Key Takeaways
- Record profitability, temporarily disrupted quarter: PAT hit INR 1,049 Crore for 9M FY24, already nearly double FY23’s full-year figure, even as a core banking system upgrade and Tamil Nadu floods briefly slowed momentum.
- Asset quality ticked up on known, seasonal factors: PAR 30 rose to 120 bps from 90 bps QoQ, driven by seasonality, steady-state delinquencies outside Karnataka, and flood impact; management expects normalization in Q4.
- A 50 bps lending rate cut signals structural confidence: The reduction, driven by a board-approved pricing policy tied to falling operating costs, is a pass-through of efficiency gains, not a competitive reaction.
- The growth engine is intact but shifting geographically: Full-year 25% growth was reiterated, with expansion now concentrated in 16 states outside the top 3-4, where branch additions are district-based and contiguous.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether PAR 30 normalizes as guided, the pace of Madhya Pradesh’s resumed growth after four stagnant quarters, and any early signs of the CBS upgrade’s promised efficiency benefits.
Profitability & Operating Efficiency
- Profit surge: PAT for 9M FY24 reached INR 1,049 Crore, exceeding the full FY23 total of INR 533 Crore, underscoring the earnings power of the scaled franchise.
- Cost-to-income leadership: The ratio sits at an industry-leading ~31%, built on low operating costs, low borrowing costs, and better NIM; management believes this is sustainable and expects further efficiency improvements.
- Opex trajectory: Opex declined QoQ due to efficiency gains, following the normal microfinance pattern where Q1 is high and Q4 is lowest; a small INR 5 Crore employee cost reversal in Q3 also helped.
- Opex guidance: Near-term opex-to-AUM is expected at 4.5% to 4.6%, with cost-to-income remaining between 31% and 33% going forward.
Udaya Kumar Hebbar: "We strongly believe that we can remain between 31% to 32% or 33% of the cost-to-income ratio going forward."
Asset Quality & Delinquency
- PAR 30 movement: The increase from 90 bps to 120 bps QoQ was attributed to three factors: normal seasonality in Q2 and Q3 (rain, holidays, festivals), slightly higher steady-state delinquencies outside Karnataka, and the temporary impact of floods in Tamil Nadu.
- Non-Karnataka variance: A roughly 10 bps difference in PAR emerged in non-Karnataka areas, particularly from northern Gujarat and parts of Rajasthan where some migration-driven stress is occurring.
- Tamil Nadu recovery underway: PAR in flood-impacted Tamil Nadu branches has been declining as strong recovery continues.
- Q4 normalization expected: Management expects asset quality to return to normalcy in Q4 and remain within guided numbers.
- ECL provisioning nuance: ECL rates for both standard and delinquent loans are higher in other states versus Karnataka, so faster growth outside the home state will lift provisioning slightly, but this is compensated by higher loan prices in those states.
Growth & Geographic Mix
- Full-year confidence: Management reiterated confidence in delivering 25% growth for FY24, with all guidance described as deliverable.
- Customer acquisition dip: Weaker client addition of 90,000 (versus 3.7 Lakh in the previous quarter) was due to a 2-3 week disruption in November from the core banking system upgrade; acquisition normalized in December. Attrition and write-offs in the quarter also partly offset gross additions.
- Unique borrower trend: The unique borrower ratio has fallen to 33-34% from north of 40% a year ago, a natural outcome of growing outside the home turf; about 11% of customers acquired from other MFIs become unique within a year.
- Branch expansion strategy: Most expansion is in 16 states outside the top 3-4, where branch additions are district-based and contiguous; in the top states, expansion is only via splitting existing branches due to their size. No new states are being entered.
- Madhya Pradesh stagnation resolved: The book in Madhya Pradesh had been stagnant at ~INR 1,450 Crore for four quarters due to vulnerability in some districts, particularly migration; issues have been fixed and growth has resumed.
Udaya Kumar Hebbar: "You are having release and, what we call, attrition also comes there. Attrition and write-off, both come in the quarter also. You need to look for a longer period."
Lending Rate Cut & Pricing Policy
- 50 bps reduction: The company reduced its lending rate by 50 bps for both the MFI and retail finance businesses during December and January.
- Policy-driven, not competitive: The cut was based on a board-approved pricing policy reviewed quarterly, which considers four factors: credit cost, operating cost, funding cost, and capital cost. Operating cost has come down by almost 50 bps, so the benefit was passed to customers.
- No RBI prompt: When asked whether any communication from the RBI prompted the review, management emphasized the importance of having the right policy and disclosures, and noted the regulator would ask if there were a big pricing change, but did not confirm any specific directive.
- NIM impact is gradual: The full impact of the revised pricing on portfolio yield will be realized over 18-20 months, so no major impact on NIM guidance is expected in any single quarter.
Udaya Kumar Hebbar: "The policy clearly defines every quarter to review and recheck. So, we are going by that process Rajiv."
Funding & Capital
- Borrowing mix shift: Bank borrowings declined from 55% to 50% of the mix QoQ, though the absolute amount rose with book growth; the strategy is to keep bank borrowing between 50% and 55%, with the remaining 45% diversified.
- Q4 bank drawdown planned: Bank borrowing may rise in Q4 as the company plans to draw maximum money from banks, with many sanctions currently undrawn.
- Stable borrowing cost: Marginal cost of borrowing is stable, and management expects it to remain stable in the near term.
- No capital raise needed: With a capital adequacy of 24.5% against a philosophical floor of 20%, management does not expect to raise capital for at least the next two to three years.
- ROE outlook: Growth and ROE are expected to be almost equal, so ROE should remain largely range-bound.
Udaya Kumar Hebbar: "We philosophically always want to maintain at least 20% of capital. So currently, we are at 24.5%. So, we are not expecting to raise any capital for at least the next two to three years time."
Strategic Initiatives
- Core banking system upgrade completed: The major CBS upgrade and migration was completed in November 2023, causing a 2-3 week disruption in business momentum; operations returned to normal in December. The upgrade enables significant business scalability and makes the company future-ready.
- CBS benefits to phase in: Management expects the upgrade to take two to three quarters to deliver significant benefits, which will span faster go-to-market, improved paperless processing, and quicker decision-making.
- Credit rating upgrade: CRISIL upgraded the rating from A+/Positive to AA-/Stable, making CreditAccess Grameen the highest-rated standalone microfinance company in India by three credit rating agencies.
- Retail finance product launched: A retail product has been piloted and launched, primarily to serve customers graduating from microfinance who expect better, differentiated products.
- Retail finance target: The medium-term guidance is for retail finance to reach 12% to 15% of AUM, with a timeline of FY27-FY28 (four to five years out).
Udaya Kumar Hebbar: "I think overall it will take a little more time, maybe two to three quarters to give a significant benefit to us. It will benefit in all areas and not just one I would say."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Full-year AUM growth | 25% growth | FY24 |
| Asset quality normalization | PAR to return within guided numbers | Q4 FY24 |
| Cost-to-income ratio | Remain between 31% and 33% | Ongoing |
| Opex-to-AUM | 4.5% to 4.6% | Near term |
| NIM stability | No major impact from 50 bps rate cut | Over 18-20 months |
| Bank borrowing mix | 50% to 55% of total borrowings | Next few years |
| Capital raise | No raise needed | At least 2-3 years |
| Retail finance as % of AUM | Reach 12% to 15% | FY27-FY28 |
| CBS upgrade benefits | Significant benefits to materialize | 2-3 quarters |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| AUM | ₹23,382 cr, +31.5% YoY |
| Disbursements | ₹5,344 cr, +10.3% YoY |
| Interest income | ₹1,245 cr, +45.6% YoY |
| Net interest income | ₹802 cr, +41.6% YoY |
| Net interest margin | 13.1%, firm |
| PPOP | ₹602 cr, +58.6% YoY |
| Profit after tax | ₹353 cr, +63.8% YoY |
| ROA | 5.5% (Q3 FY24); 5.6% (9M FY24) |
| ROE | 23.6% (Q3 FY24); 24.8% (9M FY24) |
| Cost-to-income ratio | 29.5% |
| Opex to AUM | 4.4% |
| Gross credit cost | ₹126 cr, partially offset by ₹10.9 cr bad debt recovery |
| Net credit cost | 0.5% (Q3 FY24); 1.3% (9M FY24) |
| GNPA (60 dpd) | 0.97%, vs 0.77% in Q2 FY24 |
| Net NPA | 0.29% |
| PAR 90+ | 0.75% |
| Collection efficiency | 98.3%, excluding areas |
| Capital adequacy | 24.5% |
| Customer base | 46.93 lakh, +19.2% YoY |
| Customer additions (12 months) | 14.86 lakh, 44% outside top 3 states |
| Customer acquisitions (quarter) | 2.7 lakh, vs 3.3 lakh in Q2 FY24 |
| Unique borrower share | 33% to 34% |
| Branch count | 1,894, 17 new branches in Q3; 100+ in 9M |
| Average cost of borrowing | 9.8% |
| Marginal cost of borrowing | 9.7% |
| Lending rate reduction | 50 bps for MFI and retail finance, effective Dec–Jan |
| Retail finance share of AUM | 2.1% |
| Customer retention | 85% to 88% |