Key Takeaways
- Volume miss on agri price sensitivity: Pipes & Fittings volume grew only 6% YoY as agri buyers postponed purchases anticipating PVC price drops, dragging overall performance despite strong non-agri growth.
- Resin production hit by supplier breakdown: Resin output was low because of major breakdowns at Middle East suppliers, constraining EDC/VCM supply; normalization is expected in H2.
- Full-year volume confidence intact: Management remains "very confident" of 15–20% Pipes & Fittings volume growth for FY24, betting on PVC price stabilization and agri recovery.
- Margin story is a mix shift, not a cost story: Non-agri mix hit a best-ever 40%, but EBITDA margin contracted because fixed costs were amortized over seasonally lower Q2 volumes.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether agri volumes bounce back as PVC prices stabilize, the pace of resin segment normalization, and any concrete announcement on capacity expansion or land monetization.
Pipes & Fittings: The Agri Drag
- Agri segment froze in September: July and August were good months, but September saw rains plus a month-long overhang of anticipated PVC price cuts that did not materialize, causing agri buyers to pull back sharply.
- Non-agri is the growth engine: Non-agri (plumbing & sanitation) grew significantly faster than agri, pushing the non-agri mix to 40%, the best of all quarters so far.
- Channel behavior amplifies PVC moves: In dropping PVC price scenarios, the channel pulls back on holding inventory and expects price protection; in rising markets, they stock up. Agri segment is highly price-sensitive; non-agri is less elastic.
- Organizational restructuring supports mix shift: Teams have been segregated into two focused areas (agri and non-agri) over the last financial year, with increased connect to the plumber and sanitation influencer community through engagement programs.
- Credit days ticked up but not strategic: Working capital saw a slight increase in Q2, but management says there is no shift in credit terms and it should normalize; agri pipes remain cash and carry.
Niraj Kedia: "If this price correction would have probably happened in the first week of September itself, then we might not have seen so much of this. But the fact that this overhang of our base going to be price correction, price reduction for a month, that had a very negative impact."
Resin Segment: Supplier Breakdown and Recovery Path
- Supplier breakdown choked supply: A major Middle East supplier had a technology change and did not anticipate the restart taking so long, constraining EDC and VCM supply and hitting resin production.
- No compensation due: Management clarified that no compensation is liable from the supplier due to force majeure provisions.
- H2 recovery expected: Resin production is guided at 200,000–220,000 metric tons for the full year, with larger volumes in the second half; some normalization in profitability expected by Q4.
- Resin EBIT guidance: Full-year average around ₹7 to ₹8 per kg.
- Minimal external sales: External resin sales are minimal; higher realization comes from emulsion-grade PVC used for medical equipment and synthetic leather versus suspension-grade.
Margins: Mix Improvement, Volume Headwind
- Gross margin improved, EBITDA margin did not: Non-agri mix improvement helped gross margin, but EBITDA margin contracted because fixed costs were amortized over lower volumes (60,000 tons in Q2 vs 90,000 tons in Q1).
- Other expenses rose on advertising: Other expenses as a percentage of revenue rose to ~23% vs historical ~19%, driven by higher advertising spend on content reaching relevant customer segments (Big Boss, Khatron ke Khiladi, World Cup logo presence) and BTL spends, partly amplified by a lower top line.
- Long-term pipe margin aspiration: As the non-agri to agri mix moves toward 50-50, management aspires for pipe segment EBIT to move up to ₹14 per kg and beyond, from the current-year guided range of ₹10–₹12.
Niraj Kedia: "INR14 is something that we are aspiring for in a few years' time, not in this year. See, as our non-agri to agri moves more towards the 50-50 mark, we aspire that our margin in the pipes segment should also move up to INR14 and plus."
PVC Price Dynamics and Inventory Impact
- Q2 saw a marginal inventory gain: PVC prices rose ₹4 from mid-July to August, giving a marginal inventory gain; the sharp fall started 30th September/1st October, so no material inventory loss for Q2.
- Q3 starts with some inventory loss: A ₹11 drop in 7–8 days at the start of Q3 implies some inventory loss, but prices have since recovered ₹1.
- CPVC prices eased but not material: CPVC prices came off roughly 5% recently, but no material inventory loss.
- Management sees a PVC price floor: The expectation is that the bottom has been reached.
- Import quality order having some effect: The government implemented a quota system for PVC imports; monitoring is unclear, but inferior quality PVC imports have reduced.
Niraj Kedia: "The positive thing is that this morning, the prices have gone up by ₹1. So that fall it seems have been arrested. But we'll see how it pans out."
Capital Allocation: Expansion First, Then Shareholders
- Capacity will max out in 2–3 years: Management expects capacities to max out by FY26 and is actively looking at expansion; several projects are in the pipeline, to be announced once they fructify.
- Cash return gated by capex clarity: Once capex for expansion is figured out, remaining cash will be moved to shareholders, but capex must be fixed first.
- Land monetization still in play: Management is hopeful of closing one substantial transaction by the end of this year.
- Retail network quality over quantity: Non-performing dealers are being replaced with performing ones; dealer count is stagnant but quality has improved.
Ajit Venkataraman: "We do need expansion of our capacities in the next couple of years, because we expect our volumes to -- our capacities to max out. And once we have figured that one out, we will be moving the rest of the remaining cash to the shareholders, but we will have to fix our capex first."
CPVC and Regulatory Watch
- Anti-dumping duty expiry could be a tailwind: If anti-dumping duty on Korean and Chinese CPVC resins goes away upon expiry next year, management personally sees it as positive for pipe makers because raw material becomes cheaper.
- CPVC disclosure pared back: The company stopped sharing CPVC and other subsegment-wise numbers two quarters ago, stating they are not separate segments; management declined to share CPVC volume growth, local vs import mix, or price differentials, calling them not material.
- New PVC manufacturing capacity on the horizon: A few manufacturers are looking to establish large facilities in the next 4–5 years, per management.
Niraj Kedia: "If it goes away, frankly, I would personally see it as a positive for the pipe makers, because obviously, the raw material becomes cheaper. So from a pipe makers perspective, it would be a positive move in my view."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Pipes & Fittings volume growth | 15% to 20% growth | FY24 full year |
| Resin production | 200,000 to 220,000 metric tons | FY24 full year |
| Resin EBIT per kg | ₹7 to ₹8 average | FY24 full year |
| Pipes segment EBIT per kg | ₹10 to ₹12 | FY24 full year |
| Resin profitability normalization | Some normalization expected | By Q4 FY24 |
| Long-term pipes EBIT per kg | ₹14+ as non-agri/agri mix moves toward 50-50 | "A few years" |
| Capacity expansion | Projects in pipeline, to be announced once fructified | Before capacity maxes out (FY26) |
| Capital return to shareholders | Remaining cash moved to shareholders after capex is fixed | After capex plan finalized |
| Land monetization | Hopeful to close one substantial transaction | By end of this year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total income from operations | ₹883.15 cr, down 6.16% YoY from ₹941.13 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹102.98 cr vs EBITDA loss of ₹142.67 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| EBITDA margin | 11.66% vs negative 15.16% in Q2 FY23 |
| Profit after tax | ₹93.78 cr vs loss of ₹93.92 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Pipes & Fittings revenue | ₹857.15 cr, up 7% YoY from ₹801.73 cr |
| Pipes & Fittings volume | 62,914 metric tons, up 6% YoY from 59,218 metric tons |
| Pipes & Fittings EBIT | ₹67.60 cr vs EBIT loss of ₹47.63 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| PVC Resin revenue | ₹297.85 cr, down 38% YoY from ₹481.07 cr |
| PVC Resin volume | 37,516 metric tons, down 31% YoY from 54,063 metric tons |
| PVC Resin EBIT | ₹20.40 cr vs loss of ₹110.68 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Cash surplus | ~₹1,500 cr as on 30th September 2023 |
| Pipes & Fittings volume growth guidance (FY24) | 15% to 20% |
| Resin production guidance (FY24) | 200,000 to 220,000 metric tons |
| Agri/non-agri volume mix | 60:40, vs 63:37 in Q2 FY23 |
| Pipes & Fittings EBIT per kg guidance (FY24) | ₹10 to ₹12 |
| Resin EBIT per kg guidance (FY24) | ₹7 to ₹8 |
| Fittings plant utilization | upwards of 60% of 900–1,000 metric tons capacity |
| Retail network | ~23,000 retail touch points, ~800 dealers/distributors |