Key Takeaways
- An outlier year, closing with a reset: Revenue degrew -0.3% YoY CC in Q3, but operating margin improved 100 bps QoQ to 9.4%, aided by a one-time write-back. Management narrowed FY23 guidance to -2% to -1% growth and framed the year as an anomaly driven by macro shocks.
- Mortgage drag is now contained: The mortgage business contracted another 20% sequentially and will shrink to just 8.5% to 9% of revenue in Q4, meaning any further sharp moves are no longer material to the overall company.
- A margin inflection is promised for Q4: Cost actions taken in H1 are now flowing through, and management expects a normalized run rate of 11.5% to 12% in Q4, which will serve as the new base for FY24.
- Growth engines outside mortgage are intact: Excluding mortgage and acquisitions, the rest of BFS grew 30% YoY CC, CMT grew 17.5% YoY CC, and the company added 11 new clients across collections and CMT this quarter.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Q4 margin run rate of 11.5% to 12% actually materializes, the pace of recovery in collections and healthcare deal conversions, and the FY24 guidance that will be issued with Q4 results.
The Mortgage Reset: From Headwind to Immaterial
- Origination-to-servicing mix shifted to 35:65 as the market remained subdued along expected lines; servicing also saw downward pressure from client pullbacks and some onshore/offshore cannibalization.
- Servicing decline is now largely behind the company: clients have taken whatever cost actions they intended, and some are now looking for more offshoring and structural solutions, so no significant further decline is expected.
- Origination could pick up if rates cooperate: if interest rates stabilize in the 5% to 5.5% range, a pickup in the home purchase market is expected over the calendar year in hot geographies like Florida, Texas and Colorado, though this would be purchase-driven, not refinance-driven.
- The gross margin mix effect was mechanical, not strategic: a bigger chunk of the revenue reduction happened in the higher-margin offshore portfolio, so the onshore percentage rose simply by reduction, not by conscious choice, pressuring gross margins.
Vipul Khanna: "Hence, any further sharp movements in this business are unlikely to have a material impact on our overall business."
Margin Walk & the Q4 Inflection Promise
- Operating margin improved 100 bps QoQ to 9.4% in Q3, aided by a ₹59.8 crore other income write-back of variable considerations linked to two acquisitions and a structured mortgage contract, because variable payout thresholds were not met due to adverse market conditions.
- Operating expenses fell from ₹344 cr to ₹310 cr sequentially, driven roughly 70% by cost actions taken in Q1 and Q2 now showing effect and 30% linked to the revenue decline in the legal collection business, which carries variable expense.
- Cost actions targeted excess mortgage capacity and did not compromise critical growth investments; for example, the company continued investing in its digital collection platform build but reduced technology expense on it since the provider was soft.
- Facility-related cost actions take 6 to 9 months to become effective; some hit in Q3 and more are happening in Q4, so the full benefit is still building.
- The Q4 margin run rate of 11.5% to 12% will be driven by higher revenue, more profitable collection business kicking in, and the net impact of year-to-date cost actions, with no disproportionate action expected between direct cost and SG&A.
- Some operating expense reduction is sustainable, but as growth picks up, certain expenses that were reduced, such as technology expense on the digital platform, will need to be reinstated.
Vipul Khanna: "We think we will come back to a run rate of between 11.5% and 12%."
Growth Engines Outside Mortgage
- BFS ex-mortgage and acquisitions grew 30% YoY CC, demonstrating that the underlying franchise outside the troubled mortgage segment is healthy and gaining share.
- CMT delivered a strong quarter with 14.8% YoY reported growth and 17.5% CC growth; US CMT grew 63.8% YoY CC, and the company added four new clients including two major tech companies.
- UK BFS momentum continues with top partner status achieved at another top 10 retail bank; management expects momentum to sustain into next year with sharper focus on new client adds and more offshore business activity products.
- Collections added seven new clients across Fintech, Healthcare, Finance and Communication this quarter, and the deal pipeline is at its highest and most diversified across sectors.
- Legal collections operates at a lag from early-stage debt and is still finding its bottom; the company is ensuring readiness to capitalize on growth momentum as delinquencies and charge-offs rise, though US card-based metrics remain lower than historical averages due to very low unemployment.
- A large UK client relationship is strengthening with new programs and initiatives where Firstsource played an integral part; sustained offshore growth will cause some onshore revenue cannibalization, which is lower yield but higher margin, and the client is grappling in a competitive market where people need more support in some of those payments.
Healthcare: Delays, Not Demand Destruction
- Growth slowed due to deal delays, not a loss of opportunity: eight of the top ten health plans are open, but they are very large, mature buyers with sophisticated, longer evaluation processes, and even after decision-making, implementation cycles are longer because of vendor consolidation and switching.
- Digital intake and BPaaS solutions carry longer implementation cycles with volumes coming incrementally, which further stretches the timeline from deal win to revenue recognition.
- The provider segment was disproportionately impacted by the Public Health Emergency (PHE), which made Medicaid enrollment compulsory for states to get federal funding, causing automatic enrollment that reduced eligibility business volumes.
- Medicaid Redetermination is a coming tailwind: the PHE provision on compulsory Medicare enrollment is expected to end in April, after which states can take individual decisions on rolling off compulsory enrollment, creating demand for Medicaid Redetermination Services; the company has already signed its first anchor clients for the digital solution being developed.
- A second BPaaS deal was won with another top 10 Medicare Health Plan for building their membership administration platform, partnering with a product company to deliver the solution.
- Longer term, hospital cost hikes should lead to more outsourcing and offshoring, and the market is big and strong, not as much impacted by macro factors.
Strategic Moves: Consulting-Led Deals & Automation
- IDEA services launched as a focused consulting offering to help clients design customer experiences, translating digital contact center operating learnings into a structured design and consulting framework; described as a "tip of the spear" strategy to open doors and win ongoing outsourcing revenue.
- A global education testing player initially engaged for an IDEA consulting assignment that has now evolved into a large-scale build and run of their CX organization, validating the consulting-led sales model.
- Managed Services constructor for automation launched as an all-inclusive solution covering licensing, building, maintaining and making automation sustainable within an enterprise; being received well by clients.
Vipul Khanna: "It won't be a massive revenue, but it is kind of tip of the sphere strategy like the example that I gave of the Ed tech company where through our consulting engagement we identified opportunity and when we won that opportunity competitively and that now gives us ongoing outsourcing revenue. So, you have seen that strategy play out in most of the players where you use that as the tip of the sphere, so consulted targeted consulting offering to open up, now get inside the tent and then sort of win the business."
FY24 Direction & Capital Allocation
- No formal FY24 guidance yet, as the company is in the middle of its budgeting and planning cycle; guidance will be given at Q4 results in late April or early May.
- Directionally, the demand environment is good: businesses like mortgage, collections, and providers that faced headwinds in FY23 will see those headwinds ease off, removing friction, while Europe and healthcare businesses continue to operate in a good demand environment.
- M&A posture is opportunistic, not paused: the company has taken learnings from its last two acquisitions and consolidated them; the core hypothesis played out but the timing suffered as the market softened significantly after closing. The defined strategy of building adjacent capabilities in healthcare, CMT, and parts of BFS remains, and the company will continue to evaluate both organic and inorganic opportunities.
- Working capital is the only debt on the balance sheet; there is no long-term debt, and cash generation will be deployed for growth. The company is paying around ₹243 crores as dividend this quarter.
Vipul Khanna: "I would like to reiterate that this year has been an outlier and the rapid changes in the broader macroeconomic environment made it difficult for us to predict accurate outcomes for our businesses."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| FY23 revenue growth | -2% to -1% YoY; ex-mortgage and acquisitions, 12.5% to 14.5% growth | FY23 full year |
| FY23 operating margin | Land in the range of 9.25% to 9.5% | FY23 full year |
| Q4 FY23 margin run rate | Normalized run rate of 11.5% to 12%, serving as the new base for FY24 | Q4 FY23 |
| Mortgage revenue share | Shrink to 8.5% to 9% of total revenue, making further sharp moves immaterial | Q4 FY23 |
| Q4 implied sequential growth | 1% to 5% QoQ growth implied by revised guidance | Q4 FY23 |
| FY24 guidance issuance | Formal guidance to be provided at Q4 results | Late April / early May |
| Medicaid Redetermination demand | PHE provision expected to end, states begin staggered roll-off, creating services demand | Starting April (FY24) |
| Mortgage origination recovery | Pickup in home purchase market expected if rates stabilize between 5% and 5.5% | Over calendar year 2023 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹1,504.9 crore or $183 million, 2.8% YoY growth in rupee terms, flat in constant currency |
| Revenue degrowth (constant currency) | 0.3% YoY |
| Operating margin | 9.4%, improved 100 bps QoQ |
| Operating profit | ₹140.9 crore |
| EPS | ₹2.25, grew 17.2% YoY |
| Other income | ₹59.8 crore, from write-back of variable considerations linked to two acquisitions and a structured contract in mortgage |
| FY23 revenue growth guidance | -2% to -1% |
| FY23 revenue growth guidance excluding mortgage and acquisition | 12.5% to 14.5% |
| FY23 operating margin guidance | 9.25% to 9.5% |
| Q4 FY23 implied QoQ growth | 1% to 5% |
| Q4 FY23 margin run rate expected | 11.5% to 12% |
| BFS vertical growth (constant currency) | -14.1% YoY |
| BFS growth excluding mortgage and acquisition (constant currency) | 30% YoY |
| Mortgage revenue sequential contraction | 20% QoQ |
| Mortgage share of revenue | ~10% of Q3 revenue, expected 8.5% to 9% in Q4, down from 31% peak in Q1 FY22 |
| Mortgage origination to servicing mix | 35:65 |
| US card-based delinquency rate | 2.08%, versus 1.85% in Q2 |
| US card-based charge-off rate | 2.02%, versus 1.83% in Q2 |
| New clients added in collections | 7, across Fintech, Healthcare, Finance and Communication |
| Healthcare segment growth (constant currency) | 7.2% YoY |
| CMT segment growth (constant currency) | 17.5% YoY |
| US CMT segment growth (constant currency) | 63.8% YoY |
| New clients added in CMT | 4, including two major tech companies |
| Gross margin sequential change | Down 150 bps QoQ |
| Operating expense | ₹310 crore, reduced from ₹344 crore in Q2; ~70% of reduction from cost actions, ~30% linked to revenue decline |
| Dividend payout | ~₹243 crore |