Key Takeaways
- Dismal optics, deliberate reset: Q2 FY24 looks weak against an abnormally high base, but management frames it as a quarter of expected stabilization costs and one-off hits, not structural decay.
- Ammonia plant: the drag and the promise: Stabilization losses hit EBITDA by ₹87 crores and PBT by ₹148 crores, but the plant is now at 100% capacity and the spread between gas-linked cost and global ammonia is $100–$150.
- Subsidy and dumping compressed returns: A backward-looking subsidy formula cost the company ₹106 crores, while Russian dumping of fertiliser-grade ammonium nitrate pressured TAN margins.
- Specialty pivot is the long thesis: Management is betting that scaling up steel-grade nitric acid, solar-grade nitric acid, pharma-grade IPA and an outcome-based mining solutions model will insulate earnings from commodity cycles.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the ammonia plant sustains 90–100% utilization and captures the current spread, the pace of TAN margin recovery now that exports are partially allowed, and any NCLT progress on the demerger.
Ammonia Plant: Stabilization Cost vs Strategic Benefit
- Stabilization loss quantified: The plant was commissioned in early August, so Q2 absorbed roughly two months of incremental depreciation and interest. The stabilization loss was ₹148 crores at PBT and ₹87 crores at EBITDA, which management calls "quite normal and expected" for a global-scale plant.
- Plant now at designed capacity: After a quarter of trips and restarts, the plant has stabilized and already reached 100% of designed capacity. Management expects 90–100% utilization through H2.
- The spread that matters: The benefit is driven by the gap between the company's gas-linked production cost and FOB Middle East ammonia prices. That spread is currently $100–$150, though management notes it will change over time with global prices. The recent UMPP benefit change to 100% (from 75%) for this greenfield project is factored in.
- Risk mitigation angle: A running ammonia plant provides "huge risk mitigation" for the group's downstream businesses by insulating them from global ammonia price swings, a structural benefit that sits above the quarterly spread.
- Peculiar Q2 headwind: Ammonia prices during the quarter were unusually low at $330 in the Middle East, which compressed the realized benefit. Prices have since climbed to $550.
S.C. Mehta: "Now on the face of it, as we look at the figures, I'm sure we all would feel that it seems to be quite dismal. However, let me share some insights for your better appreciating and understanding the numbers."
Fertiliser & TAN: Policy and Dumping Headwinds
- Subsidy mechanics hurt: The government's backward-looking subsidy formula (based on the previous six months' prices) created a mismatch when global raw material prices rose. The company took a ₹106 crores hit on the discount applied to channel inventory that had been sold but not yet moved to farmers. Management does not expect further changes because the subsidy notification runs until March 2024.
- Russian dumping compressed TAN: Sanctions on Russia have redirected cheap fertiliser-grade ammonium nitrate to India, one of the few remaining open markets. The anti-dumping duty imposed in 2017 had a five-year tenure and has expired, leaving the domestic industry exposed. Despite this, the company insured strong volume growth in Q2.
- TAN margin disconnect: WAN prices normally move in tandem with ammonia IPP prices, but they are currently not doing so. Management expects things to "get better from where it is" but concedes "we'll have to wait and watch how the actual year pans out."
- Export ban partially lifted: The government lifted the TAN export ban with a 20,000-ton cap for this financial year, implemented state-by-state rather than abruptly. Future quantities will be reviewed based on domestic demand and supply for mining and infrastructure.
- Capacity expansion underway: The company is adding 50,000 metric tons of TAN capacity by March 2024.
Tarun Sinha: "Timeline is anybody's guess, so we would not speculate."
Industrial Chemicals: Mixed Currents
- Nitric acid under double pressure: The business faced a monsoon lull plus downstream agrochemical and pharma customers impacted by Chinese dumping.
- IPA running positive: The IPA business had a "very positive current" and capacity utilization could improve from 76% if demand continues.
- Chemical margin caution: Management expects some margin pressure for "a couple of quarters" because ag-chem prices are not moving in line with TAN prices, but frames this as a wait-and-watch situation.
Specialty Pivot & Mining Solutions
- The transformation thesis: Management is steering the company from commodity to specialty, targeting steel-grade nitric acid, solar-grid nitric acid, and pharma-grade IPA. The stated goal is to create "good insulation from global vagaries" and bring Deepak into "a complete different light" over the next few years.
- Solar specialty chemicals: Production is set to start from October 2023.
- Mining Solutions: outcome-based model: The company is developing a Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) model where it guarantees KPIs across drilling, blasting, excavation, transport and crushing, rather than simply invoicing for explosives inputs as competitors do. Management declined to put a revenue figure on this early-stage initiative, calling the entire Indian mining and infrastructure industry the long-term opportunity.
- Strategic investor for mining: Discussions continue; management will communicate when Board approvals are obtained.
Tarun Sinha: "All the explosive manufacturers in India, they supply explosives to the mining industry... They invoice the client for the inputs... What we are developing as a business model is... we guarantee certain outcomes as a result of the inputs that we provide to the mines and infrastructure projects."
Corporate Restructuring & Balance Sheet
- Demerger progress: Smartchem (housing TAN and fertiliser) has been renamed Mahadhan Agritech Limited. The NCLT hearing for the demerger is fixed for 10th November, with the outcome awaited. License transfers for the highly regulated TAN business are in final steps and expected to complete "hopefully in this month."
- Demerger listing: No approvals have been obtained to go for listing; plans will be communicated when firmed up. When asked about the strategic objective behind the restructuring, management described the structural change (separating TAN from CNV, renaming to Deepak Mining) but did not articulate the strategic rationale.
- Debt comfort: Management states the company will remain in a comfortable position from a gross debt-to-equity perspective, but declined to provide a peak debt figure or timeline when asked.
- Pune real estate: The company will look for a sale opportunity and take action based on Board approvals.
- New CFO: Mr. Deepak Rastogi introduced as President and Chief Financial Officer.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Ammonia plant utilization | 90–100% capacity utilization | H2 FY24 |
| TAN capacity expansion | Additional 50,000 metric tons | By March 2024 |
| Solar specialty chemicals production | Production start | October 2023 |
| TAN export quantity | 20,000 tons allowed; government to review based on domestic demand/supply | FY24; review next year |
| NCLT demerger hearing | Hearing fixed; outcome awaited | 10th November 2023 |
| Fertiliser subsidy policy | No changes expected; notification applicable | Until March 2024 |
| License transfers for TAN business | Final steps expected to complete | "Hopefully in this month" |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total operating revenue | ₹2,424 cr |
| Operating EBITDA | ₹286 cr, 11.8% margin |
| Net profit | ₹63 cr, 2.6% margin |
| EBITDA charge, ammonia plant stabilization | ₹87 cr |
| EBITDA charge, fertiliser inventory subsidy | ₹106 cr |
| Gross debt to equity | 0.76x |
| Manufactured TAN business revenue | ₹516 cr |
| TAN sales volume growth | Over 9% YoY |
| Manufactured Pharma/Specialty Chemicals revenue | ₹409 cr |
| IPA volume growth | 62% YoY |
| Nitric acid volume growth | Almost 12% YoY |
| Manufactured fertiliser revenue | Around ₹708 cr |
| Manufactured NP/NPK sales volume | 1,47,000 metric tons, vs 1,55,000 metric tons in Q1 FY24 |
| IPA capacity utilization | 76% |
| Ammonia plant spread, current | $75 to $100 |
| Ammonia plant spread including government benefit | $150 to $160 (per an analyst's math) |
| TAN export ceiling for FY24 | 20,000 tons |
| TAN capacity addition by March 2024 | 50,000 metric tons |
| Ammonia plant capitalized cost | Close to ₹4,500 cr |