Key Takeaways
- Resilient quarter in a tough cycle: Revenue grew 17.4% YoY to ₹675 crores with 15% volume growth, even as the company navigated what management calls the worst milk shortage cycle it has seen.
- Margin held despite cost surge: Procurement prices rose ~₹5/liter (12%) while selling prices rose ~8%; the remaining gap was closed through operational efficiency, keeping gross margin at 25.3% vs 25.6% QoQ.
- International business is scaling fast: International revenue surged 32.7% YoY to ₹57 crores, and the new Kenya manufacturing unit is expected to add 20,000–30,000 liters of daily sales in its first year.
- The flush season is the near-term catalyst: Management expects procurement prices to correct by a couple of rupees post-April, while selling prices hold steady, a combination that would expand margins instantly.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the post-April flush season delivers the expected procurement price correction, the pace of the new Kuppam feed plant ramp-up, and any acquisition announcements as industry stress creates opportunities.
Milk Procurement & the Supply Cycle
- Worst cycle in memory: COVID disrupted animal impregnation cycles, excessive monsoons caused disease and grazing issues, and global price increases led India to export powder and fat stocks, creating a domestic deficit. Management stated this is the worst cycle the company has gone through.
- Procurement cost trajectory: 9M FY23 procurement cost per liter was ₹36 vs ₹31.7 in 9M FY22, a ~13.5% increase that drove the gross margin compression from 25.6% to 25.3% QoQ.
- Price transmission with a lag: The company passed costs to consumers with a 15-day to one-month time lag; selling price per liter moved from ₹48.9 in 9M FY22 to ₹52.2 in 9M FY23, partially mitigating the procurement increase.
- Procurement density rising structurally: Milk procured per farmer improved from 6 to 7 to 8 liters year-on-year; management believes this will only go higher because good hybrid cows give 12–15 liters during lactation and smaller-volume animals have largely exited the system.
- Farmer count fluctuation is tactical, not structural: Farmer count dropped from ~1,25,000 to ~1,20,000 in Q3 because procurement prices rose four times from April to December; if a competitor raises price one week earlier, some farmers shift temporarily. Payments go directly from the corporate office to 1,20,000–1,25,000 farmers every 2–3 days.
- CMC expansion as a moat: 22 Conventional Milk Coolers of 1,000-liter capacity were established over the past 1–1.5 years; these reduce vehicle trips from twice to once daily, cutting costs and improving milk quality. Next year, the company will explore increasing CMC numbers, assessed village-by-village based on volume viability.
Sunil Reddy: "I think that's the worst cycle that we have gone through. We are hoping that the cycle will improve and become better than expected."
Margin Structure & Resilience
- Gross margin held near-flat despite cost pressure: Consolidated gross margin declined only 30 bps QoQ (25.6% to 25.3%) in what management called one of the toughest years for operational prices, with fuel, packaging material and procurement prices all rising.
- Price-cost gap management: Procurement price rose ~₹5/liter (12%) while sales realization rose ~8%; the remaining 3–4% gap was covered through operational efficiency improvements.
- Volume sensitivity is the operating leverage: Management stated that even a slight improvement in milk volumes would move margins up instantly, because fixed costs are spread over a larger base and surplus milk enables higher plant utilization.
- Capacity utilization constrained by supply, not demand: Plant utilization was 64–65% for 9M because there was no surplus milk in the system; with fodder plants running, utilization would have been 77–80%. No front-end capacity additions are planned until an acquisition provides a new territory.
- Sri Krishna acquisition a minor drag: Sri Krishna contributed ₹47–48 crores revenue YTD at 2.68% EBITDA margin, dragging overall domestic EBITDA by less than 0.5%.
- Other expenses grouping is not a structural concern: Other expenses appearing at ~30% of grosses is a grouping issue, not structurally different from peers like Heritage Foods.
Sunil Reddy: "This is comparatively one of the years, which is the toughest years in terms of operational prices going up in terms of fuel, packaging material, procurement price, everything going up. And we've been able to maintain this margin level."
Value-Added Products & Mix
- VAP revenue grew 11.1% YoY to ₹153 crores, representing 23.1% of overall dairy revenue and demonstrating strong brand recall.
- Curd is the quiet growth driver: Curd revenue grew from ~₹107 crores in FY22 to ₹127 crores in FY23, driven by consumers viewing it as a health product and substituting away from aerated beverages. Growth is not double-digit industry-wide but is gaining traction.
- Fat revenue masked VAP strength: Fat revenue declined sharply in Q3 from ₹18 crores to ₹7.9 crores, dragging overall VAP growth perception; excluding fat, the underlying VAP portfolio performed well.
- Cheese is not a margin story: Management does not view cheese as truly value-added because cheddar cheese involves holding costs and whey byproduct utilization challenges that erode margins despite higher MRP.
- Retail parlor rationalization underway: The company is actively streamlining non-viable retail parlors, which currently represent around 11% of sales; management stated that parlor and non-parlor sales have "almost the same" EBITDA, with parlors serving a strategic rather than margin-accretive role.
Sunil Reddy: "I don't truly think it will be a value-added product. It depends on how you view in terms of appropriating your costs."
International Business & Inorganic Growth
- International revenue surged 32.7% YoY to ₹57 crores, with the Kenya acquisition adding a manufacturing unit to the existing Uganda operation, derisking each country and enabling market share gains.
- Kenya ramp-up target: Management expects to add 20,000–30,000 liters of daily sales in the first financial year from the new Kenya unit.
- Acquisition pipeline is active but cautious: The company is actively evaluating opportunities in adjoining states from Maharashtra to Odisha and expects some to arise this year due to industry stress. However, management held back this year because price volatility made acquisitions risky in the short term.
- Industry stress is creating bargains selectively: Stress is felt more by players unable to pass on price to customers and those who had not invested in back-end procurement earlier. Management will "actively keep looking" but insists on the right bargains.
- Organic growth remains the baseline: The company will pursue both organic and inorganic growth; no states have been finalized yet for the next market entry.
Sunil Reddy: "Current year the price is being so volatile. We didn't want to make acquisition because it might hurt us in the short-term. That's why we were a little low key this time."
Feed Business & Backward Integration
- Orgafeed revenue stood at ₹43 crores in 9M FY23 with EBITDA of approximately ₹4 crores, contributing to the company's backward integration strategy.
- New Kuppam feed plant imminent: A new feed plant at Kuppam (border of Tamil Nadu and Andhra) is expected to commence by end of March or first week of April; management is targeting at least another 15,000 to 20,000 tons in FY24 from this plant.
- Direct procurement as a structural advantage: Almost all milk is procured directly from farmers across more than 7,800 villages, with all collection center assets owned by the company and village rentals paid by the company. Agents act only as consolidators measuring milk quantity and quality via automated analyzers, with no role in pricing or payments.
Tax & Below-the-Line Items
- PAT growth was aided by a sharp decline in the effective tax rate from 36.4% to 19.5%, driven by a one-off goodwill write-back from the KC Dairy acquisition following a Finance Ministry announcement.
- Normalized tax rate is ~23% and is expected to remain in that range going forward.
- 9M YTD PBT dropped 0.3% vs last year, attributed to gross margin impact from procurement price increases, partially offset by lower financial costs and other income.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | Target historical growth rates of ~10% volume, ~15% value | Next 2–3 years |
| Feed plant ramp-up | Additional 15,000–20,000 tons from new Kuppam plant | FY24 |
| Procurement price correction | A couple of rupees differential expected as flush season arrives | Post-April |
| Selling prices | Expected to remain the same even if procurement prices correct | Post-flush season |
| Kenya capacity | 20,000–30,000 liters of daily sales added | First financial year from new unit |
| Tax rate | Normalized rate of ~23% | Going forward |
| Price hikes | No major increases expected; only marginal corrections if procurement prices rise further | Near term |
| CMC expansion | Explore and increase CMC numbers, assessed village-by-village | Next year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Operating revenue | ₹675 cr, +17.4% YoY |
| Domestic revenue | ₹618 cr, +16.2% YoY |
| International revenue | ₹57 cr, +32.7% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹54 cr, vs ₹52 cr in Q3 FY22 |
| Profit after tax | ₹35 cr, +29.6% YoY |
| EPS | ₹5.9, vs ₹4.48 in Q3 FY22 |
| Effective tax rate | 19.5%, vs 36.4% in Q3 FY22 |
| Consolidated gross margin | 25.3%, vs 25.6% in Q2 FY23 |
| Average milk procurement | 12.8 LLPD, +3.8% YoY |
| Average milk sales | 10.5 LLPD, +6.7% YoY |
| Procurement cost per liter | ₹37.8 (Q3), vs ₹36.0 9M FY23 average |
| Selling price per liter | ₹53.76 (Q3), vs ₹52.2 9M FY23 average |
| VAP revenue (incl. fat) | ₹153 cr, +11.1% YoY; 23.1% of dairy revenue |
| Curd sales | 260 MTPD, +5.9% YoY |
| Plant capacity utilization | 64–65% (9M cumulative) |
| Farmer count | 1,21,000, vs 1,24,000 in Q2 FY23 |
| Cash and liquid investments | ₹388 cr cash, plus ₹122 cr bonds, ₹138 cr mutual funds, balance in FDs |