Key Takeaways
- Strong demand, supply-side friction: Revenue grew 22.4% YoY despite a Shraddh-period shift, Chennai floods, and store renovations compressing October. Underlying monthly momentum accelerated from 13% in October to 28% in December.
- CHF/INR movement is the margin story: EBITDA margin held at 17.7% as the Swiss franc moved from ~INR85 to ~INR93.90 YoY, creating a direct exchange loss of INR2.21 crores and a lagged pricing gap that management expects to close within two quarters.
- The pole-position bet is explicit and timed: Management framed the next two years as decisive for locking in a dominant multi-decade position in Indian luxury watches, targeting 25 new boutiques and using exclusivity wins like Ulysse Nardin as the wedge.
- Pre-owned is scaling fast but carefully: CPO revenue grew over 45% YoY in Q3, constrained only by the need to protect the brand with a two-year warranty and in-house restoration, with a second service centre now being built in South India.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the INR95-level price increases land with consumers by April, the pace of the 25-store rollout given Red Sea furniture delays, and the Favre Leuba global launch at Geneva Watch Days in August.
Demand & Revenue Momentum
- October was the anomaly, not the trend: The Shraddh period shifted from Q2 FY23 into Q3 FY24, suppressing October. November grew 26% and December 28%, and nine-month performance tracked the guidance given at the start of the year and reaffirmed at the end of Q2.
- Same-store growth tells the same story: Reported SSG of 11.2% rises to 15.3% when the Shraddh shift and store renovation disruptions are stripped out, putting the underlying metric inside the 13-14% decade target range.
- Volume growth is concentrated above INR1 lakh: Quantity sold above that price point rose 15.5% YoY in Q3 and 19.2% over nine months. Below INR1 lakh, the company is deliberately moving volume out of its own stores and into a new distribution entity, RF Enterprises.
- The customer base is broadening, not just deepening: New client enrolment ran at 88% and repeat customers at 46% for the nine-month period, suggesting the brand is pulling in first-time luxury buyers while retaining existing ones.
- Tier-2 cities are validating the expansion thesis: New cities are starting to perform very well, giving management confidence to press further into those markets as part of the 25-store build-out.
Saboo: "I think our customers are celebrating the success of India's stock markets and Indian businesses worldwide are celebrating the new highs they are reaching."
Margin Structure & CHF/INR Mechanics
- The margin hit has two layers: The direct exchange loss of INR2.21 crores is the visible piece. The larger, lagged impact is that it took roughly a year to pass through the prior CHF move from INR80 to INR90, and the current rate of ~INR93.90 is still working its way into selling prices.
- The pass-through timeline is now defined: Price increases to cover the INR95 level will be implemented over the next two quarters, by April. If the franc stabilises near INR95, margins are maintained; a move to INR105 would replay last year's pressure.
- Pre-operative hiring is a small but real drag: About 60 people have been hired ahead of the 25-store expansion, adding roughly INR60 lakh in employee costs for the quarter. At six people per store, the full 150-person pre-hire will layer in before the new boutiques open.
- Operating leverage is the offset thesis: Management expects margins to continue increasing as the store base matures and the CHF/INR gap closes, though it declined to put a long-term margin target number on the record, calling it sensitive.
The Pole-Position Strategy
- The next two years are framed as decisive: Management believes that whoever reaches 100-125 stores first locks in brand partnerships for the next 25 years, because most luxury watch brands will then want to work exclusively with the scale leader. The 25-store expansion in the coming year is the vehicle.
- Exclusivity is already shifting: Ulysse Nardin, previously available through six or seven retailers in India, is now available only with Ethos starting this quarter. Management called brand exclusivity shifts a big part of its strategy.
- The market-share ambition is directional, not a precise target: The CFO corrected an analyst's reference to a 40-45% figure, stating the company has roughly 20% market share today and aims for a larger share over time without committing to a specific number publicly.
- Store economics were not disclosed: When asked for unit economics per store (capex, inventory, first-year and third-year revenue and margin), management declined to answer on the call and offered to take the discussion offline.
Saboo: "I believe that the next two years are very important to take a pole position in the new watch area because whoever takes the position in the next two years, you see, once you get to 100 stores or 125 stores, most brands will want to work with you."
Pre-Owned (CPO) & Service Infrastructure
- CPO is the fastest-growing segment: Revenue grew 35% YoY for the nine-month period and over 45% in Q3, but the bottleneck is capacity, not demand. Every watch sold through CPO is opened, restored, and backed by a two-year warranty, a practice management says no other Indian player offers.
- A second service centre is being built to unlock scale: The existing North India centre is being supplemented by a state-of-the-art facility in South India, which will increase restoration throughput and bring in more watchmakers.
- The brand-protection constraint is deliberate: Management is unwilling to accelerate CPO by relaxing the restoration-and-warranty standard, because the CPO business sits inside the Ethos brand and any quality slip would damage the core retail franchise.
Saboo: "Every watch that we get, we give a two-year warranty. Nobody else in India is doing this."
Brand Portfolio & New Ventures
- Rimowa had a strong start: The first boutique at Jio World Plaza, Mumbai was profitable from its first month and contributed to the bottom line from roughly 60 days of revenue. Two more boutiques are planned for Delhi and Bangalore over the next 12-15 months, subject to finding the right space and board approval.
- Favre Leuba launch is now dated: The brand will launch globally during Geneva Watch Days in the last week of August 2024 with three collections. The current in-store stock is the old collection acquired with the brand; the new collection will be positioned at CHF2,500 ex-factory, roughly doubled in India.
- Favre Leuba's ambition is large but distant: Management aims for 100,000 watches per year over the next 10 years at that CHF2,500 average ex-factory price, and expects it to be extremely profitable at scale, but called it too early to discuss profitability or capital requirements in detail.
- RF Enterprises is the below-INR70,000 play: A new entity will distribute non-Swiss watches like Maserati to other retailers, with Ethos holding 2-3 months of inventory while the buying retailers bear the downstream inventory risk. A future stage envisions importing kits, assembling in India, and selling at higher margin.
- Jewellery is on the horizon but not imminent: Management said jewellery may be there in a couple of years and that it is still learning the new vertical, with no commitment to a launch date.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue CAGR | Grow revenue at a CAGR of 25% for this decade | Decade-long |
| Same-store growth | 13% to 14% SSG | Decade-long |
| New boutique openings | Open 25 new boutiques | By end of next financial year (FY25), subject to landlord delays |
| CHF/INR price pass-through | Price increases to cover INR95 franc level | Within next two quarters (by April 2024) |
| Favre Leuba global launch | Launch three collections at Geneva Watch Days | Last week of August 2024 |
| Rimowa expansion | Two more boutiques in Delhi and Bangalore | Next 12-15 months, subject to space and board approval |
| App launch | Launch Ethos app | 1 March 2024 |
| Favre Leuba volume target | Reach 100,000 watches per year at CHF2,500 avg ex-factory | Next 10 years |
| CPO service infrastructure | Second service centre in South India | Underway, no completion date given |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹281.2 cr, up 22.4% YoY from ₹229.7 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹50.8 cr, up 28.5% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 17.7%, impacted by CHF/INR movement and pre-operative hiring |
| Profit after tax | ₹25.5 cr, up 23.5% YoY |
| 9M FY24 revenue from operations | ₹746.5 cr, up 28.5% YoY from ₹581 cr |
| 9M FY24 EBITDA | ₹130.9 cr, up 33% YoY |
| 9M FY24 EBITDA margin | 17.2%, up 50 bps YoY |
| 9M FY24 profit after tax | ₹62.3 cr, up 32.4% YoY from ₹47 cr |
| Same-store growth | 11.2%; 15.3% excluding Shraddh period and store renovation impact |
| Revenue growth by month | 13% in October, 26% in November, 28% in December |
| Volume growth above ₹1 lakh price point | 15.5% YoY in Q3 (6,308 watches vs 5,462); 19.2% YoY for 9M |
| Share of exclusive brands | 29.3% of revenue; 30.7% for 9M FY24 |
| Certified Pre-Owned revenue | Over 45% YoY growth in Q3; 35% YoY growth for 9M (₹49.7 cr) |
| New client enrolment | 88% for 9M FY24 |
| Repeat customers | 46% for 9M FY24 |
| Inventory days | 156 days at sales as of 31 Dec 2023 |
| Gross debt | ₹6.85 cr as of 31 Dec 2023 |
| Cash and bank balance | ₹350 cr as of 31 Dec 2023 |
| Luxury watch market share | 21% as per Technopak industry report |
| Direct exchange loss (CHF/INR) | ₹2.21 cr on remittance and reinstatement in Q3 |
| Favre Leuba pre-operative loss | ₹58 lakh in Q3 |
| Pre-operative employee cost (advance hiring) | ~₹60 lakh in Q3 for 60 people hired ahead of 25 planned store openings |
| Rimowa boutique expected annual revenue | ~₹20 cr per boutique to start |
| Lost sales from Red Sea shipment delays | ~₹1.5–2 cr, expected to be recovered in Q4 |