Key Takeaways
- AUM grew 24% YoY, disbursements more than doubled: Disbursements hit ₹803 crores, up 127% YoY, in what management called one of the best quarters ever.
- Asset quality is normalizing fast: Gross Stage 3 fell to 1.15% from 1.44% YoY, and 30+ DPD dropped to 13.62%, with a clear path to pre-COVID levels of 10–12% by March end.
- Spreads widened despite rate hikes: Spreads rose to 13.71% from ~13.5% YoY, driven entirely by lower funding costs, and management is confident of holding 12–13% going forward.
- Branch build-out was front-loaded: 41 branches opened in Q2 alone, the most ever, as an upfront investment so they contribute in H2; H2 additions will be far lighter.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 30+ DPD glidepath to 10–12% stays on track, the pace of borrowing-cost pass-through to lending rates once the rate cycle stabilizes, and any update on the Sequoia holding question that management declined to address.
Asset Quality Normalization
- Stage 3 improvement: Gross Stage 3 dropped from 1.44% to 1.15% YoY, a decline of 30–35%, attributed to post-COVID normalization rather than any one-off cleanup.
- 30+ DPD trajectory: 30+ DPD fell from 17.6% to 13.62% YoY, and management expects to comfortably reach pre-COVID levels of 10–12% by March-end and maintain that in steady state.
- Collection efficiency: Reached 100.1% in Q2, with three of the last five quarters above 100%, signaling a return to normalcy after the pandemic disruption.
- Restructured book is still fragile: Only ~30% of the restructured book sits in Stage 1, while Stage 2 is over 60% and Stage 3 is 8–9%; collection efficiency on this pool runs at 70–75%, well below the main book.
- Stage 2 to Stage 3 migration control: Quick mortality and quick arrear triggers force full staff accountability analysis; for customers beyond 24 months, genuine life events get one-EMI flexibility, but once a customer moves from 31–60 days to 61–90 days, flexibility is cut off and concerted collection efforts arrest further flows.
- Provision coverage built up: Pre-COVID provision coverage on Stage 3 was ~20%, driven purely by PD and LGD methodology; post-COVID overlays pushed coverage on 90-plus assets to 34–35% even before Ind AS adoption, and overall provisions stand at ₹101.6 crores (1.77% of AUM).
Management: "During the 5-year cycle and 7-year cycle, we can't expect those customers to pay the dues in the month as normally you and me will do it. So, you have to have some flexibility. That is where Five Star differentiates from others. We give the flexibility to those customers -- but at the end of 90 plus, we ensure that flexibility is not misused."
Growth & Branch Expansion
- Disbursement surge: Disbursements grew 127% YoY to ₹803 crores, described as one of the best disbursement quarters ever, driven by branch expansion and strong demand.
- Branch openings front-loaded: 52 branches added in H1, with 41 in Q2 alone, the highest quarterly addition ever; H2 will not see the same pace because the investment was pulled forward so branches contribute in H2.
- AUM per branch diluted by new branches: Current AUM per branch is ₹16.3 cr, down from pre-COVID ~₹17 cr, because 84 branches are less than one year old and contribute only ~₹1.5 cr each; vintage branches show full productivity (3–5 years: ₹17.3 cr; 5+ years: ~₹29 cr).
- Steady-state branch productivity: Expected around ₹17–18 cr per branch; 65% of branches are already over three years old, and that proportion should reach 70–75% over the next few years.
- Geographic strategy remains southern-focused: For the next 3–5 years, the company will continue penetrating southern geographies where it has a 15+ year track record; the South proportion may drop from 93% to 85–80% over that period, but newer states are not for significant near-term growth.
- Contiguous expansion discipline: No branch is ever placed more than 100 km from an existing one; when entering a new state, a maximum of four branches are opened initially, then a 24-month assessment period evaluates customer behavior, employee loyalty, leadership, loan defaults, political influence, fraud, and legal challenges before any decision to scale from 4 to 40 branches.
Margins, Spreads & Profitability
- Spread expansion: Spreads increased to 13.71% from ~13.5% YoY, purely on the back of lower funding costs, even as the RBI raised rates; management is confident of maintaining spreads at 12–13% in the quarters ahead.
- NIM improvement: NIMs improved to 18.2% from 15.94% YoY, driven by lower cost of funds and stable yields.
- Borrowing cost decline: All-in borrowing cost dropped from ~9% to 8.6%; cost of funds on book dropped from 10.7% to 10.5%; incremental cost of borrowings is now 8.5–8.75%, and management expects the overall cost of funds to stay flat or improve before stabilizing.
- Cost-to-income improvement: Cost to income improved to 34.11% from 35.34% YoY, reflecting increasing efficiencies, though management cautions that significant further operational efficiency gains are limited because Five Star is already at one of the best productivities in the industry.
- PAT growth: PAT grew 22% YoY in Q2 and 30% YoY in H1, supported by robust growth, spreads, and operating leverage.
- Yield management philosophy: Management will consider passing on benefits of lower borrowing costs to customers once the interest rate cycle stabilizes, not driven by competitive pressure but by a philosophy of being a reasonable lender.
Management: "Our focus is not so much on the yields, but it is more on the spreads that we want... we can clearly say that our focus will be on the spreads, and we would like to maintain our spreads at about 12% to 13% in the quarters to come. We are confident of maintaining that."
Competitive Position & Customer Franchise
- Customer retention is high: 75–80% of customers stay with Five Star; only ~10% graduate to larger institutions, and balance transfer outs are low at 3–5% while balance transfer ins are higher at 6–8%, giving a positive net balance transfer position.
- Repeat customer base: ~15% of customers are repeats who closed an old loan and returned; combined with top-up loans, ~40,000–50,000 customers are some form of repeat.
- Top-up loan discipline: Top-up loans are not extended in the first 24 months; the customer must have a good track record and be 0 DPD, and a fresh assessment of LTV and DBR is done; ~10% of portfolio customers run two loans together.
- The niche is defended by operational intensity: Management argues that larger players, whether NBFCs or banks, resist coming down to this ticket size because it is operationally too intensive or economically unviable given their cost structures.
- Core sourcing is from the unorganized sector: The business model targets customers borrowing from moneylenders and friends and family, not files from other NBFCs or small finance banks; balance transfers are only 1–2% net and are a very small trickling segment.
- Due date culture shift: Almost 90–93% of customers now pay on the due date rather than within the due month, a shift enabled by the RBI's nine-month deferral of the circular, which gave time to fine-tune internal systems and set borrower expectations across the entire NBFC sector.
Lakshmipathy D.: "There's a perception in the market that Five Star has been lending to an overcrowded market. Let me be very clear. As I said, this is a very niche segment where we don't compete taking the files from other NBFCs and other small finance banks, we take the file from unorganized lender, which is money lenders and borrowing from friends and families."
Capital, Funding & Balance Sheet
- Rating upgrade: Received A+ rating from both ICRA and CARE, and management will take up with rating agencies for a possible further upgrade.
- Borrowing diversification: Diversified into NCDs, market-linked debentures, securitization transactions, and external commercial borrowing.
- Liquidity sufficiency: On-balance sheet liquidity of ₹795 crores is sufficient to meet growth targets for the next two quarters without assuming incremental sanctions.
- CAR decline: CAR declined ~7% on a six-month basis, driven by portfolio and balance sheet growth plus a shift in liquidity deployment from FDs (no risk weight) to mutual funds (which carry risk weight); management expects a ~10–15% YoY decline going forward but does not use CAR as a reference point for justifying growth, given it remains at a very high level.
- Post-IPO net worth: Stood at about INR 4,006 crores as of September.
Steady-State Economics & Pricing Philosophy
- Steady-state ROA guidance: Around 6–6.5% when leverage reaches ~3x to 4x; the current 8%+ ROA is not sustainable, not because of competition but because management wants to pass on benefits from lower borrowing costs and operational efficiency to customers by bringing down lending rates.
- Lending rate structure: Seven-year rates (24%) are priced lower than two-year rates (26%) to nudge customers toward longer tenures and ease EMI pressure; customers are allowed to prepay whenever they have access to good cash flows, and management believes customers appreciate this flexibility.
- Steady-state OPEX to AUM: Expected at 5–5.5%, with cost to income around 35%; management sees limited room for further operational efficiency gains because productivity is already among the best in the industry.
- Revised RBI NPA norm impact: In steady state, the difference between Stage 3 and NPAs per the revised RBI norm should be around 100 bps; no significant provision impact is expected because cases that could become RBI NPA but are not gross Stage 3 are already provided at 10% or more.
Management: "We can guide you a steady-state ROA of around 6% to 6.5%... we don't say that 8% ROA will stay here. But not because of the competition that the ROA will get reduced, but I think from a reasonable lender, we wanted to also bring down the lending rate wherever we get the benefit both from borrowing cost and operational efficiency going up, we wanted to pass on that benefit to the customer."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| 30+ DPD normalization | Reach pre-COVID levels of 10–12% and maintain in steady state | By March-end (next 2 quarters) |
| Spread maintenance | Maintain spreads at 12–13% | Quarters ahead |
| Branch openings | ~70 branches for full year FY23 (vs 50–60 steady state), majority in South | FY23 |
| Steady-state ROA | 6–6.5% when leverage reaches ~3x to 4x | When leverage target reached |
| Steady-state OPEX to AUM | 5–5.5% | Over next few years |
| Steady-state cost to income | ~35% | Over next few years |
| RBI NPA norm impact | Difference between Stage 3 and RBI NPAs ~100 bps in steady state | Steady state |
| CAR decline | ~10–15% YoY decline expected | Ongoing |
| Geographic mix shift | South proportion may drop from 93% to 85–80% | Next 3–5 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| AUM | ₹5,732 cr, +24% YoY and +8% QoQ |
| Disbursements | ₹803 cr, +127% YoY and +41% QoQ |
| H1 FY23 disbursements | ₹1,371 cr |
| PAT | ₹144 cr, +22% YoY |
| H1 FY23 PAT | ₹284 cr, +30% YoY |
| Net worth | ₹4,006 cr as of 30 Sep 2022 |
| Average yield on portfolio | 24.19% for the quarter |
| Cost of funds | 10.48% for the quarter, down from 10.7% a year ago |
| Spread | 13.71%, up from 13.5% in Sep 2021 |
| NIM | 18.2% for the quarter, up from 15.94% in H1 FY22 |
| Return on assets (H1 FY23, on avg total assets) | 8.68% |
| Return on equity (H1 FY23) | 14.66% |
| Cost-to-income (H1 FY23) | 34.11%, improved from 35.34% in H1 FY22 |
| Gross Stage 3 (90+ DPD) | 1.15%, improved from 1.44% in Sep 2021 |
| 30+ DPD | 13.62%, down from 17.6% in Sep 2021 and 15.7% in Jun 2022 |
| Provision coverage on Stage 3 assets | a little over 44% |
| Provision coverage on overall AUM | 1.77% (₹101.6 cr) |
| Collection efficiency | 100.1% for the quarter |
| Restructured book outstanding | 1.18% of portfolio (₹65 cr gross), provision coverage over 50% |
| Total active loans | ~2.5 lakh, +32% YoY |
| Branch count | 352, up from 268 a year ago; 41 branches added in Q2 |
| On-balance sheet liquidity | ₹795 cr as of Sep 2022 |
| Incremental cost of borrowing | 8.5% to 8.75% |
| Fixed-rate borrowings | 60% of total borrowings |
| Branch manager and above attrition | 8% to 9% |
| Officer-level attrition | 25% to 30% |