Key Takeaways
- Profit milestone with broad-based strength: Net profit crossed ₹200 Crores for the first time, rising 85.3% YoY, while portfolio growth, asset quality, and operating efficiency all improved sequentially.
- Asset quality turnaround is real: GNPA fell 46 bps QoQ to 1.71% and collection efficiency held at 98%, even as the company absorbed a ₹131 Crores write-off within its guided credit cost envelope.
- NIM held near peak despite funding drag: Consolidated NIM of 11.9% was pressured by excess liquidity from long-term debt raises, but the 9M average of 11.5% already delivered the promised 60 bps YoY improvement.
- The merger is finally closing: NCLT approvals are in hand, so FY23 annual financials will be presented as a merged entity, removing a long-standing overhang.
- What to watch next quarter: FY24 NIM and growth guidance (explicitly deferred to Q4), the pace of normalization in marginal cost of borrowing, and any early signal on borrower leverage trends as the new regulation beds in.
Profitability & Operating Performance
- Net profit milestone: PAT grew 85.3% YoY and 23.1% QoQ to ₹217 Crores, crossing the ₹200 Crores mark for the first time on the back of improved business momentum, operating efficiency, and asset quality.
- NII and PPOP: NII grew 37.7% YoY to ₹567 Crores, while PPOP rose 38.7% YoY to ₹380 Crores, reflecting strong core income generation.
- Cost efficiency: The cost-to-income ratio improved 300 bps YoY to 36.3%, helped by operating leverage as the branch network matured.
- NIM resilience: Consolidated NIM stood at 11.9%, or 12.1% adjusted for excess liquidity. The sequential 11 bps decline was driven by high average liquidity during the quarter after raising money in November that could not be deployed immediately. The 9M FY23 NIM of 11.5% is 60 bps higher than FY22, meeting the full-year improvement target.
- Sustainable NIM view: Management sees sustainable NIM between 11.75% and 12%, with an expected NIM of 12.5% that needs to be adjusted downward for leveraging since equity stands at about 22%.
- ROA/ROE guidance intact: FY23 guidance of 4.0%–4.2% ROA and 16.0%–18.0% ROE was reiterated, with the impact of higher credit costs built into revised customer pricing.
Hebbar: "We always look at tech initiatives at the core for this kind of mass volume, the large volume transactions."
Portfolio Growth & Geography
- Portfolio growth: Consolidated gross loan portfolio grew 21.9% YoY and 7.5% QoQ to ₹17,786 Crores, with pre-write-off growth at 22.8% YoY. Disbursement grew 2.7% YoY and 10.8% QoQ to ₹4,847 Crores, with muted YoY growth reflecting a high base from pent-up demand in Q3 FY22.
- Borrower base: Consolidated active borrowers grew 5.3% YoY and 3.7% QoQ to 39.4 Lakhs, with 3.05 lakh borrowers added in Q3. CA Grameen borrower base grew 11.2% YoY to 31.3 Lakhs, while MMFL showed 13.3% YoY degrowth but 14% pre-write-off growth.
- Geographic mix shift underway: Core states (Karnataka, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu) show moderate growth because penetration is already high, while newer northern states grow much faster. Of 9.05 lakh customers acquired in the last 12 months, 53% came from northern states, and 95% of new branches opened there.
- Portfolio concentration targets: Karnataka GLP share should move from ~34% toward 25%–26% over the next two years, and the core three states should fall below 60% of the portfolio within three years in a stable environment.
- Branch strategy: 43 new branches opened mainly in newer states, taking the total to 1,727 across 344 districts. Future focus is on leveraging headroom in 500+ branches opened in the last three years, with Maharashtra openings limited to splitting overgrown branches of 7–8 thousand customers.
- New-to-credit acquisition: In core states, new-to-credit proportion runs at ~33% in Karnataka, ~27% in Tamil Nadu, and ~41% in Maharashtra. In Bihar and northern states, 40%–50% of borrowers are new-to-credit because the company operates in Tier 3–4 traditional villages.
Hebbar: "Our experience is very good in all the northern states, very, very liquid or what you want to call - portfolio quality, process quality, new customer, new to credit customers. All these are very, very good."
Asset Quality & Credit Cost
- Asset quality improvement: GNPA at 60+ DPD reduced from 2.17% to 1.71% QoQ, PAR 90 reduced from 1.72% to 1.34% QoQ, and net NPA at 60+ DPD reduced from 0.77% to 0.59% QoQ. Collection efficiency held at 98% excluding arrears.
- Credit cost composition: Credit cost of ₹89 Crores included ₹131 Crores in write-offs at the 270 DPD policy, partially offset by ₹16.5 Crores in bad debt recovery. CA Grameen credit cost was within budget, while MMFL ran higher due to lagged collections in the last leg of its legacy book.
- MMFL new book quality: The new MMFL book, now 92% of its portfolio and originated under the CA Grameen model, is showing excellent portfolio quality.
- Credit cost trajectory: FY23 gross credit cost is estimated at 2.3%–2.4%, with net credit cost sub 2.0%. Normal stable credit cost is expected between 1.5%–1.6%, and next year's credit cost is expected in that 1.5%–1.6% range.
- ECL coverage: Overall ECL at 2.04% remained higher than GNPA, providing a buffer.
- Borrower leverage still unclear: Management has not observed too much variation in borrower leverage yet, and expects the full picture to take 2–3 more quarters as the majority of players would have adopted the new regulation only by Q3. Approval rates are up only 2%–3% versus pre-COVID levels.
Hebbar: "We have not observed too much variation at this point of time. Probably, the change in regulation impact may take at least two, or three more quarters because the majority of the players would have adopted only by Q3. Therefore, it's a little early to get the full detail."
Funding, Liquidity & ALM
- Cost of borrowing: Marginal cost of borrowing spiked to 10.2% in Q3 due to a higher proportion of long-term debt (foreign ECB, NCD, public NCD) in incremental drawdowns, though the cost of bank and NBFC MFI borrowings was stable QoQ. The weighted average cost of borrowing increased only 70 bps to 9.6% versus March 2022 despite a 225 bps repo rate hike.
- 9M cost within guided range: The 9M FY23 weighted average cost of borrowing stayed within the guided 9.3%–9.4% range, and management expects normalization in Q4 as bank borrowings regain a predominant share of incremental drawdowns.
- ALM extension: Average maturity of liabilities increased to over 24 months from over 22 months QoQ, reflecting dedicated efforts to raise long-term borrowings.
- Liquidity drag on NIM: Excess liquidity from foreign debt drawdowns and a public NCD issuance of ₹1,685 Crores (49% of total Q3 drawdowns) weighed on NIM, with average liquidity exceeding 8% during the quarter.
- Long-term borrowing mix target: 30%–35% international borrowing, 15% long-term via BFIs and NCDs, 5%–10% DA and securitization, and 40%–45% stable domestic bank borrowings.
- Capital adequacy: At 24%, capital adequacy is sufficient for the next four or five quarters. Management may start working toward the next capital raise after the end of FY23–24, likely via a QIP, and the promoter does not plan to sell alongside that raise.
Hebbar: "We always believe that we should hold capital adequacy of more than 20%."
Merger, Promoter & Corporate Developments
- NCLT merger approval: The NCLT Bengaluru Bench pronounced its order approving the Scheme of Amalgamation between CA Grameen and MMFL, with the order copy awaited. NCLT Chennai Bench approval was received in October 2022, so the company can now proceed toward amalgamation and present FY23 annual financials as a merged entity.
- MD & CEO term extension: The Board approved extension of Mr. Udaya Kumar Hebbar's term as MD & CEO for a further two years until June 2025, subject to shareholder approval, after expiry of the current term in June 2023.
- Promoter stake and share sale: Leading Italian bank Intesa Sanpaolo acquired about 2% in the promoter company recently. The promoter may consider one or a few bilateral share sale transactions with selected high-quality long-term investors, aggregating up to around 10% over the medium term at a price reflecting business fundamentals. No shares will be offered in the market or via any advisor-led offer.
- Promoter majority commitment: The promoter intends to keep holding a clear majority stake above 55%–60% over the long term, even after any minor dilution and potential future capital raise plans.
Hebbar: "I would like to reiterate that the strategic view of our promoter remains to keep holding a clear majority stake in the company above 55% - 60% over the long term. Even after considering any minor dilution as described above and potential future capital raise plans of CA Grameen also."
New Products & Diversification
- Individual loans: An individual loan product for matured customers has been piloted across about 192 branches and is disbursing nearly a crore every day.
- Two-wheeler loans: Piloted in a few branches, started and described as promising.
- Loan Against Property: The LAP book is disbursing almost ₹5 Crores per month with an increasing trend.
- Asset-backed/MSME ambition: The asset-backed and MSME book is targeted to reach ₹5,000–6,000 Crores in four to five years, becoming 10%–12% of the overall portfolio. Management is not in a hurry, wanting to make the model right before scaling up since it is a new business.
- Non-microfinance traction: The non-microfinance book should see good traction in FY23 and FY24.
Hebbar: "So, we are not in a hurry. We want to make the model right before scaling up and it's a new business for us. We also are planning very steadily and stable."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| ROA | 4.0%–4.2% | FY23 |
| ROE | 16.0%–18.0% | FY23 |
| Gross credit cost | 2.3%–2.4% in FY23, normalizing to 1.5%–1.6% | FY23 / FY24 |
| Net credit cost | Sub 2.0% | FY23 |
| NIM | 12.0%–12.25% (50–70 bps higher from 12% base) | FY24 |
| Portfolio CAGR | 20%–25% overall, including microfinance and non-microfinance | Next 4–5 years |
| Karnataka GLP share | Move from ~34% toward 25%–26% | Next 2 years |
| Core 3-state portfolio share | Below 60% | Next 3 years (stable environment) |
| Asset-backed/MSME book | ₹5,000–6,000 Crores (10%–12% of portfolio) | 4–5 years |
| Capital adequacy | Above 20% maintained; next raise after FY23–24 end | Ongoing / post FY24 |
| Promoter majority stake | Above 55%–60% | Long term |
| RBI regulation benefit | Remaining ~50% of pricing benefit to flow through | Next 12 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated gross loan portfolio | ₹17,786 cr, +21.9% YoY and +7.5% QoQ |
| Disbursement | ₹4,847 cr, +2.7% YoY and +10.8% QoQ |
| Consolidated NII | ₹567 cr, +37.7% YoY |
| PPOP | ₹380 cr, +38.7% YoY |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹217 cr, +85.3% YoY and +23.1% QoQ |
| ROA | 4.6% in Q3 FY23; 3.8% in 9M FY23 |
| ROE | 18.8% in Q3 FY23; 16.2% in 9M FY23 |
| Consolidated NIM | 11.9%; adjusted NIM excluding excess liquidity impact was 12.1% |
| Cost to income ratio | 36.3%, 300 bps lower YoY |
| Weighted average cost of borrowing | 9.6%, increased by 70 bps vs March 2022 |
| Marginal cost of borrowing | 10.2% during Q3 FY23, a one-off spike due to higher proportion of long-term debt |
| Credit cost | ₹89 cr, including write-off of ₹131 cr, partially offset by ₹16.5 cr bad debt recovery |
| FY23 gross credit cost estimate | 2.3%–2.4%; net credit cost estimate sub 2.0% |
| GNPA at 60+ DPD | 1.71%, down from 2.17% in Sep 2022 |
| PAR 90 | 1.34%, down from 1.72% in Sep 2022 |
| Net NPA at 60+ DPD | 0.59%, down from 0.77% in Sep 2022 |
| Consolidated collection efficiency (excl. arrears) | 98% |
| Consolidated active borrower base | 39.4 lakh, +5.3% YoY and +3.7% QoQ; 3.05 lakh borrowers added in Q3 |
| Total branch network | 1,727 across 344 districts; 43 new branches opened in Q3 |
| Capital adequacy (consolidated) | ~24% |
| Average maturity of liabilities (consolidated) | Over 24 months, up from over 22 months a quarter ago |
| Share of foreign borrowings | 17% in Q3, up from 9% in Q2 |
| MMFL new book share | 92% of MMFL book; legacy book at 8% of MMFL book and 1.3% of consolidated book |
| New-to-credit customers in core states | Karnataka ~33%, Tamil Nadu ~27%, Maharashtra ~41% |