Key Takeaways
- Growth deliberately slowed to 25%: The board cut FY25 guidance from 30% citing the overleveraged environment and regulatory sentiment, while asset quality held firm with Stage-III up only 6 bps to 1.47%.
- A 200 bps rate cut resets the P&L path: Lending rate on new disbursals drops to 22.5% from 1st November, accelerating the journey toward a 12% steady-state spread and compressing ROA toward 6% over two to three years.
- Overleveraging is real but contained: A bureau scrub found 14% of borrowers overleveraged, yet only 0.4% of active loans showed lower collection efficiency, and management expects the stress to fade within two quarters.[15-16]
- Liability franchise is quietly strengthening: Non-bank borrowings fell from 74% to 70% as mutual fund PTC partners were onboarded, and incremental borrowing cost rose just 5 bps despite the mix shift.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 200 bps rate cut triggers faster portfolio yield compression than the guided FY26-27 timeline, how the 1,600 stressed accounts evolve, and any signal on FY26 growth when the board revisits.
The Deliberate Growth Slowdown
- Board took a conservative call: Growth guidance was cut from 30% to 25% for FY25 after considering the current overleveraged environment and regulators' views from all sources; the board will revisit in the next financial year when conditions improve.
- Disbursement dipped QoQ: Disbursement of ₹1,251 crores grew 4% YoY but fell 5% QoQ, reflecting the intentional slowdown rather than demand weakness.
- Portfolio still grew 32% YoY: AUM reached ₹10,927 crores with 6% sequential growth, but the slower disbursal pace means H2 will be flattish or only slightly higher than H1.
- Branch additions are investments, not immediate growth drivers: Of 113 new branches, 77 were splits addressing concentration risk, not fresh expansion; new branches take 3-6 months to stabilize and 7-9 months to reach ₹2.5 crores breakeven AUM.
- No geographical stress concentration: The bureau scrub showed stress tied to a particular customer category (overleveraged), not concentrated in any single geography.
Lakshmipathy Deenadayalan: "My hope is this is not going to be a longer-term issues... my hope is it should be shorter, not more than two quarters from now." [15-16]
The 200 bps Rate Cut: Mechanics and Rationale
- Rate drops to 22.5% on 1st November: The board approved a 200 bps cut on incremental disbursals, sharper than the previously guided 50-75 bps, because management wants to get close to the 12% steady-state spread sooner rather than gradually.
- Portfolio yield impact will be back-ended: The ₹11,000 crores existing book is fixed-rate at higher yields, so the rate cut affects only new disbursals; FY25 yield stays around 24% or slightly lower, but FY26-27 will see a sharper drop than previously guided.
- Regulatory context was real but not a directive: Regulators have had public commentary and interactions trying to understand the reasoning behind rates charged, but have not pushed, nudged or forced any changes; the decision was voluntary, though management believes it will put them in good stead.
- Spread compression is the new reality: Spread was at 12% two to three years back and is at 14% today, which management says "doesn't really gel in well"; if RBI cuts rates and spreads inch up, those benefits will also be passed to borrowers.
- Profitability impact muted in FY25: Because the rate cut applies only to about five months of disbursals on a smaller incremental portfolio, the immediate P&L hit is limited; the bigger impact comes in outer years as the book reprices.
Srikanth Gopalakrishnan: "Originally we were thinking that the book will start being at around incremental yields in three years, but maybe today that could probably be in FY'26/27 you will start seeing some impact which is more sharper than what we would have guided."
Overleveraging: The Data and the Response
- 14% of borrowers are overleveraged by count: A bureau scrub of all primary applicants on active loans as of September 2024 found 59,000 loans (14% by number of accounts) where borrowers have three or more other loans; on a value basis the proportion is slightly lower.
- Only 0.4% of active loans show stress: Just 1,600 loans exhibited lower collection efficiency in the last six months, and even those customers have paid 2-3 installments during the period, indicating some cash flow issues rather than outright default.
- More than half likely took additional loans after Five Star's sanction: At underwriting, DBR is capped at 50%, making it unlikely these customers had all this overleverage at sanction time; the overleveraging largely happened after Five Star's loan was disbursed.
- Borrowers prioritize Five Star: Even on the portfolio with microfinance overlap, no deterioration is visible; management attributes this to the secured nature of the loan and the strong collection infrastructure built over 22 years and five crises.
- Underwriting is tightening: Stricter norms on LTV and DBR will be implemented for identified pockets where stress could build, using the bureau scrub data as the basis for revised underwriting principles.
- ECL provision is already conservative: Weighted average LGD on defaulted loans is ~10% while Stage-III provision coverage is ~52%; management, the board and auditors feel the current provision level is appropriate and the ECL model does not give much flexibility to push numbers higher given strong PDs and LGDs.
Lakshmipathy Deenadayalan: "Only 1,600 loans translating to just 0.5% of our total active loans have exhibited lower collection efficiency in the last six months."
Asset Quality and Collections
- Collection efficiency dipped marginally: Overall collection efficiency at 98.4% (vs 98.5% in June) and unique customer collections at 97% (vs 97.2% in June); the marginal dip contributed to a slight increase in DPDs but remains impressive in industry context.
- Gross Stage-III rose 6 bps to 1.47%: The increase is modest and management characterizes asset quality performance as good, with no deterioration signals beyond the identified overleveraged pocket.
- LTV declined to 39%: Portfolio LTV dropped from 40.5% because slower disbursal growth means higher-LTV loans are not being added at the same pace while existing loans run down without collateral revaluation.
- Credit cost guidance holds a buffer: The 1% credit cost guidance is at the higher end of the 75-100 bps range; management notes that when growth slows and the portfolio seasons, LGD (currently 10%) could rise due to more legal actions and discounts to customers.
- Write-offs were ₹11 crores this quarter: Up from ₹7 crores last quarter, per an analyst's math confirmed by management.
Liability Diversification and Margins
- Non-bank borrowings fell from 74% to 70%: The company onboarded Nippon Mutual Fund and Kotak Mutual Fund as lenders via PTC transactions, with HDFC Mutual Fund and HSBC Mutual Fund also subscribing to PTCs.
- Borrowing cost nearly flat: Overall cost of borrowing stable at 9.65%; incremental borrowing cost rose just 5 bps to 9.52% despite the slightly higher rates from non-bank sources.
- Securitization carries a 20-25 bps premium: This premium over bank borrowing is expected to come down as partners gain comfort with portfolio performance; no long-term impact on cost of funds is anticipated.
- NIM expanded ~20 bps QoQ: Partly because leverage came down (debt-equity from 1.23 to 1.20) as net worth growth outpaced borrowing growth.
- No direct assignments planned: Capital adequacy is very good and the company wants to keep assets on balance sheet; PTCs were started only after Ind AS allowed holding assets on balance sheet, and direct assignments would at best cover 6-8% of the overall held-to-maturity book.
Profitability and Steady-State Targets
- PAT of ₹268 crores, up 34% YoY and 6% QoQ: Healthy ROA at around 8.3% and ROE crossed 19% for the first time; management confirmed PAT will cross ₹1,000 crores this financial year.
- Steady-state guidance unchanged: Long-term targets remain spreads around 12% and ROA around 6%, achieved through 14-15% NIM at 3-3.5x leverage, 5-5.5% OPEX, ~1% credit cost, and ~8.5% pre-tax profit.
- ROA compression will be gradual: This year will not see too much compression because the rate drop affects only about five months of disbursals; steady-state ROA of about 6% is expected in two to three years.
- ROE target of 20-22% in two to three years: Assuming leverage around 3-3.5x, ROE should land anywhere in that range.
- Cost-to-income guided at 35-36% including credit cost: OPEX is 65-70% fixed and 30-35% variable (linked to disbursals), so slower growth limits operating leverage; management declined to guide on cost-to-income ex-credit cost going below 30%.
- Spread timeline depends on growth: If growth stays at 25% for the next three years, reaching 12% spreads may not happen in two years; if growth improves, the timeline could accelerate.
Srikanth Gopalakrishnan: "If you are going to grow at 25%, let us say for the next three years if the environment is going to stay where it is and we will have to grow only 25%, then I agree with your point, it may not happen in two years."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| FY25 AUM growth | 25% (revised from 30%) | FY25 |
| Lending rate on new disbursals | 22.5% (200 bps cut from 24.5%) | Effective 1st November 2024 |
| PAT | Cross ₹1,000 crores | FY25 |
| Steady-state spread | ~12% | Two to three years; longer if growth stays at 25% |
| Steady-state ROA | ~6% | Two to three years |
| Steady-state ROE | 20-22% (at 3-3.5x leverage) | Two to three years |
| Cost-to-income (incl. credit cost) | ~35-36% | Steady state |
| Branch split program completion | Most pending splits done | Mid-FY26 |
| Overleveraged stress duration | Hope it is shorter, not more than two quarters | By Q4 FY25 |
| Growth revisit | Board will take a call when environment improves | Next financial year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Disbursements | ₹1,251 cr, +4% YoY and -5% QoQ |
| AUM / Portfolio | ₹10,927 cr, +32% YoY and +6% QoQ |
| AUM growth guidance (FY25) | 25%, revised from 30% |
| PAT | ₹268 cr, +34% YoY and +6% QoQ |
| ROA | ~8.3% |
| ROE | crossed 19% for the first time |
| Net worth | a little over ₹5,700 cr |
| Yield on portfolio | ~24% |
| Cost of funds | 9.65%, flat QoQ |
| Incremental borrowing cost | 9.52%, +5 bps QoQ |
| Spread (steady-state guidance) | ~12% |
| NIM movement | expanded by almost 20 bps QoQ |
| Cost-to-income (incl. credit cost, steady-state) | ~35% |
| OPEX to income (current quarter) | ~5.1% |
| Lending rate on incremental disbursals | 22.5%, reduced by 200 bps from 24.5% effective 1 Nov 2024 |
| Collection efficiency | 98.4% vs 98.5% in Q1 |
| Unique customer collection (Due One, Collect One) | 97% vs 97.2% in Q1 |
| Gross Stage-III assets | 1.47%, +6 bps QoQ |
| ECL provision on overall AUM | 1.65% |
| Provision coverage on Stage-III assets | 52% |
| Write-offs (quarter) | ₹11 cr vs ₹7 cr in Q1 |
| Active loans | 4.3 lakh |
| Overleveraged loans (≥3 other FI loans) | 14% of active loans, ~59,000 accounts |
| Overleveraged loans with lower collection efficiency | ~1,600 accounts, 0.4% of total active loans |
| Average LTV | 39%, down from 40.5% in Q1 |
| Branches opened in quarter | 113, comprising 32 new and 77 split branches |
| Borrowing mix: other than banks | 70%, down from 74% in Q1 |
| Securitization portfolio | 18% of borrowings, up from 14% |
| Liquidity buffer | ~₹1,700 cr |
| Undrawn sanction lines | ~₹250 cr |
| Debt-equity ratio | 1.20, down from 1.23 in Q1 |
| Full-year FY25 disbursement estimate | ~₹5,200 cr, implying ~10-12% growth (per an analyst's math) |