Key Takeaways
- A year of consolidation, not growth: CSL missed its AUM target as industry-wide unsecured stress spilled into secured lending, forcing a deliberate pivot to caution over rapid expansion.
- SME Retail bore the pain: Asset quality deteriorated solely in SME Retail, driven by external shocks (elections, weather) and a failed pilot product, pushing the AUM mix toward Wholesale.
- Profitability hit from multiple fronts: PAT reflected higher provisions, write-offs, and elevated operating costs from branch expansion, while NII was dragged by negative carry on excess liquidity.
- Management promises a reset: With credit policies tightened, team structures realigned, and a new prime product launched, the company expects SME Retail to return to growth and recoveries to begin accruing from FY26.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised SME Retail growth materializes after two quarters of silence on guidance, and if elevated write-offs and provisioning actually subside as forecast.
The SME Retail Reset
- External shocks compounded internal churn: The segment serves the bottom 30-40% of the population in semi-rural and rural areas. The first four to five months of FY25 were lost to elections, a severe heat wave, and a strong monsoon, which directly impacted repayment behavior.
- Contagion from unsecured lending: Slippages from MFI and unsecured segments spilled into CSL's secured portfolio, while concerns about overleveraged borrowers became more prominent across the industry.
- Credit policy went stricter than the industry: CSL adopted even tighter credit policies than peers, prioritizing caution over rapid growth. This led to a year of consolidation in SME Retail, shifting the AUM mix in favor of the growing Wholesale segment.
- Suvidha pilot was a costly detour: The pilot product with APL Apollo targeted a community-dominated segment with 100% cash collection. Operating costs proved too high, maintaining a 90-day DPD cycle was difficult, and the achievable 26-30% yield was insufficient for operating profits. Management stopped it and committed to only secured lending going forward.
- Senior hires did not pay off yet: Over the last two years, expense incurred on senior and middle-level hires did not generate corresponding revenue due to low performance on the SME side. Management says no further senior hires are needed for the next 12 to 18 months.
- Cancellation rates eliminated: Earlier, a large proportion of SME sanctions used to get cancelled before disbursement. Due to regulatory changes and internal process corrections, cancellation is now practically 0% for the last 3-4 years, so all reported numbers are actual disbursements.
Management: "we believe that it's the time to move from the kind of startup kind of culture to the growth phase of the company itself. We are definitely damn sure that onwards the products are ready, everything is ready and we would be doing a good growth the coming years onwards."
Asset Quality & Recoveries
- Slippages rose solely in SME Retail: GNPA and NNPA increased due to SME Retail deterioration, with some additional impact from the Suvidha pilot during the first half of the year.
- Write-offs elevated, recoveries promised: Write-offs increased in FY25, but management expressed confidence in making decent recoveries from these cases over the next 12 to 18 months, with recoveries beginning to accrue from FY26.
- Foreclosures were substantial: Last year, the quantity of foreclosures matched disbursements. Pre-payment came partially through borrowers' own sources or takeovers by other lenders, generating substantial foreclosure charge income.
- Provisioning expected to subside: Elevated provisioning and write-offs should decline in the coming year as the credit cycle turns and tighter policies take effect.
Product & Channel Evolution
- New prime product added at lower ROIs: A new product targets prime borrowers in Cat A/B locations with ticket sizes of ₹20-60 lakh. An auto-builder system now determines interest rates algorithmically, with limited discretionary power for negotiation.
- Product structure simplified: Earlier schemes (Unnati, Pragati) have been consolidated into LAP Self-Employed and LAP Salaried. ROI bucketing has been expanded to target a broader customer segment.
- DSC and connector platform opened: In the last 3-4 months, CSL launched a Direct Selling Channel and connector platform to source prime-segment business from larger companies, a channel that was not available earlier.
- Supply chain finance in early pilot: The company has started working on supply chain finance at an evolving stage. Origination will be done by CSL with small fees in association with one or two NBFCs, without going on CSL's books initially. Management will experiment for the next 6 months and share more after September.
- Yield moderation expected: Average yields should moderate due to a mix of reducing ROI and changed product policies, though the overall weighted IRR is expected to remain the same as the new prime product will not exceed 5-10% of the total SME book even after a full financial year.
Chandan Kumar: "the players, which you have mentioned, SBFC and Capri not name, but they're definitely working at the lower IRR between 12 to 14% where our average bracket is between 16 and a 1/2 to 22-23% on the SME side."
Funding, Costs & Margins
- Cost of borrowing rose marginally, not sharply: Management disputed an analyst's calculation of a 104 bps increase, stating the weighted average cost of borrowing moved from 11.12% to 11.22%, and was never 9.4% or 10.8%.
- Repo-linked benefit incoming: Borrowing costs linked to Repo and T-bills have already come down by 25 bps. Reset clauses of 3-month and 6-month tenors will further reduce rates as they kick in, with benefits from the February RBI rate cut accruing from Q1 and subsequently from the April cut.
- Negative carry should not repeat: Last year, most disbursements and sanctions happened at quarter-end (₹200-250 crores in 7 days), requiring money to be parked in short-term liquid funds and FDs, creating significant negative carry. Management expects this scenario will not repeat this financial year. [11-12]
- Branch expansion will pressure near-term profitability: New branches take 9-12 months to stabilize and become profitable, so there will be a "little hit on the bottom line" initially, compensated in coming years. Operating costs are expected to normalize as new branches mature and begin contributing to AUM growth.
- Employee cost ratio should improve: As SME numbers start going up, employee cost as a percentage of revenue will come down because proportionate increases in employee cost will not accompany branch-level hiring.
- Lender base expanded: Nine lending partners were added, bringing the total to 32. The borrowing mix is 72% from banks (including private, public-sector, and small finance banks) and 28% from NBFCs.
Rohit Gupta: "No, no, no. I don't know, Sir. Neither it was 9.4 ever. We never had 9.4, and neither it was 10.8. Our weighted average cost of borrowing was 11.12, and it went up to 11.22."
Capital & Leverage
- Debt capacity sufficient for near term: Existing ability to raise debt for the next 1 to 1.5 years will be more than sufficient, giving the company room to raise equity at appropriate levels depending on market conditions.
- Leverage targets by segment: Wholesale book is targeted at 1.5 to 2 times, while SME Retail is targeted at 3 to 4 times in the initial phase over the next 18-24 months. When pressed on whether 2.5 times overall is the comfortable equity ratio, management deflected with "You can interpret that way." [13-14]
- Equity dilution may come later: Focus is to build SME and show numbers first. Once SME starts performing and the mix improves in favor of SME, capital infusion would enable much faster growth. Equity dilution to a "reasonable big player" may be considered at the right time after SME numbers are proven.
Rohit Gupta: "Strategically I would not like to give numbers, but definitely as you said, once those that kind of infusion also happens then the growth becomes much faster."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| AUM growth floor | Bare minimum growth of 20-25%, matching the last 2-3 years' trajectory | FY26 |
| AUM growth guidance | Will provide better guidance after observing performance | After Q2 FY26 |
| SME Retail growth target | 30%+ growth in SME business | FY26 |
| NII growth improvement | Higher than last year's 15%, with 100-200 bps improvement as SME mix increases | FY26 |
| SME Retail AUM mix | 50-60% of total AUM (original 60% target by FY27 may not be achieved) | Next 18-24 months |
| Recoveries from write-offs | Decent recoveries from elevated write-off cases to begin accruing | FY26 onwards |
| Provisioning and write-offs | Elevated levels to subside | FY26 |
| Operating cost normalization | Costs to normalize as new branches mature and contribute to AUM | As branches stabilize (9-12 months per branch) |
| Employee cost ratio | Employee cost as percentage of revenue to decline as SME numbers rise | Next 12-18 months |
| Supply chain finance update | Will share more details after experimenting for two phases | After September 2025 |
| Senior/middle-level hiring | No requirement for senior and middle-level hires for expansion | Next 12-18 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY25 |
|---|---|
| AUM | ₹1,195 cr, +5% QoQ and +25% YoY |
| Loan book | ₹1,157 cr as of year-end |
| SME Retail to Wholesale AUM mix | 34:66 for FY25 |
| Net Interest Income (FY25 full year) | ₹146 cr, +21% YoY |
| PAT (FY25 full year) | ₹72 cr, +14% YoY |
| GNPA increase | +2 bps over previous financial year |
| NNPA increase | +9 bps over previous financial year |
| Weighted average cost of borrowing | 11.22%, up from 11.12% in FY24 |
| Cost of borrowing increase | +0.10% for the full year |
| Total lending partners | 32, with 9 added during the year |
| Total branches | 43, net addition of 14 in FY25 |
| Borrowing mix: banks vs NBFCs | 72% from banks, 28% from NBFCs as of March 31 |
| Co-lending AUM managed off-book | ₹700 cr |
| Dividend recommended | ₹3 per equity share |
| Employee cost as a percentage of revenue | 12–13%, stable over last 3–4 years |
| SME average IRR bracket | 16.5% to 22–23% |
| Current leverage | 1.3x |
| Target leverage: wholesale | 1.5x to 2x over next 18–24 months |
| Target leverage: SME retail | 3x to 4x in initial phase over next 18–24 months |
| New branch break-even timeline | 9 to 12 months |