinational American companies placed orders roughly 1.5-2 years ago for generators and off-highway vehicles; production starts from Q3 onwards.
- China Plus One tailwind: Multinationals are setting up plants in India across construction equipment, SUV, and farm segments, though management notes Craftsman is "too small to grab any big opportunity."
- Powertrain sub-segment outlook: Tractors expected flat or negative for FY24 (~20% of powertrain); passenger vehicles (10% of powertrain) growing significantly with a key domestic customer's second-phase expansion; commercial vehicles growing strongly with 15-ton trucks gaining traction and higher value addition per truck for Craftsman.
Srinivasan Ravi: "So, I think product mix is improving, and we will continue to see further improvement also."
Efficiency & Balance Sheet
- Value addition efficiency improving: Company-wide value addition to net block improved from 78% in FY22 to 92% in FY23, driven by efficient capex deployment and older equipment being fully depreciated; management targets above 125% in time. Auto powertrain dipped from 106% to 103% on high depreciation from the oldest capex segment, with correction expected.
- Headcount flat by design: Employee cost as a percentage of revenue declined despite DR Axion consolidation because DR Axion uses more contract labour; Craftsman has consciously kept headcount flat for 2-3 years through automation and modern machinery, with salary outflow increases coming only from wage hikes.
- Debt reduction commitment: Consolidated debt should come down by at least ₹200 crores.
- Cash conversion cycle: Consolidated cash conversion cycle will operate at 55 days or lower.
- Permanent tax rate shift: Company permanently adopted the new 25.168% tax rate and cannot revert; the decision was based on a calculation that only very large capex would make the old rate beneficial.
- Backward integration optionality: Management may do limited backward integration in cast iron if raw material supply from foundry partners becomes a bottleneck to the 20% CAGR in auto powertrain; no impact on P&L or ROCE is expected.
Strategic Positioning & Long-Term View
- Three-to-six-year visibility claimed: Management states clear visibility for at least three years, confidence about six years, and bullishness on ten years, though the ten-year view is not presented as firm.
- Diesel phase-out not a concern: Engine, axle, and gearbox are required regardless of fuel type, so the shift away from diesel does not threaten Craftsman's LCV exposure.
- Two-wheeler EV still nascent: Numbers are small; aluminium content in the addressable market is small and machining value addition is also small; conventional two-wheeler business is coming back post-subsidy.
- Automated storage leadership undisclosed: Management claims market leadership in automated storage (V-store) and a top-two domestic position but declined to share revenue or unit data, calling it competitive information that will be disclosed when the market matures in a couple of years.
Srinivasan Ravi: "I would say that six years is very clear and 10 years is, we cannot, I am bullish on the 10 years also, but to investors, I would say, three years is firm and six years is surely achievable and we are working towards 10 year growth."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Value addition growth | 20% YoY growth in each of the three segments (auto powertrain, aluminium, industrial engineering) | FY24 |
| Auto powertrain top-line growth | 22-25% | FY24 |
| Aluminium top-line growth | Slightly higher than 20% value addition, ~25% | FY24 |
| Industrial engineering top-line growth | 20-25% | FY24 |
| DR Axion EBITDA margin | 14-15% (upward of 13% even with adverse commodity moves) | FY24 |
| DR Axion revenue growth | 10-15% | FY24 |
| DR Axion capacity headroom | 20% headroom by July | July 2023 |
| Consolidated debt reduction | At least ₹200 crores | FY24 |
| Consolidated cash conversion cycle | 55 days or lower | FY24 |
| Domestic SUV manufacturer order | Production starting July, Q2 upward trend, Q3 peak | July 2023 / Q2-Q3 FY24 |
| Stellantis order scale-up | Scaling up in Q3 | Q3 FY24 |
| Off-highway and generator orders | Production starting from Q3 | Q3 FY24 |
| Value addition to net block target | Above 125% company-wide | No date (transition underway) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Standalone revenue | ₹2,980 cr, 35% YoY growth |
| Standalone value addition growth | 27% YoY |
| Standalone EBITDA | ₹671 cr, 25% YoY growth |
| Standalone EBIT growth | 37% YoY |
| Standalone PBT growth | 37% YoY |
| Standalone PAT growth | 48% YoY, aided by shift to new tax regime |
| Standalone EPS | ₹112.53, up from ₹75.94 |
| Effective tax rate | 25.168% for FY23, down from 34.944% |
| Capex | ₹309 cr |
| Debt to equity | 0.72, up from 0.63 due to acquisition finance |
| Debt to EBITDA | 1.48, up from 1.33 |
| ROCE (pre-tax annualised) | 22.5%, up from 20% |
| Auto-powertrain segment revenue | ₹1,527 cr, 32% YoY growth |
| Aluminium segment revenue | ₹741 cr, 34% YoY growth |
| Industrial engineering segment revenue | ₹713 cr, 42% YoY growth |
| Storage solutions revenue | ₹376 cr, 49% YoY growth |
| Auto-powertrain EBIT | ₹382 cr, 26% YoY growth |
| Aluminium EBIT | ₹65 cr, 57% YoY growth |
| Industrial engineering EBIT | ₹62 cr, 89% YoY growth |
| DR Axion 2-month revenue (consolidated) | ₹196 cr |
| DR Axion 2-month EBITDA | ₹22 cr |
| DR Axion 2-month EBIT | ₹16 cr |
| DR Axion 2-month PAT | ₹11 cr |
| DR Axion net worth | ₹253 cr |
| DR Axion term loan | ₹161 cr |
| Q4 value addition: Powertrain | ₹241 cr |
| Q4 value addition: Aluminium | ₹79 cr |
| Q4 value addition: Industrial Engineering | ₹73 cr |
| Full year exports | ₹220 cr |
| Q4 exports | ₹60 cr |
| Aluminium value addition to net block | 76% in Q4, up from 59% in Q3 and 42% in FY22 |
| Automated storage solutions revenue | ₹110 cr for FY23, up from approximately half that in FY22 |
| Static storage solutions revenue | ₹265 cr for FY23 |
| Standalone value addition to net block | 92% for FY23, up from 78% in FY22 |
| Auto-powertrain value addition to net block | 103% for FY23, down from 106% in FY22 |
| Powertrain segment mix: Commercial vehicle | 55% of segment revenue |
| Powertrain segment mix: Off highway | 20% of segment revenue |
| Powertrain segment mix: Tractor | 15% of segment revenue |
| Powertrain segment mix: Passenger vehicle (SUV) | 10% of segment revenue |
| Aluminium segment mix: Two wheeler | 56% of segment revenue |
| Aluminium segment mix: Commercial vehicle | 10% of segment revenue |
| Aluminium segment mix: Passenger vehicle | 2% of segment revenue |
| Aluminium segment mix: Others | 22% of segment revenue |
| Standalone cash conversion cycle | 56 days, improved from 60 days |
| DR Axion capacity utilization | ~80% as of December 2022, with headroom for 20-25% growth |
| DR Axion full year EBITDA margin | ~14% for FY23 |
| DR Axion royalty rate | 2.5% of revenue |
| Standalone gross block (actual) | ₹3,135 cr |
| DR Axion gross block | ~₹500 cr |
| DR Axion permanent employee strength | ~387, flat YoY |
| Consolidated debt reduction expected in FY24 | At least ₹200 cr |
| Revenue growth guidance (value addition) | 20% YoY for each segment in FY24 |
| DR Axion revenue growth guidance | 10-15% for FY24 |
| DR Axion EBITDA margin guidance | 14-15% for FY24, upward of 13% in adverse scenario |
| Standalone capex guidance for FY24 | ₹320-330 cr |
| DR Axion capex guidance for FY24 | ~₹30 cr |