Key Takeaways
- Volume stagnant, price-led growth: Revenue grew 10.4% YoY, but liquid milk volumes were flat as price hikes taken over 3-4 quarters did the work. Unseasonal rains, a Karnataka rate dispute, and industry-wide pack-size reductions all weighed on offtake.
- Deliberate inventory build is the quarter's strategic call: Procurement is running well ahead of sales to flip the company from a net buyer of powder to a net seller, a move management argues will stabilize milk pricing and quality. Inventory may end the year ₹50-70 cr higher.
- Margin inflection promised next quarter: The procurement-to-selling-price spread of ₹18-₹19 is sustainable or better, and procurement prices are expected to ease. Management guided for a double-digit EBITDA margin in the coming quarter and 9-10% as a sustainable run-rate thereafter.
- Two new plants, two different clocks: The cattle feed plant was commissioned in September and will scale through H2; the Kenya plant begins trials in Dec-Jan with commercial production by March 2024. A third plant in Maharashtra is at the land-acquisition stage with a ~2-year timeline.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised double-digit margin materializes as procurement prices ease, the pace of cattle feed plant ramp-up, and any update on Kenya trial runs.
Volume & Revenue: The Price-Volume Split
- Price hikes carried the quarter: The 10.4% YoY revenue growth was almost entirely price-led, with liquid milk volumes stagnant. Rate increases in Karnataka caused a correction as cooperatives lagged in raising prices, while unseasonal rains and stagflation in per-pack volumes (price increases met with grammage reductions across the industry) further suppressed offtake.
- No bulk sales cushion: The company did no bulk sales in Q2; all revenue was B2C, so the topline reflects end-consumer demand with no wholesale fillip.
- Value-added mix improved quietly: Value-added product share rose 100 bps, but because fat sales dropped from 2% to 1% of mix while other VAPs rose from 3% to 4%, the headline VAP shift looks small. Beneath the surface, the non-fat VAP category is gaining share.
- Pre-COVID comparison: Revenue is up 57% versus Q2 FY21, with milk sales rising from 10.25 lakh liters to 14.15 lakh liters over the same window.
The Inventory Bet: Net Seller, Not Net Buyer
- Procurement is running hot on purpose: A strong flush season let the company procure far more milk than it sold. Management is deliberately building powder inventory so it can become a net seller of commodities if needed, rather than a net buyer, a structural shift intended to stabilize milk pricing and maintain quality.
- Inventory will stay elevated through year-end: By March, inventory may be ₹50-70 cr higher than normal, but the company expects to maintain its usual year-end status quo. The build replaces the normal practice of buying third-party powder stocks in Nov-Dec-Jan with own-manufactured powder.
- Commodity balancing act: The company is matching procurement and sale because sale output in solids and milk is higher than input (less buffalo milk, more cow milk). Small surpluses can be sold as commodity, but the core strategy is to avoid dependence on third-party milk or powder purchases.
Sunil Reddy: "we will keep increasing our procurement in the future that we will not be a net buyer, but we will become a net seller if required of commodities of powder to make our milk pricing more stable and keeping the quality of milk to be higher is what the call that we have made."
Margin Bridge & Outlook
- Gross margin jumped on procurement prices: A 4.2% QoQ gross margin expansion was driven primarily by lower procurement prices. The spread between selling and procurement prices sits at ₹18-₹19, a level management called sustainable or improvable.
- Procurement prices expected to ease further: In the coming quarter, procurement prices are not expected to increase and may come off a bit, which would help margin improvement.
- New plants will not drag EBITDA: Management stated that new plants, including Kenya, will not operate negatively at the EBITDA level. Depreciation may impact PAT marginally, but not materially at the EBITDA line. The cattle feed plant's shift away from third-party manufacturing also removes a profitability headwind.
- Operating margin may flex on growth spend: While gross margins are expected to hold, operating margins may vary depending on spending to capture market share.
Sunil Reddy: "I think we can look at the double digit -- the coming quarter can come to the double digit margin. And also going forward, I think we can try to be closer to them, right, between the 9% to the 10% should not be much of an issue."
Capacity Expansion: Three Plants at Three Stages
- Cattle feed plant (commissioned): The new plant was commissioned in September 2023, expanding capacity from 2,000 tons to an additional 10,000 tons. Ramp-up will take the third quarter; numbers become visible from Q1 next year. Current utilization is ~2,000 tons, with another 1,000-1,500 tons expected once stabilized. Raw material prices are stable with only minor jumps, and costs are passable to farmers.
- Kenya plant (trials imminent): Trial runs are scheduled between December 2023 and January 2024, with commercial production likely in March 2024, subject to trial results. Africa revenue will be "little flattish" this year versus last, and permitting issues between Uganda and Kenya cause revenue variability. Seasonality means Q1 profitability is high, Q2 low, and Q3 has already picked up.
- Maharashtra plant (land stage): The board approved ₹15 cr for land acquisition in Eastern Maharashtra. The company already collects 2.2 lakh liters per day from Solapur district and targets 5 lakh liters per day in 2-3 years. The plant will start with milk collection and condensing/powder-making, eventually adding product sales. Capex is estimated at ₹100-150 cr or more, with an at-least-two-year timeline. Competition in Maharashtra is more from commodity players than cooperatives.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EBITDA margin | Reach double-digit margin | Coming quarter |
| Sustainable margin run-rate | 9% to 10% | Ongoing, starting from coming quarters |
| Procurement prices | Not expected to increase; may come off a bit | Coming quarter |
| Revenue growth | 10% to 12% by value, double-digit kind of growth | Ongoing |
| Inventory days | 20 days, might go up to 25-30 days | Near term |
| Kenya plant commercial production | Start commercial production, subject to trial results | March 2024 |
| Cattle feed plant numbers visible | Ramp-up numbers visible in financials | Q1 next year |
| Maharashtra plant operational | Integrated plant up and running | At least two years from now |
| Maharashtra plant capex | At least ₹100-150 cr, maybe more | Over the build period |
| FY24 capex | Reach around ₹60-70 cr for the year | FY24 |
| Cattle feed capacity utilization | 10-15% in remaining part of current year; 30-40% in another couple of years | Current year / 2 years out |
| Africa business revenue | Little flattish this year vs last year | FY24 |
| Margin guidance (conservative) | Deliver 8-9% range, maybe higher at year-end | FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹767.8 cr, +10.4% YoY |
| Domestic revenue | ₹715.5 cr, +11.2% YoY |
| International revenue | ₹52.1 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹70.2 cr, +19.2% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 9.1%, expanded 68 bps YoY; lower raw material pricing by 118 bps YoY, partly offset by employee and other expense growth |
| Profit after tax | ₹43.6 cr, +10.5% YoY |
| PAT margin | 5.7% |
| EPS | ₹7.26, vs ₹6.58 in Q2 FY23 |
| Value-added products revenue | ₹195.3 cr, +13.1% YoY |
| VAP share of dairy revenue | 26.1%, vs 25.2% in Q2 FY23 |
| Average milk procurement | 17 lakh litres per day, +18.9% YoY |
| Average milk sales | 10.9 lakh litres per day |
| Curd sales | 309.3 metric tons per day, +5.8% YoY |
| Curd sales value | ₹160 cr |
| Average procurement price (consolidated) | ₹38.3 |
| Average realization (consolidated) | ₹57.50 |
| Average procurement price (India) | ₹39 |
| Average sale price (India) | ₹57.5 |
| Cattle feed revenue | ₹20 cr in the quarter, +13% vs last quarter |
| Cattle feed EBITDA margin | 24.70%, vs 24.93% in prior period |
| Milk procured from farmers daily | ~1.4 lakh, 89% with direct bank payment |
| Villages covered for procurement | Over 8,500 |
| Processing plants | 15, with ~22 lakh litres per day capacity |
| Dodla retail parlours | 631 |
| Milk and milk distributor channels | 2,000+ |
| Agent network | ~2,700 |
| Market share in Karnataka | ~8% to 9% (per management estimates) |
| Inventory days expectation | 20 days, may go up to 25–30 days |
| FY24 capex budgeted (excl. new plant) | ~₹109 cr; ₹40 cr spent so far |
| FY24 full-year capex expectation | ~₹60–70 cr (per management) |
| New Maharashtra plant estimated capex | ₹100–150 cr (not yet finalized) |
| Revenue growth outlook | 10–12% by value |
| Historical revenue growth rate | 15–20% |