Key Takeaways
- Record year, strong Q4 despite COVID waves: FY22 delivered highest-ever revenue, EBITDA and PAT even though Q1 saw malls closed for 80% of the period and Q4 faced city lockdowns from the third wave.
- Margin expansion driven by mix shift: Gross margin expanded 130 bps YoY in Q4 as the business deliberately moved away from sub-INR 40,000 watches toward the INR 1 lakh to INR 10 lakh luxury and high-luxury segments.
- Certified pre-owned is a breakout growth pillar: The pre-owned business nearly tripled to INR 32 crore in FY22, with a target to exceed INR 75 crore in FY23, supported by a new service center, trained watchmakers and a website drawing 100,000 monthly visitors.
- FY23 off to a record start with no demand slowdown: April and May revenue is estimated at INR 120 crore, and management sees zero impact from resumed international travel or global financial market weakness.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 30–35% FY23 revenue growth target stays on track as the 13 new stores come online, the pace of certified pre-owned scaling toward the INR 75 crore target, and any new exclusive brand signings in the high-price segment.
Demand & Revenue Drivers
- Premiumization is the core engine: ASP rose from ~INR 73,000 to ~INR 1,45,000 over four years as Ethos deliberately shifted focus away from low-price-segment watches toward luxury and high-luxury, a trend management expects to continue with steady ASP growth.
- Same-store sales accelerated well above pre-COVID norms: Same-store sales growth hit 21% in Q4 FY22, up from a pre-COVID trend of 10–12%, driven by the move to higher price points which yield much higher growth rates for the same store. Management hopes to sustain around 18–20% in the near future.
- First two months of FY23 signal no demand impact: April and May revenue is estimated in the vicinity of INR 120 crore, a record quarter, with zero impact observed from resumed international travel or global financial market weakness.
- Seasonality shapes the year: Q2 and Q4 are generally stronger than Q1, while Q3 is significantly the strongest of all quarters, so the Q1 strength is notable.
Y Saboo: "We see absolutely no impact of what of seeing of the global sort of trends... we have seen zero impact on our sales."
Certified Pre-Owned: The Second Growth Pillar
- Business nearly tripled in FY22: The pre-owned business grew from INR 11 crore in FY21 to INR 32 crore in FY22, driven by a pan-India sourcing network, a newly opened state-of-the-art service center that restores watches and provides a 2-year warranty, and the secondmovement.com website receiving 100,000 visitors per month.
- FY23 target exceeds INR 75 crore: Management hopes to exceed INR 75 crore of business by the end of the year through one lounge in Delhi and the website, with expansion to four to five major cities over the next two years.
- Stock turns fast, bottleneck is refurbishment: Pre-owned watches sell out within a month on average after refurbishment; the constraint has been refurbishing capacity, which is steadily increasing with 17 trained watchmakers.
- Adds to the industry, does not cannibalize: Management argues the pre-owned sector promotes multiple ownership and brings in first-time luxury enthusiasts, expanding the overall market rather than eating into new watch sales. The pre-owned watch sector is already 33% of the new watch business globally and expected to become half its size by 2025.
Pranav Saboo: "Certified pre-owned watches is a great growth pillar for the watch industry. The pre-owned watch sector does not cannibalize the new watch business. On the contrary, it adds to the overall industry size by promoting multiple ownership of watches and adding a whole sector of first time, luxury enthusiast."
Margins & Operating Leverage
- Gross margin expanded on mix shift: Gross profit margins expanded 130 bps YoY in Q4 and 165 bps YoY for the full year, driven by the deliberate shift away from low-price-segment watches toward higher-price-segment watches where luxury and high-luxury segments earn better margins.
- EBITDA margin also expanded: EBITDA margin expanded 110 bps YoY in Q4 and 160 bps YoY for FY22, benefiting from improved gross margins and greater leverage on fixed costs.
- Consumer discounting is gradually declining: Discounts offered to consumers are going down because customers value the service, product and reliability of Ethos, helping improve margins further.
- Management sees no ceiling at 10%: The earlier goal was INR 1,000 crore billing and 10% EBITDA, now almost reached; management believes EBITDA margins will exceed 10% with constant improvement in margins and operating leverage, though it declined to give a cap number.
- Inventory efficiency is improving: Stock carrying months on sales reduced from 6.2 to 5.3 months, and inventory days reduced from ~190 days of sales three years ago to ~155–157 days, with further improvement expected as scale improves, though a certain minimum inventory is required because luxury customers need to see the physical product.
Y Saboo: "However is 10% the EBITDA ceiling I don't think so. Because what is happening now is that we are seeing a constant improvement in our margins and a constant improvement in our operating leverage. And therefore, I believe that the EBITDA margins will exceed 10%."
Store Expansion & New Categories
- 13 new boutiques planned, most in malls: Ethos plans to add 13 boutiques across India and renovate six stores, including a certified pre-owned lounge in Mumbai to open very soon, though a large number of the new stores are expected toward the end of FY23 dependent on mall readiness.
- Rimowa and Messika expand the portfolio beyond watches: Ethos entered into an exclusive agreement with Rimowa for retailing luxury luggage and Messika for retailing luxury jewelry in India, with the first Rimowa location finalized in Mumbai and each boutique expected to deliver INR 12 crore to INR 15 crore of business.
- Watch business remains the mainstay for now: Over the next two to three years, luxury and premium watch business will remain the mainstay; new segments like jewelry and luggage will build a growth vector for future years when watch segment growth may slow.
- Exclusive brands build the moat: Exclusive arrangements build a strong competitive moat and offer a differentiated product portfolio; management plans to add more exclusive brands, especially in the high-price segment, and is in discussion with more globally recognized brands.
Pranav Saboo: "Relationships with luxury brands and their owners typically take many years to develop and are difficult to replicate."
Digital & Customer Experience
- Digital expected to reach 35–40% of overall business: The digital channel is growing, supported by 3D and augmented reality now available for many watches on the website, an own content studio coming up to create shoppable content, and an app launching later in the year.
- Secondmovement.com is a standalone digital asset: The certified pre-owned website already receives 100,000 visitors per month, with all watches shot in-house and content created by Ethos.
- GPHG partnership elevates brand positioning: Ethos was chosen as the partner for the Geneva-based GPHG pre-award exhibition in 2022, an event held in only two cities globally each year; it will be held in New Delhi in October with Ethos as the sole watch retail partner, and the Chairman is a member of the global GPHG academy since 2021.
Y Saboo: "Ethos has changed that forever. Today you go into an Ethos store, the experience, the portfolio of brands, the brand width the product width within each portfolio is equal to similar global stores in India."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| FY23 revenue growth | 30% to 35% growth over FY22 | FY23 |
| Certified pre-owned revenue | Exceed INR 75 crore | By end of FY23 |
| Certified pre-owned footprint | Expand to 4–5 major Indian cities | Over the next two years |
| Store expansion | Add 13 boutiques, renovate 6 stores | FY23 (most toward year-end) |
| Same-store sales growth | Around 18–20% | Near future |
| EBITDA margin | Exceed 10% | No date (trend underway) |
| ROCE | Attain higher than 25% | Long-term |
| Digital share of business | Reach 35–40% | No date (trend underway) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Billings | ₹185 cr, +30% YoY |
| Exclusive brands billings | ₹52 cr, 28% of total billings |
| Revenue from operations | ₹159 cr, +29% YoY |
| Gross profit | ~₹48 cr, +35% YoY |
| Gross profit margin | 30.2%, expanded 130 bps YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹15.4 cr, +46% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 9.6%, expanded 110 bps YoY |
| PBT | ₹11.6 cr, +65% YoY |
| Same-store sales growth | 21% |
| Stock carrying months on sales | 5.3 months, reduced from 6.2 months in FY21 |
| Consolidated debt | ₹60 cr, post-IPO repayment reduced to almost half |
| Certified pre-owned business revenue | ₹32 cr in FY22, up from ~₹11 cr in FY21 |
| Club ECHO registered members | 283,300+ as of March 31, 2022 |
| ASP | ~₹1,45,000, up from ~₹73,000 four years ago |
| Exclusive brands in portfolio | 33 brands out of 50+ portfolio, nearly two-thirds |
| Inventory days of sales | 155–157 days, down from ~190 days three years ago |
| New stores planned | 13 boutiques identified, timing dependent on mall readiness |
| FY23 Q1 estimated revenue (Apr–May) | ~₹120 cr for the first two months |
| FY23 revenue growth guidance | 30% to 35% over FY22 |
| Long-term ROCE target | >25% |
| Digital business share target | 35% to 40% of overall business |
| Certified pre-owned business target | >₹75 cr by end of FY23 |
| Certified pre-owned stock turn | <1 month of stock on average |
| Watchmakers trained for service center | 17 |
| RIMOWA boutique expected annual business | ₹12 cr to ₹15 cr per boutique (per an analyst's math) |