Key Takeaways
- A year-end PPA true-up, not a structural jump: Q4 revenue and profit were the highest of FY23 solely because annual PPA reconciliations for fuel, water and O&M are booked in the March quarter, a normal phenomenon that will repeat each year.
- Khavda 600 MW solar is the growth story, now fully in motion: LOI received, BOS tenders issued, INR200 crores already spent, and management is confident of commissioning by December 2024 despite difficult terrain pushing project cost to ~INR5.8 crores per MW.
- Fixed cost under-recovery persisted but was managed: An economiser beam replacement and a unit-4 COH issue caused another year of fixed cost under-recovery, though strong plant availability kept PPA profitability well-behaved.
- Renewable profitability is back-end loaded: The renewable portfolio earns ~12%+ IRR, but PBT is only ~INR85 crores today because depreciation and interest dominate early years; management asks for 2–3 years of patience for the cash flow inflection.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Khavda PV module tender is published and concluded by August as promised, any update on the insurance claim recovery now expected in FY24, and whether Gas Plant 1 gets a restart trigger as gas prices fluctuate.
Khavda 600 MW Solar Project: The Growth Engine
- Project locked in: LOI issued by GUVNL, PPA likely at INR2.73 paisa per unit, and initial BOS tenders already on the street with finalization expected within three months.
- Site challenges priced in: Terrain is under liquefaction, requiring deeper foundations, and the earthquake-zone location demands a more robust design, pushing cost to ~INR5.8 crores per MW versus ~INR5.5 crores for conventional solar. Management believes project scale will keep costs competitive.
- Tender timeline: The structural BOS tender (INR1,300 crores) is already live; the PV module tender is under consideration and expected to be published by July 2023, with both concluded by end of monsoon (~August). Site work begins September end 2023.
- Commissioning confidence: Management states the 600 MW plant will be commissioned by or before December 2024, citing back-to-back supplier agreements, an expert team, and a track record of completing the last three projects well ahead of schedule with one- or two-months margin in hand.
- Funding mix taking shape: INR1,500 crores of equity from internal cash generation over two years plus existing cash; the remaining ~INR500 crores may come via rights issue, QIP, preferential allotment, or promoter contribution, with management noting promoters are cash-rich.
- Debt timing is manageable: Project debt expected in FY25–26, but the plant will already be generating revenue by then, so interest servicing is not a concern. In-principle approval received from two or three large lenders at ~8% interest.
Management: "That is correct, but somehow you have to take the opportunity and then you have to go ahead. Otherwise, if you miss the bus, then you will have next future development will be at stake. So, you have to take risk for your company and requirement of the current scenario."
Khavda Park Developer Role & Phase 2
- Park developer allotment: GIPCL has been allotted 2,375 MW of park developer opportunity at Khavda, with the first phase covering 1,200 MW.
- Phase 1 split: 600 MW is GIPCL's own capacity; the balance 600 MW is being tendered out to other project developers, with details already submitted to GUVNL for the tendering process.
- Phase 1 park capex: INR600 crores to be incurred in the current fiscal (FY24), with park development to start by December 2024.
- Phase 2 decision deferred: The remaining 1,175 MW has a December 2026 deadline, but GIPCL will decide how much capacity (600–700 MW) it will take only after next year, based on opportunities and funding availability.
- No penalty risk on park delays: GIPCL's job is to make the park available per government guidelines; it will not be penalized for park development delays, though GUVNL may need to grant specific timeline relaxations to incoming developers as required.
Thermal & Gas: Steady State, No Expansion
- Q4 revenue spike is a PPA mechanic, not a windfall: Provisional quarterly billing happens all year; at year-end, actual annual figures for fuel cost reimbursement, water charges and O&M are crystallized, and the differential is booked in Q4. This is a normal PPA phenomenon, not extra or one-off income.
- Fixed cost under-recovery repeated: An economiser beam was replaced in one unit and a COH issue in unit-4 was addressed during FY23, causing another year of fixed cost under-recovery versus the prior year. However, plants performed very well, so PPA profitability was managed in a well-behaved manner.
- PLF is not the profit driver: Commercial availability matters more than PLF; if the plant is available but not dispatched due to high wind or solar on the grid, GIPCL still receives full fixed cost.
- Gas Plant 1 remains idle: The station is maintained in preservative mode and has not resumed operations despite cooling gas prices. Management is keen to run it but says a naked gas price of $8–$8.5 is not viable because transmission, GST and other costs push the effective price to $12, yielding a per-unit tariff above INR10.
- Gas restart is price-dependent, with no trigger given: Management deflected a direct timeline question, saying only that the decision depends on gas prices in coming days. A promoter offtake becomes easy if GIPCL's tariff falls below the discom rate, which is generally above INR8 per unit.
- No new thermal capacity planned: Management confirmed it is not looking at adding any thermal power plants at the current stage.
Management: "Sir, current gas price is very volatile like every day, you will find different rate like today, it is trading around $9 per mmbtu. You take $9 plus taxes and everything $12 to $13, per unit tariff would be around more than INR10."
SLPP-1 R&M: Extending the Legacy Asset
- 10-year life extension: An R&M project for the existing PPA-based SLPP-1 station has been principally approved by GUVNL, the PPA counterparty, to enhance plant life for the next 10 years.
- Capex covers two things: Machinery expenditure for plant availability, plus land acquisition for mining to secure the fuel requirement for the next 10 years.
- Strategic rationale: The project takes care of the plant's plan for the next decade, locking in continued fixed-cost recovery under the existing PPA framework.
Renewable Portfolio: Patience Required
- Current returns are real but thin: All renewable projects are earning ~12%+ IRR, but PBT is only ~INR85 crores because early years carry high depreciation and interest costs against steady revenue.
- The inflection is 2–3 years out: As depreciation and interest decline while revenue remains steady, the profitability portion will rise materially, and profit after tax will begin showing as higher positive cash flow in books. Management explicitly asks investors to wait 2–3 years.
- Wind and site headwinds: Wind velocity issues and problems at Charanka Park reduced renewable revenue by INR25–30 crores last year, factors beyond management control.
- Conservative IRR assumptions: Management says the 12% IRR target is conservative; if CUF comes in 1–2% higher, IRR would rise, and past projects have already delivered at or above this level.
Management: "You have to wait for 2-3 years once the interest goes down, depreciation goes down and revenue generation will remain as it is. But all this expenditure will go down, then the profitability portion will go up in next couple of years."
Capital Management & Disclosures
- Dividend raised to INR3.75 per share from INR3.00 in the prior year, following the Gujarat government guideline of 30% of PAT. Management noted the alternative 5% of net worth threshold is not feasible and no GoG-controlled company has declared at that level.
- Insurance claim recovery expected in FY24: Most queries have been sorted out; the loss of material claim will be processed first, followed by loss of profit.
- Disclosure improvements promised: Management committed to updating the PAF percentage on the website within days, and to improving the earnings presentation with more qualitative and quantitative detail, including PLF and energy generated in million units, along with better separation of renewable and thermal segments.
Management: "See, it is basically as I explained to you, this is a guideline. At least some profit has to be shared to the equity partner. So, the policy was published by the GoG, which is basically a guideline in nature. And looking to the government support which we are getting, being a GoG entity, we have also fallen in line with the GoG requirement and the guideline."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Khavda 600 MW solar commissioning | Plant operational | By or before December 2024 |
| Khavda Phase 1 tenders concluded | Structural BOS and PV module tenders awarded | By end of monsoon (~August 2023) |
| Khavda Phase 1 site work begins | Construction start at location | September end 2023 |
| Khavda Phase 1 park development start | First phase 1,200 MW park | December 2024 |
| Khavda Phase 2 completion deadline | Remaining 1,175 MW park | December 2026 |
| Insurance claim recovery | Loss of material claim processed first, then loss of profit | FY24 |
| SLPP-1 R&M project | Capex to extend plant life and secure mining land | Next 10 years (post-approval) |
| Renewable profitability inflection | Profit after tax to show higher positive cash flow as depreciation and interest decline | Next 2–3 years |
| Disclosure upgrades | PAF percentage on website; improved presentation with PLF, energy data, segment split | PAF within days; presentation timeline unspecified |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue (thermal division) | ₹1,082 cr (FY23) |
| Revenue (renewable division) | ₹266 cr (FY23) |
| EBITDA (thermal) | ₹226 cr (FY23) |
| EBITDA (renewable) | ₹231 cr (FY23) |
| Profit before tax | ₹253 cr (FY23) |
| Depreciation | ₹164 cr (FY23) |
| Finance cost | ₹37.54 cr (FY23) |
| Dividend per share | ₹3.75, up from ₹3.00 last year |
| Dividend payout ratio | 30% of PAT, in line with GoG guideline |
| Lignite production | 30 lakh metric tons (FY23) |
| Khavda solar project tariff | ₹2.73 per unit, PPA to be executed with GUVNL |
| Khavda Phase 1 capex (GIPCL share) | ₹3,780 cr total outlay (₹3,600 cr project + ₹180 cr park equity) |
| Khavda Phase 1 equity IRR (post-tax) | ~12%, conservative internal estimate |
| Khavda Phase 1 commercial start | November 2024 |
| Khavda park development cost (Phase 1) | ₹600 cr, of which GIPCL equity share 30% |
| Khavda project spend to date | ₹200 cr on park activities; ₹50–60 cr on project |
| Debt interest rate (in-principle approval) | ~8% from two or three large lenders |
| Gas plant viability threshold | Per-unit tariff above ₹10 at current gas price of ~$9/mmbtu plus taxes; viable below ₹8 |
| Insurance claim expected | ₹3–4 cr material loss, ₹12–15 cr loss of profit, under process |
| Operating cash flow | ~₹400 cr per year, last few years |
| Cash in hand | ₹600–700 cr available |