Key Takeaways
- Revenue declined 1.6% YoY CC, in line with guidance: The quarter absorbed a 3% mortgage base-effect headwind and the start of a 3.5-4% onshore-to-offshore revamp, while operating margin improved 375 bps YoY to 11.7%.
- The top-client relationship was locked in for a decade: A 10-year contract extension cements Firstsource as the primary partner, though the accompanying offshore shift will create a near-term revenue drag before restabilizing.
- Mortgage has found a floor: Management declared the worst of the volatility behind them and volumes bottomed out, with origination inching up and purchase demand steady in high-growth US regions.
- Collections tailwinds are building, but on a lag: US credit card delinquencies and charge-offs rose for the sixth straight quarter; early-stage work should reflect sooner, while legal collection is expected to pick up only from Q4 or Q1 next year.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the onshore-to-offshore drag peaks as guided, the pace of the promised sequential growth acceleration into H2, and any early signs that the collections upturn is converting into revenue.
The Top-Client Relationship: A 10-Year Anchor With Near-Term Drag
- Contract extended: Firstsource will serve as the top client's primary partner for another 10 years, a relationship management described as built "across the value chain and across product lines."
- The offshore shift is the story: A big chunk of the work is moving onshore-to-offshore, with the heaviest impact concentrated in Q2 and Q3 before restabilizing. This shift, plus some UK volume softness, drove the Q1 revenue decline in the top-client relationship.
- Investment committed: The company is investing approximately GBP 1.5 crore as part of the extension.
- Growth expectations intact: Management said it continues to expect incremental growth from the client and that there is no capacity reduction, though it did not address whether the extension came with an increased annual budget commitment.
Vipul Khanna: "I am pleased to inform that we have further cemented our relationship with this client and have extended our contract to serve as their primary partner for another 10 years. This is a huge testament of the relationship we have built over the years and the value we provide to our clients."
Mortgage: Stabilized, With a Floor in Place
- Volatility is behind us: Mortgage, now around 9% of revenue (down from 17% a year ago), has stabilized. Management stated volumes have bottomed out barring a significant macro shift, and the overall outlook for the year is unchanged.
- Origination inched up: Home purchase volumes are steady, supported by new home projects, and purchase demand for existing property in high-growth US regions remains strong. The roadblock is sellers reluctant to swap into higher-rate mortgages.
- Refi still on hold: Refinance activity is not expected to return until the Fed reverses interest rate direction.
- Margin recovery underway: The mortgage volume drop had a significant impact on BFS margins given its scale, but good progress has been made over the last three quarters and management is confident of continued improvement over the next two quarters.
Vipul Khanna: "Overall, our mortgage business has now stabilized. We believe that the worst of volatility in this business is behind us and volumes have bottomed out unless there is a significant shift in the macro environment from here."
Collections: Macro Signals Are Flashing, But the Revenue Lag Is Real
- Delinquencies are climbing: US credit card delinquencies rose to 2.43% (from 2.25% last quarter) and charge-offs to 2.90% (from 2.54%), marking the sixth consecutive quarterly increase post-COVID.
- The sequence matters: Early-stage collection work will reflect sooner in revenue, while legal collection, which was relatively flat Q4 to Q1, is expected to see an uptick only from Q4 of this fiscal or Q1 of next year.
- Underlying activity is solid: Normalizing for Q4 tax-season seasonality, which was not as high as in past years, early-stage collections held steady with new wins and volume from big clients remaining firm.
- Gradual recovery expected: Management anticipates a gradual recovery through the year, especially in H2, with macro indicators suggesting an increase in business activity in the near future.
Healthcare: A Tale of Two Segments
- HPHS drove the 4% segment decline: The slower-than-expected scale-up of volumes, accounts ending their implementation phase (especially BPAS), minor volume corrections in one account, and deal closures running behind schedule all weighed on the quarter. Management believes the softness is transitionary and is confident of strong H2 growth.
- Provider is past the PHE headwind: The Public Health Emergency was lifted in May 2023 after nearly 40 months, and the resulting Medicaid auto re-enrollment headwinds have subsided. Growth is expected from H2 as states and health systems adjust to the new reimbursement environment, though one or two programmes that ended created some Q1 drag.
- New wins support the H2 thesis: A top-20 health plan was added with a significant digital intake win, one new provider client and one existing onshore client were added for offshore, and the segment added five new clients overall this quarter.
- The split: HPHS and provider were roughly 55:45 of healthcare revenue in Q1, with the full year in the same ballpark.
Growth Drivers: EdTech, CMT, and the New Client Pipeline
- EdTech is scaling into a material contributor: A large strategic deal, estimated at $15-18 million in annual revenue, has been signed and will go live in October, ramping through Q4 or early FY2025. The practice is designing end-to-end learning journeys with GenAI-based solutions, and the consultative approach is enabling large annuity deals.
- CMT grew 7% YoY CC despite top-client headwinds: Outside the top client, growth traction remains strong, and the EdTech deal will further augment CMT performance as it ramps.
- 10 new clients added: Four in BFS, five in Healthcare, and one in CMT, with new relationships expected to scale gradually over the next 12 to 15 months.
- Auto finance expanded: Two new auto finance clients were added and three existing relationships expanded during the quarter.
- UK BFS remains strong but slower: Performance is solid, but the pace of growth has moderated from last year due to lower industry volumes from the challenging economic environment and the onshore-to-offshore movement. Several new ramp opportunities within the existing client set are expected to augment growth in H2.
Margins: Improved YoY, With Investment Spending Ahead
- Operating margin improved ~375 bps YoY to 11.7%: Performance was in line with the guided 11-12% range for the full year.
- BFS margins are on a recovery path: The mortgage volume drop had weighed heavily on BFS margins, but good progress has been made over the last three quarters and management is confident of continued improvement over the next two quarters.
- Investment spending is coming: Management flagged that investments are lined up for GenAI and other initiatives, and that it needs to "stay on top of" these, implying the margin range is being managed with an eye on funding future growth.
- Finance costs reflect capex, not rate pressure: Borrowing costs remain around 5%, with the larger component of the finance cost line coming from the capitalization of new offshore centers. Three new centers were added this quarter and one old center was closed.
- Medium-term margin ambition exists but is not yet a commitment: Management expressed an intent to deliver 25-30 bps of year-on-year improvement once the business reaches a steady state, and to slowly and strategically tilt new deals toward a heavier offshore mix, but no timeline was given.
Vipul Khanna: "For now we are keeping the 11% to 12% outlook. We have some investments also lined up given GAI and other things on the horizon that we need to kind of play with and kind of stay on top of."
GenAI: Early Days, No Long-Term Bets
- More than a dozen implementations underway: GenAI work spans proofs of concept, pilots, and production across six different clients and in-house use cases.
- Management declined to quantify cannibalization risk: When asked about a larger BPO's estimate of 20% cannibalization over three years, management called extrapolating pilot-level estimates across the portfolio a "fallacy" and said it hesitates to make a long-term prediction.
- The posture is experimentation, not disruption: Management characterized the current moment as one where "everybody wants to experiment," and is funding investments to stay on top of the technology rather than betting on a specific outcome.
Vipul Khanna: "I am very circumspect giving that sort of estimate but at this stage everybody wants to experiment... I kind of hesitate to make a long term prediction yet."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | 2% to 5% YoY CC, including ~3% mortgage base-effect headwind and 3.5-4% onshore-to-offshore headwind | FY2024 |
| Operating margin | 11% to 12% range | FY2024 |
| Tax rate | 18% to 20% | FY2024 |
| Sequential growth trajectory | Modest growth in Q2 (higher onshore-to-offshore impact), accelerating into Q3 and Q4 | Q2-Q4 FY2024 |
| Cash flow normalization | Cash flow from operations expected to normalize | By next quarter |
| Collections legal uptick | Legal collection volumes to pick up | Q4 FY2024 or Q1 FY2025 |
| Healthcare provider growth | Growth to emerge as states and health systems adjust to the post-PHE reimbursement environment | H2 FY2024 |
| HPHS growth | Strong growth expected | H2 FY2024 |
| EdTech deal ramp | Deal goes live, ramps through Q4 or latest Q1 FY2025 | October go-live; ramp by Q4 FY2024/Q1 FY2025 |
| BFS margin improvement | Continued improvement expected | Next two quarters |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹1,529.2 crore or $186 million, +3.9% YoY in rupee terms, -1.6% YoY in constant currency |
| Operating margin | 11.7% (₹178.9 crore), up 375 bps YoY and up 52.8% YoY in absolute terms |
| Profit after tax | ₹126 crore (8.2% of revenue), up 48.1% YoY |
| Diluted EPS | ₹1.8 for the quarter |
| Revenue growth guidance for FY24 | 2% to 5%, including ~3% headwind from mortgage base effect and 3.5%-4% headwind from onshore-to-offshore movement |
| Operating margin guidance for FY24 | 11% to 12% |
| Mortgage revenue share | ~9% of revenue, down from 17% a year ago |
| BFS segment revenue change | -13.6% YoY, -1.5% QoQ |
| CMT segment revenue growth | 7% YoY in constant currency |
| Healthcare segment revenue growth | Flat YoY in constant currency |
| Healthcare split (HPHS vs Provider) | 55:45 for Q1 FY24, full year in same ballpark |
| New client additions | 10 new clients: 4 in BFS, 5 in Healthcare, 1 in CMT |
| US credit card delinquencies | 2.43%, versus 2.25% last quarter |
| US credit card charge-offs | 2.90%, versus 2.54% last quarter, sixth consecutive quarterly increase post COVID |
| DSO | 63 days, versus 60 days last quarter |
| Net debt | ₹713.3 crore as of June 30, 2023, versus ₹615.9 crore as of March 31, 2023 |
| Cash balance including investments | ₹220.7 crore at end of quarter |
| Tax rate | 18.9%, within guidance range of 18% to 20% |
| Onshore-offshore mix | 70:30 |
| Top client contract extension investment | GBP 1.5 crore total, GBP 0.95 crore payable in FY24, balance in FY25, amortized over 10 years |
| EdTech new deal estimated annual revenue | $15-$18 million, expected go-live in Q3 FY24 and ramp-up by Q4 FY24 or Q1 FY25 |
| Interest rate on borrowings | ~5% |
| Centers added in quarter | 3 centers added, net center count decreased by 1 as an old center closed |