Key Takeaways
- Volumes up, margins crushed: Pipes & fittings volumes grew 29% YoY, but EBITDA fell 40% YoY as a sharp PVC price decline triggered inventory losses and power/fuel costs spiked.
- Agri demand is the missing piece: Overall volumes remain below pre-Covid levels entirely because of the agri segment; non-agri volumes are already 20% above pre-Covid Q1.
- Cash return is on the table: Management stated explicitly that if cash cannot be deployed in the business, it will be returned to shareholders, with a decision waiting only on PVC price stability.
- PVC prices near a floor, but no quick rebound: Management sees current ~$1,050/ton PVC prices as range-bound and calls a return to ₹70-80/kg "too aggressive" near-term.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the ₹20/kg PVC price drop already seen in early Q2 drives further inventory losses, and whether post-monsoon agri demand materializes as pent-up farmer spending.
The Margin Squeeze: Inventory Losses Meet Fuel Costs
- PVC price crash drove inventory losses: A sharp correction in PVC prices during the quarter hit margins hard, with the integrated structure amplifying the pain because smaller players can simply shut facilities while Finolex cannot.
- Power and fuel costs surged: Coal prices jumped from $45-55 to over $110 per ton, pushing fuel costs from ~₹47 Cr in Q4 to over ₹70 Cr in Q1, despite pipes production rising only 5% QoQ and resin production falling sequentially.
- Forex losses added pressure: Foreign currency exchange losses on buyer credit, concentrated in the PVC resin segment, contributed to the other-expenses spike; the combined power and forex hit was roughly ₹20-25 Cr.
- Inventory losses to persist in Q2: A further ₹20/kg drop in PVC prices has already occurred in the first few weeks of the current quarter, so additional inventory losses are expected.
- Pipe EBITDA per unit at a five-year low: The combination of weak agri demand and inventory losses in a falling price regime drove unit profitability to its lowest June-quarter level in five years.
- Spreads near cycle-bottom: On an annual basis, current spreads are in the lower part of the historical range and have more or less reached the bottom for the last few years, excluding the Covid disruption.
Kedia: "If your input prices goes up and your output prices do not go up, it is not good for anybody."
Agri Demand: The Waiting Game
- Farmers are deferring, not abandoning: Management attributes lower agri volumes over the past two to three years to price volatility, not structural demand destruction; farmers view pipe purchases as a one-in-a-lifetime investment and prefer to wait for prices to settle.
- Good monsoons enabled the delay: Two to three consecutive years of good monsoons have given farmers the flexibility to defer purchases to the next season without immediate consequence.
- Price drop should unlock pent-up demand: PVC prices have now come down to older levels, which management sees as a positive for agri demand, though Q2 is a lean quarter and monsoon outcomes still matter.
- No market share lost in agri: Management does not believe the company has ceded share in agri pipes over the last two to three years, framing the volume weakness as an industry-wide demand problem, not a competitive one.
- No demand signals yet from the price drop: Despite the correction, the company is not yet seeing any market signals of demand stimulation.
Whabi: "See most because of the volatility, in case of farmer this is one in lifetime type of investment so they would rather wait for the prices to come down then take the plunge."
Non-Agri: The Quiet Growth Engine
- Non-agri volumes structurally higher: Non-agri volumes are 20% above pre-Covid Q1 levels, and the mix has improved steadily from 25% in Q1 FY20 to 36% in Q1 FY23.
- Plumbing and sanitation focus: The company is slowly growing in plumbing and sanitation, with priority on west and south where its market position is stronger; in newer markets, the goal is penetration improvement where market size is decent but share is low.
- Plumber engagement is paying off: Increased engagement with plumbers and influencers over the last two to three years, an area management admits was lacking previously, is now reflected in volume growth.
- CPVC volumes stable sequentially: CPVC volumes were flat QoQ at 3,600 tons but up from 2,400 tons in Q1 FY22; CPVC prices have fallen only slightly and tend to lag PVC movements.
PVC Prices & Channel Dynamics
- Asian glut, not US weakness: US PVC prices have been relatively stable; the sharp movement has been in Asian markets due to China's construction slowdown, Covid lockdowns creating a supply glut, and low domestic Indian demand.
- Current prices seen as range-bound: At ~$1,050/ton, management expects PVC prices to be range-bound now and does not see material downside, though the market remains volatile and subject to external factors.
- Channel inventory at multi-year lows: In a falling price environment, distributors de-stock and keep minimum inventory; management assumes channel inventory is at its leanest in several quarters or even a couple of years.
- Price stabilization is the trigger: For inventory levels to normalize to pre-Covid levels, some assurance of price stability is needed; if prices remain range-bound until September, inventory should return to comfortable levels and the de-stocking mindset should shift.
Kedia: "Once the prices stabilize this mind set should change, which is natural I mean, which is natural normal for our business."
Capital Allocation: Cash Return Looms
- Explicit commitment to return excess cash: Management stated clearly that if cash cannot be deployed in the business, it will be returned to shareholders "in one way or the other" and that high cash balances will not be kept on the books for a long time.
- Decision contingent on PVC price stability: The company is waiting for PVC resin prices to stabilize and for its ability to predict to improve before taking a capital allocation decision; no fixed timeline has been set.
- Capex is largely maintenance: The FY23 capex plan is ₹200-250 Cr, of which ~₹50 Cr is annual maintenance capex and the remainder is largely for moulds; no major capacity expansion is planned.
- No new resin capacity in the near term: While some industry players are expanding and new entrants are coming, no new capacity is expected to be operational in the next two years given the minimum three-year gestation period.
- Greenfield eventually, not now: Capacity expansion when required would first be in existing plants; eventually a greenfield facility will need to be considered, but that is not imminent.
Kedia: "See if we are not able to deploy this in business, this will be returned to the shareholders in one way or the other. We will not keep such high levels of cash in a books for long time."
Competitive Position & Industry Structure
- Integrated player, asymmetric pain: Being integrated means Finolex is more affected during downturns than smaller players who can easily shut facilities and restart; this is accepted as part of the business model.
- Brand does not compete with unorganized players: Management draws a clear line: even when PVC was at ₹75/kg, unorganized players existed, but Finolex's brand does not compete with them.
- Price protection is offered when needed: The company does provide price protection to the channel if market demand or the scenario requires it.
- Credit rating upgraded: CRISIL upgraded the company's rating from AA to AA+ during the quarter, a bright spot in an otherwise difficult period.
Whabi: "Even when the price was 75 those players in an organized players were inexistence but I do not think our brand competes with unorganized players."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Cash return to shareholders | Excess cash returned "in one way or the other" if not deployable in business | Decision after PVC price stability improves predictability; no fixed timeline |
| PVC price outlook | Current ~$1,050/ton expected to be range-bound; no material downside seen | Near-term, subject to volatile market conditions |
| Inventory loss continuation | Additional inventory losses expected due to ₹20/kg PVC drop already in early Q2 | Current quarter (Q2 FY23) |
| Channel inventory normalization | Inventory should reach comfortable levels if prices stay range-bound | By September, conditional on price stability |
| Capex | ₹200-250 Cr, largely maintenance and moulds; no major capacity expansion | FY23 |
| Agri demand recovery | Pent-up demand expected to open up as PVC prices have returned to older levels | Post-monsoon; Q2 is a lean quarter |
| CPVC price trend | CPVC prices expected to come down to an extent; gap vs PVC not seen widening | No specific timeline |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total income from operations | ₹1,190 cr, +23% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹126 cr, −40% YoY |
| PAT | ₹100 cr, −32% YoY |
| Pipes and fittings revenue | ₹1,132 cr, +34% YoY |
| Pipes and fittings volume | 71,960 MT, +29% YoY |
| PVC resin segment revenue | ₹785 cr, +25% YoY |
| PVC resin segment volume | 62,746 MT, +25% YoY |
| PVC resin segment EBIT | ₹73 cr, −54% YoY |
| Net cash surplus | ~₹1,300 cr as on 30 June 2022 |
| Credit rating | Upgraded to AA+ from AA by CRISIL |
| Power, fuel and forex impact on other expenses | ~₹20–25 cr for the quarter |
| Agri/non-agri volume mix | 40:60 |
| CPVC revenue | ~₹150 cr |
| CPVC volume | ~3,600 tons, flat QoQ, up from 2,400 tons in Q1 FY22 |
| Fittings revenue | ~₹200 cr |
| Capex plan for FY23 | ₹200–250 cr, largely maintenance; maintenance capex not more than ₹50 cr annually |