Key Takeaways
- PBT guidance flat despite new solar: FY2023-24 PBT is guided at ₹250–300 crores, roughly the same as FY2019-20, even after adding 175 MW of solar capacity, because lost contributions from the gas station and SLPP-I under-recovery have washed away the gains.
- Gas station contribution has gone to zero: The Vadodara gas-based station, which used to add ₹20–25 crores to the bottom line, ran at zero utilization for the last six months and is now in preservation mode, with a possible restart only 1–2 years out.
- Khavda is the real growth story, but it is years away: The 2,375 MW solar park is on schedule, with a PMC finalized and LTA signed for 600 MW, but no capacity addition hits the P&L in FY2023-24; management targets 1,500–1,800 MW of own capacity there in five to seven years.
- SLPP-I drag should ease in FY2022-23: The Economizer Beam replacement is planned for July FY2022-23, which should restore fixed cost recovery and remove the ~₹23 crores of under-recovery that weighed on the last two years.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 75 MW PSU/promoter solar expansion is finalized and at what module price, the actual timeline of the SLPP-I beam replacement, and any update on Khavda solar park development spend versus plan.
Profitability Bridge: Why New Solar Has Not Lifted PBT
- The ₹65 crore hole: Compared to FY2019-20, the current year lost ~₹40 crores from SLPP-I maintenance and under-recovery plus ~₹25 crores from the gas station contribution going down, offsetting the contribution from new solar capacity.
- Gas station decline was gradual: Utilization fell from 90% to 70% to 50% to below 50% over four to five years, and for the last six months it has been zero; the stations are debt-free and depreciated but gas availability has dried up.
- SLPP-I ran below par for two years: The Economizer Beam issue forced lower capacity utilization, which reduced fixed cost recovery under the PPA; COVID delayed both the beam supply and the availability of contract workmen for maintenance.
- All solar stations are now PBT positive: Even the 75 MW commissioned in August 2021 contributed positively, and the 100 MW project is generating above 30% PLF.
- EBITDA split is roughly balanced: Thermal (lignite) contributed ₹200–215 crores; wind and solar together contributed ₹200–220 crores; management did not break out wind versus solar separately.
K. K. Bhatt: "In the phase manner since the last four to five years gas-based stations profitability is getting depleted year by year. Earlier it was contributing a lot into the profitability bottom line because the stations are totally debt free and depreciation free. It was adding to the bottom line very well, but with the reduction in availability of gas, the machines are not running at full capacity."
Khavda Solar Park: The Multi-Year Growth Engine
- Project is in development stage: The Detail Project Report has been submitted to MNRE, a Project Management Consultant has been finalized, and a Long Term Agreement for 600 MW has been signed with CTUIL; MNRE approval is in hand for 2,250 MW.
- Timeline is long: The project is a five-year plan with 50% completion targeted by December 2024; solar park development must finish first, then power projects can begin, so no capacity addition hits in FY2023-24.
- Own capacity ambition: GIPCL is targeting at least 1,500 to 1,800 MW of its own capacity addition at Khavda over the next five to seven years.
- FY2022-23 capex: ~₹300 crores for Khavda solar park development, plus the 75 MW expansion, bringing total capex to ~₹400–450 crores; funding comes from internal accruals, MNRE subsidy at 30% of cost, upfront development charges from project developers at the back end, and debt for the balance.
- Construction timeline per project: Once everything is clear and available, an individual project takes 15 to 18 months; 18 months is the ideal time.
K. K. Bhatt: "We are targeting at least 1500 to 1800 capacity addition in the Khavda location by our own in the next five to seven years down the line."
Near-Term Capacity: 75 MW Solar Expansion
- Route changed after GUVNL tender loss: The company lost the GUVNL 500 MW bidding to competitors who bid at very low prices; management did not want to compromise on quality or profitability, so the 75 MW expansion is now being pursued through the PSUs/promoters modality instead.
- Finalization expected soon: Management said finalization is expected "in a few weeks."
- Module price risk: The EPC price was discovered via the GUVNL tender, but the order has not yet been placed; if there is a vast difference between the quoted and current module prices, management will negotiate with the EPC contractor to reduce the project cost.
- Operational timeline: The project will be operational "down the line in 18 months," meaning no contribution in FY2023-24.
K. K. Bhatt: "That was the tender for GUVNL 500-MW bidding, that was won by the other bidders at a very low price, however, we do not want compromise with quality and profitability and to go below certain level..."
Thermal & Legacy Assets: Stability and Life Extension
- Lignite plants are the bedrock: SLPP-II is running above 75% PLF; SLPP-I is at 65% PLF due to the beam issue at Unit I, with replacement planned for July FY2022-23.
- Lignite sourcing is fully captive: In FY2021-22, the company was entirely dependent on its own mines with no outside lignite purchased; the previous year had required minimal imported coal/lignite due to extended monsoon and heavy rainfall.
- Life extension under consideration: Management is evaluating a 10-year life extension for SLPP-I and is also thinking about extending SLPP-II; the lignite power plant is expected to operate for at least another 20–25 years, with a further 5 or 10 years possible depending on lignite availability.
- Gas station preservation: The Vadodara gas-based stations are debt-free, depreciated, and maintained in preservation mode; management believes it may be possible to run them again one to two years down the line.
- Machine reliability risk: The units are 20 years old, and while the company does annual and capital overhauls, management acknowledged that technical issues are possible and that "we cannot predict" mechanical failures.
K. K. Bhatt: "Your question is valid but it is all mechanical. We cannot predict. We are doing our best to maintain the availability of the station with annual overhauling and capital overhauling as may be required, but since the machines are old 20 years it may be possible to have technical issues and we are trying our best so that availability is not affected."
Unresolved Questions from the Call
- Why is PBT guidance flat despite solar additions? Two analysts pressed on why FY2023-24 PBT guidance of ₹250–300 crores is essentially the same as FY2019-20 PBT of ~₹300 crores despite 175 MW of solar capacity added in between; management explained the gas station depletion and SLPP-I issues but did not reconcile how the new solar capacity contributes to the unchanged PBT figure. One analyst said, "we will probably engage on this separately."
- Solar capacity-wise profitability not disclosed: Management confirmed all solar stations are PBT positive but did not provide a capacity-wise breakdown when asked.
- Wind versus solar EBITDA split not provided: Management gave a combined wind-plus-solar EBITDA range of ₹200–220 crores but did not separate the two, nor did they quantify the exact gas station loss.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| SLPP-I beam replacement | Economizer Beam replacement at Unit I to restore fixed cost recovery | July FY2022-23 |
| 75 MW solar expansion finalization | PSUs/promoters modality to be finalized | "In a few weeks" |
| 75 MW solar operational | Project to be operational | "Down the line in 18 months" |
| Khavda solar park completion | 50% of project complete | By December 2024 |
| Khavda own capacity addition | 1,500–1,800 MW of own capacity | Next five to seven years |
| FY2023-24 PBT | ₹250–300 crores under normal scenario with current capacities (Station I not in operation) | FY2023-24 |
| Gas station restart possibility | Preservation mode; possible to run again | One to two years down the line |
| SLPP life extension | 10-year extension for SLPP-I; SLPP-II also being considered | No date (under evaluation) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| EBITDA | Nearly ₹400 cr for FY2022 |
| EBITDA – thermal | ₹200–215 cr for FY2022 |
| EBITDA – wind and solar | ₹200–220 cr for FY2022 |
| PBT guidance (normal scenario, current capacities) | ₹250–300 cr for FY2023-24 |
| Gas-based station PBT contribution | Zero for FY2022, down from ~₹23 cr in FY2020-21 |
| Under-recovery of fixed cost at SLPP-I | ~₹23 cr for FY2022 |
| Additional maintenance expenditure (overhauling) | ~₹10 cr for FY2022 |
| Profitability washed away vs FY2019-20 | ~₹65 cr combined impact from Station I shutdown and SLPP-I under-recovery |
| Dividend per share | ₹2.50, down from ₹2.90 previously |
| Lignite production | 29 lakh metric tonnes in FY2022 |
| Lignite production requirement | 34 lakh metric tonnes targeted for FY2023 |
| SLPP-I availability / PLF | ~65%, constrained by beam issue at Unit I |
| SLPP-II availability / PLF | Above 75% |
| Khavda solar park Phase-I capex | ~₹300 cr for FY2022-23 |
| 75 MW solar project capex | ₹400–450 cr |
| Khavda capacity addition target (GIPCL own) | 1,500–1,800 MW over next 5–7 years |
| 75 MW solar project timeline | 18 months to operational |
| No capacity addition in FY2023-24 | Confirmed |