Key Takeaways
- Record year, foundation laid for next decade: Revenue grew on surging high-end watch demand, exclusive brands hit 29% of sales, and the company added 9 net new stores while setting a 10x revenue ambition over 10 years.
- EFTA deal is a structural margin unlock: The zero-duty glidepath on Swiss watches, starting H2 FY25, will lift gross margins directly and, management argues, pull more global luxury brands into India.
- Strategic exit from affordable fashion watches: Online traffic halved after delisting sub-INR 1 lakh brands, but website revenue and profitability rose, a deliberate trade of volume for return on capital.
- Election dampener is temporary, per history: April and May are subdued by the Model Code of Conduct restricting cash movement and events, but management expects a booming June and a stronger following three quarters.
- What to watch next quarter: The pace of the 20 planned FY25 store openings, the actual start date of the EFTA duty cuts in H2, and whether the post-election demand surge materialises as strongly as management predicts.
The EFTA Margin Opportunity
- The deal mechanics: India’s trade pact with EFTA nations cuts customs duty on Swiss watches to zero over seven years, with the first 3% reduction expected in H2 FY25 once Swiss paperwork is complete.
- Direct margin capture: If Ethos reaches its 50% exclusive brand target (from 29% today), it will capture the entire duty reduction, worth 22% of tax, as incremental gross margin because it imports those brands itself.
- Indirect brand flywheel: Management believes the duty cut removes a profitability deterrent that kept many global luxury brands out of India, opening a pipeline of new exclusive partnerships.
Pranav Saboo: "This will improve Ethos' gross margins. More importantly, it will open doors for many more luxury brands to come in, for whom these rates were a deterrent to profitability and therefore, an Indian presence."
Exclusive Brands & the 50% Ambition
- Current traction: Exclusive brands generated 29% of sales in FY24, delivering higher revenue and higher return on capital employed than multi-brand lines.
- The 50% goal: Management wants half of all brands to come from exclusivity and strategic tie-ups, a mix shift that reduces discounting and structurally lifts gross margins.
- New brand pipeline: Ethos is in talks to bring one of the world’s largest brands (over $700–$800 million global turnover) exclusively into India, though it cannot name the brand for competitive reasons.
- Organisational commitment: The Chief Operating Officer has been moved to head this new mono-brand and exclusive brand vertical full-time.
Store Rollout & Unit Economics
- FY24 footprint: Started the year with 54 stores in 20 cities, ended with 63 stores in 24 cities after adding cities like Surat, Bhubaneshwar, Raipur and Mohali, and closing two for relocation.
- FY25 plan: Approximately 20 new boutiques, a mix of multi-brand Ethos stores and mono-brand boutiques (Breitling, Panerai, RIMOWA), plus a first store in Kochi opening June 2024.
- 150-store runway: Management sees a clear path to 150 boutiques over the next five to six years and will reassess capital needs only once that target is reached.
- Unit economics: Most boutiques are profitable from year one, targeting 18–20% return on capital in the first year itself, with returns increasing in year two, a pattern holding across both metro and non-metro locations.
- Airport entry: After the first airport store in Delhi, Ethos is now entering Bangalore Airport, and management says it remains bullish on travel retail.
The High-End Pivot & Volume Story
- Deliberate trade-down exit: Ethos removed all lower-price-point watches (Casio, Fossil, Michael Kors) from its website, causing a 50% drop in online visitors but an increase in website revenue and profitability.
- Volume is still growing: Watches sold above INR 1 lakh rose 19% YoY, from 18,471 units in FY23 to 22,000 units in FY24, disproving any narrative of volume decline.
- Strategic rationale: Management wants Ethos to be a premium Swiss and luxury watch destination, not a fashion-watch retailer, because the higher price point delivers better return on capital employed.
Pranav Saboo: "We want to focus on prices above INR1 lakh because it gives us better return on capital employed, and we want to make Ethos a premium journey, Swiss watches, luxury watches, not fashion watches, which are made in China."
New Verticals: Lifestyle, Pre-Owned & Favre Leuba
- Lifestyle division: The RIMOWA store in Mumbai has been profitable on a PAT basis since month one. Two more RIMOWA boutiques are signed for Delhi and Bangalore, a first luxury clock boutique (QlockTwo) opens in Bangalore this year, and Ethos is actively scouting for a flagship Messika jewellery boutique.
- Pre-owned watches: The segment contributed to revenue growth in FY24. Ethos is working to remove bottlenecks via manpower additions, training schools, and regulatory work, and remains committed to growing it.
- Favre Leuba restructuring: Ethos diluted its stake in Silvercity Brands to its holding company KDDL, retaining ~30% while KDDL holds 65%. Manufacturing moves to KDDL; Ethos focuses solely on India retail, which management frames as a return to core competency.
- Conflict-of-interest pushback: When an analyst raised the related-party nature of the Favre Leuba stake transfer, management deflected, saying it saw no conflict and moved the discussion on.
Pranav Saboo: "Ethos is focused upon its core competency of retail in India."
Margin Trajectory & Investment Phase
- Gross margin mechanics: Q4 saw a forex gain of INR 1.3 crores, but the full year had a forex loss of INR 1 crore. The CHF/INR rate swung from 92 to 99 and back to 92, and brands began raising prices from January, though management did not directly explain why gross margins did not improve in Q4.
- Cost build-up: Employee costs are rising because Ethos is hiring ahead of time for new stores and building senior leadership for new verticals, including the Lifestyle division and AI and app technology teams.
- Profit margin conviction: Management believes margins can increase through operating leverage and brand mix improvement, but declined to quantify the potential, saying only that the direction is "upwards."
- Capex opacity: When asked for total capex guidance for the coming year, management declined, saying it did not have that number available yet.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Store openings | Add approximately 20 boutiques in FY25 | FY25 |
| 150-store target | Reach 150 boutiques, then reassess capital needs | Next 5–6 years |
| EFTA duty reduction start | First 3% customs duty cut on Swiss watches, subject to Swiss paperwork completion | H2 FY25 |
| Exclusive brand mix | Grow exclusive/strategic brands from ~30% to 50% of sales | No date (stated goal) |
| AI deployment | Deploy proprietary AI models through sales network and digital platforms | Within the next year |
| 10x revenue ambition | Grow revenue tenfold | 10 years |
| Q1 FY25 election impact | April and May subdued; June expected to be a big month; Q1 slightly subdued overall | Q1 FY25 |
| Post-election recovery | Following three quarters expected to be better than Q1 | Q2–Q4 FY25 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹252.5 cr, +21.7% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹44.4 cr, +45.1% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 17% |
| PAT | ₹21 cr, +57.9% YoY |
| Revenue from operations (FY24) | ₹999 cr, +26.7% YoY from ₹788 cr in FY23 |
| EBITDA (FY24) | ₹175.3 cr, +36% YoY |
| EBITDA margin (FY24) | 17.1% |
| PAT (FY24) | ₹83.3 cr, +38.1% YoY |
| PAT margin (FY24) | 8.1% |
| Same-store growth | 10% |
| Store count | 63 stores in 24 cities, up from 54 stores in 20 cities at start of FY24; 2 stores closed due to relocation |
| Exclusive brands share of total sales | 29% in FY24, from a portfolio of 51 brands |
| Volume growth (watches above ₹1 lakh) | 22,000 watches sold in FY24, +19% from 18,471 in FY23 |
| Pre-owned watch billing | ₹66 cr in FY24 |
| Inventory days | 161 days as of March 31, 2024 |
| Cash and bank balance | ₹345.5 cr as on March 31, 2024 |
| Forex gain/loss | +₹1.3 cr in Q4; full year loss of ₹1 cr |
| Capex on store fit-outs and restoration | ₹38.3 cr in FY24 |
| Planned store additions for FY25 | Approximately 20 boutiques, mix of multi-brand and mono-brand outlets |
| Custom duty reduction timeline | 3%-something reduction per year starting H2 FY25, from 20% plus 2% CESS to 0% over 7 years under EFTA |