Key Takeaways
- Volume recovery, price still soft: Volumes rebounded to +8.1% YoY after two subdued quarters, but exit prices slipped back to September-quarter levels, muting the sequential price gain.
- Margin snapped back to 21.5%: EBITDA margin recovered from the 12.8% trough in Q2 FY23, driven largely by a 23% YoY drop in power and fuel cost as commodity prices stabilized.
- Jaypee deal closing is the near-term catalyst: Management is confident the acquisition will consummate this quarter (Q4 FY24) , unlocking the path to bring those assets onto Dalmia’s cost structure.
- Mid-teens volume ambition for next year: The company is targeting 15–16% YoY volume growth and an industry EBITDA per ton of INR1,100–1,200, though the timeline between FY25 and medium-term was left blurry.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Jaypee deal actually closes, the pace of green power capacity additions now that panel prices have fallen, and the promised expansion roadmap announcement.
Volume & Pricing
- Volume snapped a soft patch: 8.1% YoY growth in Q3 followed two quarters of subdued performance; management attributed the pickup to initiatives taken during the quarter and expects to build on the momentum.
- Pricing improved sequentially, then gave back: A 4% sequential price rise in both East and South was undercut by quarter-end exit prices that fell back to September-quarter levels, signalling that the improvement was not durable.
- East market share gained despite weakness: Management believes it gained share in most markets, especially in the East, even though the Eastern market itself was very soft in Q3.
- Long-term pricing assumption is modest: The company models only 1.5–2% CAGR price growth over the long term, consistent with the last two decades, and expects quarterly volatility around that trend.
Puneet Dalmia: "While the pricing could be volatile for a few quarters, I believe prices will grow 1.5% to 2% CAGR on an average over the long term as we have seen over the last two decades."
Costs & Margin Recovery
- Fuel costs drove the margin rebound: Power and fuel cost fell 23% YoY on a \$53/ton decline in fuel consumption cost; management expects a further marginal reduction of around 3% in Q4.
- Freight cost rose sequentially: A 6.5% QoQ increase came primarily from the busy-season surcharge added in Q3, plus some increase in lead distance and L2 movements.
- Renewable power share dipped temporarily: RE percentage fell to 25% from 29% due to an unplanned stoppage at one plant’s WHRS facility; the issue is resolved and the share is expected back to normal in Q4.
- Raw material costs were flat sequentially: Overall raw material costs dropped about 3% over nine months and were nearly flat quarter-on-quarter; management declined to provide a slag or fly ash breakup.
- One-off depreciation charge: INR9 crores of the INR45 crores YoY depreciation increase relates to components replaced under the debottlenecking project, which had been previously flagged.
Jaypee Acquisition & Tolling
- Deal closure expected this quarter: Management is confident the acquisition will consummate in Q4 FY24; the delay has been on the lender-approval process, not on Dalmia’s side.
- Tolling profitability is materially lower: JPA tolling margins are significantly below core business margins because the operation is still in its investment phase (first 18–24 months), building a dealer network and brand in a new region.
- Cost structure reset waits on ownership: Dalmia does not yet have full control of manufacturing operations, so the cost structure remains high; bringing it to Dalmia’s level can only happen after the acquisition completes.
- Clinker shortfall manageable: The 0.94 crore tons of acquired capacity will have some clinker deficit during ramp-up, but required clinker is available, and management sees expansion opportunities for both clinker and cement within the same assets.
Puneet Dalmia: "We still don't have full control of the manufacturing operations. So the cost structure of these plants is also quite high. And I think to bring them to the Dalmia cost structure, it can be done only once we complete the acquisition."
Capacity Expansion & Capital Allocation
- 2031 target reaffirmed: The company remains committed to 11–13 crore tons by 2031, with an interim milestone of 7.5 crore tons by FY27 and a guardrail of 2x net debt to EBITDA.
- First milestone nearly met: 4.66 crore tons will be completed by March 2024, against the 4.9 crore ton target; closing Jaypee this quarter would bridge the gap.
- Next expansion announcement delayed: Planning is largely done and final details remain, but the announcement has been pushed back by a quarter because this year’s volumes have been subdued.
- Green power additions to accelerate mid-year: Solar panel prices have fallen significantly recently; management noted that had contracts been signed six months earlier, the company would have locked in higher rates. The bulk of RE additions may come around mid-year or Q3 of the coming year.
- Pan-India ambition intact: The company wants a significant presence in every market, targeting that position by 2031.
Rajiv Bansal: "So we have put an intermediate milestone of 7.5 crore ton for FY27. And we also have put a guardrail of 2x net debt to EBITDA for ourselves."
Balance Sheet & One-Offs
- Divestment proceeds flowed in: The final INR120 crores tranche from the Hippo Store divestment was received, along with an INR320 crores installment from refractory assets; the balance INR320 crores is due September 2024.
- Short-term debt repaid: With cash inflow of INR440 crores, some short-term debt was repaid during the quarter.
- Treasury MTM gain booked: An INR476 crores mark-to-market gain on the IEX holding increased the treasury balance by INR704 crores.
- Incentive collections ran ahead of accruals: Q3 collection of INR153 crores exceeded the INR69 crores accrual; over nine months, accruals and collections were nearly equal at INR217 crores and INR216 crores respectively.
Industry Structure & Long-Term View
- Consolidation thesis intact: Management believes entry barriers in the cement business are rising and that consolidation is inevitable, even though periods of high competitive intensity will occur.
- ROCE expectation set at 15%: Leading players should earn about 15% return on capital employed on a blended basis (post-tax, incentives included), though new assets normally take a couple of years to reach that level.
- Demand growth question deflected: When asked for industry demand growth in Q3 and nine months, management declined to provide a figure, suggesting the analyst likely had better numbers.
Puneet Dalmia: "My personal view is that, in the long term, the entry barriers in this business are rising. And I feel that there will be periods of high competitive intensity. But we feel that consolidation is inevitable in this business."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Jaypee acquisition close | Deal consummation; lender approval process underway | Q4 FY24 (this quarter) |
| Capacity milestone | 4.66 crore tons completed; Jaypee close bridges gap to 4.9 crore ton target | March 2024 |
| Volume growth | Mid-teens YoY | Next year (FY25) |
| Industry EBITDA per ton | INR1,100–1,200 range, barring unforeseen events | Next year |
| Fuel cost reduction | Marginal reduction of ~3% in fuel consumption cost | Q4 FY24 |
| RE percentage | Back to normal levels after WHRS stoppage resolved | Q4 FY24 |
| Green power mix | Close to or upwards of 35% | By end of FY25 |
| Capacity milestone | 7.5 crore tons, with 2x net debt to EBITDA guardrail | FY27 |
| Capacity target | 11–13 crore tons | By 2031 |
| ROCE target | ~15% blended post-tax return on capital employed | Steady-state (new assets: ~2 years to reach) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Volume | 0.68 crore tons, +8.1% YoY |
| 9M FY24 volume | 2 crore tons, +9% YoY |
| Revenue | +8% YoY, in line with volume growth |
| EBITDA margin | 21.5%, up from 12.8% in Q2 FY23 |
| EBITDA per ton | ₹1,138, up from ₹656 in Q2 FY23 |
| Total cost per ton | ₹4,147 |
| Power and fuel cost per ton | ₹1,102, down 23% YoY |
| Blended fuel cost | ₹1.50 per million kcal |
| Freight cost per ton | ₹1,091, down 2% YoY; lead distance 283 km |
| Employee cost | ₹221 crores, up ₹28 crores YoY |
| Renewable power consumption | 25%, down from 29% QoQ due to unplanned WHRS stoppage |
| Blended cement share | 84% |
| Trade sales share | 63% |
| Premium cement share of trade sales | 21% |
| Closing gross debt | ₹4,928 crores |
| FY24 capex guidance (excl. Jaypee) | ~₹3,000 crores |
| FY25 capex guidance (incl. Jaypee) | ₹3,000–3,500 crores |
| Next-year volume growth expectation | Mid-teens |
| Long-term price growth assumption | 1.5%–2% CAGR |
| Industry demand growth expectation (FY24) | 8.5%–9% |
| Incentive accrual (Q3) | ₹69 crores; collection ₹153 crores |
| FY24 expected incentive accruals | ₹280–300 crores |
| Jaypee acquisition cash outflow | ~₹3,300 crores, expected consummation by June 2024 |
| Capacity by end FY24 (excl. Jaypee) | 4.66 crore tons; South capacity 1.7 crore tons |
| Jaypee capacity | 0.94 crore tons |
| CC ratio | 1.66 |
| Rail-road mix | 86% road, 14% rail |
| Fuel mix | 54% petcoke |
| Green power mix target by end FY25 | Close to or upwards of 35% |
| Expected industry EBITDA per ton range | ₹1,100–1,200 |
| Expected ROCE for leading players | 15%, post-tax, incentives included |