Key Takeaways
- A quarter of two halves: Record production in several chemical products was overshadowed by a net-negative fertilizer segment, where one-off regulatory hits of INR91 crores compounded an already loss-making underlying business.
- Chemical margins under pressure: While the chemical portfolio showed volume resilience, high input costs and sharp price corrections in acetic acid and TDI squeezed profitability, with TDI remaining in losses.
- Input cost relief is arriving, but slowly: Management noted that elevated input costs are now showing signs of tapering off from Q4 onwards, with commodity prices normalizing to pre-Covid levels.
- A capex cycle is loading: A INR2,000 crores three-year capex plan is underway, headlined by a polycarbonate project expected to add INR1,000 crores to turnover, alongside a coal-based power plant and a green hydrogen project awaiting regulatory clearance.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the TDI plant can sustain its improved reliability to narrow losses, the trajectory of input cost normalization, and any board action on the capital restructuring proposal per Gujarat government guidelines.
Fertilizer Segment: A Deepening Loss
- Urea hit by energy norms: A retrospective adjustment to energy consumption norms cost the company INR41 crores, including arrears, dragging the urea business deeper into the red.
- Complex fertilizers hit by subsidy revision: A reduction in Nutrient-Based Subsidy (NBS) rates and a price cut together inflicted a INR50 crores impact on the complex fertilizer P&L.
- Underlying business is unviable: Even stripping out these one-off adjustments, the fertilizer segment posted an EBIT loss. Management attributed this to competition, product availability, and factors beyond subsidies, stating that at current subsidy levels it would be very difficult to have a profitable scenario if the company continues with current manufacturing and capacity utilization.
- Trading as a workaround: The company is exploring trading in other agri-inputs where better margins are available, to compensate for the structural losses in its own fertilizer manufacturing.
Manish Billore: "The costing which we are having when we cost it on the opportunity cost is higher so based on the subsidy levels for segment of fertilizer it would be very difficult to have this kind of a scenario going ahead if we continue with the manufacturing or the capacity utilization here."
Chemical Portfolio: Mixed Performance, TDI Drag
- Volume story is intact: Total chemical sales reached approximately 763,000 tons, a small YoY improvement even after factoring in lower volumes of aniline and methanol. The company achieved record production and sales of ethyl acetate, ammonium nitrate, and formic acid post-revamp.
- Acetic acid prices have corrected sharply: Prices have now stabilized and normalized at levels seen during the previous Covid period. Management expects them to sustain at current levels and not decline further.
- Aniline was deliberately curtailed: The plant was not operated at optimum levels because input prices were so high that the margin versus opportunity was unattractive. The company chose to sell more CNA in the market rather than produce nitrobenzene and then aniline.
- Ammonium nitrate was the star performer: It was the most profitable product in FY23, driven by consistent demand from mining activities growing at approximately 6% per annum per Coal India estimates.
- TDI remains in losses: The plant has suffered from low capacity utilization and non-recovery of fixed costs. Management acknowledged supporting customers even at the cost of contribution. However, production reliability has improved over the last 4-5 months, which is lowering variable costs and improving realizations, thereby reducing the loss.
- TDI profitability is not guaranteed even at full load: Management cautioned that even if TDI Plant II runs at full capacity, positive impacts on variable margin may not necessarily translate into profit, because the outcome depends on the dynamic between plant yield and input costs, especially natural gas prices.
D.V. Parikh: "We have supported the customer at times even at the cost of contribution."
Input Costs & Commodity Prices
- The peak appears to have passed: Input costs were very high all through the year but are now showing signs of tapering off, especially from Q4 onwards. The intensifying war and China lockdowns had a massive impact on both input costs and elevated finished goods prices.
- Commodity prices normalizing: Prices are now normalized at levels of the previous Covid period and should be stabilized.
- Ammonia production is sticky: The company cannot simply stop producing ammonia and buy from the market when market prices are cheaper, because the manufacturing process serves other downstream integrations. Producing ammonia through the oil route still retains some margin compared to purchasing.
D.V. Parikh: "manufacturing company like ours cannot do that on a huge scale why because it is through the manufacturing process other integrations are served. It is not that if you buy ammonia when it is cheaper, we stop producing the full ammonia and yet we are in a position to make the downstream products. It is not possible."
Capex & Strategic Projects
- Three-year, INR2,000 crores plan: The capex cycle is fronted by a polycarbonate project that is expected to increase turnover by about INR1,000 crores. Approximately 80% of the total amount will be capitalized by FY25-26, depending on project progress.
- Coal-based power plant: A substantial commitment has been made, with 90% of the total investment of around INR600+ crores already committed.
- CNA 4 expansion: The new plant is being prepared for commissioning, and management sees sufficient demand to absorb the additional production.
- Green hydrogen project on hold pending regulation: In-principle approval from management has been received and a bid has been floated, but the final investment decision is contingent on regulatory support. Management will wait for clearance from regulatory authorities before moving ahead decisively.
- Methanol plant restart conditional on gas price: The company would like to restart the methanol plant for captive consumption in acetic acid production, but only if natural gas is available at around INR32, which would make imported methanol and domestic production roughly equal.
Y.N. Patel: "we are waiting for clearance from regulatory authorities unless that is received, we may not move ahead decisively in this project. So final investment decision will be based on regulatory support unless there is clarity, we will try to wait for the decision to come"
Balance Sheet & Capital Management
- Debt-free position: The company currently has zero debt. Any future debt for capex or a potential buyback will be planned accordingly, with the company's capex needs always taking first priority.
- Cash and treasury returns: Out of a total cash balance of INR2,831 crores, INR800 crores is deployed in inter-corporate deposits and the rest in bank fixed deposits, earning an average pre-tax return of approximately 7.2%.
- Capital restructuring on the horizon: The Gujarat government has issued guidelines covering capital restructuring proposals including buyback, bonus, and share splits for government-supported companies. Management stated the board will consider the proposal at an appropriate time, calling it premature to comment further as it is price-sensitive.
- Employee cost accrual: An accrual for a wage settlement effective 1st July 2022 has been booked, though the settlement itself has yet to be finalized.
Ashwin Shah: "the board of directors of the company is quite matured. We have the senior IAS officer's additional chief secretary rank, and we have other learned members on the board so let the board take a call whenever the things are considered right?"
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Capex capitalization | 80% of INR2,000 crores capex plan to be capitalized | By FY25-26, depending on project progress |
| Polycarbonate turnover addition | Project to add ~INR1,000 crores to turnover | On commissioning (part of 3-year capex plan) |
| TDI Plant II capacity utilization | Target to achieve at least 90% to 100% utilization | Coming year (FY24) |
| TDI Plant II full capacity | Management expects to run at full capacity | Coming year (FY24) |
| Methanol plant restart | Restart for captive use if natural gas available at ~INR32 | Conditional on gas price; no date |
| Green hydrogen final investment decision | Decision contingent on regulatory clearance | Awaiting regulatory authorities; no date |
| Acetic acid pricing | Expect prices to sustain at current level, not decline further | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹10,227 cr (excluding other income; exceeds ₹10,500 cr including other income) |
| Chemical segment revenue | ~₹6,500 cr in FY23 |
| Dividend | 300%, ₹30 per share |
| Total capex plan | ₹2,000 cr over next 3 years |
| Coal-based power plant capex committed | 90% of ₹600+ cr committed |
| Cash and bank balance | ₹2,831 cr (before dividend payment) |
| Inter-corporate deposits | ₹800 cr of total cash balance |
| Treasury return | ~7.2% pre-tax |
| Total ammonia production | 6,79,000 tonnes in FY23; ~40% from oil-based feedstock |
| WNA production | 4,31,000 MTPA in FY23 (3.23 lakh tonnes production, 1.08 lakh tonnes sales) |
| WNA average price | ₹55,000 per metric ton in FY23, vs ₹39,000 in FY22 (100% basis) |
| CNA production | 1,10,000 MTPA in FY23 |
| CNA average price | ₹61,000 per metric ton in FY23, vs ₹44,000 in FY22 |
| Ammonium nitrate production | 1,97,000 tons in FY23, vs 1,85,000 tons in FY22 |
| Ammonium nitrate revenue share | 20% of chemical segment revenue in FY23 |
| TDI-1 capacity utilization | 99% in FY23 |
| TDI-2 capacity utilization | 64% in FY23; ~87% in Q4 FY23 |
| TDI-2 fixed cost at full load | ₹50,000 per ton |
| Acetic acid price change | 43% lower than previous financial year |
| Natural gas price | ~₹38 per standard cubic meter, ~$11 per mm Btu |
| Employee cost accrual for wage settlement | ~₹150 cr in P&L, ~₹90 cr in OCL |
| Urea energy norms impact | ~₹41 cr total impact, including ~₹5 cr arrears |
| Complex fertilizer NBS and price revision impact | ~₹50 cr accounted for |
| Fertilizer segment EBIT | Net negative in Q4 FY23 |