Key Takeaways
- A brutal year ends with a cleanup quarter: Accelerated write-offs of INR 479 crore crushed Q4 profit to just INR 47 crore, but management argues this front-loads the pain to safeguard future profitability.
- Karnataka is the fresh wound: A hostile political and media environment ahead of a state ordinance drove a new spike in delinquencies from late January, delaying the industry's recovery timeline by at least a quarter.
- The recovery thesis rests on normalization, not growth: New PAR accretion rates have largely normalized outside Karnataka, and 40% of PAR 1-60 borrowers are making partial payments, but absolute stressed loans remain elevated.
- FY26 guidance embeds a long rehab: Management guided for 5.5-6.0% credit cost and only 8-12% MFI loan growth, signaling that elevated provisions and a cautious disbursement stance will persist through H1.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Karnataka PAR accretion normalizes by the end of Q1 as promised, the pace of the cleanup write-offs, and any sign that the Tamil Nadu political situation is mimicking Karnataka's trajectory.
The Karnataka Shock & Broader Delinquency Cycle
- The cycle's arc: Industry-wide delinquency began rising in April 2024, peaked in November 2024, and then reversed through March 2025. New PAR accretion rates largely normalized across all states except Karnataka by fiscal year-end.
- Karnataka broke the recovery: Stress became visible from the last week of January 2025 due to operational ambiguities ahead of the state ordinance, an on-ground hostile environment, media and political sensitivities, and collections being limited to centre meetings. The hostile situation persisted for roughly a month before the ordinance brought clarity.
- The over-leverage narrative is incomplete: Only 41% of PAR-15 comes from borrowers with more than three lenders. Management emphasized that the balance 60% stems from business-as-usual factors: income variations, heat waves, migration, and ringleader issues.
- Partial payments offer a floor: 40% of borrowers in PAR 1-60 and 10% of borrowers in PAR 60+ made partial payments, signaling that borrower willingness to repay remains intact even if full capacity is strained.
- Tamil Nadu is calm but watched: Management stated there is "absolutely no change or no impact as on date" from the Tamil Nadu bill, and contrasted it with Karnataka where heightened media, police, and political intervention preceded the ordinance. The FY26 credit cost guidance assumes no Tamil Nadu disruption.
Udaya Kumar Hebbar: "In Karnataka, what happened, there was a heightened media, police, political intervention, everything before the ordinance, and that led to the ordinance. There was a hostile situation for a month actually. By that time the delinquency was elevated and the ordinance came later with the clarity. So then slowly delinquency came down. Whereas in Tamil Nadu there is no such situation at all."
Portfolio Quality & Provisioning Mechanics
- ECL coverage declined on mix, not model revision: Stage-3 borrowers paying more than 50% of EMIs attracted a lower credit cost based on historical experience, causing roughly a 2% variation in total ECL coverage. Stage-2 ECL fell because a higher proportion of delinquency came from Karnataka, which historically has more low-risk and medium-risk districts. Management did not confirm or deny an ECL model revision when asked.
- Provisioning fell QoQ for three reasons: (1) Karnataka's higher PAR share lowered the district risk weightage in the ECL model; (2) Stage-3 partial payers were assigned lower credit costs given current repayment behavior; (3) new PAR accretion declined compared to Q3 FY25, reducing fresh provisions.
- Write-off timeline has slipped: The original plan to complete the cleanup by end of June 2025 may now extend by another quarter to September because of the Karnataka disruption. Write-offs will be concentrated in H1 FY26.
- Ex-bucket collections are the preferred lens: Management argued that with absolute PAR elevated, ex-bucket collection efficiency is more relevant for assessing true collection effectiveness. Once provisioning and write-offs are complete, standard collection efficiency will return as the norm. An analyst noted that ex-bucket metrics improve mechanically as delinquent borrowers drop from the denominator; management did not directly address this concern.
Udaya Kumar Hebbar: "If you put the PAR as a control, it is difficult to assess the actual efficiency because every part of even 0.1% actually increase the total PAR. Therefore, the ex-bucket becomes relevant today." [16-17]
Growth Strategy & Product Mix Shift
- MFI growth takes a back seat: FY26 group lending growth is guided at 8-12%, with H1 expected to be flattish excluding write-offs before catching up in Q3 and Q4. Even on a steady-state basis, microfinance growth is seen range-bound at 8-14% through FY28.
- Retail finance is the accelerator: Management aims for 14-18% overall AUM growth in FY26, with the gap above MFI growth filled by retail finance. By FY28, non-microfinance loans are targeted at 12-15% of the book.
- Secured mix to double: The secured loan book currently stands at 25% of retail finance; management aims to take it to roughly 50% over the next 2-3 years. Home loans will follow a partnership route once there is sufficient traction and book size.
- PBT neutrality across products: The company will optimize pricing on retail finance products to remain competitive while maintaining PBT-level neutrality and consistent ROAs. NIM is not expected to face major pressure from the mix shift, helped by minimal acquisition costs from existing customers.
- Customer growth levers remain: Management sees 7-8% customer growth potential, with retained customer renewals still possible and 30-40% unmet demand persisting even in districts with 80% MFI coverage.
Liability & Cost Management
- ECB diversification underway: The company raised USD 50 million through the ECB route from IFC in Q4 FY25, moving toward a medium-term target of sourcing 25-30% of funds from foreign sources by FY28.
- Marginal cost of borrowing ticked up: Q4 marginal cost was 9.6%, higher than earlier borrowings because of the significant IFC draw, but still below the average cost of borrowing of 9.8%. Management expects no impact on the overall cost of borrowing and sees a declining trend ahead.
- Employee base expanded for collections intensity: Roughly 8% extra employees were added, largely in Tamil Nadu where Q3 attrition was high. This expanded base is expected to improve monitoring, connectivity, and follow-up intensity in coming quarters. Annualized attrition was maintained at 30.5% amid high industry churn.
- Centre meeting attendance improving: Attendance has recovered across Bihar, UP, Jharkhand, and Odisha, with borrowers returning to centre meetings and in-centre payments increasing.
Industry Structure & Regulatory Response
- Every cycle reinforces the basics: Management argued that the fundamentals of microfinance remain intact. Regulatory gaps between different player types have been closed, the industry is collaborating under SROs, and underwriting systems are improving.
- Data infrastructure is strengthening: Bureau data frequency has improved from monthly to fortnightly by regulation, enabling faster identification of multiple lending. MFIN now tracks KYC and multiple-lender data for members. Voter IDs are deduped and validated through the voter ID portal before customer acquisition.
- Audit intensity has increased: The audit team has been expanded to audit branches at a frequency of less than 45 days.
- Multiple-lender borrowers are not a permanent loss: 80% of borrowers with more than four lenders (excluding Karnataka) continue making payments. Because loans are short-term, customers who drop out may become eligible again within three months after paying down installments.
Nilesh Dalvi: "This is not going to be a permanent loss for us. It is only a temporary adjustment wherein the borrowers will have to wait for some time, get their obligations under control and they again become eligible."
Leadership Transition
- MD retiring, CEO elevated: Udaya Kumar Hebbar will retire as Managing Director on 25 June 2025 and will be appointed as a non-executive Nominee Director (subject to approvals) and to the Managing Board of CreditAccess India B.V. CEO Ganesh Narayanan will be appointed as MD & CEO for a five-year term from 26 June 2025, subject to RBI and shareholder approval.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Karnataka PAR normalization | New PAR accretion rate in Karnataka to normalize | By end of Q1 FY26 |
| FY26 AUM growth | 14% to 18% overall; MFI 8% to 12%, balance from retail finance | FY26 |
| FY26 NIM | 12.6% to 12.8% | FY26 |
| FY26 credit cost | 5.5% to 6.0% (no buffer for Tamil Nadu ordinance risk) | FY26 |
| FY26 ROA | 2.9% to 3.4% | FY26 |
| FY26 ROE | 11.8% to 13.3% | FY26 |
| Write-off cleanup completion | Originally June 2025; may extend due to Karnataka | By September 2025 |
| Normalized credit cost | 3.0% to 3.5% (steady-state, post-cleanup) | FY26; future years to be reviewed |
| Foreign funding mix | 25% to 30% of borrowings from foreign sources | By FY28 |
| Non-MFI loan mix | 12% to 15% of total loans | By FY28 |
| Secured loan mix within retail finance | ~50% (from current 25%) | Over next 2-3 years |
| Multiple-lender customer reduction | Customers with >3 lenders and >₹2 lakh ticket size to decline to industry-accepted level | Over 2-3 quarters |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Net profit | ₹47 cr |
| PPOP | ₹634 cr in Q4 FY25, ₹2,638 cr in FY25 |
| Net interest income | ₹876 cr, up 1.7% QoQ |
| NIM | 12.7% in Q4 FY25, 12.9% for FY25 |
| Portfolio yield | 20.4% |
| Interest spread | 10.3% |
| Cost-to-income ratio | 31.9% |
| Credit cost | ₹583 cr in Q4 FY25, ₹1,929 cr or 7.7% for FY25 |
| ROA | 1.9% for FY25; cross-cycle ROA of 3.6% over past 8 years |
| ROE | 7.7% for FY25; cross-cycle ROE of 14.4% over past 8 years |
| AUM growth guidance (FY26) | 14% to 18%, with MFI growth of 8% to 12% and balance from retail finance |
| NIM guidance (FY26) | 12.6% to 12.8% |
| Credit cost guidance (FY26) | 5.5% to 6% |
| ROA guidance (FY26) | 2.9% to 3.4% |
| ROE guidance (FY26) | 11.8% to 13.3% |
| Gross loan portfolio (GLP) growth guidance, group lending (FY26) | 8% to 12% |
| PAR 90 | 3.28% |
| GNPA | 4.76%, measured at 60-plus DPD |
| NNPA | 1.73%, measured at 60-plus DPD |
| Collection efficiency (excluding arrears) | 91.9% for Q4 FY25, 92.4% for March 2025 |
| New PAR accretion rate, May 1–14 | 0.12% |
| Ex-bucket collection efficiency, April | ~99.2% overall, ~99.5% excluding Karnataka |
| Total write-offs in FY25 | ₹1,124 cr |
| Accelerated write-offs in FY25 (180+ DPD) | ₹479 cr, resulting in additional credit cost of ₹151 cr |
| Provision coverage over PAR 90 | 179 bps, or ₹457 cr higher provision over PAR 90 |
| Provision coverage over IRAC prudential norms | 370 bps, or ₹959 cr higher provision |
| Average cost of borrowing | 9.8%, stable for last seven quarters |
| Marginal cost of borrowings in Q4 | 9.6% |
| Share of foreign borrowings | 21.0% at end of FY25, moving toward FY2028 target of 25% to 30% |
| Capital adequacy | 25.4% |
| Liquidity (cash and cash equivalents) | ₹2,336 cr, 8.4% of total assets |
| Sanctions in hand | ₹3,618 cr; sanctions in pipeline: ₹4,664 cr |
| Borrowers added in Q4 FY25 | 2.61 lakh, of which 43% new-to-credit |
| FY25 new borrower addition count | 7.49 lakh |
| Unique borrower count | 31.1% at end of March 2025, up from 26.3% in August 2024 |
| Branches opened during FY25 | 100 |
| Employee strength | 20,970 at end of March 2025, up from 19,333 in December 2024 |
| Annualised employee attrition rate | 30.5% in Q4 FY25 |
| Retail finance AUM | ₹1,543 cr, contributing 5.9% of AUM, up from 2.7% a year ago |
| Retail finance AUM breakup | Unsecured: ₹1,100 cr; secured business lending: ₹240 cr; home loans: ₹110 cr; overall mortgage book: ₹350 cr |
| Retail finance PAR 30 | Unsecured business loan: 1.97%; secured business loan: 0.89%; home loans: almost nil |
| Borrowers with >3 lenders and >₹2 lakh unsecured indebtedness | 10.8% in March 2025, down from 19.1% in August 2024 |
| Average total unsecured debt of CA Grameen borrowers | Declined 14% YoY |
| Average monthly obligations of CA Grameen borrowers | Declined 10% YoY |
| PAR 15, borrowers with >3 lenders | 41% of overall PAR 15 of 6.6%; this set is about 2.5% of overall customers |
| Disbursement rates as proportion of normal rate | Dropped to 57% in February and 65% in March |
| Microfinance growth range-bound expectation (FY27–28) | 8% to 14% |
| FY28 target for non-microfinance loans | 12% to 15% of total loans |