Key Takeaways
- Revenue down 22% YoY, but margins up across segments: The headline decline was driven by a Diwali timing shift in Consumer Electronics, a sharp open-cell price correction, and sluggish Lighting demand, yet operating margins expanded in Consumer Electronics, Lighting, Home Appliances, and Mobile phones through value engineering and cost optimization.
- ODM is now the profit engine: ODM contributed 24% of sales but ~48% of operating profits, up from ~20% last year, as Lighting and washing machine margins recovered to sustainable levels.
- Mobile revenue halved vs guidance, but a doubling is promised for FY24: FY23 mobile revenue closed at ~₹4,000 crores vs an earlier ₹5,000+ crore target because Motorola’s U.S. export volumes did not materialize; management expects two new customer wins to double revenue to ~₹8,000 crores in FY24.
- The balance sheet is in its best shape yet: Net debt to equity fell to 0.06, working capital days stood at positive 1 day, and ROCE improved to 26.3%, driven by debt reduction and cash flow discipline.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the two new mobile customers are onboarded on schedule and start contributing revenue, whether Motorola’s FY24 export plan firms up, and whether U.S./Europe lighting export breakthroughs materialize.
Revenue Decline: The Mechanics
- Consumer Electronics: a timing and pricing story, not a demand collapse. YoY revenue fell ~39% because Diwali was one month earlier, pulling peak sales into Q2 and leaving Q3 volumes 17% lower, while open-cell prices corrected from ~₹16,000 to ~₹11,500 per unit, compressing the selling price. Over 9 months, volumes actually grew 16% YoY even as revenue declined 21%, confirming the price pass-through effect.
- Lighting: three headwinds hit at once. Sluggish demand, a reduction in commodity prices and freight rates, and a technology migration from driver-based LED bulbs to driver-on-board (DOB) SKUs, which carry an 18–20% lower unit value, all compressed the top line. The monthly revenue run rate had shrunk to ₹75–80 crores before recovering to ₹110 crores in Q3.
- Mobile phones: the Motorola export bet did not pay out. Motorola’s volumes to U.S. operators dwindled as the global smartphone market weakened, and expected export volumes simply did not materialize. Motorola’s India market share was sustained, but that was not enough to offset the export shortfall.
- Security surveillance: relocation costs created a temporary margin drag. Operating profit and margin declined YoY and QoQ mainly due to shifting expenses and duplication of fixed costs during the campus relocation from Tirupati to Kopparthi.
Atul Lall: "Undoubtedly, we appreciate your input. But please appreciate in our nature of the industry, we are a B2B company. And we are closely associated with the budgeting exercise of our customers. On the basis of their inputs, we plan our capacities and we plan our numbers."
Margin Expansion: The ODM Story
- Consumer Electronics margin expanded 90 bps YoY to 3.1% as Dixon migrated step-by-step from pure manufacturing to owning the design, capturing more value per unit even as selling prices fell.
- Lighting margin jumped 90 bps QoQ to 9.1% through a combination of lower input prices, calibrated pricing actions, inventory planning, and value engineering. Management called this level sustainable in the coming months.
- Home appliances margins improved both YoY and QoQ by passing on commodity cost and exchange rate fluctuations to customers, alongside improved operating leverage and cost optimization.
- Mobile phones margin expanded despite the revenue shortfall, driven by a huge focus on generating more efficiency and cost optimization. The 9-month mobile and EMS margin stood at 2.8%, with mobile-only at ~2.5–2.6%.
- ODM profit contribution surged: ODM now delivers 24% of sales but ~48% of operating profits, up from ~20% last year, and is growing fast in absolute terms. Lighting and washing machine margins are sustainable in the coming months at current ranges, and TV margins are also sustainable due to larger ODM/JDM volumes.
- Volume recovery could add a small margin upside: When volumes return next year, operating leverage could provide a further lift, though the core margin improvement is structural, not volume-dependent.
Atul Lall: "I'm kind of sanguine about it. What you are saying is correct. So, we have to keep watching and let's see how it evolves. So, we can't be absolutely gung-ho about it. I think it's going to be guarded kind of growth in existing businesses."
Mobile Phones: The Big Reset
- FY23 revenue is expected to close at ~₹4,000 crores, well below the ₹5,000+ crore target, because Motorola’s export volumes to U.S. operators dwindled and the global smartphone market weakened. Motorola’s India share held, but the export pipeline did not deliver.
- Two new customer wins are the FY24 doubling story. Management expects the first account to close within a week and the second by the end of the current quarter; together they can potentially add almost ₹6,000 crores in annual revenues. FY24 mobile revenue is guided to double to ~₹8,000 crores, with the two new customers expected to add at least ₹5,000 crores.
- New customer 1 is expected to generate ₹1,000–1,200 crores in FY24, starting around Q2. New customer 2 is expected to generate ₹2,500–3,000 crores. One account is combined domestic and export, the other mainly domestic-focused to start.
- Margins on new customers will be higher because commercials have been partly negotiated, fixed costs get absorbed on much larger revenues, and operating leverage kicks in. Mobile margins should inch up in FY24 from the current ~2.5–2.6%, based on the broad commercials and operating benefit.
- Motorola FY24 remains an open question. Budget discussions are ongoing and numbers are not concluded; management is reassured that more exports will come but is adopting a "let's wait and watch" stance.
- The contract structure limits downside but does not protect profit: When Motorola does not meet volume commitments, it compensates Dixon for CAPEX investment and certain fixed costs, but the profitability element is not covered. Machinery cost amortization is covered at a higher rate on lower volume, but profit is lost.
Saurabh Gupta: "Those margins will be definitely higher than what we are doing today because those commercials have been partly negotiated. And plus the fixed cost gets absorbed of the team there on a much larger revenues."
New Business Development
- Google ODM license secured: Dixon closed ODM sublicensing rights with Google for Android and Google TV, opening an opportunity pool of an additional 0.1 crore TV sets over 1–1.5 years. One project is already signed with one brand, and rollout is expected by Q1 of next fiscal.
- Lighting exports gaining traction: First supply to a new UAE customer was executed in Q3, repeat orders have been received for Q4, and consistent business is now established. Breakthroughs in LED bulbs and ceiling lights for the U.S. and Europe are expected in the next quarter, with execution starting from Q3.
- Lighting technology acquisition completed: Dixon acquired Bluetooth mesh technology and a work-in-progress WiFi solution for smart lighting from Ibahn Illumination, and hired Kunal Chaudhary as Head of R&D for Lighting Solutions. New smart products leveraging the acquisition will launch in Q1 of next fiscal.
- Telecom and networking orders won: A very large order for HD Zapper set-top boxes from Airtel was bagged, along with large business for Android set-top boxes in partnership with a global ODM. Mass production for both starts by Q2 of next fiscal, and the Android business has potential to expand to geographies outside India.
- Wearables and hearables ramping: Dixon is manufacturing TWS and smart watches for Samsung, with a heavy weighted front in Q4. More SKUs like Bluetooth speakers and smart watches will be added next fiscal, and SMT for PCB will be done in-house.
- Refrigerator construction underway: Construction has started on 20 acres in Greater Noida, trial production is expected to start in Q2 of FY24, and a positive response has been received from multiple global and national brands.
- IT hardware PLI 2.0 on the horizon: Dixon was a beneficiary of the IT PLI scheme 1, achieving both CAPEX and revenue thresholds with anchor customer Acer. The government is expected to roll out a much larger, more attractive PLI scheme 2, and Dixon is confident of being awarded.
Segment-Level Outlook
| Segment | FY24 Outlook | Key Drivers |
|---|---|---|
| Mobile phones | ▲ Revenue doubling to ~₹8,000 crores | Two new customer wins adding ₹5,000+ crores; Motorola volumes assumed flat |
| TV | ▲ ~15% volume growth to 0.42–0.43 crore units | New customer additions; large portion ODM; Google Android solutions contributing |
| Washing machines | ▲ Fully-automatic volumes to more than double | Semi-automatic growing ~15% with current customers; fully-automatic realizations much higher |
| Lighting | ▲ 15–20% growth | Revenue run rate recovered to ₹110 crores/month; exports to Middle East, U.S., and Europe ramping |
| Home appliances | ▲ More than 100% growth targeted | New customer additions (Bosch, TCL, Onida, Lloyd, Croma, SHARP); healthy order book |
| Consumer Electronics | ▬ Guarded growth | ODM/JDM migration in active discussion; backward integration into injection molding starting |
| IT hardware | ▬ Premature to quantify | Waiting for PLI scheme 2 rollout and brand contract conclusions |
- Export revenue in FY24 is sensed at ₹2,300–2,500 crores, depending on the Motorola plan. The new mobile customer includes exports, and lighting is expected to crack more export accounts.
- CAPEX in FY24 is guided at broadly ₹250–260 crores, lower than FY23, because mobile asset turns are significantly higher and new customers do not require proportionate CAPEX.
Atul Lall: "They're reassuring us that more export is going to come in, but let's wait and watch on that."
Balance Sheet & Capital Efficiency
- Net debt to equity fell to 0.06 as gross debt was reduced by ₹223 crores in 9 months, with a further ₹50 crore reduction targeted before March 31, 2023.
- Working capital days stood at positive 1 day, driven by a huge focus on the cash conversion cycle and working capital management.
- ROCE improved to 26.3% and ROE to 22.3%, and management is confident both will keep improving on account of more debt reduction, working capital efficiency, and improved earnings.
- Lighting capital employed reduced by ₹161 crores due to a huge focus on current investment, freeing up capital for other segments.
- Free cash flow generation was strong post-CAPEX of ₹114 crores in 9 months, enabling the debt paydown while still funding growth investments.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Mobile revenue doubling | FY24 mobile revenue to reach ~₹8,000 crores (vs ~₹4,000 crores in FY23) | FY24 |
| New mobile customer 1 revenue | ₹1,000–1,200 crores contribution | FY24, starting around Q2 |
| New mobile customer 2 revenue | ₹2,500–3,000 crores contribution | FY24 |
| Mobile margin improvement | Margins to inch up from current ~2.5–2.6% on better commercials and operating leverage | FY24 |
| TV volume growth | ~15% growth to 0.42–0.43 crore units | FY24 |
| Washing machine fully-automatic volumes | More than 100% growth | FY24 |
| Home appliances revenue | More than 100% growth | FY24 |
| Lighting revenue growth | 15–20% growth | FY24 |
| Export revenue | ₹2,300–2,500 crores | FY24 |
| CAPEX | Broadly ₹250–260 crores | FY24 |
| Debt reduction | Further ₹50 crore reduction | By March 31, 2023 |
| Google TV/Android product rollout | First products to market | Q1 FY24 |
| Lighting PLI plant operational | New Dehradun plant for LED lighting components | March 2023 |
| Security surveillance relocation | New Kopparthi facility operational | March 2023 |
| Refrigerator trial production | Trial production start | Q2 FY24 |
| Telecom set-top box mass production | HD Zapper and Android set-top boxes | Q2 FY24 |
| U.S./Europe lighting export execution | First shipments | Q3 FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹2,408 cr, degrowth of 22% YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA | ₹114 cr, growth of 10% YoY |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹52 cr, growth of 12% YoY |
| Consumer Electronics revenue | ₹864 cr, down 39% YoY; volumes down 17% YoY |
| Consumer Electronics operating margin | 3.1%, expansion of 90 bps YoY |
| Lighting revenue | ₹253 cr |
| Lighting operating margin | 9.1%, expansion of 90 bps QoQ |
| Home appliances revenue | ₹244 cr |
| Home appliances operating margin | 10.3%, improved YoY and QoQ |
| Mobile phones and EMS revenue | ₹915 cr |
| Mobile phones and EMS operating margin | 3.6% |
| Security surveillance revenue (Dixon share) | ₹118 cr |
| Wearables and hearables revenue (boAt) | ₹85 cr in Q3, ₹230 cr in 9 months |
| ODM share of sales | ~24% in first 9 months, up from ~20% last year |
| ODM share of operating profits | ~48% |
| ROCE | 26.3% as on 31st December 2022 |
| ROE | 22.3% as on 31st December 2022 |
| Net debt | ₹68 cr, net debt to equity of 0.06 |
| Working capital days | Positive 1 day at end of December quarter |
| Free cash flow post CAPEX | ₹114 cr in first 9 months |
| Gross debt reduction | ₹223 cr in first 9 months |
| TV volumes | 6.9 lakh units, down from 8.3 lakh YoY; 26.7 lakh in 9 months, up 16% YoY |
| TV weighted average selling price | ~₹11,500, down from ~₹16,000 YoY on open cell price decline |
| TV volume growth guidance (FY23) | ~20% growth vs 0.29 cr last fiscal |
| TV volume guidance (FY24) | 0.42–0.43 cr units, ~15% volume growth |
| Mobile revenue guidance (FY23) | ₹3,800–4,000 cr |
| Mobile revenue guidance (FY24) | ~₹8,000 cr, doubling from FY23 |
| Two new mobile customers annual revenue potential | At least ₹5,000 cr in FY24, up to ₹6,000 cr potential |
| Motorola volumes (Q4 expected) | 800,000 to 850,000 units |
| Lighting monthly revenue run rate | ₹110 cr in current quarter, recovered from ₹75–80 cr |
| Lighting growth guidance (FY24) | 15–20% |
| Semi-automatic washing machine volume (FY23) | ~0.15 cr units, up from 0.11 cr in FY22 |
| Fully-automatic washing machine volume (FY23) | ~160,000 units, expected to double in FY24 |
| Export revenue (FY23) | ~₹1,100 cr closing estimate |
| Export revenue guidance (FY24) | ₹2,300–2,500 cr |
| CAPEX (FY23) | ₹360–380 cr |
| CAPEX guidance (FY24) | ₹250–260 cr, lower than FY23 |
| PLI incentive booked (9 months) | ~₹8–9 cr |
| Bill discounting at quarter-end | ~₹130 cr, interest rate ~7.5–8% |
| Interest cost for the quarter | ₹15 cr, including ₹4 cr MDS adjustment |
| FY23 revenue guidance | ₹12,200–12,700 cr |