Key Takeaways
- Disappointing quarter despite decent top line: EBITDA margins and profit collapsed, driven by a sudden ~65% crash in sulfur prices that forced the company to absorb inventory losses as customers refused to pay on higher raw material cost.
- Demand disruption is global and interconnected: European energy crisis and supply chain destocking caused shipment deferrals, while even Indian customers exporting to Europe dragged down demand indirectly. Management believes destocking is nearly exhausted.
- Capex cycle complete, debt at peak: All planned capex including the Dahej speciality chemical plant is finished. Working capital pressure is easing as inflated raw material prices come off, and no significant new investment is planned.
- Speciality margins held; bulk chemicals took the hit: Contractual raw material pass-through protected the speciality business, while the bulk side bore the full brunt of the price crash. Speciality volumes also held up better than bulk.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether destocking truly ends by December as management expects, the pace of Dahej speciality plant ramp-up, and any signal on Ukraine settlement that could unlock European demand.
The Sulfur Price Shock
- What happened: Main raw material prices crashed within a couple of weeks in July, with sulfur dropping ~65%. Market prices fell immediately, but customers refused to pay on the older, higher raw material cost, forcing DMCC to absorb the loss.
- Accounting treatment: Most of the inventory loss impact was already captured in Q2 numbers under weighted average cost accounting.
- Bulk vs speciality split: The speciality business was largely insulated because most contracts are written or understood to adjust for raw material fluctuations. The bulk side, where no such protection exists, took the full hit.
- Forex added to the pain: A mark-to-market loss of about ₹3 crores was booked on foreign currency term loans due to rupee devaluation, despite the company having a positive foreign currency revenue balance over the loan tenure.
Bimal Goculdas: "But if the demand itself is disrupted then the question of cost and all does not arise."
Demand Environment
- Destocking cascade: High energy prices and uncertainty in Europe drove customers to reduce stock across the supply chain, which in turn pushed panicky producers to drive prices down further. Shipment deferrals were widespread.
- Destocking floor in sight: Management believes destocking is nearly over, arguing there is nothing left to destock. Customers in dyes, intermediates, and pigments are operating at low levels but will eventually have to restart buying just to maintain operations by end of December.
- Discretionary vs non-discretionary split: Purchases that can be postponed (cars, components) are being delayed, while non-discretionary items like medicines continue. Management could not quantify the company-level split between the two categories.
- Interconnected demand: DMCC does not distinguish between domestic and export demand because they are always linked. Supplying to an Indian company that exports to Europe means a European slowdown hits DMCC indirectly. Energy costs in India are under control and a growing population helps, but all chemicals going overseas are affected directly or indirectly.
- Quantification avoided: Management called the demand impact "significant" but declined to put a percentage number on it when pressed by an analyst.
Bimal Goculdas: "We do not really distinguish between the two demands, because they're always interconnected. If we supply to a company in India, but that company is exporting to Europe. Then, if their customer is affected, it will affect us as well. So this is a global situation. Everything is interlinked."
Capex & Capacity
- Capex cycle complete: All planned capex is finished, including the speciality chemical plant at Dahej commissioned during the second part of the quarter. Bulk chemical and other plants were also recently commissioned.
- Debt at peak: Management believes debt has peaked. Working capital pressure is easing as inflated raw material prices come off, and no significant investment is planned.
- Revenue potential: At full capacity utilization, around ₹500 crores of visible top line is expected, depending on price levels.
- Dahej sulfuric acid: Once specialties reach capacity, management expects roughly 50% consumed in-house and about 50% sold externally.
- Dahej strategy: The idea is to replicate Roha operations at Dahej, with some products common and some different.
- Boron constraints: Raw material availability is better than last year but still insufficient. There is effectively one global supplier trying to meet everyone's needs, and it is not enough yet. Some investments on the boron side may be considered but nothing is final.
- Energy recovery: Plans underway at Roha to reduce carbon footprint and reduce dependence on the grid.
Segment & Product Performance
| Segment | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Speciality chemicals | ▬ Stable margins | Contractual raw material pass-through protected margins; volumes did not see much de-growth. |
| Bulk chemicals | ▼ Hit hard | No raw material price protection; bore the full inventory loss from the sulfur price crash. |
| Sulfone division | ▬ Reasonably well | Continuing to perform but not seeing full impact due to global slowdown; now has a couple of products in line vs relying on one previously; customer approvals expected to yield results in next six months. |
| New products | ▲ Early stage | Three new products launched in last six months from the multipurpose plant; individual names not disclosed. |
- Dahej speciality ramp-up: The main plant was commissioned in January, but expansion may take longer than liked because of the Ukraine situation. Under normal conditions, full capacity utilization would have been achieved by March-April; the delay depends on an unknown: the Ukraine situation.
- Intermediate plant: Recently commissioned and going through approval processes with an anchor client (non-exclusive). The Europe situation has slowed things down; management expects to reach capacity by next year.
- Dedicated sulfur-based products plant: At Dahej, expected to ramp up in the next quarter or two.
Costs & Maintenance
- Repair & maintenance elevated: Running at 3-5% of top line every quarter due to ongoing infrastructure upgrades at Dahej (roads, laboratories to international standards) and Roha (infrastructure, roads), plus advance payments for a planned maintenance shutdown in the October-December quarter.
- Base effect distortion: Last year had no sulfuric acid plant at Dahej and significantly lesser operations, so the comparison base is different. Management indicated that numbers from October to March onwards, published at end of April, will give a clearer picture of the likely trajectory.
- Shutdown impact muted: Demand itself has slowed down, so the company has been able to fulfill most demand despite the shutdown. Many customer segments are not showing great requirement at this time.
Investment Thesis & Payback
- Competitive positioning intact: Management believes the company has made the right investment to be among the lowest cost producers anywhere in the world and is well positioned for the medium term.
- Payback extended by war: The payback period, originally three years, may now be four years because of the war. The major investment was on the bulk chemical plant where a longer-term view was taken.
- No near-term capex: Enough capacity exists for the immediate time. No significant capex plans are on the table.
Bimal Goculdas: "...in the medium term, we believe we've made the right investment where we will be the lowest cost producers anywhere in the world so that way we are well positioned, instead of three years, you may have a payback for four years because of the war."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Destocking end | Supply chain destocking cannot go further down; customers must restart buying just to maintain operations | By end of December |
| Dahej speciality ramp-up | Ramp up the speciality chemical plant | Over the next few quarters; full capacity was originally expected by March-April, now delayed by Ukraine situation |
| Sulfur-based products plant ramp-up | Dedicated plant at Dahej expected to ramp up | Next quarter or two |
| Sulfone customer approvals | Should have some results from the customer approval side | Next six months |
| Intermediate plant capacity | Reach full capacity, subject to Europe situation | By next year |
| Repair & maintenance trajectory | Clarity on likely going-forward level | Numbers published end of April (October-March period) |
| Payback period | Originally three years, now expected at four years due to the war | Medium term |
| Europe recovery | No recovery expected unless there is a settlement in Ukraine | Conditional on Ukraine settlement |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| Net profit/loss | Loss of ₹2.8 cr |
| Inventory loss (sulfur price crash) | ~₹15 cr, sulfur price dropped from ₹35,000/ton to ₹10,000/ton on ~5,000 tons held |
| Forex mark-to-market loss | ~₹3 cr, rupee devalued from 75 to ~81 on ~$5 mn foreign currency loans |
| Raw material price crash | ~65% drop in main raw material prices within a couple of weeks |
| Revenue potential at full capacity | ~₹500 cr visible top line from current investments |
| Sulfuric acid capacity | 2 lakh tons, doubled from 1 lakh ton with new Dahej plant |
| In-house consumption of sulfuric acid | ~50% at both Roha and Dahej, once Dahej specialties reach capacity |
| Asset turnover – specialties | 2–2.5x expected |
| Asset turnover – commodities | 1–1.5x expected |
| Planned maintenance shutdown (Q3 FY23) | ~25 days, Roha site almost totally shut, ~1/3 of quarter lost at Roha |
| New products launched (last 6 months) | 3 products, smaller volumes from multipurpose plant, expected decent bottom-line contributors |
| Sulfone division products | A couple of products now in line |