Key Takeaways
- Strong headline growth, messy quarter: Revenue rose 18.8% YoY and EBITDA 28.7%, but the quarter was disrupted by heat waves, elections, floods, and a 3-day ERP shutdown that halted sales.
- ASP, not volume, is doing the work: ASPs grew 25% YoY while cash-sensitive volume segments were hit by election-era cash-movement restrictions; above-INR2.5-lakh volume still grew a healthy 9.5%.
- EFTA is the big unlock, and it has a deadline: Management expects the trade pact to be implemented before 31 March 2025, calling it a "game changer" that could bring unrepresented global mega-brands into India under a one-partner model Ethos believes it will win.
- Inventory and cash flow are absorbing growth: Operating cash flow is strained by a deliberate strategy to stock every new brand entering India, plus pre-opening inventory for a rapid store rollout; management says this normalizes as the market matures.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether July's reported ~28% growth and record gross margin sustain into Q2, the pace of new boutique openings against the 22–23 full-year target, and any concrete EFTA-driven brand signings.
The Quarter's Disruptions
- Four simultaneous headwinds: An extreme heat wave pushed customers to travel and extended holidays; national elections spanning nearly two months brought restrictions on cash movement above INR50,000; severe floods in Switzerland in June disrupted committed shipments; and a 3-day ERP system replacement (the first in 15 years) took most boutiques offline for sales, with the downtime used for manpower training instead.
- Cash sales took the election hit: The restriction on moving cash above INR50,000 directly suppressed transactions in the INR0.5-lakh to INR2-lakh band, a segment where cash is the normal payment mode. Volume in segments where cash is not required grew 9.5%, confirming the election was the binding constraint rather than underlying demand.
- Gross margin dipped on deliberate inaction: The company chose not to market during the quarter, so it gave slightly deeper customer offers and discounts to move inventory, compressing gross margin. Management flagged that July already hit a record gross margin, implying the Q1 dip was tactical and temporary.
Pranav Saboo: "I am very glad to report that in July, all of the above issues came to rest, and I'm happy to report that it was a fantastic month for us with growth resurging."
EFTA & The Next Wave of Brand Partnerships
- The EFTA catalyst has a hard deadline: Management stated the trade agreement will be implemented before 31 March 2025 and called it a "game changer." The pact opens the door for some of the world's biggest watch brands that have not yet entered India, and Ethos believes those brands will adopt a one-partner policy in the country, with Ethos as the natural choice.
- Exclusive brands are the margin engine: House-plan (exclusive) brands contribute roughly 30% of total revenue, and management wants to grow that share. These brands carry higher margins than non-exclusive ones, even though higher ASP does not automatically mean higher margin. The custom-duty benefit from EFTA will flow entirely to Ethos for 90% of exclusive brands, with the split pre-negotiated in contracts; for non-exclusive brands, the sharing terms are still under discussion.
- Brand portfolio strategy is test-then-keep: Management is deliberately stocking every new brand entering India to capture the relationship. After three years, unsuccessful brands will be removed from the portfolio, with no obsolescence risk because inventory can be discounted or sold back to the brand.
- New signings this quarter: ID Genève and Singer Reimagined joined the watch portfolio. The company also finalized its first Messika boutique at The Chanakya Mall in New Delhi, converting a pop-up beta test into a permanent store opening in January or February, marking formal entry into international branded jewellery.
Pranav Saboo: "EFTA will be a game changer for us. As far as we understand, it will be implemented before 31st March of this financial year."
Store Rollout & Capacity Build-Out
- Boutique openings on track, with some friction: Three boutiques opened in Q1 (Kochi, Dehradun, Pune). Five more are expected in Q2, and the full-year target remains 20–25 stores, with management still pushing for 25. Real-estate delays may push two stores out, leaving roughly 22 or 23 by 31 March, with a dense launch pipeline between October and March.
- Pre-owned business is capacity-constrained, not demand-constrained: Growth is limited by two factors: the supply of legally procured watches (only those sold compliantly after 2017 qualify), and the number of trained watchmakers who can open, service, certify, and warranty pieces. The first service center is at full capacity; a second center in South India opens this quarter to double throughput. A major Swiss agency is being brought in to train 16 master watchmakers annually starting next year.
- RIMOWA is a small base with big ambitions: The single small-format store is generating INR1.5–2 crores per month with extremely good return on capital employed, sales per square foot, and EBITDA margins. Management wants at least 10 RIMOWA boutiques in the next five years and is in discussions with 7–8 other lifestyle brands, though the signing cycle runs 15–18 months.
Pranav Saboo: "We want that in the next 5 years, we have at least 10 boutiques of RIMOWA alone."
ASP, Volume & The Margin Equation
- Growth is ASP-led, and that is by design: ASPs rose 25% YoY while the company actively exited price points below INR30,000–50,000. Volume above INR2.5 lakhs grew 9.5%, and above INR1 lakh grew 2%, with the weakness concentrated in cash-dependent lower bands hit by election restrictions. Management expects quantity growth to return.
- Higher ASP does not equal higher margin: Management explicitly separated the two: exclusive brands carry higher margin, but higher ASP alone does not. The margin uplift will come from growing the exclusive-brand revenue share, not from selling more expensive watches per se.
- Gross margin dip was small and partly reversible: The Q1 decline versus recent quarters was less than 1% in EBITDA terms, driven by tactical discounting in a quarter where the company chose not to market. Some portion will be recovered over the rest of the year, and July's record gross margin supports that trajectory.
Inventory, Cash Flow & The Growth-Funding Trade-Off
- Operating cash flow is funding a deliberate brand-capture strategy: Cash is being absorbed by stocking inventory for every new brand entering India, a conscious choice to establish relationships now and cull later. Additionally, the rapid store-opening program of the last two years requires buying stock ahead of time, which sits in warehouses before boutiques go live. Management calls this temporary, not structural.
- Normalization has a precedent but no date: Management pointed out that global watch retailers carry far lower months of stock in mature markets, and Ethos will converge toward that level over time. Multiple levers exist to bring inventory under control "at a later stage," but no timeline was given.
- Dividends are deferred in favor of growth: When asked about a dividend policy, management responded that it wants to utilize funds for growth at the moment and will revisit the question later.
Pranav Saboo: "We want to be sure that we capture all the brands, right? All the brands may not be successful, right? And after 3 years, we will remove the brands from our portfolio that are not successful."
New Ventures: Favre Leuba, Lifestyle & Design
- Favre Leuba revival is approaching its market test: The first collection after the brand's revival will be showcased at Geneva Watch Days on 29 August, with deliveries starting in December and January. Management declined to disclose sales numbers for the quarter, calling it too early for public platforms.
- Lifestyle division is in early build mode: Beyond RIMOWA, discussions are underway with 7–8 other brands, and a major lifestyle brand partnership is in negotiation, though the 15-month signing cycle means no announcement is imminent. Management declined to name targets or give a medium-term revenue mix contribution.
- In-house design capability is being built: A design team with two full-time designers was established this year, after Ethos helped brands create limited editions. The plan is to expand the limited-edition program next year, collaborating with group companies to supply components to brands.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EFTA implementation | Trade pact implemented, unlocking new global brand entries | Before 31 March 2025 |
| Boutique openings | 20–25 new stores, likely 22–23; 5 in Q2 | FY25 (by 31 March 2025) |
| Pre-owned service capacity | Second service center in South India to double capacity | This quarter (Q2 FY25) |
| Master watchmaker training | Swiss agency to train 16 watchmakers annually | Starting next year |
| Favre Leuba global launch | First revived collection showcased; deliveries begin | Showcase 29 Aug 2025; deliveries Dec–Jan |
| Messika boutique | First permanent international branded jewellery store | January or February 2025 |
| RIMOWA expansion | At least 10 boutiques | Within 5 years |
| Brand portfolio culling | Remove unsuccessful brands after 3-year test period | Ongoing, starting after 3 years per brand |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹273.2 cr, up 18.8% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹49.7 cr, up 28.7% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 17.8% |
| Profit after tax | ₹22.8 cr, up 25.6% YoY |
| Same-store growth (SSG) | 12.3% |
| Exclusive brands share of revenue | ~30% of total revenues, including pre-owned |
| Pre-owned watches billing | ₹19.6 cr, up 32% YoY |
| Inventory days | 156 days as of 30 June 2024 |
| Cash and bank balance | ₹329 cr as of 30 June 2024 |
| Watches sold | 13,245 units, vs 14,070 in Q1 FY24 |
| Volume growth above ₹1 lakh MRP | 2% |
| Volume growth above ₹2.5 lakh MRP | 9.5% |
| July revenue growth (unaudited) | ~28%, with a record margin; not guidance |
| New boutiques opened | 3 (Kochi, Dehradun, Pune); 5 more expected in Q2 |
| Limited edition bookings | ₹70 cr worth of bookings for editions designed this year |