Key Takeaways
- Volume-led quarter, margin squeeze: Sales volume jumped 27% YoY on capacity expansion, but a 20% QoQ fuel cost spike and weak pricing pushed margins down; management flags exit prices below quarterly averages.
- Cost leadership intact: Total cost of Rs. 4,360/ton and freight of Rs. 1,096/ton remain among the industry's lowest, with the adverse cost delta likely the narrowest in the sector.
- Fuel relief is coming, not here yet: Q2 fuel cost stays elevated near \$220 before tapering; petcoke has already softened to \$180-190, with the benefit expected in Q3.
- Capacity expansion on track, next phase delayed: The 4.9 crore ton FY24 target is intact, but announcements for the next leg toward the 11-13 crore ton FY31 ambition are "a little bit more delayed than promised."
- What to watch next quarter: Whether price increases in North and Central spread to West, East and South; the actual Q2 fuel cost print; and any concrete inorganic opportunity emerging from sector consolidation.
Volume & Operating Performance
- Broad-based volume growth: The 27% YoY increase was driven by a 17% capacity rise and utilization climbing from 64% to 69%, with growth across both East and South regions including the North East.
- Murli ramp-up progressing: Now in its second quarter of operation, the acquired asset typically needs 9-12 months to stabilize and remains on track for ~60% utilization by year-end.
- Blended cement ratio rose to 82%, lifting the low-carbon share and helping reduce CO2 emissions to 468 kg/ton, among the lowest globally.
- Power cost managed dynamically: Where captive generation cost was high, the company pulled back and sourced more from the grid or IEX, optimizing the fuel and power mix in real time.
- Region-wise volume withheld: Management declined to share region-wise plant utilization or volume splits when asked.
Mahendra Singhi: "Friends, as Puneet just said, again I am delighted to share that we have emerged as probably the lowest cost producer with total cost of Rs 4,360/T."
Pricing & Realization
- Cost inflation outpaced price recovery: A 20% QoQ rise in average fuel cost (from \$180 to \$218/ton) met a sequential sales price delta of only ~3%, compressing margins.
- Exit prices weakened: Prices at quarter-end fell below the average for the period across all markets, signaling a deteriorating trajectory through the quarter.
- Regional divergence: Realization improved in Eastern and North Eastern markets while the South stayed slightly weak; July prices were stable but seasonally soft. Price increases in North and Central were promising, with West, East and South expected to follow.
- East remains the laggard: East pricing was lower versus other regions; management sees sluggishness now but expects better prices after two months when demand picks up.
- Non-trade pricing stays competitive: The non-trade segment is entirely competition-driven and management expects that dynamic to persist.
Costs & Fuel Trajectory
- Fuel cost the dominant headwind: Fuel consumption cost rose almost 20% QoQ, with Q1 average cost around \$220/ton. Q2 consumption cost is likely to stay elevated around \$220 before tapering, with an expected Q2 fuel cost of \$195-200 and Q3 at \$170-185.
- Petcoke and coal softening: Prices have started declining, with petcoke hovering around \$180-190; the benefit will flow through with a lag and land in Q3.
- Freight cost lowest in industry at Rs. 1,096/ton, though up 4% YoY on diesel inflation and a lead distance increase to 311 km.
- Slag cost pressure expected: Management anticipates a 10% plus or minus increase in slag prices but believes its own tie-ups will secure supply at that level.
- Renewable power economics compelling: Operational cost of 25-30 paisa per unit versus Rs. 7-9 for captive or grid power; total renewable capacity (solar plus WHRS) is expected to reach ~172 MW by year-end, covering ~16% of total consumption.
Capacity Expansion & Growth Ambition
- FY24 target locked: The committed expansion to 4.9 crore tons by March 2024 remains on track, with 0.2 crore tons of clinker, 0.11 crore ton of cement and 41.4 MW of renewable energy commercialized in Q1.
- Next phase delayed: Announcements for the next capacity phase are "a little bit more delayed than what we had promised this year"; management asks for patience and says it will return with updates as projects near finalization.
- Long-term vision intact: The ambition to reach 1.1-1.3 crore tons (11-13 crore tons) by FY31 stays, to be achieved through a mix of organic and inorganic growth.
- Limestone risk downplayed: Management called limestone availability concerns "overrated" and "blown out of proportion," stating it is comfortable across all plants and continues to augment resources. Land acquisition, not limestone, is flagged as the bigger risk for organic projects.
- East mining land acquisition progressing: All necessary government approvals obtained for the majority of the land; some portion already acquired; the full process is expected to complete in 1-1.5 years, with limestone extraction possibly starting in 6 months, adding over 20 years of reserves for Rajgangpur.
- Waste heat recovery rollout: All kilns will have WHRS by end of FY24 except one in the South where heat is needed for raw material processing.
Puneet Dalmia: "I personally think that this is the overrated risk, it is being blown out of proportion. We are very comfortable in all our plants and we continue to augment our resources in a way which is consistent with the long-term sustainable growth of the company."
M&A & Sector Consolidation
- Adani entry seen as positive: Management views Adani's arrival as a catalyst for more consolidation and believes sector attractiveness has increased, with India well-positioned among major economies.
- Inorganic pipeline expected to grow: After the Holcim exit, the assumption is that many good assets will come on the block, with small players facing pressure and domestic competition for deals likely to intensify.
- M&A driven by focus, not stress: Management believes future deals will be driven more by sellers focusing on other businesses or markets than by financial distress, barring a few situations.
- Net debt discipline: Net debt to EBITDA will stay under 2x during this expansion phase; the only exception would be a very strategic, very attractive acquisition where it may temporarily breach but would then be brought back down.
- Decisive but realistic on M&A: The company has demonstrated its ability to close and turn around acquisitions but acknowledges the competitive nature of the process: "you will win some, you will lose some."
Puneet Dalmia: "No, in fact, we think that Adani is a positive in this sector, it will lead to more consolidation and our belief is that sector attractiveness has gone up."
Balance Sheet & Accounting
- Debt reduction: Gross debt reduced by Rs. 131 crores in the quarter.
- Incentive accruals: Rs. 58 crores accrued and Rs. 44 crores collected in Q1; receivables stood at Rs. 683 crores. Full-year accruals including Murli are expected around Rs. 240 crores for each of FY23 and FY24.
- Employee welfare trust wound up: The trust was wound up over a year ago, was never consolidated in the company's books, and all related loans have been repaid.
- Accounting cleanup underway: The company has begun benchmarking its accounting policies against the best in the industry and country; the cleaning process is expected to be visible by year-end, over the next 2-3 quarters.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity expansion | Reach 4.9 crore tons | By March 2024 |
| Fuel cost trajectory | Q2: \$195-200/ton; Q3: \$170-185/ton | Q2 FY23, Q3 FY23 |
| Renewable power capacity | ~172 MW (solar + WHRS), ~16% of total consumption | By end of FY23 |
| Incentive accruals | ~Rs. 240 crores/year including Murli | FY23 and FY24 each |
| CAPEX spend | Rs. 3,000-3,500 crores | FY23 |
| Net debt to EBITDA | Remain under 2x (barring a very strategic acquisition) | During expansion phase |
| Margin outlook | Around 25% | Ongoing |
| Accounting cleanup | Policies benchmarked and cleaned | Visible by end of FY23 |
| WHRS coverage | All kilns covered except one in South | By end of FY24 |
| East mining land acquisition | Full process complete; limestone extraction possibly in 6 months | 1-1.5 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹3,302 cr, +27% YoY |
| Sales volume | 0.62 crore tons, +27% YoY |
| Capacity utilization | 69%, up from 64% in Q1 FY22 |
| Total cost per ton | ₹4,360, one of the lowest achieved |
| Variable cost per ton | ₹2,224 |
| Freight cost per ton | ₹1,096, lowest in the industry, +4% YoY |
| Lead distance | 311 km |
| Average fuel consumption cost | \$218/ton, up 20% from \$180/ton in Q4 FY22 |
| Blended fuel cost per Kcal | 2.47, up from 2.07 in Q4 FY22 |
| Q2 fuel cost expectation | \$195–\$200/ton |
| Q3 fuel cost expectation | \$170–\$185/ton |
| Blended cement ratio | 82% |
| Cement-to-clinker ratio | 1.67 |
| CO2 emissions | 468 kg/ton of cement, one of the lowest globally |
| Power consumption | 64 units/ton of cement, one of the lowest in Indian cement industry |
| Trade mix | 63% |
| Renewable energy capacity commercialized in Q1 | 41.4 MW |
| Waste heat recovery capacity at end of Q1 | 37 MW |
| Renewable energy capacity projected by end of FY23 | ~170 MW, ~16% of total consumption |
| Renewable power operational cost | 25–30 paisa/unit (ex-interest and depreciation) |
| Incentive accrued in Q1 | ₹58 cr |
| Incentive collection in Q1 | ₹44 cr |
| Incentive receivable as on 30 June | ₹683 cr |
| Full-year incentive accruals expected (incl. Murli) | ~₹240 cr each for FY23 and FY24 |
| Gross debt reduction | ₹131 cr |
| CAPEX spent in Q1 FY23 | ₹525 cr |
| Total budgeted CAPEX for FY23 | ₹3,000–₹3,500 cr |
| Clinker capacity commercialized in Q1 | 0.2 crore tons |
| Cement capacity commercialized in Q1 | 0.11 crore tons |
| Murli operations utilization target by year-end | ~60% |