Key Takeaways
- Volume surge, but Q3 was exceptional: Pipes & Fittings volumes jumped 49% YoY, the highest Q3 ever, driven by pent-up demand and market reopening. Management expects Q4 to be softer as that pent-up demand normalizes.
- Inventory losses masked underlying improvement: Reported losses stemmed primarily from inventory provisioning as PVC prices fell through October and November. Most of the old high-price inventory is now consumed, with resin profit normalization expected in Q4.
- Agri demand dominated the quarter: Agri pipe and fittings volume nearly doubled QoQ from 37,000 to 66,000 tonnes, while non-agri moved only modestly from 22,000 to 24,000 tonnes. The long-term aspiration remains a 50/50 volume mix.
- Cash deployment signal is clear: Management expects to need additional capacity in a year or two; surplus cash beyond that will be returned to shareholders, not held indefinitely on the balance sheet.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether resin margins normalize as promised, the pace of non-agri volume growth against a renewed brand push, and any progress on the land sale.
Volume & Demand Dynamics
- Pent-up demand drove the quarter: Q3 volumes were abnormally high because markets opened up and released long-pending demand. Q4 is described as a normal quarter by comparison, with demand good but slightly sluggish versus Q3.
- Agri skewed the mix sharply: Agri volumes more than doubled YoY, while non-agri grew 33% YoY on a standalone basis. The agri surge reflected both seasonal strength and pent-up demand in the irrigation business, visible in the jump in profit from associates.
- Channel inventory normalized: After the volatility of the past quarters, channel inventory is now back to more or less normal levels.
- Demand visibility remains low: Management declined to give a FY2024 volume growth outlook, saying clarity will come only after Q1 FY2024 because industry dynamics are very volatile, having swung from a slump to excess demand and back to normalization.
- Non-agri catch-up underway: The company acknowledges it started late in non-agri and is now focused on increasing brand awareness, expanding the dealer network for non-agri, and broadening the product range. There is no gap in the product portfolio, just a need to catch up.
Ajit Venkataraman: "I do not think there is any gap in the product portfolio. We do agree that we started a little bit late in the whole process; so it is more of a catchup than anything else."
PVC Pricing & Inventory Impact
- Price decline drove inventory losses: PVC prices kept falling through October and November, down a further Rs.11.5 by November, forcing inventory provisioning that depressed reported earnings. Prices stabilized and rose in December.
- PVC-EDC delta improved: The current delta of $665 is roughly $100 higher than last quarter's average of $570, a tailwind for resin margins going forward.
- Price stability now visible: After the first week of January, no price increases or reductions have been seen. Management does not foresee abnormal movements on either side as of now.
- China demand supporting prices: The China market has picked up after its New Year closure, with better demand. Prices up to March are expected to either strengthen or at least not fall, though any rise will be range-bound rather than phenomenal.
- Old high-price inventory largely consumed: Most of the pain from carrying high-cost inventory is now behind the company, setting up Q4 for a normalization of profit in the resin segment.
Niraj Kedia: "Now most of all that old high price inventory has been consumed; so in our view large part of the pain is behind us."
Anil Whabi: "After their new year closure in fact China market has picked up so demand is better there now. So what is expected is prices up to March if not strengthened will definitely not fall."
Margins & Realization
- Realization spread widened sharply: The ratio of pipe and fittings realization per tonne to PVC moved from ~1.28x to ~1.52x, driven by price correction in pipes when demand exceeded supply, and a higher proportion of fittings in the mix.
- Fittings provide stability: Fittings volumes show less seasonality than pipes because agri demand for fittings is much lower; the major volume is in plumbing and sanitation where volatility is lower.
- Sustainable margin view: With PVC prices stable over the last month and at normal pre-COVID levels, management believes the company is almost at a point of sustainable margins, assuming conditions hold.
- Mix shift should lift margins: Margins are expected to improve as the agri/non-agri mix moves toward the 50/50 long-term target, versus the current agri-heavy skew.
- Management declined to quantify ex-inventory margins: When asked what margins would be excluding inventory fluctuations in both divisions, management said that is difficult to quantify because prices kept falling through October and November.
Capacity, Capex & Capital Allocation
- No near-term capacity constraint: With 370,000 tonnes of annual capacity and peak quarterly production capability of 1 lakh tonnes, substantial headroom exists. No debottlenecking is required as of now.
- New capacity likely in 1–2 years: Management expects to need additional capacity in a year or two. Cash will be deployed there first; any surplus beyond that will be returned to shareholders in one form or another and will not sit on the balance sheet long-term.
- FY2024 capex similar to FY2023: Expected around ~₹150 Crores unless a large project is taken up. On the pipe side, nothing concrete is planned for a new factory. On the fittings side, the company keeps adding moulds and machines.
- No outsourcing on pipes: Management was explicit that the company will not outsource pipe production to anybody.
- No lean-season stocking: Building inventory in lean seasons for peak demand is not advisable because it exposes the company to commodity price volatility; stocking when metal prices could crash does not make sense.
Niraj Kedia: "So we will see probably in a years or two times we will require additional capacity. So this money will be either used there and if the money generation is more then it will be returned to the share holders in one form or other. It will not be kept in the balance sheet for a very long term."
Operational Updates
- CRM/DMS fully live for dealers: Dealers have been on the CRM system for almost a year; no more orders are taken on emails or Excel. The secondary side covering retailers has commenced in pockets and is gradually rolling out to all dealers, with completion expected in three to six months.
- Land sale progressing: The board mandate is clear to dispose of the land. Management is working toward closing as soon as possible, with no intentional delay. When an analyst suggested a December timeline, management responded with "hopefully" but committed only to closing as soon as possible.
- Agri/non-agri split is inherently blurry: Management declined to give a value-wise split for agri and non-agri, noting that in many markets, especially North and West, agri pipes are used for non-agri applications, making a usage-based split difficult.
- Competitive intensity acknowledged: Competition from regional players and new entrants has always been present, but management believes the growing market leaves space for everybody to grow.
Niraj Kedia: "We have to close this as soon as possible. We are working towards it. There is no intentional delay or there is no intention in speeding up of things. The mandate from the board is very clear. We have to get this disposed off and we are working towards this."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Resin profit normalization | Old high-price inventory consumed; profit should normalize in Q4 | Q4 FY2023 |
| DMS secondary-side rollout | Retailer-side implementation completed | 3–6 months |
| Land sale | Disposed of as soon as possible; "hopefully" by December per analyst suggestion | As soon as possible |
| FY2024 capex | ~₹150 Crores, similar to FY2023, unless a large project is taken up | FY2024 |
| Capacity addition | Additional capacity likely required | 1–2 years |
| Volume mix target | Agri and plumbing/sanitation to be equal contributors | Long-term, will take time |
| PVC price outlook | Prices expected to strengthen or at least not fall | Up to March |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total income from operations | ₹1,125 cr, +12% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹92 cr, -62% YoY; improved from EBITDA loss of ₹142.67 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Profit after tax | ₹72 cr, vs ₹178 cr in Q3 FY22 and loss of ₹93.92 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Pipes & fittings revenue | ₹1,077 cr, +30% YoY |
| Pipes & fittings volume | 90,396 MT, +92% YoY |
| Pipes & fittings EBIT | ₹69 cr, +25% YoY; vs loss of ₹47.63 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| PVC resin segment volume | 696 MT, +49% YoY (per transcript; likely 69,600 MT) |
| PVC resin segment EBIT | ₹12 cr, vs ₹178 cr in Q3 FY22 and loss of ₹110.68 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Net cash surplus | ₹1,520 cr as on 31 Dec 2022 |
| Non-agri volume mix | 27% of total pipe & fittings volume; 30% for 9M FY23 |
| CPVC volume | 4,100 MT |
| CPVC revenue | ~₹160 cr |
| Fittings revenue | ₹200 cr |
| Fittings volume | ~8,000 MT |
| PVC-EDC delta (current) | $665 |
| PVC-VCM delta (current) | $190 |
| Capex guidance FY23 | ~₹150 cr |
| Capex guidance FY24 | Similar range (~₹150 cr), unless large project undertaken |