Key Takeaways
- Collections quality hit a new high: Unique collection efficiency crossed 98%, driving 30-plus DPD down from 9.68% to 8.59% and putting the 90/10 current-to-arrears target within reach.
- Branch-led growth is accelerating: The company opened 70 branches in Q2, one of its highest ever, and revised full-year branch opening guidance from 70-80 to nearly 120.
- AUM grew 9% sequentially to ₹8,264 crores, with disbursements at an all-time high of ₹1,204 crores, yet management declined to raise its 35% growth guidance, preferring to wait two more quarters.
- The southern market remains the engine: Over 50% of new branches went to Andhra Pradesh, and management sees deep Tier-6 and Tier-7 penetration runway in the four big southern states before needing to rush newer geographies.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 30-plus DPD trajectory continues its downward march toward the 90/10 target, the pace of the Salesforce ERP rollout completion in Telangana, and any signal on a growth guidance revision.
Collections & Asset Quality
- Collection efficiency broke a ceiling: Unique collection efficiency improved from 97.5% to 98%, and overall efficiency crossed 100%, arresting forward flows meaningfully.
- 30-plus DPD dropped sharply: Fell from 9.68% to 8.59% QoQ, with management expecting the decreasing trend to continue.
- Current-to-arrears ratio improved: Now at 86.5% current and 13.5% arrears, with a stated target of reaching 90% current and 10% arrears, maybe by June 2025.
- Stage-3 and NPA nudged lower: 90-plus NPA improved from 1.08% to 1.07%, and IRAC Stage-3 from 1.41% to 1.37%.
- Provision coverage strengthened: PCR on Stage-3 assets rose from ~44% to over 50%, driven by the ECL model and conservative overlays, while the restructured book shrank to 0.66% of the overall book with close to 50% provision coverage.
- Credit cost conviction: Management expects credit cost to stay at sub-1%, citing that even demonetization and COVID did not cause a permanent spike.
- Why collections work: Three structural factors: (1) customer sales are back to pre-COVID levels with good margins; (2) secured lending on residential property creates emotional attachment; (3) collection infrastructure lets customers reach the company within 30 minutes.
Lakshmipathy D: "The business model what Five Star has built for last 20 years plus or more than that, is from the back of the assessing the collection first and assessing the customer on the cash flow and character, leaving the collateral aside."
Growth & Branch Expansion
- Disbursements hit an all-time high: ₹1,204 crores, up 6% sequentially and 50% YoY, driven by branch expansion and borrower base growth from 3.2 lakhs to 3.4 lakhs, not ticket-size inflation.
- Branch opening guidance revised sharply upward: From 70-80 to nearly 120 for the full year, with 83 already opened in H1 and another 40-45 planned for H2.
- Andhra Pradesh is the new growth engine: More than 50% of the 80-plus branches opened in H1 went to Andhra, which is becoming a leading contributor to disbursement and AUM growth due to good demand, dense population, interconnected coastal towns, good collection traction, and a strong team.
- Branch breakeven is fast: New branches are breaking even at six to nine months, signaling strong demand and customer movement from informal to formal lending.
- Southern market depth is the priority: Management sees huge opportunity in Tier-6 and Tier-7 cities in the four big southern states, noting HDFC has 500 branches in Tamil Nadu versus Five Star's 120.
- Newer geographies are deliberately slow: Growth in Rajasthan, Maharashtra, Chhattisgarh, and Uttar Pradesh is slow by design, with extreme conservatism in the first 24 months (only 4-6 branches per state) and every loan in a new state approved by the MD or a named senior executive for the first year.
- Cultural nuance as a moat: Cash flows, repayment track, employee loyalties, land records, legal risks, title deeds, and ancestral property handling all differ significantly between states, which is why no growth pressure is put on new states for the first 24 months.
Lakshmipathy D: "We are very clear here to say we are not going to rush for the growth in the newer geographies… we don't want to do that. So, the growth is going to come from the southern market where we have been lending and collecting for the last 20 years."
Competitive Positioning
- The ₹1-10 lakh sweet spot is lightly contested: Competitive intensity is increasing at sub-₹1 lakh and above ₹10 lakhs, but between ₹1 lakh and ₹10 lakhs, fewer players find it operationally viable or underwriting-feasible.
- Five Star's core is ₹3-5 lakhs: Turnaround time is 5-7 days with 3 days of ground-level underwriting, a model fintechs cannot easily replicate because they operate in Tier-1/2 cities with unsecured, short-term, cash-flow-based algorithms, while Five Star operates in Tier-3 to Tier-7 towns with secured, longer-term loans.
- Competition is not forcing strategy changes: The company is not tweaking lending rates or altering growth pace due to competition; the business model is not easy to replicate.
- Balance transfers are negligible: Only 2-3% of loans move in or out, because the model displaces money lenders and borrowers stay as long as they get desired loan quantums, good service, and repayment flexibility.
Lakshmipathy D: "Between 1 lakh and 10 lakhs, we see lesser people getting into it, either they see it is operationally not viable or the underwriting becomes more challenging. I think that's where Five Star kicks in."
Profitability & Margins
- Income and PAT grew in lockstep: Income rose 8% sequentially (44% YoY) to ₹522 crores, and PAT grew 9% sequentially (38% YoY) to ₹199 crores.
- Cost-to-income held steady at 36%: Despite the heavy branch expansion, the ratio stayed within the guided steady-state range of 35-37%, and management expects it to remain range-bound even with additional technology spends.
- Opex-to-AUM guidance intact: The broad guidance of about 6% to 6.5% continues to stand even in a growing scenario.
- Yield movement is noise, not signal: A 20 bps drop in portfolio yield is normal, with 20-25 bps movements expected depending on DPD numbers and the accrual process; penal interest on overdue accounts does not flow into yield.
- Spread strategy is deliberate: The intent is to maintain spreads at 12-13% in a steady state, not to keep yields at current levels; once the interest rate environment stabilizes, the company will gradually pass on some benefits to borrowers, noting the segment is not very price-sensitive (a percentage difference in yield translates to about ₹70-80 EMI per month per lakh of loan over seven years).
Srikanth Gopalakrishnan: "The question is not compromising yield or compromising growth or whatever. I think the question is more towards ensuring that we are a responsible lender, lending at the right interest rates to our borrowers."
Funding & Liquidity
- Cost of funds improved: Cost of borrowing on book decreased from 9.8% to 9.7%, with incremental borrowing at 9.5%; the company is seen as an attractive destination for lenders.
- Rating upgrade supports liability profile: Rating was upgraded from A+ to AA-minus over the last couple of quarters, with one rating agency upgrading in the most recent quarter.
- Securitization strategy is capped: Management will try to maintain securitization at 25-35% of overall borrowings and will ensure it does not cross one-third of borrowings in securitization form.
- NCD market penetration is a priority: Efforts are underway, with traction expected to build up substantially sooner or later.
- Two new banks onboarded: Both with sizable sanctions, adding diversity to the funding mix.
Operations & Technology
- Salesforce ERP rollout is on track: Went live with Tamil Nadu in Q1, Karnataka and central Indian states in Q2, and Andhra Pradesh in October; only Telangana remains, with training kicked off on the day of the call. Disbursement and growth were not affected during the transition.
- Cash collections are declining gradually: Currently at 55%, may come down further as the company moves forward, but there is no hard target; management is comfortable with cash as long as the customer is comfortable.
- Attrition is concentrated and manageable: Attrition has not increased and is expected to gradually come down over the next 3-4 quarters; it is largely among employees with less than 12 months tenure and at junior levels, while attrition at branch managers and above is extremely low.
- One-year vintage Stage-3 is not an apple-to-apple comparison: The current 1.95% includes the new RBI norm (1.35%), whereas historical comparisons at Q2 FY22 were on a 90-plus days basis (1% to 1.1%); quick mortality on one-year vintages is extremely low, with Stage-3 typically taking about three years to materialize.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Current-to-arrears ratio | Reach 90% current / 10% arrears | Maybe June 2025 (next two quarters) |
| 30-plus DPD trajectory | Continue decreasing trend | Ongoing |
| Branch openings | Add 40-45 more branches (total ~120 for FY24) | H2 FY24 |
| Growth guidance | 35% YoY growth; revision possible if trend continues | Hold for next two quarters; revise in March quarter if needed |
| Cost-to-income | Stay within 35-37% range | Steady state |
| Credit cost | Stay at sub-1% | Ongoing |
| Securitization cap | Not to exceed one-third of borrowings | Ongoing |
| ERP transition | Complete move from old ERP to Salesforce | End of Q3 FY24 |
| Attrition | Gradually come down | Next 3-4 quarters |
| New state expansion | Reach 10-11 states | In a year or two |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| AUM | ₹8,264 cr, +9% QoQ and +44% YoY |
| Total income | ₹522 cr, +8% QoQ and +44% YoY |
| Profit after tax | ₹199 cr, +9% QoQ and +38% YoY |
| Yield | ~24.2%, stable |
| Cost of borrowing (book) | 9.7%, down from 9.8% QoQ; incremental borrowing at 9.5% |
| Spread | ~14.5% |
| Net interest margin | ~17.7% |
| Return on assets | ~8.5% |
| Return on equity | a little over 17% |
| Cost-to-income ratio | ~36%, guided to remain in 35% to 37% range |
| AUM growth guidance | 35%+ YoY, maintained |
| Branch count | 456, 70 added in Q2; 83 added in H1 FY24 |
| Full-year branch addition guidance | ~120 branches, revised up from 70-80 |
| Loan disbursement | ₹1,204 cr, +6% QoQ and +50% YoY |
| Borrower base | 3.4 lakh, up from 3.2 lakh in June |
| Collection efficiency | over 100%, up from 99.6% QoQ |
| Unique collection efficiency (D1C1) | 98%, up from 97.5% QoQ |
| 30+ days past due | 8.59%, down from 9.68% QoQ |
| 90+ days past due (NPA) | 1.07%, down from 1.08% QoQ |
| IRAC Stage-3 | 1.37%, down from 1.41% QoQ |
| Current-to-arrears customer ratio | 86.5% current / 13.5% arrears, improved from 85%/15% in June |
| Provision coverage ratio (overall book) | 1.63%, down from 1.64% QoQ |
| Provision coverage ratio (Stage-3 assets) | a little over 50%, up from ~44% QoQ |
| Restructured book | 0.66% of overall book, with close to 50% provision coverage |
| Capital adequacy | almost close to 60% |
| Cash collection share | 55% cash, 45% non-cash; down from ~65% earlier |
| Branch mix guidance | 75% south, 20-25% rest of country |
| Opex to AUM guidance | ~6% to 6.5% |
| Incremental cost of borrowing | 9.5% to 9.6% |
| One-year lag Stage-3 | 1.95%, historically around 1.75% to 2% level |
| Balance transfer (in and out) | not crossing 2% to 3% |