Key Takeaways
- Resilient quarter despite industry headwinds: Consolidated total income grew +8.1% YoY and EBITDA +19.2% YoY, even as the Indian two-wheeler industry de-grew 2.44% and European car production rose only 3.7%.
- EV order book hit by subsidy shocks: FAME II removal in India and reduced European incentives from September 2023 have postponed new EV order volumes, though management expects a recovery this quarter or next.
- Maxwell drag persists, profitability promised soon: The EV subsidiary posted an EBITDA loss of ₹4.33 cr this quarter; management is targeting profitability from Q4 FY24 and full-year profitability from FY25.
- Margin story is mixed: Standalone India EBITDA margin (ex-megaproject) improved 80 bps YoY to 11.9%, but Europe QoQ margin fell 130 bps to 14.8% on lower summer OEM production and energy costs still running 3x pre-COVID levels.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether postponed EV order volumes actually materialise, the Maxwell Q4 profitability milestone, and the pace of rural two-wheeler demand recovery in H2.
India Two-Wheeler & Three-Wheeler Demand
- Industry de-grew, Endurance outgrew: The two-wheeler industry contracted 2.44% YoY (motorcycles down 4.1%, scooters up 1.13%), yet Endurance posted 3.8% YoY standalone growth despite a ₹57 crore metal price headwind.
- Premiumisation is a structural tailwind: High-end bike sales (150cc+) are surging, with new model entries from Harley-Davidson and Triumph. Inverted front fork volumes are increasing every year across India, KTM Bajaj and exports, driven partly by value-engineered adoption on higher-end Pulsar bikes.
- Rural demand expected to improve: Management sees volumes increasing for two-wheelers and three-wheelers in H2, supported by improving rural economic well-being and premium bike and EV scooter/three-wheeler sales.
- Three major OEMs de-grew in Q2: This made Q2 tougher sequentially versus Q1, compounding the EV volume shortfall from subsidy-related obstacles.
Anurang Jain: "We are very highly focused on profitable growth."
European Operations: Volume vs Value Divergence
- Production lags registrations significantly: Q2 saw a 10% registration drop but an 18.7% production drop versus Q1. In Germany, registrations rose 17.7% YoY but production grew only 3.7%, as dealers reduced stock.
- Endurance grew revenue despite flat production: European sales in value terms grew 10.1% in Euro terms, with turnover up 10% YoY in Germany on just 3.7% production growth, driven by new project starts.
- The pre-COVID market is still 20-25% smaller: Current registrations are ~0.95 crore versus 1.3 crore in 2018, and this volume compression is structurally pressuring auto ancillary EBITDA.
- Energy costs remain a 2% EBITDA drag: While not facing the acute energy crisis of the prior year, Endurance is still paying roughly 3x gas and energy costs versus 2019-20, eroding approximately 2% of EBITDA.
Massimo Venuti: "New car production data is adverse compared to new car registration. Moreover if you compare current period against the pre covid situation there would be 20-25% reduction in the market, whichever way you see. Volumes are not expected to revive unless interest rates fall."
EV Order Book: Won but Postponed
- ₹619.4 cr of EV business won in India, now delayed: FAME II subsidy removal from 1st July 2023 impacted Indian EV sales, and most EV OEMs are now working on value engineering. Management expects volumes to start coming in this quarter or next.
- European EV incentives also reduced: Some European countries cut EV incentives from 1st September 2023, adding to the sluggishness in EV order intake. The bulk of recent orders have been for EV and hybrid, not ICE, so the pipeline is EV-heavy but conversion is slow.
- Aluminium content debate clarified: Management pushed back on the 30-50% aluminium content increase narrative, explaining that EV two-wheeler castings have 9 parts versus 7 in ICE, but are lightweight and not 30-50% heavier in aluminium content.
- Maxwell is the strategic EV bet, still loss-making: Endurance increased its stake to 56%. The EBITDA loss this quarter was ₹4.33 cr, with a PAT loss of ₹6.42 cr. The product mix issue is expected to resolve from Q4 FY24, and management is confident due to technology and new order wins.
Anurang Jain: "In India, we have won 619.4 crore of EV business. But FAME II subsidy in India was largely removed from 1st July 2023 and this did impact the sales in the Indian EV market."
New Order Wins & Capacity Build-Out
- Suzuki suspension order is a large anchor win: Front forks and rear shock absorbers for scooters, supplies starting Q2 FY24, worth ₹175 crores per annum.
- ABS is scaling fast: Two-wheeler ABS assembly supply to Bajaj Auto and Royal Enfield has commenced, reaching a run rate of 4,00,000 assemblies per annum. Dual-channel ABS supply begins Q4 FY24. ABS valve manufacturing started in March 2023 for backward integration.
- Disc brake capacity and customer base expanding: A second disc brake assembly plant at Waluj raised assembly capacity to 0.62 cr units and brake disc capacity to 0.81 cr units. Hero Motocorp supply starts March 2024, HMSI from November 2024.
- Mahindra relationship deepening: Two oil sump orders won; management noted Mahindra is "coming in a much bigger way."
- BMS SMT line to start February 2024: The surface-mounted technology line for BMS assembly at Waluj will begin operations, targeting a ₹120 cr per annum peak in FY25 alongside ABS ECU.
- Wheel capacity expanding to 0.55 cr per annum from April 2024: The new Chakan plant, added in July 2022, is scaling toward this target.
Aftermarket & Export Diversification
- Aftermarket grew 20.3% YoY: Driven by exports to 32 countries, with Brazil, DR Congo and Cameroon added to reach 35 countries. Management is targeting continued good growth in FY24.
- Export revenue up 12.6% YoY: Growth came from machined casting sales to Ford UK, IVECO Italy and Case New Holland, plus two-wheeler suspension exports to KTM Austria, China and Southeast Asia.
- Machined castings are the margin and stickiness play: Currently ~70% of castings are machined in India; management aims to take this to 100%, though some legacy OEM customers still take raw castings. Four-wheeler casting margins rank highest for commercial vehicles, then passenger cars, then two and three wheelers.
- Export volumes carry a caveat: Management flagged that LOI volumes are not always sustained, and this year saw volumes come in below OEM estimates.
Anurang Jain: "The question is whether the volumes as per the LOI are sustained or not. So we did have an issue in this year where volumes were lesser than what OEMs had earlier estimated."
Margin & Cost Levers
- Standalone India margin improved YoY despite headwinds: EBITDA margin (ex-megaproject) rose from 11.1% to 11.9% YoY, and PAT margin from 5.8% to 6.3%, achieved despite a ₹57 crore metal price impact and a motorcycle-heavy industry de-growth.
- Europe QoQ margin fell on seasonal production drop: EBITDA margin declined from 16.1% in Q1 to 14.8% in Q2, as turnover fell from EUR 68.8M to EUR 62.8M due to lower summer OEM production. Year-to-date margin of 15.4% is still well above the prior year's 12.6%.
- Energy cost overhang is structural, not cyclical: Gas and energy costs remain at roughly 3x 2019-20 levels, eroding approximately 2% of European EBITDA. This is no longer an acute crisis but a persistent margin headwind.
- Furnace oil usage eliminated entirely: This is one operational cost lever now fully realised.
- Margin trajectory depends on order-book volume conversion: Management stated margins will improve quarter-to-quarter, contingent on volumes from orders already won.
Anurang Jain: "At Maxwell, Endurance team is fully focused on lowering the bought out component cost and the fixed and variable costs along with the increase in Total Income to be profitable from FY25 onwards and we hope to be profitable in the Q4 FY24."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Maxwell profitability | Hope to be profitable; fully profitable from FY25 onwards | Q4 FY24 / FY25 |
| Maxwell product mix resolution | Product mix issue expected to resolve | From Q4 FY24 |
| Two-wheeler industry sales | Reach 20.5 to 2.1 crore units | FY24 |
| ₹777.4 cr business peak | Peak revenue realisation | FY26 |
| ₹3,664 cr business peak | Peak revenue realisation | FY25 and FY26 |
| TVS ₹527.8 cr business peak | Peak revenue realisation | FY25 |
| Suzuki front fork SOP | Start of production | Q2 FY25 |
| BMS/ABS ECU peak | ₹120 cr per annum peak | FY25 |
| EV scooter aluminium castings peak | Peak revenue realisation | FY25 |
| Aluminium forging peak | Peak revenue realisation | FY25 |
| Structural aluminium casting peak | Peak revenue realisation | FY25 |
| Maxwell business full realisation | ₹374.3 cr fully realised | FY26 |
| ABS capacity target | 0.12 cr single and dual channel ABS assemblies per annum | By end of 2025 |
| Wheel capacity expansion | 0.55 cr per annum | From April 2024 |
| Carbon-neutral target | Greater than 50% renewable energy (from 30% FY24 to date) | Next three years |
| Hero Motocorp disc brake supply | Supply commencement | March 2024 |
| HMSI disc brake supply | Supply commencement | November 2024 |
| Dual channel ABS supply | Supply commencement | Q4 FY24 |
| BMS SMT line operations | Start of operations | February 2024 |
| KTM Austria 35 dia air suspension | Supply commencement | End of this year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated total income | ₹2,560.55 cr, up 8.1% YoY from ₹2,369.06 cr |
| Consolidated EBITDA | ₹333.84 cr, up 19.2% YoY from ₹280.02 cr; margin 13% |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹154.56 cr, up 17.5% YoY from ₹131.49 cr; margin 6% |
| Maharashtra PSI scheme incentive (included in PAT) | ₹24.88 cr |
| Standalone total income | ₹1,984.3 cr, up 3.8% YoY from ₹1,911.3 cr |
| Standalone EBITDA | ₹258.44 cr, up 8.7% YoY from ₹237.74 cr; margin 13% |
| Standalone PAT | ₹142.54 cr, up 8.6% YoY from ₹131.27 cr; margin 7.2% |
| Standalone EBITDA margin (excl. megaproject incentive) | 11.9%, up from 11.1% in Q2 FY23 |
| Endurance Overseas total income | ₹565.07 cr; EBITDA ₹83.52 cr (14.8%); PAT ₹22.94 cr (4.1%) |
| Endurance Overseas turnover (Euro terms) | EUR 62.8 million, up 10.1% YoY from EUR 57 million |
| Endurance Overseas EBITDA margin (Euro terms) | 14.8%, up from 11.5% in Q2 FY23 |
| Maxwell total income | ₹17.13 cr; EBITDA loss ₹4.33 cr (-25.3%); PAT loss ₹6.42 cr (-37.48%) |
| Consolidated net cash | ₹456.16 cr; no consolidated net debt |
| Aftermarket sales | ₹125.52 cr, up 20.3% YoY from ₹104.36 cr |
| Export sales (India standalone) | ₹45.06 cr, up 12.6% YoY from ₹40.01 cr |
| India new business won from OEMs other than Bajaj Auto (till date in FY24) | ₹777.4 cr (₹466.3 cr new, ₹311 cr replacement); peak in FY26 |
| Total four-wheeler business won (till date in FY24) | ₹117 cr |
| Total EV business win (standalone, till date) | ₹619.4 cr |
| Europe business won in FY24 | EUR 19.76 million |
| Europe orders won in last 18 months | EUR 104 million, of which EUR 60 million for battery EV market |
| Maxwell BMS business won (till date in FY24) | ₹88.3 cr; RFQ pipeline ₹81 cr |
| Disc brake assembly capacity | 0.62 cr numbers per annum; brake disc capacity 0.81 cr numbers |
| ABS assemblies run rate | 4,00,000 per annum; total capacity 6,40,000 per annum |
| Wheel capacity | 0.45 cr per annum; expanding to 0.55 cr per annum from April 2024 |
| Carbon-neutral percentage | 30% in FY24 to date, up from 24.6% in FY23 |