Key Takeaways
- Best-ever quarter, but one-off tailwinds: Operational profitability hit a record, with nine-month profit matching all of FY2022, aided by a ~Rs 20 Cr one-time Egyptian export incentive and sudden raw material sourcing gains that will not repeat.
- AMET volumes troughed, recovery tentative: The region grew 11% sequentially from its lowest point since FY2017, and management called the worst behind it, but the call is conditional on no further currency depreciation after the Egyptian Pound's 100% drop.
- Specialties declined on Europe/China weakness: Specialty volumes fell 9% in Q3 and 5.6% YTD as demand contracted in developed markets; a recovery is expected in FY2024 but rests entirely on consumption rebounding and recession being avoided.
- EBITDA per ton is unsustainably high and will correct: The nine-month figure was inflated by mix, export benefits, and sourcing gains; management explicitly refused to guide on it for FY2024 and warned that prioritizing volume growth will bring it down.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether AMET's sequential recovery holds without further currency shocks, the pace of raw material price pass-through into lower reported revenue, and any demand signal from Europe and China for specialties.
AMET: The Volume Drag That Is Turning
- Structural damage from currency: The Egyptian Pound depreciated 100% and the Turkish Lira 71%, crushing purchasing power and driving AMET volumes to their lowest since FY2017; nearly 10% of aggregate company volume decline came from this region alone.
- Sequential green shoot: Q3 saw AMET volumes grow 11% QoQ, driven by the local Egyptian market, where demand improved despite 100% inflation.
- Recovery conditions: Management is hopeful the worst is behind but wants one more quarter of observation; the outlook assumes no further currency depreciation and benefits from easing commodity, food, and energy inflation as winter ends.
- Customer sentiment aligns: Customers in the region are signaling that price corrections should help, and they expect things to start getting better.
- Turkey earthquake adds near-term uncertainty: The earthquake's business impact was still being assessed; management expects some short-term demand sentiment hit but sees a lower probability of significant, prolonged risk once adjustment to the new normal occurs.
Krishnan: "I can conclude safely that the worst is behind us as far as AMET volumes are concerned."
Specialty Products: Waiting on the West
- The decline: Rest-of-world and specialty volumes were hit first by pandemic disruptions in FY2020/21, then supply chain issues in FY2022, and now by demand contraction in Europe and China; specialties declined 9% in Q3 and 5.6% YTD.
- The bet: Management expects performance to improve significantly in FY2024, based on an assumption that consumption makes a strong comeback in Europe and developed markets ward off recession.
- Inflation reshaped the product mix: Highly inflationary pressures over the last year shifted the market toward certain product categories and away from Prestige products, which contributed to the specialty decline; multinational customers noted consumers preferred smaller packs.
- No visible premiumization trend yet: Management sees no clear signal of demand moving back toward premium products versus mass; all markets remain a combination of Mass, Masstige, and Prestige, and the recent shifts are not viewed as a normal, stable situation.
The EBITDA-per-Ton Distortion
- What drove the record: Nine-month EBITDA per metric ton was phenomenally high due to a confluence of factors: product mix, operational improvements, judicious pricing, a ~Rs 23–24 Cr Egyptian export incentive booked on a cash basis, sudden sourcing gains from a steep reversal in raw material prices, and improved freight rates versus adverse rates a year ago.
- Why it will correct: Management's cardinal principle is to grow volumes ahead of the market when demand returns; as volumes recover, particularly in AMET and specialties, the product mix and pricing that inflated EBITDA per ton will normalize, and the one-off export incentive and sourcing gains will not repeat.
- Revenue will reflect RM declines with a lag: Falling raw material prices have not yet shown up in reported revenue because pricing lags RM costs by three to five months; Jan–Mar revenue growth is expected to be much lower as corrected prices flow through.
- Management refuses to anchor on the number: The company explicitly declined to guide on EBITDA per metric ton for FY2024, calling it a derivative of business conduct rather than a target; the priority will shift to volume growth when the market affords it, and EBITDA per ton will then be different.
Shekhar: "We do not design our business on the basis of EBITDA per metric ton. We repeat EBITDA per metric ton is always a derivative."
Volume Growth & the Cardinal Principles
- The framework: Management reiterated its cardinal principles: volume growth of 6% to 8%, EBITDA growth higher than volume growth, PAT growth higher than EBITDA growth, and ROCE in the 22% zone.
- Volume growth is the priority: When the market offers volume growth opportunities as prices correct and consumer demand returns, the company will prioritize growing volumes ahead of the market; if volume growth is not possible, it will manage operations, product mix, and pricing to deliver profitable growth.
- Flat aggregate volumes mask a mix shift: Aggregate volumes have been flat for three years, but this hides India crossing 100,000 MT while AMET dragged; India's structural COVID-era growth has sustained, and easing inflation is expected to build further momentum.
- MNC share rising: Multinational customer share increased to 56% YTD from 51%, demonstrating that large players absorbed inflation and grew, reflecting the strength of Galaxy's relationships and business model.
- Customer ladder is slow and sticky: The topmost step on the customer ladder takes 25 to 30 years to reach; climbing is gradual, deliberate, compounded, and cumulative, and customers always maintain at least one more supplier for risk management.
Krishnan: "The only way to sustainably grow your business is to ensure that you grow your volumes ahead of the market... the ultimate aim is to deliver profitable growth."
Competitive Position & Capex
- Competition dismissed as nothing new: Management has seen and managed competition over four decades and does not view current intensity as anything of great significance; it remains confident in maintaining and improving market share.
- Capex run-rate: Approximately Rs 150 Cr per year is expected for the next two to three years, a combination of maintenance and growth; capacity addition is triggered when utilization reaches 80% to 85%.
- Inventory corrections nearly done: Inventory reductions have been completed in most geographies except the US, where some pipeline inventory correction is still expected.
- Raw material inventory pricing is easing: Management ensured inventory flowed in line with the market; buying prices directionally are coming down, with Jan/Feb/March expected to be lower than Oct/Nov/Dec as corrections that started in June/July work through.
Krishnan: "In the last 4 decades we have seen and managed a huge amount of competition. So this is nothing new I do not see this as anything of great significance."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth | Grow volumes ahead of the market; 6% to 8% volume growth in line with market growth | FY2024 |
| EBITDA growth | EBITDA growth higher than volume growth | FY2024 |
| PAT growth | PAT growth higher than EBITDA growth | FY2024 |
| ROCE | Weighted average ROCE of 22% | Ongoing threshold |
| AMET volume recovery | Worst is behind, barring further currency depreciation | FY2024, conditional |
| Specialty performance | Significant improvement expected | FY2024, conditional on Europe/China recovery |
| Capex | Approximately Rs 150 Cr per year | Next 2–3 years |
| Revenue growth | Jan–Mar revenue growth expected to be much lower as corrected RM prices reflect | Q4 FY2023 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue growth | Flat volumes, revenue growth driven by raw material price lag of 3–5 months |
| India volume growth | 12% in Q3, 7.7% for nine months |
| AMET volume growth | -6% in Q3, -14.8% for nine months; sequential growth of 11% |
| Specialty volume growth | -9% in Q3, -5.6% YTD |
| EBITDA per metric ton (9M FY23) | ~₹25,000, including ~₹23–24 cr export incentive from Egypt |
| EBITDA per metric ton (9M FY23, ex-export incentive) | ~₹23,700 (per an analyst's math) |
| Export incentive from Egypt (9M FY23) | ₹23–24 cr, booked on cash basis in Q3 |
| MNC share of revenue | 56% YTD, up from 51% last year YTD |
| Turkey revenue contribution | 9–10% of overall revenue |
| Capacity utilization | 66–67% |
| Capex (9M FY23) | ~₹120 cr incurred; annual run-rate ~₹150 cr expected for next 2–3 years |
| ROC threshold for projects | 22%+ |
| Customer base | 1,800+ customers; majority on first step of the ladder |
| International sales share | ~2/3 of total sales; India export revenue split ~50/50 |
| Lauryl alcohol share in raw material | ~60% of raw material buying |